Episode 784 Global Town Hall Aug 2026

Notes

Metta Spencer hosts an international panel discussing Arctic climate collapse, the origins of the Ukraine war, NATO–Russia geopolitical conflicts and the role in influencing Russian public opinion.

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

war, Russia, Putin, NATO, Ukraine, country, Russian, countries, peace, Pastor, Germany, anyway, Peter, ago, basically, believe, neutral, opinion, big, European

SPEAKERS

Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Metta Spencer hosted Episode 784 of Project Save the World, a Global Town Hall in August 2026, with guests including a pastor from South Germany, Kelly from northern California, Bill Leikam, Alexey Prokhorenko, Andre Kamenshikov, Victor Kogan-Yasny and Erika Simpson. The talk covered the Arctic, the war in Ukraine, and what peace activists could realistically achieve. Spencer began by celebrating her 95th birthday and welcoming newcomers. Peter, an Arctic sea ice expert, reported that his new paper had drawn attention in an Italian newspaper. Bill Leikam asked to receive Peter's publications, and Spencer proposed posting a layman's AI summary on Substack. A guest named Pia said the paper was open access and offered to send the link.

Read more…

Kelly, who hosts an environment show on community radio, said the climate crisis and the situation in Gaza concerned her, and she criticized a congressman for voting to fund military aid. She argued that President Biden could have stopped the war in Ukraine early on but chose not to. Spencer asked whether that was possible without starting a war, suggesting Biden was timid because he feared Russia. Alexey Prokhorenko, a Russian who fled Moscow, agreed with Kelly. He said Biden lost his resolve when Putin mentioned nuclear weapons, and that American arms arrived only slowly after Ukrainians showed they would fight. He said history would not forget this.

Pastor Smith, a Lutheran pacifist, called for negotiations, disarmament and diplomacy, and criticized German military spending. Spencer said she could not see any nonviolent approach that would have worked and asked him for a concrete scenario. He answered that the West should listen to Putin's wish for distance between NATO and Russia's border. Andre Kamenshikov, a peace organizer who had recently left Kyiv for the United States, said the real blunder was the 2008 recognition of Kosovo's unilateral independence, which opened a Pandora's box. He argued that Putin's war arose from his own misconceptions inside an authoritarian system that told him what he wanted to hear.

Alexey disagreed about Kosovo, saying no territory was annexed there, unlike Crimea. He said Putin's 2021 ultimatum was not an invitation to dialogue, so firm resolve could have helped. Pastor Smith recalled hopes after 1990 for a common Europe and proposed neutrality for Ukraine. Alexey replied that this picture left out the right of Central European peoples to choose their own alliances, and that they had sought NATO membership themselves. Andre said Eastern European fear drove expansion, that mutual security guarantees could have been an alternative, and that neutrality can mean very different things. Spencer recalled that she had once opposed NATO but came to accept that Eastern Europeans had reason to fear Russia. Kelly then spoke about unaccounted Pentagon funds and the Epstein files, and left the call.

Andre argued that Russian public opinion still matters, that Ukraine and the West ignore a thoughtful information campaign aimed at ordinary Russians, and that wartime costs were pushing them toward two very different reactions. Spencer summarized Konstantin Samoilov, a former Russian businessman who fled to Tashkent, ran a breakfast club, and broadcast on YouTube until security agents reportedly followed and poisoned him. Alexey said such poisoning seemed credible to him, and he described how hard asylum has become in Europe, citing a young Russian granted asylum in Finland. Erika Simpson, joining late, described a trip to a Chinese peace event and her online teaching. Spencer announced that Project Save the World had become a registered Canadian charity, and the session ended with farewells.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:02

Hi, everybody. This is Metta Spencer, back in business after a little vacation, so to speak, in the hospital. And I'm back and eager to do this Global Town Hall, which is, of course, what we do on the last Sunday of every month. Yesterday, I had my 95th birthday party by Zoom. So you can see flowers behind me and little succulents. That people have contributed to my glorification. It was a great day. Now, I'm recording this, and I think I can let people in now. Admit, you know, they have changed the system. In the waiting room, okay, admit this person and admit Zoom Benutzer. I have no idea what Zoom Benutzer is. And here's Kelly, somebody named Kelly. Good. Oh, we've got some. Hi, Marilyn.

Hi there. Hello, hello. Hello, Zoom Benutzer. And hello, Kelly. So we have some newcomers here. They're not usually on our global town hall. But let me ask you to introduce yourselves. Zum, tell me about yourself.

Speaker 2 1:48

I'm a peace activist pastor in South Germany.

Speaker 1 1:58

Wonderful. Good for you.

Speaker 2 2:00

My name is Smith.

Speaker 1 2:05

You're a pastor.

Speaker 2 2:06

Pastor.

Speaker 1 2:08

Oh, good. And your name is Smith?

Speaker 2 2:12

Correct.

Speaker 1 2:14

So, but this Zoom Benutzer, does it mean, does Benutzer mean something?

Speaker 2 2:23

No, I changed the name. Sorry, I changed it. I tried to change the name. Benutzer is Juzo.

Speaker 1 2:36

Oh, Juzo. Okay. Well, welcome anyway, especially peace activists in South Germany. I'm trying to visualize what are the big cities in South Germany. My map of Germany is pretty hazy.

Speaker 2 2:54

Stuttgart.

Speaker 1 2:55

Stuttgart. Oh, yeah.

Speaker 2 2:57

Big factories, Mercedes and BMW, Mercedes and Volkswagen, Porsche.

Speaker 1 3:08

Okay. And you're a pastor of what?

Speaker 2 3:12

Of a Lutheran church, but I'm very left and pacifist wing of my church.

Speaker 1 3:26

Okay. Welcome, and we'll hear more from you in a bit. I should welcome a couple more people. Here's Kelly. Hello, Kelly. Tell me about yourself.

Speaker 2 3:38

Hello. I'm in far northern California of the United States. I interviewed you many years ago, and I still get your emails. Oh, I see. We're very concerned about what's going on in Palestine. And I focus a lot on the climate and the catastrophe that is unfolding in front of us. I just came to listen, you know.

Speaker 1 4:13

Well, don't listen. Don't just listen. We want to hear from you, too. Yes, I think I remember our interview once. And let's see. They changed the system here on Zoom. So I'm going to try a gallery view. Let's see what happened. Yeah. All right. That'll do for a while. And here we have the top of Bill Leikam's head. Bill and Marilyn were with me yesterday because I was celebrating my 95th birthday and both of them showed up. And I believe both of you had cupcakes with candles on them, right? And we all blew out our candles together. And Peter didn't get a cupcake. So what happened? What happened in Cambridge, England instead? What were you doing yesterday? Well, working like that. Yes.

Speaker 2 5:14

Yes.

Speaker 1 5:20

I sent you an email apologizing for my delay. Okay. Okay. Well, if you were working, we will give you credit because you're doing some of the most important work that needs to be done in the world. Right. You know, really. Peter Bottoms is probably the most influential and best-known writer Expert on Arctic sea ice of anybody in the world. He wrote a book called Farewell to Ice a few years ago. And I have to say, things have gone downhill even since then. I mean, there's been more melting since that book was published. So it didn't seem to have helped much. I published a paper yesterday, which is Apparently, it seems to have had a big impact because I published it in

Speaker 2 6:29

an article

Speaker 1 6:31

in La Repubblica, which is a big Italian newspaper. La Repubblica sounds Italian, yeah. I should give a little more introduction to Peter, because Peter is back in Cambridge, England, where he was a professor of physics, ocean physics at Cambridge University. And he's been retired a while, but he was living in Italy with his wife, who's also an expert on the Arctic, Pia, whose face popped up, but only briefly, I think. And so they wanted to Settle in Italy permanently, but he had a stroke. And I don't know whether that… Did the stroke happen while you were in England or did you go back to England to get treatment? It was while I was in England. So I was laid low by…

Despite having an intense desire to move to Italy, I was forced to stay in England because of… You were forced to stay, yeah. Okay. Okay. Well, anyway, I'm sorry that you're unhappy about that, but I think being stuck in Cambridge, England, would be a great treat for me because it sounds intellectually very stimulating. So you should have had a big impact concerning the loss of the loss of Iceland. And that means for the world. And for some reason, it seems to have struck a chord. It's got about three or four co-authors. And it's made a big impact. So I'm very pleased that that's happened. Except that my conclusions are highly negative. You know, we've sort of had it. Uh-huh.

