Notes
Academics Martin Klein, Subha Xavier, and political philosopher Hady Ba discuss Senegal's history, changing social norms, current political polarization, and the democratic robustness of Senegalese elections.
Guests
- Martin Klein
- Subha Xavier
- Hady Ba
Video
Podcast
SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
Senegal, president, Sonko, rape, everyone, party, Assembly, National, political, Senegalese, women, Africa, Makisal, friends, Jomai, minister, came, elections, fishing, Muslim
SPEAKERS
Martin Klein, Subha Xavier, Hady Ba, Metta Spencer.
SUMMARY
Metta Spencer hosted a conversation with Martin Klein, Subha Xavier, and Hady Ba about Senegal, covering its past, its religious and family life, and its current political conflict. Martin Klein described his first visit in 1963, when he was researching the Sine Saloum region. He recalled being invited into local households and meeting the Ingam family, whose large household gave him a sense of Senegalese values. He also described religious tolerance among Muslim Sufi orders and families, and Hady Ba confirmed that the Serer people accept religious differences within families. Both agreed that Senegal is overwhelmingly Muslim.
Read more…
Metta Spencer asked whether polygamy remains common. Subha Xavier said it appears less often among younger generations and is tied to economic arrangements that matter less in today's economy. Martin Klein argued that large families are harder to sustain in cities, so people often rely on adoptive child-rearing. Hady Ba then explained the current political conflict. He said the president and his former ally Ousmane Sonko split after Sonko was accused of rape, went to prison, and was later removed as prime minister, and he described the resulting standoff in the National Assembly.
Subha Xavier added that many young voters supported Sonko's anti-French, revolutionary message, and that public attitudes toward rape changed after it was made a crime. Hady Ba compared Sonko to Donald Trump, arguing that his economic views were simplistic, and he raised the fishing industry as an example of why hard choices are difficult. Metta Spencer asked about the fishing disputes and about whether rape allegations matter politically, comparing the situation with the United States. Hady Ba answered that courts often convict on lesser charges, which affects outcomes.
Martin Klein described how early Senegalese legislatures had no women, and how the 1963 election introduced a female member, leading to much greater female participation today. Hady Ba explained that a parity law now requires roughly equal numbers of men and women on electoral lists, producing an Assembly that is close to half women. Hady Ba also described how Sonko's and the president's parties were founded and how their supporters disputed each other's legitimacy. He argued that Senegal's elections are hard to rig because votes are counted locally in front of party representatives. Metta Spencer then asked for his opinion on whether the country's future depends on one leader, and he answered that Senegal's institutions are strong. Metta Spencer thanked the guests and ended the episode.
Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.
Speaker 1 0:02
Hi, I'm Meadow Spencer. Hey, let's go to Africa, shall we? I haven't been, in fact, I've never been to Africa, not even once. But let's go to Senegal, which I have a good impression on, that of all the countries in Africa that might be fun to visit, Senegal is one of them. And I have some friends here who really know Senegal. Let me start with Martin Klein, because I've known him the longest, I think. No, maybe not. I mean, Sue has been in my life a long time. But Martin Klein is a professor emeritus of history, University of Toronto, and he is a specialist in the history of Africa. He has been emeritus a long time.
Retired and just published, or is publishing, an encyclopedia of African history, which he edited. And it's got thousands of pages of which four articles were written by him. So we'll find out a little bit about Senegal, because he used to go there every year and start his journeys through other parts of Africa there. Subha Xavier, I met when she was, what, five years old? Something like that. And that Suba came as a refugee from Sri Lanka back in the 80s. Suba grew up in Montreal and learning French and became a professor of French at Emory University in Uruguay, Georgia, where she actually leads groups of students, I believe, to Africa To study Africa and especially Senegal.
So every year she takes a bunch of students and has been going for several summers, taking her family. I think her two sons are both learning some African language. And Marnie were both talking about the importance of not talking about African politics without an African intellectual presence. And I understand that Hady Ba is an academic who knows a lot about a particular, especially about a particular conflict going on among leaders of Senegal now. So I'm going to ask, because we're only getting acquainted personally, barely, I'd like for Suba to introduce her friend and colleague, Hady Ba.