Which is not good because everybody seems to agree that we've had it.

Speaker 3 8:52

Peter, Peter.

Speaker 1 8:54

Yeah, listen, let me interject and advise people. When Peter's speaking, sometimes his stroke gets in the way. So I advise you to turn on your closed captioning. And all kinds of foreigners. When I get a foreigner, I usually do too. Although not Andre Kamenshikov, who's just arrived. Because he's half American. So he's both American and Russian. But Bill Lycom has been waving, trying to get the floor to ask Peter a question.

Speaker 3 9:34

So the floor

Speaker 1 9:36

is yours, Bill.

Speaker 3 9:39

Peter, whenever you publish anything, would you let me know? I mean, I am very much interested in what you are doing.

Speaker 2 9:48

Why don't you let all of us know? Maybe send to Meta and Meta can send it to all of us.

Speaker 1 9:55

Yes, if that I could do, I'd be happy to. Do you know what we might do, Peter? Let's think about this, because the idea just occurred to me. When I do a talk show, an hour-long conversation with somebody about a technical question, well, anyway, I do it for everyone. Afterwards, I ask AI to give me a synopsis or an article or something, because I might not be able to get it quite right. And AI gives me… I send it a transcript and it gives me a thing which I post. Now what I could do, I'd love to do, is take the article that you published yesterday, get an AI layman's version and post it onSubstack as one of our contributions to Substack.

How would you feel about that and how would your co-authors feel about it?

Speaker 2 11:05

Well, I feel they stick about that, and I'm sure my colleagues would agree with me. Yeah, if I may. Hello, I'm Pia, I'm Peter Swart. Hi Pia. Sideways. Yeah, I mean, let's clarify. Peter actually had published a big paper, With a second author and somebody from Australia, a senior author. And it's all about, it's quite a long paper. It's being published in Frontiers, which is from a Swiss journal. And that is in English. And I can certainly send the link to Metta so she can Spread it around. The latest thing is simply an interview that an Italian journalist that Peter collaborated with for many, many, for many years. And it's basically his comments on the state of the world, the incredibly hot summer that came.

And it just happened to have, you know, the ice… The glaciers of the Himalayas disappearing, etc. And it happened exactly with this Nepal tragedy that happened exactly on that day. So it became very topical to have that kind of comments from Peter. And that is in Italian. So I can easily send you a translation of it.

Speaker 1 12:54

Would I need special permission from other publishers to get to?

Speaker 2 13:00

Absolutely delighted to have everything spread as far and wide as possible. In fact, this paper, the paper, not the interview, the paper is open access. So if you just click on the link that I'm going to send you, then you can just do it and send it to other people, to your groups, the more the merrier, really.

Speaker 1 13:34

I'll post it on Substack, and that way ourSubstack postings go out to Nearly 9,000 computers. And then we have as well, we post to YouTube, which gets maybe 50 or 100 a day, and to our website, which gets several hundred a day. So we get well over 10,000 people receiving whatever we post. But of course, not everybody watches everything. And in fact, the majority, not nearly as many, but it's still a very good way to get information out in a

Speaker 2 14:23

quick way. I'm on my computer at the moment and I hear you and what's going on anyway. So I'll just send it to you. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Can you also post it to the chat? You know, we have a chat in this Zoom meeting also, so you do both. Is that possible? I don't think so. I had to copy it. Oh, okay.

Speaker 1 14:51

I think it'd be better to get a version of it. Let's work out the details of how to best do this later. But a chat, I don't think, would get the coverage that you want. Very few people look at the chat.

Speaker 2 15:05

It's just a practical thing. You know what, Marilyn? Can you put your email in the chat? And I can send it to you. Yeah. Copy and paste from the computer.

Speaker 1 15:22

But also, if we put the publication citation in the chat, that would be okay. There would be very few people who would go and look at it, especially… Thank you so much.

Speaker 2 15:35

This is a good idea and I'm glad Bill brought it up and I'm glad Marilyn

Speaker 1 16:04

Elaborated on the idea. Bill, is that to your liking?

Speaker 2 16:10

Yes.

Speaker 1 16:12

You'll get it that way.

Speaker 3 16:14

Yeah, I put it in there.

Speaker 1 16:16

All right, good. Fine. Well, let's go to Northern California and hear a little bit more about what Kelly is doing. You have a, is it a radio show? I've forgotten what you have.

Speaker 2 16:30

I am the… The low standing person in this crew. I do a round of the environment show on our local community radio. I focus on the climate collapse that we're experiencing. The situation in Nepal is just terrifying to us all. And in a community group that I'm involved with, we think about ways to pressure our local representatives Around what's happening in Gaza, since the United States funds that to a greater or lesser degree. We have a pretty good congressman here. His name is Jared Huffman. And until until he started voting to fund that, you know, I thought the moon rose and set over him. But that has been very sad.

And then the other thing that's on our minds a lot up here is what's going on in Ukraine. And how our government is putting Europe in jeopardy right now through its inaction and putting a stop to this. And that started before Trump in many of our views. President Biden could have stopped that right when it got started. And he chose not to. Well, could he?

Speaker 1 18:02

That's a really interesting question. Could, if the U.S. had taken a different

Speaker 2 18:07

position. It's very cold in that part of the world, and all their munitions and all their supplies were on a train. Trains are fairly easy to derail, and Malcolm Dance was over there. There were covert operations going on over there. So, yeah, that could have been stopped right away.

Speaker 1 18:29

You mean without starting a war? Obviously, Biden was pretty timid because he was very scared about what Russia would do. Your personal opinion is.

Speaker 2 18:50

That's my observation of it. I'm very excited to read your paper, Peter. That'll be

Speaker 1 18:59

It's my next thing to do today, to go and find that. Will they be able to access it, Peter, online, your big paper? Yes.

Speaker 2 19:15

Just click on the link. I can't hear.

Speaker 1 19:20

Click on the link. Click on the link. Yes. So we will send, we can, I don't know, we'll figure it out. All right. Good. But you know, Kelly, about this thing of whether or not the U.S. could have prevented the attack on Ukraine. We have somebody who has thoughts of his own here because he's a Russian who had fled from Moscow, rather than being sent off to kill Ukrainians. His name is Alexey Prokhorenko. And there is another person lurking named Andre Kamenshikov, who no doubt also has opinions about this. I don't know why he's lurking. I sent a message asking him to unmute himself, because you don't know that he's here, although I can see that he really is.

And so both of these people are Russians, although Kamenshikov is both Russian and American. He has dual citizenship because his mother was American, but he was brought up in Russia. So when he comes on, we'll ask his opinion. But first of all, I think I'd love to hear what you, Alexei, think about the question. Whether the US could have prevented the attack on Ukraine in the first place. Hello, Meta.

Speaker 4 21:05

May I just take a second for the most important thing for me right now? The most important thing on Earth is your birthday. Happy birthday, Meta. Thank you. I mean, it's just this fact is dear to my heart that you are here, that you are That you look excellent. You're the most beautiful flower. You have beautiful flowers there, but nothing to compare with you. And that your smile is as kind and warm as always. And I'm really happy to see you. Many happy returns of the day. Happy birthday. I hope you had a blessed one, a warm one, a joyful one. All my heart goes to you.

I've been thinking, these two days, I've been thinking only about you and your birthday, and it's so great to have you here at the helm of our meeting.

Speaker 1 22:05

You are so sweet. Can you imagine anybody sweeter? There's just, I had that kind of accolades all the time. I was blushing constantly at the people saying nice things about me, but I really didn't do it for that. I wanted to hear what my friends were up to. So thank you for that. And Alexander Likotal was present and gave a little toast. And then that allowed me to put him back in touch with an old friend of his, Doug Roach, who was a Canadian… Ambassador for Disarmament, at the same time when Lekotov was Gorbachev's spokesman, press secretary, and was representing Gorbachev's views whenever Gorbachev wanted to have them known. Anyway, that was a lovely day.

And now let's turn back to the question I asked you, because Kelly here has just given her opinion that if Biden had wanted to, he could have prevented Putin from attacking Ukraine. And I don't think I have ever heard anybody say that before. So I wonder what you would think and what you think most Russians would think.

Speaker 4 23:37

Well, most Russians may differ a lot from what I will say right now, or maybe some of them will prefer to keep silent for a number of reasons, first of them being fear. But I fully agree with you, Kelly. Sorry, it took me a little while to start answering your point, but I fully agree with what you said. I'm glad you said that, and I'm glad it was said, because some people think that Ukraine's problems began with Trump. Although it needs to be remembered that, and that's the word, Biden was timid.

Biden was timid and I remember that last visit of Zelensky and his team to Washington DC, I guess it was February 20 or 21, 2022, when they really, when Biden and his team were looking at the Ukrainians Like some doomed man. So, okay, it's your right to resist, it's your right to fight against the aggression, but you're not going to make it. You're not going to make it. You're going to be dead in a few days. So maybe they didn't have a good intelligence on… What the Russians were up to and what they were capable of. Putin didn't have that either. He overestimated his army, his armed forces for that matter.

And of course, I guess Biden was timid later in 2023 when it was time to equip The Ukrainians with all kinds of munitions, with all kinds of weapons to make this summer offensive more successful. Probably it was a real chance to inflict a defeat on Putin and to end the war in 2023, but he didn't do that. And anytime Putin mentioned The nuclear bomb, Biden got paralyzed. He just lost all of his courage as President of the United States and he ceased to be, he lost his resolve that was typical of him at other times. Maybe he was too deeply ingrained in his habits of the Cold War. Maybe he had been scared of a nuclear conflict during the Cold War.

But anyway, he was too easy to impress with that kind of bragging on Putin's side. And let's not forget that The real armament of Ukraine began only after the war broke out, when the Americans saw that the Ukrainians fight and fight successfully, that they have the guts, that they have the resolve to fight back at all costs. And only then, in March, Real shipments began and only very, very, very slowly. I remember how really, how scared they were to amp up the shipments. Let's not give that kind of weapons. Let's not allow the Ukrainians to strike there. They always kept the hands of the Ukrainians tied, at least one hand was tied behind their back. I think history will not forget this.

Speaker 1 27:23

Okay, well, that is one point of view that I'm very interested to know how much you do match the views that Kelly has expressed. But let's go to Germany now, because Pastor Smith is in South Germany. And we have, I don't know when we last had a person participating in our town halls from I may be forgetting something, but that doesn't, maybe, yeah, I know one guy who did, but at any rate, Pastor Smith, please tell us what you think yourself and what you believe most of the German people believe about not only the state of the war now in the situation in Ukraine, but Whether or not it could have actually been prevented by stronger U.S. or by any kind of U.S. actions.

Speaker 2 28:42

There should be negotiations and disarmament and more diplomacy. And the arms race against Russia is not a good way. We have big military build up in Germany, high military spending. This is not a good way. We want to change this, the peace movement in Germany, want to change this way. Well,

Speaker 1 29:36

that's pretty much what I would imagine you might want to do. But the question is not only what you believe in because of your faith and because of, well, A value that I share with you that most of my life I've been so much committed to nonviolent means of dispute resolution that it came as a blow to me to realize that I really could not believe that any Nonviolent action that was available to Biden or any other American would actually have the effect that we would want. I honestly internally great cognitive dissonance, because everything I believe as a peace activist is It looks to me ineffective now. I cannot see how one could have sweet-talked Vladimir Putin into anything.

Now, if you can think of a scenario, an agenda, an image of the kind of conversation that Biden might have had With Putin, that would have had the effect of settling the problem. Please share it because I wish I could believe in it myself. So far, I'm unable to convince myself that it would have been possible. Please help me with it if you think you can do it.

Speaker 2 31:54

Please use easy words and say it again. You want to know nonviolent actions?

Speaker 1 32:10

Yes. How do you believe that Putin could have been prevented from attacking Ukraine?

Speaker 2 32:22

We should… The first is to hear what he wants, really open the ears and talk with him and understand him, really dialogue with him could help He wants distance between the NATO and the Russian Empire, the NATO Empire and the Russians Empire. Putin don't want the NATO as near to the frontier, to the Russian frontier. Okay.

Speaker 1 33:11

I wish Andre Kamenshikov would show his face. He's muted. Oh, here you go. Andrei, you've been listening, no doubt. And you certainly have thoughts. Andre Kamenshikov is a peace organizer. He was, until recently, the head of an organization that Sort of was an umbrella outfit for peace movements in Eastern Europe. And he was based in Kyiv until a few months ago when he returned to the US where he has dual citizenship with Russia. And as a peace worker, We've come down to the nitty-gritty here, this conversation about what might have actually worked.

Could nonviolence have prevented any, could nonviolence have prevented Putin from attacking Ukraine and from without giving him All of the rights to prevent other former Soviet bloc countries joining NATO or doing other things that they might wish to do that he disapproved of. So, Andre, what's your view?

Speaker 3 34:53

Okay, well, a few points. You know, we can argue without, you know, for ages whether history could take this turn or that turn, you know, but that's not really going to change much because I think that if there is something that the West could do to prevent the war in Ukraine and not only that, but many other things, that would be not opening up the Pandora box in 2008. With the unilateral recognition, I mean with the recognition of the unilateral proclamation of independence of Kosovo. That was the first time that in on the European continent since 1945. A territory declared its independence without the consent of the government of the country to which this territory officially belonged to. And that never was recognized previously.

And suddenly the key powers, Western powers, went along with that. And I think that that was the blunder. That's what opened the Pandora box. Now, would Putin do the same thing, you know, 15 years or later, or if that wouldn't happen or not? Who knows? But actually, that's when the Pandora box was open, in my opinion. So, you know… As for 2001, 2002, could, you know, we can guess, someone might say maybe, someone maybe he could, maybe he couldn't. The reality was that this war was a result of Putin's own misconceptions. He didn't think he's going to go into the war. What he did is he created this authoritarian dictatorship where the system basically fooled itself.

He kept spending money various groups, both through his various agencies and Ukrainian politicians that he thought were pro-Russian or pro-favorable to him. And they, to get his money, kept lying to him about the real situation in Ukraine. And it's pretty clear that the War began based on his absolutely, absolute, you know, this conception that had nothing to do with reality. He fooled himself. He created a authoritarian system that fooled him. You know, because everybody on every level tried to give their boss information that their boss wants to hear. And of course, being on top of this pyramid, all you see is confirmation of your own boss. So that's what happened. He was not expecting a major war. He was expecting a short police operation.

Now, for anyone who had some common sense, it was quite obvious, number one, that there's not going to be any short police operation, you know, no way. Number two, it wasn't, it was quite obvious that when you have an invasion army that has a maximum strength of 200,000 people, and you're trying to invade a country with about 40 men in population, With a standing army of over 300,000, you know, and you're expecting a victory in three days, that's not a very rational calculation.

And so for me, I remember those days, you know, I was in Kiev and, you know, considering options for myself and, you know, I I was worried, but I was quite certain that they wouldn't get anywhere in terms of actually taking the capital and so forth. And I think that if I, just being an ordinary person with some common sense, I was pretty confident that that wouldn't happen. I don't know why people in the CIA or in all these think tanks in Washington didn't realize that reality. So I understand why Putin ended up fooling himself. I was surprised that it was such a surprise for people internationally You know, in the U.S.

that, you know, Ukraine stood for its independence and was able to turn around, you know, to a great deal, turn around the course of events. So, you know, again, what does that mean? I think what you need to realize is that often politicians on different levels make decisions that are… Less, I would say, less wise than anyone would make just with orderly common sense. And it doesn't happen just with dictatorships, unfortunately. It happens maybe more in dictatorships, but not only.

Speaker 1 40:33

What really worries me today, and

Speaker 3 40:37

I should say, is that I see the war at a critical junction today because Russia cannot gain, basically can't win anything if it continues to fight the war it has been fighting so far, the way it has been fighting it so far. So it has to either agree to a ceasefire or it has to double down on the war effort. Theoretically, it has the capacity to do that. That's definitely what Putin would like to see.

At the same time, he's worried about what consequences such an effort to double down on the war, to really, he's been for quite a while trying to balance the war effort with the Not making it too much of a burden for the majority of the population, because he is worried about political instability. And right now, he can't really, he needs to make a choice, because otherwise he's not going to get any quicker. And what is happening today is that for the first time in four and a half years, Ukraine has the capacity to respond in kind to what Russia has been doing for four and a half years to Ukraine by deep strikes and really affecting the economy and so forth.