Speaker 2 2:47
Okay, thank you so much, Mena. Yes, it's my absolute pleasure to welcome Radhi Bain into this conversation. Radhi is a political philosopher. He is a professor at the Universitaire Schirr Antadiop. He has had and serves as visiting professor in many universities in the U.S. and he is also very recently the winner of the France Fanon Prize for Philosophy in Caribbean Studies. He is also very active in the political circuits and I've been very impressed by many of his, much of his writing and thoughtful Contributions to political analysis through a philosophical and theoretical point of view as well.
He, I believe, is also director of the FASTEC at the Lucade and is an incredibly published writer and author, training students as well K through 12 education at the Université Charente-Adiope. Hadi, I know that is a very limited and short introduction to a rather complex and a varied career. So if you want to add a few more things about your own profile, that would be wonderful too.
Speaker 3 4:15
I have nothing to add. You've been very generous with your introduction. So no, let's just have a conversation.
Speaker 1 4:21
Okay. Thank you. Martin Klein is almost my age, and I'm going to be 95 in a few days. Marty, how old are you?
Speaker 4 4:36
92.
Speaker 1 4:36
92. Well, we're in the same age bracket.
Speaker 4 4:42
I first went to Senegal in 1963.
Speaker 1 4:47
So I'm going to ask you to kick things off because I think we ought to talk about the past before we start talking about the current conflicts and maybe the future of Senegal. So why don't you start us off, Mari, by recollecting some of the adventures that you had back in the 60s in Africa?
Speaker 4 5:15
Yeah. People talk about them as adventures, but Senegal's not a place where there's adventures. I lucked into some wonderful relationships. I arrived before my wife had to finish. We got married just before I left, and so I went to Senegal alone. I ate my lunches every day at the student restaurant. And if I had a student who came, I was writing my thesis on an area called Sin Saloom, and if I met somebody from Sin Saloom, I would say, oh, that's interesting. I'm writing my thesis on Sin Saloum. And this would often produce an invitation. And I had one of these invitations. I was invited. I was going down there with a guy who was…
Who was probably a bit of a con man, because we never got to his village. And we passed a town called Fatih, and he said, do you want to meet Khardyuf? And at the time, I had no idea who Khardyuf was. And I said, sure. And it turned out Khardyuf was mayor of Fatigue. He was a deputy. He was a minister. And he was also grandson of the local ruler, the Bursin. And he also liked having—and this was true of some Senegalese still at this period, which was only a few years after independence—he liked having two white people in his entourage, quite frankly, because we went into his office and he immediately said, will you stay for lunch?
And it turned out that he didn't have a residence in Fatigue, that he used to eat his meals at the home of the local Lebanese merchant, which was my Introduction to some of the Senegalese local political relationships at the time. And the lunch was an education for me as a newcomer to Senegal. I also met a young man who, when I told him what I was interested in, he said, oh, my uncle is a griot. I didn't realize at the time that meant that he was a griot, because griots are hereditary. But he invited me to stay with, to interview his uncle and to stay in his father's compound where there was a house that was available.
And his father said, It did come down the next week, and his father said, you're welcome to stay here anytime you're doing research in Sin Saloon. And we probably spent about one week out of every month in the home of the Ingham family. And they were our, much of my understanding, But both the meals with students and the trips with students and the time we spent with the Ingum family, Albury Ingum had four wives, one of whom had no children. But 17 surviving children. And we developed a feeling and understanding for Senegalese life, Senegalese values. The sons of Albury and Gum were passionately involved in the politics of the time.
Speaker 1 9:51
You've got me curious, Marty. Are most Senegalese Muslim? Or maybe?
Speaker 4 9:59
Senegal is about, I don't know, Hadi, I'd say probably about 90% Muslim, maybe more. More than 95% Muslim, yeah. And part of Sin Saloon, the Kingdom of Sin, was originally pagan. It resisted Islam for a long time. But the time we were there, it was becoming Muslim. And I think Sin is probably mostly Muslim today. Would you agree, Hadi?