So there's no way Putin can continue to pretend that this war doesn't really affect the majority of ordinary Russian people. What is extremely important at the time is that Ukraine not just It affects the internal situation in Russia militarily, but also Ukraine, and I would say the West as well, engaged in a thoughtful and thought through and coordinated information campaign aimed towards the ordinary Russian people, explaining to them the realities, because if the only message that people are getting Is, you know, bombs and or drones and problems with, you know, fuel, with gasoline, with food and with other things, basically problems and things that make their life more difficult.

And that actually creates a situation where the propaganda can continue to, you know, kind of explain to people and quotes explain that. This is all the result of anti-Russian policies of the West that want to destroy Russia and blah, blah, blah, that shit. And so as a result, the chances that Putin will be successful in doubling down on the war effort, they increase. But the problem is that there's basically zero attempts to carry out a thought through information campaign And, you know, there's a lack of understanding of what public opinion means in dictatorships. The concept is that if it's a dictatorship, then public opinion doesn't mean anything. So why spend resources on trying to influence it? And that's a tremendous and very, very serious misconception.

Because public opinion means a lot in dictatorships, just as in democracies, but it expresses itself in different ways. There are not going to be men and people coming out on the streets of Moscow and demanding a change in government policies, but there are other ways in which public opinion will influence the course of events in Russia. And today, this is a key factor That is basically being ignored, both by Ukraine and by the West. So that's the way I see it.

Speaker 1 44:53

When you say double down, that can mean a lot of different things. And the worst, of course, is the threat that he's issued several times, that he could use a nuclear weapon, a tactical nuclear weapon, maybe one just to show off. Maybe that's all he wants. And it would show off. It would really make an impact. And I guess when you say he has to decide whether he's going to double down or not, is that what you mean? Or are you simply saying he needs to draft or mobilize every young male or even senile male in Russia to fight the war?

Speaker 3 45:44

Yeah, I'm pretty certain that he will not turn to nuclear weapons because that will really sever his, you know, lifeline that he has with China and India, especially today. Well, China, of course, primarily. You know, I don't think that his unofficial patron in Beijing will be very happy with that. So I don't think that that's, and then also that Create so many different uncertainties that I don't think he'll go that. What I'm speaking about is really, look, very simple figure. Today, Russia is spending somewhere under 10% of its GDP on the war. If you look at figures like for World War II, for countries like the United States or Great Britain, That figure was somewhere around 30, 40.

In the British case, I think in 1944, it went up to almost half of GDP. And, you know, of course, that's if you take other countries, then that figure is even greater. Now, theoretically, probably, you know, not half of GDP, but probably you could theoretically, you know, double that figure to like 20%. But what that would mean is that would mean, yes, mobilizing more people, forcefully mobilizing. Right now, they're kind of still trying to pretend that it's basically a volunteer choice. Of course, they put people in a situation where they have little options, but they still try to play this game that, oh, we have army of volunteers.

Number two, it means really completely changing the economic system, going back to basically a level of centralized planning and government control over private businesses and all that. There is a lot of that happening, but still it's a different situation. Number three, it's really taking money out of the pockets of both ordinary citizens and some of the oligarchs, some of his own pronies. Which is, of course, a difficult thing for him because he's not very sure about their loyalty. And things like that. So it's basically changing the economy. It's mobilizing more people. It's really forget about everything else and just focus on the war effort. That's the number one. Everything else is not important.

Basically, it's turning the country completely into a You know, militarized camp kind of. And that's something that, you know, you need to sell to the population. Even if you're a dictator, you are worried because at some point, you know, if this is going to be very unpopular, then, you know, something can break at some point. And then it's like, You know, when glass is under stress, the moment it breaks, it just breaks all around.

Speaker 1 49:06

Hey, let's give other people a chance now.

Speaker 3 49:09

Thank you.

Speaker 1 49:10

I want to see whether, well, who wants to reply? Because I'm pretty sure that either Pastor Smith or Alexei, maybe also our American friend, could speak up and speak. Reply to some of what you had to say. Who wants to the floor? Sorry, I wanted to add one thing. Happy birthday, Matt. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Alexi has his hand up, although I don't know. I don't think Pastor Smith does. I can't see. Anyway, yes, Alexi. Speak.

Speaker 4 50:01

Sorry, I have a couple of things to really say here, which I can hardly keep myself from saying. The first one, I will start with the Kosovo president, if you wish. Well, I see certain parallels and you could Well, in my opinion, you could call it the Pandora box, but in my opinion, only to a certain extent, because there are similarities with Kosovo, a new state emerged on the map of Europe. Yes, that's true. But the principal difference, which… It makes a real precipice between the Kosovo case and the Crimea case and the subsequent war, of course. There is a precipice between those two cases, like case Kosovo and case Putin.

And the precipice is that in Kosovo, no square inch was annexed to a certain country or by a certain country. It was just that a new country emerged. Yes, it was the principle of self-determination clearly dominated over the principle of self-determination. Non-violation of borders. And it was a dubious case, which is why many countries like Spain did not vote for it, did not support it, did not recognize Kosovo. It was in a certain way a doubtful move by the West, an arguable one. But I think it's… Somewhat far from what Putin did in Ukraine later.

On the surface there are similarities and Putin used those similarities on the surface to manipulate the public opinion in different countries and to stress those similarities while keeping silent about the key differences that those cases demonstrate to us. What I could not really agree with is that trying to talk to Putin and trying to convince him of anything and trying to find out what he thinks that it could bring any fruit. I guess not. I'm sure it wouldn't have brought any success because if we go back to The November of 2021, we could remember the ultimatum that Putin sent to the European leaders.

And the ultimatum was that you guys, we go back to 1997, NATO goes all the way back, no matter what Poland thinks, what the Baltic states, the Czech Republic, Germany says, we need the NATO to go back to The Cold War years borders. And that was an ultimatum. That wasn't just an invitation for a dialogue. Putin was sure that he was on the winning side. He was in the right. And what could have helped? So there was a question about whether or not peaceful resistance could have helped. I think yes, because Bluffing or flexing the muscles is also peaceful resistance. It's not like bombing anyone. It's not like attacking any other country or invading any nation. It's just showing the strength, the resolve to act.

I guess some Western leaders, maybe not only Western leaders, but some of the decision makers nowadays fail to understand the key feature of Putin's nature. Putin's personality. He's not really the type of politician that we're used to, the one that sticks to his promises, that one you can negotiate with or make a deal with. He is more of a thug. He's more of a gangster, strong man. Who only, maybe not only, but most of all he understands strength, force, coercion. He is a zero-sum game player. He can be either stronger or weaker. And if the West in 2021 had shown him that The resolve that we will not let you do what you want. It's not going to happen.

We will just fight back if you try.

Speaker 1 55:19

Alexei, I'm wondering if Pastor Smith doesn't believe that he had a reasonable request that what he was asking for was maybe the right thing to accept. You want to speak to that, Pastor Smith?

Speaker 2 55:40

Do you remember the fall of the Iron Curtain, the end of the Cold War in 1990, around 1919? Gorbachev in the German… Minister of Foreign Affairs, Genshaw, they wanted a common Europe, a common, peaceful Europe from Spain to Moscow. The US don't want this solution. They want it to expand eastwards. So, if this is the fundamental problem, the expanding of the NATO eastwards, so the solution Could be neutrality, neutral countries, neutral Ukraine and other countries between Germany and Russia.

Speaker 1 57:12

I know that Andre has his hand up. Are you through, Pastor? Andre?

Speaker 3 57:23

Look, there are two sides to coin. I think that there were many mistakes. Made by Western countries, including, of course, the United States, in their handling of relationships with Russia since the fall of the USSR. But let's face it, it wasn't the U.S.'s intent to expand NATO. It was the intent of the Eastern European countries to be under a NATO umbrella because their rationale is, okay, today Russia is peaceful and weak, but things might change, so we should think strategically. And that was their thinking. And based on what happened afterwards, you can't really say that they were that wrong. Now, this was a kind of a loop. Because what they were doing was creating a reaction in Russia and so forth and so on.

So in a sense, yes, they were thinking about their security, but at the same time, they invariably were kind of pushing Russia in the opposite direction. And we can speak and, you know, books will probably are written and will be written about this whole historical period and have one thing compounded with something else. And when I mentioned Kosovo, I mentioned Anatu. You know, compare, of course, what happened in Kosovo and what Putin was doing are very, very different things.

It was just, in my mind, kind of the last straw that kind of pushed Putin to You know, the conclusion that international order and, you know, all these words don't really mean anything, and nobody seriously considers Russia's position, because before the recognition of Kosovo, Russia was digitally against that, and Russia was on the… Strongly supporting the idea that territorial integrity is paramount to self-determination. That was Russia's position before the recognition of Kosovo. So again, what I'm saying is that we can come up with a long list of things that were done wrong, By Western Europe, by the US, by Eastern European countries, and without trying to understand how this or that event would affect Russian policies. Is that true? Yes. Does that in any way…

Excuse what Putin has been doing? No. Does that really help us today in finding answer to the current situation? Well, to a very, very minor level, maybe we can say that, yeah, if Putin If things change, that old mistake shouldn't be repeated. And, you know, we need to just like, you know, people after World War I thought that that was the end of all wars, at least in Europe. And, you know, that lasted for very long. And after World War II, it seemed for quite a while that better, better conclusions were made out of that experience. But who knows? But…

Overall, I am a little concerned that when we start speaking today about various past mistakes that definitely were there, if that kind of draws our attention away from the current realities and, you know, we start thinking in historical terms, you know, where did we turn wrong, you know, 20 years ago and so forth. And there were lots of wrong turns, but, you know, we need to deal with what we are facing today.

Speaker 1 1:01:14

Thank you. Okay, Alexi, you had your hand up a while ago. Do you still want the floor?

Speaker 4 1:01:21

Yeah, I would just say a couple of words about… Sorry, Pastor, if I didn't get you absolutely right, but what I collected from what you said is that you mostly are talking in terms of NATO versus Russia, the NATO empire versus the Russian empire. But I'm afraid what is absent from your equation, from your… This picture is the right of these countries between Russia and NATO, the right of the Central European countries like Poland, Czechia, Slovakia, Hungary, Ukraine, Belarus and the Baltic countries to determine their own fate. The right of their peoples to choose the alliances they enter into, because Andrei was, for what I remember, Andrei was right.

It was the initiative of those peoples to join NATO in the 1990s, because they had had a history of oppression by the Soviet Union, by Russia, And they wouldn't be willing to repeat that. And that's why they addressed the NATO bodies, the NATO organization, to allow them to join. It was not that the US forced them to do so. And as Andrei has said, the subsequent history has proven them right. They now have the umbrella over their hands, so Russia does not bomb them. So how would you respond to this absence of those nations in your equation? Maybe I got it wrong. Sorry if I did. Thank you.

Speaker 2 1:03:22

We should have advised the Ukraine to remain neutral. More security is neutral. More intelligent would be neutrality. As Switzerland and other countries, Finland… Okay.

Speaker 1 1:03:56

So, remain… Neutral? Suppose all the world remained neutral. I'm not sure what that would amount to. What would that be like? Do you think the US ought to become a neutral state? Do you think China, do you think Russia should become neutral?

Speaker 2 1:04:23

Mainly the Ukraine should be neutral. And this could be the solution.

Speaker 1 1:04:35

Say it again. What is the solution for…?

Speaker 2 1:04:40

For the Ukraine neutrality. How you spell this?

Speaker 1 1:04:44

Neutrality. Neutrality. You're saying neutral, fine. I'm just not sure what that would look like. At one time, I did think about that. And there was a position taken called the Minsk decision for advice, which was not followed. And it would be interesting to speculate about what that would have entailed. But I see that Andrei Kaminschukov has his hand up again. Andre, you help us think through this one.

Speaker 3 1:05:32

Yeah, look, well, first of all, you know, we're very wise now. You know, all we need to do is to get a time machine and to turn things back 30 years and then we'll do everything right. So I know now what could be done right 30 years ago. The response to the requests of European, East European nations or Central European nations for Joining NATO could be, the response could be without formally expanding the NATO bloc, engaging in maybe mutual security agreements with these countries. That's something that, by the way, is on the table right now when there's any discussion about a diplomatic solution to the Ukrainian war. So basically provide the same guarantees, but don't wave the flag around.

Maybe 30 years ago, that would be a wiser decision. But again, this is all wishful thinking. We don't have a time machine. And so decisions were made. Were they the wisest decisions? Probably not. But we do not have a time machine. We can't change that. As for neutrality, I don't know if you folks know, but I know of one country that officially, in their constitution, and even in the UN, has been recognized as a neutral country. And that's one of their key features. Their number one newspaper is called Neutral, and then the name of the country. Does anyone know what that country is? The country is called Turkmenistan. It's probably a dictatorship that can be compared only to North Korea the way it is.

But they love to speak of how neutral they are. So, you know, the term neutrality in itself can mean very different things. And what it can mean for a dictator is, you know, leave me alone. I'm totally neutral. I'm not fighting. You know, I'm not messing in your business. And you let me do whatever I wish with my own people. So, you know, you need to understand that neutrality, there are different forms of neutrality that exist in this world. And not all of them are that positive.

Speaker 1 1:08:08

Interesting. I remember at the end of the Cold War, I had reason to be in Vienna, no, in Prague for a conference. And I'd been working with people from that country, especially in the Helsinki Citizens' Assembly. An organization that brought together dissidents from communist rule and occupation, in effect, and Western peace activists. And so I knew a lot of these people and was very familiar with them, had visited them in their homes. And then we had this big meeting and suddenly I found all of these Czechs and Slovaks and Other organizations, people from other organizations who had been dissidents and pro-democracy, and they were all speaking about eagerly joining NATO. This was at a moment when I was advocating the abolition of NATO.

I thought, since they have abolished the War Trial Treaty Organization, we should do likewise and abolish NATO, So I was astounded at the eagerness of the people that I had formerly known. And I stood up and said, I thought I knew you folks. Obviously, I didn't. And there was no solution to that. There was no answer to that. They actually were very keen to join NATO. And they did. And right now… I know why they wanted to. I mean, it's clear they had experienced something I hadn't been through, and it was something that gave them every reason to fear Russia, whether or not Russia had a WTO on its side or not.

So I don't know at what moment I changed my mind, but for practical purposes, I did believe… I came to the view eventually that these Eastern European countries did have reason to be worried about being absorbed or attacked and that they probably did need to take measures of some kind that involved military preparation. Whether that would be joining NATO, which I still remain nervous about expanding. And I might have been very happy to see a solution that would have actually involved a statement of neutrality instead. But certainly I did come to the view that they had good reason to be afraid. And that, I think, has been borne out. Who wants to take issue with any of these statements? Yeah, Kelly.

Speaker 2 1:11:37

So I am not prepared or educated well enough to discuss all of that history. But what I want to sort of point out is that the hand is being Dealt by a dealer who may or may not be acting in our best interest. And it's important to realize that when the U.S. Pentagon gets audited, up to 50% of the money that it is given by Congress is unaccounted for. And a lot of that is going to intelligence corporations that are doing who knows what kind of work. And we can look at the history that unfolded with Trump's two impeachments that had to do with Ukraine to get an idea of the kinds of nefarious things that go on.

And I want to point out to this international audience that people who are researching the Epstein files are finding that the trafficking and abuse of women is… A very small part of everything that was going on and that that seems to have been a honeypot trap in order to control U.S. and international politicians through blackmail. And I won't go into the… The long version of it, but you can follow two reporters, Zev, Z-E-V, Shalev, he's Canadian, and a woman named Ellie Leonard, and they talk about these things in detail.

The reason I bring it up is that we're seeing through that the U.S., Russia, and Israel are all linked behind the scenes, and they have the ability to Maneuver people into doing things that you guys are talking about kind of the details of that put us into wars that we don't really want, that that's not where we're headed. And, you know, how do we unfund these dark ops?

I don't know the answer to that, but I think that it's important to look I mean, the past has many lessons for us, but as we're trying to move forward, it's good to also understand the current state of operations and how a lot of this is being manipulated, how we, the millions, are being manipulated by the hundreds, you know, by the few people. So that's what I needed to say. The other thing I needed to say is I have to leave now, you guys. I'll hear what you guys have to respond in the recording. And thanks for… This has been very… Yeah, it's been very educational.