Speaker 3 10:35
Yes, now it's completely Muslim. They still practice the traditional religions, but they are mostly Muslim. But also what characterizes sin is the fact that the Serer would have families where you can have brothers who are Muslim and or one would be Muslim, another would be Christian without any problem. So the Serer are very tolerant. Accepting ethnicity, even in Senegal.
Speaker 4 11:07
Well, Senegal is very tolerant in general. There is a Catholic… Is there a cardinal or an archbishop? There are… Senegal, Islam in Senegal is organized largely in Sufi orders called Tarika. And these… And so that the major leaders of these Sufi orders are very powerful people politically, religiously. And one of them was somebody I did get to meet and spend time with, and this is a man named Ibrahim Nias, who was quite an important international figure. He had a lot of followers in Nigeria. And in fact, the way I got to meet him demonstrated to me the fact that there was tolerance, that the members Others of the different religious orders would visit each other. They would attend each other's festivals.
Albori was a member of a group called the Tijinia. Followers of a man called Moloch See. But he would, he was also accepted at the, at the house And one day he said to me, do you want to meet Ibrahim and Niass? And I said, sure. By this time I knew something about Senegal. And I knew that Niass was a very important figure. And we were accepted at Niass's place. Every time we came to visit after the first visit, A Gambian disciple would quickly materialize. It was a very efficient operation. He would quickly materialize just to make sure that I would understand everything.
Speaker 1 13:39
Let me interrupt because I'm curious about whether or not the experience you had in those earlier years would be replicated today. You spoke of meeting somebody with 17 wives. How common would that be today? He didn't have 17 wives,
Speaker 4 13:59
he had 17 children.
Speaker 1 14:03
17 children, I'm sorry. Still, that's a lot of, that's a family and a half for us. Would that, is polygamy still normative today? Is that something as strong as it was in those days? And in a way, it would be interesting to compare your initiation to To Senegalese society, to Subas as another foreigner arriving, what year, four or five years ago for the first time?
Speaker 2 14:40
More than that at this point. I mean, it's been, I would say probably about a decade and a little more that I've been visiting and going to Senegal and working with colleagues at the university. I mean, I think there's probably a lot to say about Polygamy, we're always very interested in that in the West, you know, it's always the, often the topic that we all kind of glob onto. I think that, you know, not just in Senegal, but in much of West Africa and on the continent, polygamy has had different waves, so to speak, and it's been part of the culture in different ways. I certainly encounter it to some extent.
In current configurations, but in my personal experience, less and less, although I hear a different gen, I'm also in contact with a different generation, and that generation, an older generation, has more stories to share about polygamous families. I would say, and Hadi, you know, please, please correct me, but I would say In my generation, I see it less and less. It doesn't seem to be as prevalent. I think it also is an economic arrangement where certain families in order to survive will be having multiple, a man can have multiple wives that he's then responsible for economically. So that kind of configuration of family life No longer is as needed in the current economic configuration of the country.
So I don't see it quite as much, but I certainly hear about it. And there is a certain generation where I think it was much more prevalent. What do you mean by needed?
Speaker 1 16:36
Some functional explanation for polygamy, that there's… Some particular value in certain circumstances or not?
Speaker 4 16:45
Well, in the cities, large families are not an advantage. And in fact, many of the younger people, younger people, I'm talking about people now in their 70s and 80s, there were people, friends of mine, who believed in monogamy. The oldest son of Albori, my host, was deliberately But that meant that when he ran into trouble with his first wife, he got divorced instead of just taking a second wife. And most of his brothers only had one wife, and one of them had Two wives and a lot of kids. And the city, that involved a problem. And the problem is solved by the fact that people raise—I don't know how you would describe it. Hadi might describe it. A lot of my friends had adoptive children.
There were child-rearing arrangements. The son that had two wives had ten kids, and raising ten kids in the city meant Living in crowded conditions. He had a good job with the bus company. But it was difficult feeding them, finding space for them. And five of the kids were being raised by a relative. But I think increasingly that's very rare. Khadi might want to comment on that.
Speaker 1 18:51
Yes. I think also we need to bring us up to date with issues that are current in Senegal now. And in setting this up, I had a little conversation in which I was given to understand that two of the main political leaders in Senegal now are at odds and having a conflict with each other. Hari, can you talk a little bit about the politics, the current politics of your country, which I think you actually specialize in or at least know a lot about. Give us an overview of what has gone on lately that you are interested in and the issue that divides the leaders of your country.
Speaker 3 19:48
I think that we… To understand what's happening now, you need to know what happened just before they arrived to power. Because the former president of Senegal, Makisal, at the end of his term, A lot of Senegalese thought that he wanted a third term, even though the constitution didn't permit him to have a third term. So you had all these debates about whether the president of Senegal can have a third term or not, and whether Makisal wants a third term or not. And Makisal always said that he had the right to have a third term. But he never said that whether he would have, whether he would run for a third time or not. So he maintained some sort of ambiguity.
And then we had an opponent who were really prominent, Ousmane Sonko, who was the main opponent. Everyone thought that he was the only one who could He was fairly radical as an opponent. He says that he's a sovereignist and that Senegal needs a revolution. So we have this movement with a lot of young people considering that the main problem of Senegal is corruption. There is a lot of corruption in the country and if we solve this corruption and if we stop letting France meddle into our politics and our economies, Senegal would be fine. But in 2021, Sonko got accused of rape. And rather than responding to justice, he said that these accusations of rape were false.
He first said that he'd never been there, then he said, okay, I've been there, but I didn't rape her. And anyway, these accusations are just to stop me from being president. So we need to demonstrate and to even if you need, and he called on the yarn, telling them if you need to die, you will die, or otherwise Senegal would become a dictatorship. So we had…
Speaker 1 22:38
Let me get clear. This guy, this guy whose name starts with an S that you just mentioned, is the particular person who's challenging the president. And the president says he can have a third term. This is a guy who says, no, you can't. And I should be the new president. And then he gets accused of rape. Is that it? Yes.
Speaker 3 23:05
Yeah.
Speaker 2 23:05
Yeah, his name is Sanko. S-O-N-K-O. That's his last name, Sanko.
Speaker 3 23:17
So we had this situation where you have a very popular politician accused of rape. And who said that these accusations are not true and I won't respond to justice and these accusations need to go and blah. And if we need to die, we will die. I mean, if he asked the young to die for that. So we had two years of demonstration problems, etc. And by the end, he got condemned. And he was in jail. He was in jail. At some point, they made a deal. Makisal and this guy, they made a deal, so he got freed. Given that we had elections and he couldn't be a candidate, he asked one of his associates to be a candidate for the presidency of Senegal.
And this candidate got elected. So we have now a president, Bassirou Diomai Sonko, who's been designed by the guy who everyone thought would be president. So when Diomai became president, he designed Sonko as his prime minister. But Senegal is a strong presidential regime. The president of Senegal has a lot of power, let's say. So Sonko became a president, the prime minister of Senegal. For two years, he's been prime minister of Senegal, and he's been impatient, let's say. And he's been, let's say, abusive towards the president. So at some point, the president fired him. And now, given that when the president fired him, he went to the National Assembly and he became president of the National Assembly.
So we've had two years of Sonko being an all-powerful prime minister and controlling the majority party. And when he got fired, he went to the National Assembly, he became president of the National Assembly. And now from the National Assembly, he's trying to Either you can say destabilize the president or you can say control the actions of the president, depending on the side you are in. So there has been a lot of activism, parliamentary activism, since he's been president of the National Assembly. But given that Senegal is a strong presidential regime, When the president doesn't want some law voted, there are technicalities for the government to stop the voting of these laws. So we have this It's a situation where there are a lot of problems.
And in two years, in December, I think, the president will be able to dissolve the National Assembly. But before that, he can't. So, until December, he can't dissolve the National Assembly. So, there are laws. For example, the budget is voted by the National Assembly. There are some policies that need to be validated by the National Assembly. And also, the President has created his party and his Let's say, persuading people from Sonko's party, which is also his former party, to join him in his party. So we have this situation of crisis in Senegal. And also for two years, when Sonko was prime minister, he was a very conflictual prime minister. The rhetoric was that this is not only a change of government, this is a revolution.