Speaker 1 1:14:47

Thank you very much. I wish you could stay a little bit and talk more about how you imagine the US and Russia are linked. I can understand how you see…

Speaker 2 1:15:02

I would not do as well to educate you on that as Zev Shalev and the Epstein files, Ellie Leonard and the Epstein files. I think that after those become more fully understood and digested, that we will all have a better idea. I think that you can get some small understanding looking at the history of Trump's first impeachments where he's sending people to undermine Zelensky before he was elected, that you see that Michael Flynn, who was Trump's first security advisor, was in Russia sitting at a table with Putin. There's photographs of him there. You see that in this war with Ukraine, the main negotiations are going on with Putin, not with Zelensky. This hasn't been the main policy of the State Department.

Obviously, that's not the history of our State Department, but it has been going on. Behind the scenes. And those behind the scenes people have worked and succeeded at getting a character like Trump elected. And they are, you know, Project 2025 has really moved that forward, that element of our culture.

Speaker 1 1:16:42

Fascinating. Well, I'm weak minded enough to be easily swayed in your direction. You don't have to work for me. Very hard to convince me that Trump has had some peculiar ties with Russia that have never been fully explained in any of the official studies that have been done. You know, that impeachment study and so on. Never did really clarify what I think has to be true. That there is some kind of, either they have him by the throat, somebody has him by the throat, or he really is part of their game. But all I can say is I will look up the references to these people that, oh dear, there's a nurse coming up here to see me. I know what's happening.

And I've just cut her off. She's going to ring again. And I've got to let her in. And you guys are going to have to talk in my absence. Because nowadays I have a nurse that comes every day. And this time she's coming at the wrong time of day. So you can keep this conversation going among yourselves without me if she, can I let her in? I think I can let her in.

Speaker 2 1:18:13

So those two folks that I mentioned are on Substack. And when I was looking at to make sure I was getting their names right, I see that new reporting on those Epstein files and their international connections is trending right now on Substack. So it's easy for people to maybe bookmark a couple of articles rather than dive through those individual reporters that I named. You know, because in Substack, they get off on the personal stuff, and, you know, it can go all over the place.

Speaker 1 1:18:45

I look it up. Alexi, you run the show while I'm gone.

Metta Spencer 1:18:52

Okay?

Speaker 4 1:18:54

And he's a task anyway. Okay. And so, let me just… Maybe anyone wants to say something to… So someone wants to add something to what we have been discussing? I mean, lots of ambiguous, tricky questions that really have no answers. Really, we can only make informed or less informed guesses. Yes, Andre, please. Go ahead, please. Thank you, Kelly. Thank you for being with us.

Speaker 3 1:19:41

I just wanted to basically ask a question because we can discuss history forever, but we can't change anything in the past. What concerns me is that is there any way to try to get across Through the media, maybe, through any sources that could have an impact. The simple idea that right now is an absolutely critical time for developing and sustaining an effective information policy oriented toward the Russian people in general that would help At least to some extent, to resist the propaganda that most of them have to face in their daily lives. Because in reality, the way things will turn in the next months and years, in the coming months, I think some decisions will be made before the end of this year.

Depends on what people, what ordinary people hear and think in Russian cities, towns, villages, et cetera. And unfortunately, this task is being almost completely ignored today.

Speaker 4 1:21:33

Well, that would certainly be a good idea to try to appeal to the hearts and minds of Russian people, not to leave them alone in their in their situation of being subjected to propaganda but that's a tricky that's a tall order that's a it's a tricky tricky task because the FSB and the giant security apparatus which Putin has in place will do everything to prevent the Russians from Knowing the opposite, knowing any point of view that's not coherent with what the television says and what the propaganda says. So, they know, the KGB knows that people being deceived, people being tricked is key to their survival. So, please, Pastor, it's your turn, thank you.

Speaker 2 1:22:47

No, the problem is also the propaganda in our western countries, the propaganda about innocent western countries, the propaganda, the narrative of the innocent NATO

Speaker 4 1:23:15

Yeah, Andre, please. You have something to reply to that. Please.

Speaker 3 1:23:27

Yeah, yeah. Look, NATO isn't innocent, definitely. West isn't innocent. The reality today is very simple. For the first time in nearly five years, Most ordinary Russian citizens are waking up to the reality of war. For most people, the war only is beginning today when they have to stand hours and hours to And then pay very high prices to refuel their car and things like that. And their flights to a resort in Turkey or Dubai is delayed by half a day because of the threats of drones and things like that. And the critical issue is what kind of calculation will these people be making in their minds? And there are two options. The number one option, option number one is that, gosh, this is insane.

This war is insane. It has to end. And we don't want to deal with this. And let's just this war end and something like that. And basically, a general negativity to the war. The second calculation is that, gosh, this is insane. This war needs to end and so forth. And we really need to mobilize today and to support our government because that's the only way we can end the war is by winning it. These are two different, radically different calculations that people are making today. When they are facing the realities of war that are now coming, that are knocking on their doors. And whether enough people make the, you know, what decision they make will determine to a great extent.

Whether this war is going to stop or at least freeze, whether it's going to be a frozen conference or something like that, or will it just expand and continue to consume even more human lives, lead to even more human suffering, consume more resources and destabilize not only the region, but destroy not only the countries directly involved, but Really destabilized the world. That's what is happening today. And the problem is that nobody is really trying. There's many, many things that are not being done because the prevailing concept is that it's a dictatorship. Public opinion doesn't mean anything. And that's absolutely wrong. And that's a strategic mistake being made today.

Speaker 1 1:26:30

Thank you. Appreciate that. By the way, one person who might have joined us but did not and who is known to both Alexei and Andre is Konstantin Samoylov. And what I want to point out is that Konstantin You've met on this online with me several times. He's become a good friend. He is a Russian who was a successful businessman working in a company that made big hydrodoms and things. But when the war began, he totally disapproved and And when the mobilization began, he left the country in a hurry and went to Tashkent in Uzbekistan, where he's been living ever since with his family and broadcasting on YouTube. It used to be seven days a week. Lately, for some reason, it was not.

He has missed quite a bit, but I can explain. When he went there, he found Tashkent was full of other Russians who had also fled to avoid going to war. And who were just as stunned and perplexed by their new situation as he was. So he started a breakfast club for the Russians in Tashkent. And if somebody didn't have the money to pay breakfast, he would pay for it. And so, is my fool? No, sorry. Anyway, he's been broadcasting by YouTube. Every day, and he has something like 3 million followers. He did at one point.

But he has found out, because there's somebody who was actually part of the operation, who felt good about liking Samoilov, and they had told him what was going on, that the FSB, or what it used to be called the KGB, was… Interfering with his business arrangements with YouTube, and indeed, they got him cut off financially, so he's no longer making money from these YouTube events. But not only that, he found that he was being followed by FSB people that he could recognize, and they were not hiding their face at all. In fact, they came to One of his, at least one of his breakfast club meetings joined in. And they made it very clear that they were following him.

And he continued doing what he was doing, which is saying extremely critical things about Russia or about Putin, anyway, not about Russia so much. But this criticism was not ignored. And he got sick. And he thought, I don't know what he thought he had, but it turned out not to be. So he went to hospital and they put him in a room. And the minute he got to his room, the phone rings. And this FSB person in charge of his case said, how are you feeling? And he said, well, who are you? And he said, you know who I am. So we would like to invite you to join us and work with us instead of what you're doing.

So Constantine knows that other people have been poisoned and that's what was happening with him. He was poisoned and sent to hospital. He was there for a week or two, but he's shown his face And some shows since then. But he has indicated that there's some news cooking and that he'd like to be able to share what is happening with him. But he can't yet right away, but he will. And maybe even today, if you look up his show, which is called Inside Russia on YouTube, This may be the day when he tells us what's going on. I have a guess, but I won't share it. I shouldn't share it because it might endanger him. But I think he's leaving Uzbekistan.

He's been trying for a long time to get papers to move especially to a European country. And I don't know whether this is what has happened, but I certainly hope so, because he has the opinion that if he's working out of Russia, I mean, out of a European country, and very few of the European countries will accept anybody from Russia now, people are not allowed to go. I mean, Alexei can explain to me, to you all, But I think it's really tragic that Western people are not really eager to meet Russians at the airport with lays and garlands of flowers for leaving a country that is doing what it's doing.

And so I hope that he's found a place that will let him in and that that's what the The news that we can expect is. Alexia, do you want to comment on this? Does this seem any of the theory that they would actually be poisoning Russians outside of Russia? Does that have any credibility to you?