So we need to have exceptional measures in order to have a successful revolution. And he attacked Senegalese allies like France. He would attack the IMF. So we still do not have a program with the IMF and Senegal needs a program with the IMF. So the economic situation is somewhat difficult. He promised that he would He would renegotiate all the contracts, notably on gas and oil. So there has been a moment of, let's say, incertitude for the business establishment in Senegal and abroad. The investor didn't come. So the two years have been economically difficult. And you can see the rationality of the president firing him because the mandate was not going anywhere.
But also you have a lot of people saying that the president shouldn't fire the prime minister even though he had the power because his presidency is the prime minister who handled him as a presidency. So this is the situation.
Speaker 4 29:10
I wonder if I can both add something and pose a question. What I would like to add, I think it's important for your listeners to know that Senegal is a democratic society. There are lots of conflicts, but political parties, incumbent presidents have been defeated Many times. Three times? Four times? I'm not sure. I lost count. And furthermore, the presidents came from different ethnic groups. And I may add, when I made the comment that presidents had come from four ethnic groups, one of my Senegalese friends says, four? Where do you get four? And I said, well, Makisal is Tucheler. And my friend said, but he grew up in Fatigue, which is a serrer town. And that's Senegal. There's people intermarry between the major ethnic regions.
And elections are held on issues. And the fight between Diomai and Sanko is a fight over issues. And there is conflict, as there is in all societies. But only one of my friends has ever been jailed. And this is Abdullahi Bachali. And he ended up being president of the National Assembly. None of my friends has ever been killed, has ever been jailed illegally. Senegal is illegal. The only society in Africa I think that is Is comparable would be Ghana, maybe Zambia, though Zambia has been having problems in recent days. It's important to understand this about Senegal, that there are a lot of fights, but they are held according to the law, and elections are basically democratic. Would you agree, Connie?
Speaker 3 31:30
I would agree. I think one of the problems we have is that we have a very irresponsible rhetoric in politics. For example, every politician will say that the man currently in charge is a dictator. So we said that Ablaiwad was a dictator, we said that Makisal was a dictator, and we said that Songko or Jomai are dictators, depending on who is in charge.
Speaker 4 32:05
Or two dictators. Yes. Or two dictators at the same time.
Speaker 3 32:10
Yeah. So, and it's very sad, actually, because given that you have everyone saying that everyone is a dictator, you don't have the rational discussion you should have had. For example, if you take the case of Songko, when he got accused of rape, I was actually on the side of Songko in 2019, and I wanted him to win. But when he got accused of rape, What I said was that if he got accused of rape, he just need to go and respond to justice and someone else will take his place. He has no place in the public sphere now. And everyone was telling me that, no, Makisal is a dictator. So Sonko's accusation, I mean, the accusations against Sonko have no mate. And cannot have merit.
And anyway, we shouldn't talk about it because if we let it succeed, Makisal will still be president because he would cheat on the elections and all this stuff. Even though I think everyone now should agree that you can't cheat on elections in Senegal. So that to me is…
Speaker 1 33:33
Why? Because it's so democratic that you'd get caught if you tried to cheat on elections. That's a remarkable statement. You can't cheat on elections in Senegal because the United States, they're certainly arguing that you can cheat in the U.S.
Speaker 3 33:52
I mean, it's very difficult. I mean, myself in 2012, I was telling my brother that, oh, what will shit on the election? And he was telling me it's not possible. And I didn't believe it. And what he told me and what I saw afterwards, in 2012, I was living in France, then I came back. The problem with elections in Senegal is that elections are organized at the local level and with civil servants. Who preside the voting, the schools where we vote. So after the voting, the votes are counted. And when they are counted, they are proclaimed. And they are counted before everyone, before people in the neighbourhood, but also before representatives of the political parties.
So at the very lower level, you have a count, and the count goes back to the prefecture. At the prefecture, everyone brings the votes, and then they calculate it. And once they calculate it, there is a judge who validates Who is there, who attend, and who validate the calculation. Once he validates the calculation, it is transmitted to the, I don't know whether it's the Supreme Court or the Conseil Constitutional, one of them. I think it's the Conseil Constitutional, but I'm not sure. But one of the jurisdictions So it's pure calculation, which means that whenever we have an election, everyone actually, and the parties do that. By the night, everyone knows who has won, who have won.
And so with this structuration, it's very difficult To cheat, because if either you have, you say that there is this voting booth that has this result, and they will ask you, who was there? Because we vote in schools, and everyone goes to the school, and everyone knows the schools in the neighborhood. So we know exactly who voted and where he voted.
Speaker 2 36:30
Yeah, I just want to add a few things to what you're saying, Hadiwan, is that so much of Senegalese society is this kind of accountability on the local level, which is something that we see. There's less and less of, I think, in our so-called Western societies, especially with the computerization of our voting polling stations, so that there's less and less transparency at the lower levels. And so I think that's one of the things that's really remarkable. And perhaps at the base of what you're saying, which is that if you're going to cheat, you're with your brother or your neighbor right there, right? Somebody who actually knows and who was there.
I also want to say, you know, another thing about what's going on right now is that 76% of the population of Senegal is under the age of 35. Which I think is very hard for us to even imagine and understand what that means in terms of political affiliations. And a lot of what Songkou was able to do was really garner the support for us. A revolutionary position vis-a-vis French presence in Senegal and European multinational presence in Senegal. So a lot of his support was youth saying enough is enough. We want our country back and we haven't had our country back ever. Right, because every president has succumbed to the multinational and the French presence and economic control. So Soncourt represented that.
Now, at the same time, It was only, I believe, in 2024 that rape was made a crime in Senegal. And that's because the judiciary made it a crime. And then suddenly things changed, like families were, parents were going to police stations and acknowledging that their child had been raped or their daughter had been raped. Things that, you know, it used to be a thing of great shame and no one, you know, it would just affect families and women's lives, but no one would talk about it or young people's lives. I mean, so many people can get raped regardless of their gender. And so suddenly there was this awakening. There was this awareness that came alongside this criminalization of rape.
And then shortly afterwards, women came up and said that Sonko had raped them. So that became a great issue of contention because immediately those who supported him and including Sonko said, well, this is all made up. Yesterday, this wasn't a crime. Today, it's a crime. And now it's going to cost me this election. So he went to jail. He went to jail for his crime. And speaking of polygamy, he married again while he was in jail. What he did was just really, really remarkable and disturbing on many, many levels. He came back hoping he would just have, as Khadi said, continued control over his former ally, who now was the president.
And he was only the president because Sonko couldn't become president because Sonko was in jail. So it was just this really shuffling of positions. And I think Sonko just believed that he would still be the de facto president. I think something changed in the last two years, between 2024 and 2026, when Jai Mai Fai, who was, you know, probably the youngest president, right, Hadid?
Speaker 3 40:21
He's very young. He's born in 1980, I think.
Speaker 2 40:27
So this very young president, no one really expected him to take any kind of political stance outside of his relationship with Sonko. And my experience this time going to Senegal was really noting the polarization along economic lines and class lines. So a certain class lines. Of my friends who are now profoundly like their businesses are impacted, who are feeling kind of the danger of Songkoh and his kind of revolutionary stance are very much kind of standing with Ja Mai Fai. Whereas others, the younger people who have always been on the side of Sonko are convinced, you know, that all these rape allegations are false. They say they're only allegations and that Sonko is the real revolutionary leader that they need. And people are really polarized.
And I think one of the reasons I wanted Hadi to speak is because I feel like you're kind of able to kind of cut through that polarization and talk perhaps more Carefully around this topic, but it seems to me, you know, some people, they compare Sonko to Donald Trump, right? That he's this populist.
Speaker 3 41:47
Some people do it positively, actually. Yes, yes. One of Sonko's affiliates was very, he took it as a praise. He said that Sonko is a Donald Trump of Senegal. And he said, just like Donald Trump is making America great again, Sonko will make Senegal great again. And he took it like it's the Capitan Touré. He took it positively. And some people like me, for example, would say that Sonko is really the Donald Trump of Senegal in the sense that he's really ignorant. Of the dynamics of the world, and he has a very simplistic view of the economy, of the economic system.