Speaker 4 1:33:09

Yeah, I can, I'm eager, I'm very willing to believe that, to believe that some people like Konstantin might be poisoned now and then, and I really think he should have left Uzbekistan long ago because, as we all know, Uzbekistan is part of The former Soviet Union, which means that even now many of the special forces officers in Russia and Uzbekistan and other 13 republics, okay, 10 republics minus the Baltic states, they went to the same KGB schools, they share the same mentality, and they are more willing to cooperate than not. So, which means that no person who is in the former Soviet countries is in absolute safety.

Most people like that are in danger and so I strongly hope that he manages to escape to a country where he can feel safe. Really, It's true that it's become tougher to get asylum in the West, not only in the United States, which has virtually closed itself to any asylum seekers under Trump. Europe has also become, unfortunately has grown tired of asylum seekers, of migrants and in many countries, There are forces, like in Poland as well, there are forces who call on the government to curtail migration, to not accept asylum seekers, to do something to limit people who seek protection. But I know of a certain case it happened Maybe a couple of months ago, one young Russian who had a very peculiar history.

He managed to escape into France as a dissident, but he was not granted asylum in France. Although he was persecuted, he had a real chance of going to prison if he were to be sent to Russia. But France did not, France was really, in fact, willing to deport him to Russia, and only the court stopped that deportation. And then a miracle happened. He managed to travel to Finland, which is… Everyone was telling him that don't do that. Don't do that because there is such a thing as the Dublin procedure under which you have to only apply for asylum in the country of your first arrival. If you arrive to Croatia, you ask for asylum in Croatia. If it's Greece, then Greece.

If the first country of your first contact with European soil refuses, then that's it. Then you just go back to your country. But he managed to do that, he managed to go to Finland against all odds, he managed to go through a very difficult and tricky procedure and a couple of months ago he got an asylum status in Finland, meaning he started to learn the language, he can stay indefinitely in the country, he got the protection. But that might have cost him a lot of nerves, a lot of gray hair, although he's just, he's 25 or something. I guess he has gone through tough times, but…

Theoretically, it's possible, and I hope it's going to be possible for Andrei, especially if he can prove that he can… Of course, it needs to be understood that the officials, the migration officials in Europe are lenient. They understand that you can have the proof for everything, but if he can substantiate his claim that he could have… They tried to poison him, which is quite credible to me. I'm almost sure. I have no doubts about it. I have no doubts that the KGB do that. They have their own mindset, their own procedures to choose whom to poison. Such a formal, such a former officer, KGB officer as Skripal, who no one would be interested in.

An old man living somewhere in a small British town, but they decided he was a traitor and he had to pay for that. So practically it wouldn't be any use poisoning him, but from the KGB standpoint, from their mindset, it made sense. So you never know.

Speaker 1 1:38:43

Well, here comes Erika Simpson. Just in time to probably, we can change the conversation a bit. Erica, hello dear, glad to see you. You're coming late, but we're…

Speaker 2 1:39:02

I had perfect difficulty because I couldn't copy from your poster your ID number. And I've never had that problem before. And I ended up learning that you have to type in the meeting ID number. So I had the two screens. Anyway, just me. I had that. You've got that new poster and I can't do it.

Speaker 1 1:39:22

Okay. Well, you're here. That's all that counts. Happy birthday. Thank you. I had a wonderful birthday, and I'm still enjoying the remnants of it. And I'm very, very glad. Anyway, we have just been talking a lot about the Russian situation. Pastor Smith here from South Germany is, I think, Pretty much really a pacifist. Would you call yourself that, Mr. Smith? Would you say that you're a pacifist? Yes, of course. We've been talking about very basic questions, like how far can you expect nonviolent interventions to be effective? And we had until what I think I just heard a thing click.

And I wanted to, I was about to turn back to Andrei Komenchikov and invite him to talk about his exit from Russia because he's a Russian who left the country 10, 12 years ago as a peace worker. And was living in Kyiv until recently. And we've been having a conversation about what happens, what may happen to Konstantin Samoylov, who's gone in bad terms with the KGB or the FSB. And so Alexei is also someone who fled from Russia to avoid the war, and first went to Istanbul and then to Warsaw, where he is now. And I wanted to introduce, or not introduce, but go back to Andre Kamenshikov, who just now clicked off, so I think he's gone.

Because he is a dual citizen of Russia and the US. His mother was an American who married a Russian. And he was mostly brought up in Russia. But he has family in the US and often goes there over the years. So he speaks good English and is very comfortable in the US. But for the last four years or whatever, Since the war has been going on, he's been working to try to persuade the Ukrainian government to invest a lot of their attention into influencing public opinion in Russia, which they have not been willing to do. He has ideas about how they could do so.

And eventually, I believe a couple of months ago, a few months ago, He left Russia to move back to the US. I don't know whether he's ever lived there before, but now he's in the US, I think, and will be looking for work and probably giving up his previous occupation as the organizer of a peace, international peace movement of peace activists in Eastern Europe. And I wanted to have him Bring us up to date about the difficulties that are faced by other Russians who leave and who criticize Putin. So since Andrea's gone, Alexei, you're the only Russian left here. So you need to tell us about your own history. And Alexei, Erica, you may know Lexi from previous times.

Feel free to ask him questions or offer your own opinions, other Erica. But, Alexa, give us a little quick synopsis of your adventures as an expatriate. Yeah.

Speaker 4 1:43:54

Well, I had really been a dissident for two decades, and I have been trying to convince, to do exactly that, to convince people to do something against the regime. And then I had to leave after the war broke out. I've been trying to To do some anti-war work for seven months, after which I decided that it was becoming too dangerous for me and I left for Istanbul and now I'm based in Poland as a political refugee. So that's to make the long story short.

Speaker 1 1:44:42

Thank you. And now we have been joined as well by another Russian, I believe, Victor. Hello.

Speaker 2 1:44:52

Hi, Mehta. My greeting and congratulations to you.

Speaker 3 1:45:00

Very, very, very warm. So it is a little bit late now in Moscow. Unfortunately, I should leave your meeting, but I switched on to tell you my warmest congratulations. All the best to you, all the best.

Speaker 1 1:45:27

Thank you. I'm very happy to be back in touch with you, Victor. This is Victor Kogan-Yasny, who is a strong member of the Yabloko Party. Which is the only party I would have ever voted for if I were eligible to vote in Russia. He's calling in from Moscow where he lives. I presume you're in Moscow now, is that right? And we have just been talking about the situation of Russians who leave and visibly and audibly and publicly criticize Putin and Russian policy. And one particular friend of mine you had a dispute with about two or three years ago when you called in on a town hall meeting and another person, another Russian was here named Konstantin Samoylov. And the two of you locked horns.

Speaker 2 1:46:31

All the best, all the best to you, all the best. Thank you. Okay, all the best to you.

Speaker 1 1:46:36

You have to go, is that what you're saying?

Speaker 2 1:46:38

Yes.

Speaker 1 1:46:39

You have to go. Well, thank you very much for chiming in, and I hope you have very good wishes. Give my good wishes to all of the Apple party members, the Yabloko Meters, and to all my old friends. I can't be in touch with many of my Russian friends. I think they would not appreciate being put in danger. But Victor has more nerve than most of my friends because he calls in. Okay, thank you, dear Victor. Okay, bye. Yeah, Erica, what's happening with you?

Speaker 2 1:47:26

I'm doing well, Mehta. I'm going to China. And so the next town hall, I'll report back. I'm invited by the Chinese Embassy in Canada to be the Canadian rep to be at this celebration of the International Peace Day in Wuhan and also in Beijing. So we're going first to Beijing. One person, they say there'll be 250 people. So I don't know who the person from Russia or from China or not China, the United States will be, I'm curious. But I'm going, because I've spoken a few times at the Chinese Embassy in Ottawa, and because I'm the president of the Canadian Peace Research Association, and also I'm on the board of the Canadian Network to Abolish Nuclear Weapons.

And of course, I've been a board member and the former chair, vice chair. Well, it doesn't matter what all these things are, but basically I've been doing work on peace. So I want to thank the pastor for your work in South Germany and mention to you that I have a very good friend, Rudy Zimmer, who's just written a three-volume book on the life of his father during World War II and his mom. And I'm asking him to, he's going to, he speaks German, but he's 91 years old and his German is not good enough. So we need someone who could check the Translation that could actually understand English and then check the German that it was absolutely correct.