Because you can, everyone, we all talk about France-Afrique, for example, about the problems of Of fishing, for example, the fact that you have big Chinese and European boats fishing in Senegal and fishing was an important part of Of Senegalese economy, of Senegalese alimentation. And so it is just important for us. Fishing is important for us. And we have all these big boats and all these agreements with Europe. So everyone is asking that to stop. But if you talk to last, I mean, it's two weeks ago, I was talking to someone who is a professional. On fishing, on the industry. And he was telling me, yeah, but you don't know that 80% of the fishing by the traditional fishermen is done for exportation.
So if you stop the agreements With the European Union and with the Chinese, if you do it brutally, these people won't have no one to sell their fish to because the fish they now produce is not the one we want here. And people do not have the means to buy these fish. So the situation economically is complex. Sanko has a discourse which is very simple. France plus corruption, that's the only problem Senegal has.
Speaker 1 44:41
May I ask, first of all, about the fishing? What are the cleavages about fishing? Sanko In favor of a fishing ban or limiting it to fish that are preventing overfishing, I think everybody would say that is key, is what position do these politicians take on that? But also, I'm fascinated by the changing norms about rape and the ambiguity about the Positions both in the U.S. and in probably the rest of the world and certainly from what you're seeing in Africa. Because, you know, the Me Too movement a few years ago was one really attempting to make rape far more serious or even touching, you know, sexually related touching A more serious infraction of social norms. I don't know.
It looked like they were getting there, that women who protested against being sexually harassed or certainly raped were winning the fight, but not when it came to Donald Trump, because it seems that Donald Trump can do anything he pleases sexually. And nothing happens to him politically. Now, is that comparable to what you're saying is happening in Senegal, that the stronger norms of prohibiting rape simply are not having the political impact that they should? Or am I misunderstanding you?
Speaker 4 46:44
Can I introduce a little bit of history here? The first National Assembly after independence consisted of 80 men, no women, 80 men. And Senghor, the rather brilliant poet president, was convinced that partly because Tunisia had a female member of the National Assembly. I don't know if it had more than one, but it had a female. He insisted in the 1963 election that there be at least one female on his party's list. And the woman that was chosen was a woman named Carolyn Fye, who was, correct me if I get anything wrong, Hadi, who was the wife of a politician in his party. And she in many ways became the chief of the women.
So if there was a women's conference in China, she chose the delegation. Senegal has so much changed. My friends had wives who were professionally active. Some of them were in the civil service, some of them were active in different ways. So Senegal went from a position where women We had a very, very limited role in public life to a position where women were active. There are female judges, there are female ministers. Am I right about this?
Speaker 3 48:42
Actually, we've had since around 2012, I don't know the year, but it's after 2012, I think around 2010 or just before, we've had a law on parity. And the law says that in any election, in any elective list, there should be As much men as women, and if the head of the list is a man, the second should be a woman, if the third would be a man, the fourth a woman, etc., etc. And this, for example, We made that our National Assembly now is around 40 or 50% women, around 40, 45 or 47% women. I don't have the numbers, but it's around 47% women.
Speaker 4 49:42
That is a radical change from the situation that existed at Independence. Yeah, of course. At the time, there were a lot of midwives, but there weren't many lawyers. Yeah. I mean, I don't travel much anymore, but until very recently, I attended conferences and whatnot, and the students included large numbers of women, many of the teachers. What I think this means in terms of rape is that there are women expressing women's points of view.
Speaker 3 50:35
Yes, you have, for example, the law criminalizing rape is 2020, actually. And accusations of rape against Hong Kong is 2021. But it's an ambiguous progress because now rape is a crime. But when you got accused of rape, most of the time the judges won't condemn you for rape.
Speaker 4 51:03
Yeah.
Speaker 3 51:04
They will condemn you for sexual assault or they will find a way to re-qualify the facts so that you don't take the 10 years. Because if you take the crime qualification, it's automatically at least 10 years of jail. And that has been one of the problems because Sonko has not been condemned for rape. He's been condemned for detournement de jeunesse. I don't know how to say it in English.
Speaker 4 51:44
Corruption of the youth.
Speaker 1 51:46
Corruption of the youth, yeah.
Speaker 3 51:48
So you have now his supporters saying that he's not been condemned for rape. Okay.
Speaker 4 51:56
Okay. Could I ask a question here? Yeah. There are actually two questions. Where does Diomai get his support from? I mean, he's challenging Sanko. Yeah. Does he have supporters? And are there issues dividing them?
Speaker 3 52:18
Actually, when I told the story, I told it In a manner that was as generous as possible for Sonko. Another way to tell the story is that Jomai is one of the founding fathers of PASTEF. There are those who created PASTEF. Sonko was not one of them. They created the party.
Speaker 1 52:47
Is that a political party, Kasia?
Speaker 3 52:50
Yeah, it is a political party of Sonko's. That is identified with Sonko. But actually it's a group of friends who created that party and then decided to ask Sonko to come and lead the party because he was a unionist and he had already face recognition. So the argument of Jeremiah's camp is to say that Jeremiah has been the driving force Of the organization, of the actual organization of the party. He's selected everyone in the party. He's installed everyone in leadership position. He's been really the main driving force under the day-to-day functioning of the party. And Songko was only the face. That's one thing. Second, actually Songko didn't really choose Jamaica.
Songko had two other candidates, and Jomai decided to be a candidate and to ask for the parrainage. When he got the parrainage, Songko, when Songko went out of jail, he campaigned with Jomai. And the narrative was that Songko is the godfather of Jomai. But historically, if you look at what happened with him, Jomai wasn't really his candidate. So that means that it's not, I mean, we all saw Jomai as being under the leadership of Sonko, but it doesn't mean that Jomai has no legitimacy at all. And he's managing to To have people join him, actually, from PASTEF, the main party. He created his party and you have people from PASTEF who joined him.
You have a lot of people who hate Songho, because Songho is a polarizing people. And these people also, some of them, decided to join Jomai. Because they consider that of the two, Jomai is the only one who can save the Republic. Because Sonko is such a divisive figure, but also such a megalomaniac.
Speaker 1 55:30
Excuse me, that's such a strong statement. The only one who can save the Republic. I haven't heard anything else in… In this discussion so far, that's given me the impression that your republic was really vulnerable to what? Overthrow the government? Fraction of fractionation and polarization and dissolution of the political If you believe that that is possibly true, that only one person can save the Republic, tell me what the bad outcome might be in your opinion.
Speaker 3 56:23
Oh, everyone in Senegal is saying that the guy he supports is the only one who can save the Republic. But there is a real problem also. For example, from 2021 to 2024, Sonko called, effectively called for the army to take power. The army didn't do it, but he did ask for that. He had very outrageous meetings in which he attacked Makisal. And he said, for example, I don't know whether you remember Samuel Do, who got killed by the rebel in Libya. He got publicly killed. He said that if Makisal didn't stop attacking him, he would end up like Samuel Do. So you have these
Speaker 1 57:21
We're now, I mean, we've come to the end of our time, but the plot has… Let me just finish. You've thrown in a heavier storyline than I was expecting,
Speaker 4 57:37
but
Speaker 1 57:38
I don't know. Let's just say that we have to end this. Give me your opinion. Would you agree that either that the Republic depends on the election… of either one of these people?
Speaker 3 57:54
No, I think Senegal is a strong democracy. I think we have institutions. For example, the army in Senegal is an institution. The judges, the judiciary is an institution. The university in Senegal is an institution. We have one of the strongest laws for freedom of expression in the university in the world. For example, when I was head of the union and during COVID, the president of Senegal at the time, Makisal, He said, let's close the universities. He said, we close the schools and the universities. As head of the union, I wrote a public rebuke of the president saying that the president of Senegal has no authority to close the universities.
We agree with him that the university should be closed, but it's not He has no power to close the universities. And after that, he never ever said that he would do X or Y at the universities. He always would say, okay, let's open the school and the minister of higher ed will see with the president of universities whether to open or not. That was the official language of the state after the rebuke.
Speaker 1 59:37
I was getting worried a few minutes ago. But we do have to close now. This is our time is up. And I'm now optimistic that your perception of Senegal as a democracy is something I can count on. And I want to thank you all. This has been so interesting. And I've learned a lot. And I expect our friends viewing this will do as well. Thank you again and hope to see you again one time soon.
Speaker 4 1:00:11
Okay, bye. Bye.