So if you know of anyone, it's a book on pacifism. It's actually, the title is pacifism. So he has published it in Canada, self-published it, and now You know, at this age, Rudolf Zimmer, I would like to find someone in Germany who could check the German. So I can check the German. And Rudy can check the German, but we need someone who could check it for sure that it's been translated by chat correctly, by AI. So it's all going to be translated. Anyway, so when I come back, Manta, I'll talk more. But right now, I don't know much at all about the conference except for that I have to be there for nine days.

And it's endless workshops with Chinese diplomats and then a gala dinner to celebrate peace on the International Day of Peace.

Speaker 1 1:49:49

Wonderful, wonderful. Is your daughter in China now?

Speaker 2 1:49:53

She is no longer in China. She's actually in Whitehorse. She's returning. My daughter's been traveling everyone for four and a half months through Asia by herself with a backpack. So her mom is looking very much forward to seeing her when she returns.

Speaker 1 1:50:11

It's certainly a brave young woman. And then,

Speaker 2 1:50:14

of course, my son works for Amanda, and that's why I was annoyed about the poster, because I was saying to myself, My son is screwed up here. I can't get in. What has he done? I wasn't mad at you, Matt. I was mad at the poster.

Speaker 1 1:50:26

No, it's not your son. It's my fault. I didn't think about the fact that a poster is not live. I could have written something below, which I didn't do.

Speaker 2 1:50:37

I think that's why you have fewer people, because there'd be a lot of frustrated people. There's a link, but the link does not work. And so finally, I laboriously typed it in. It was the first time I've typed in a meeting ID number in a couple of years.

Speaker 1 1:50:54

So you're representing the Canadian peace?

Speaker 2 1:50:58

Yeah, the peace movement, not the Canadian government. But it's organized by the Chinese Disarmament and Peace Organization, and then clearly closely with the embassy, the Canadian embassy.

Speaker 1 1:51:11

Pastor Smith, do you know anybody in Germany who's going to this event?

Speaker 2 1:51:18

I'll get the program when I arrive. It'll be interesting to see who they think is representing Germany, who the Chinese think represents Germany for peace, for this one, for this thing. It'll be a very interesting list, a program.

Speaker 1 1:51:33

I'm sorry, you say you'll get the program when you arrive?

Speaker 2 1:51:37

No, the list of speakers. I've got the program already, but the list of speakers, I'm curious who the Chinese think are peace leaders. In the world. It'll be interesting to read that. I don't know who will be. I have no idea. So anyway, I'm getting ready for that meta, and that will be an exciting trip. But in other news, I'm just getting ready for my huge courses. You guys, I teach online three large courses, 1,000 students in each class with waiting lists. It's a lot of work.

Speaker 1 1:52:17

Can you imagine a university professor with 3000 students?

Speaker 2 1:52:23

Well, last year I had 4,800, but then the chair decided that they have to write an in-person exam for the final exam, and there's not enough classrooms to do for 2,000 students. So anyway, the university is always trying to figure out ways that professors can teach more and more students, and going online is obviously the way to go, so… I'm curious, I don't want to talk much longer because our time is nearly up in nine minutes, but I assume you have gone around and spoken to everyone, Mehta, and I don't want to hog the time.

Speaker 1 1:53:02

Yeah, well, I just don't know how you can mark papers if students actually write.

Speaker 2 1:53:09

Oh, it's all multiple choice. That's why there's massive cheating. Because it's very easy to cheat now. In fact, we just got a letter from the dean saying that in our course outline, we now have to specify that they cannot wear glasses That have the capacity to tell them the answers. I don't know what these new glasses are. But if they have a prescription, they have to be able to show us the prescription. And if they wear a baseball cap, it must be backwards. They're not allowed to wear a baseball cap like this because somehow there's some new cheating software that they can use. So we literally just, I have to put that in my course online. No baseball caps and only prescription glasses.

Speaker 1 1:53:56

It's amazing.

Speaker 2 1:53:57

It means that all the young people are being pressured to cheat because the people who cheat are getting close to 100%. So AIs will get 100%. AI is amazing, as we all know. So AI gets 100%. So some of them are deliberately making a few errors so that they're not in the cohort that's gotten perfect marks. And some of them for their essays are deliberately, they'll rewrite the essay and say, make this sound more human. Add some mistakes.

Speaker 4 1:54:29

That's tragic, tragically amazing. Yeah.

Speaker 2 1:54:34

This book I'm talking about, Alexi, is about the family and Poland during World War II. He ended up in Auschwitz. He ended up surviving in Auschwitz. It's an amazing story of a pacifist. He survived in Auschwitz for, I vote, six months at the end. There's a whole bunch of things that he did to survive. Crazy.

Speaker 1 1:54:56

That sounds like a story that I want to read but shouldn't take our time for now. We're getting toward the end of our visit, but if anybody has other issues that you, oh, I have something to tell you. Oh, good news. Project Save the World has been applying to the Canadian government For the past several years, about three years, working to set ourselves up so that we could get eligibility to be a charity in Canada. And we just got an authorization. We are now a charity. So we can do fundraising and probably even get a nickel or two here and there. Because people will give money if they can deduct the donation amount from their taxes.

So that's going to be the truth from now on. And it's been a really big struggle to make it happen. And I'm really thrilled about it. And of course, now we have to Learn a whole bunch of new things about how to be extremely rigorous in keeping our records and all that so that we…

Speaker 2 1:56:29

Yeah, Amanda, on that topic, because I was the treasurer of the Canadian Pugwash Group and we're a charity. We are a charity. I was the treasurer. Now I'm the chair of the Investment Committee. Are you going to get an audit done or are you going to get the whole audit done because they now are around $6,000 even if you don't have much revenue?

Speaker 1 1:56:49

No, I don't think we won't have enough revenue to be required to. But we should be very, very careful about keeping receipts and not mixing different kinds of funds together, bank accounts together and that sort of thing. Alexei is coming back with us. And there's another thing that we have to be careful about. And that is we must never, never, never take position in favor of a Political candidate or a party. We can, and we have to be very careful about what we actually do by way of advocacy, advocating particular positions on things. I still don't understand fully all of the nuances of how you can go wrong. It's not a simple matter, but okay.

Try to get smart enough to not make a big mistake and say something to one of the parties that I approve of you and I endorse your candidacy. That would lose our status. Bang, right? One word like that.

Speaker 2 1:58:11

I think the only thing you have to worry about, Mehta, is that they do an audit. So they did an audit on the United Nations Association and Having an audit done on an NGO is extremely stressful and very time consuming for everyone concerned. So the key is to get a good bookkeeper who knows how to deal with the government and a treasure and all those things. So it's a constant worry. It's not losing charitable status. It's the audit that they come in and they audit and they go through everything and you have to have done it absolutely correctly.

Speaker 1 1:58:48

Well, we have an accountant, a CPA, and I hope that's good enough because I don't want to spend $6,000 more.

Speaker 2 1:59:01

Well, that's a round figure. Like, I'm just quoting round estimates right now, but we in Toronto are looking for another auditing firm now in order to lower the cost. So we're going to probably move. I shouldn't say this on television because I don't know if it's recorded, right? So… But just keep that in mind now that you are. Congratulations. A registered charitable with registered charitable status.

Speaker 1 1:59:24

Do you think that makes much difference in fundraising?

Speaker 2 1:59:28

No, no, except for legacies. So if there's a legacy, and most of the money from Pugwash is from four legacies. So a person who wills their estate, they want the estate to have a charitable return. So then they will give a larger amount of money. So that's why it's very important. It's the legacies. And the audit is actually important too, because a person with a large amount of wealth will want to see the audit. But I won't say all the people that we were given money to, but in the realm of $300,000 or $400,000 by individuals.

So that is where I would like to see Project Save the World is to get some legacies, which means somebody has to die and give them money before they die. So you can create legacies, like Murray Thompson has the Travel Award. Well, I guess my own donations are probably a legacy. Yeah, it will be a legacy if you arrange your affairs properly. And then we can do named things, like we do a named Eric Fawcett. We have a lecture series. William Epstein. Doug Scott, we do a tremendous amount because he gave us his entire legacy. So, something to think about.

Speaker 1 2:00:52

Okay, well our time is exactly up, and it is 3.59pm, and so I get to say goodbye to you. Thank you, Pastor Smith, for joining us. It has been an extremely valuable conversation, I think. And I wish you every success in bringing peaceful suggestions or peaceful solutions to this terrible crisis. So blessings and let us see you all again in a month, the last Sunday of September. All right?


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments