Notes
Metta and CUNY professor David Lee discuss health communication, exploring media influences, vaccine misinformation, and the complexities of language in public health messaging.
Guests
- Metta
- David Lee
Video
Podcast
SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
communication, book, sense, true, therapeutic, better, community, COVID, false, health, risk, person, vaccinated, vaccine, vaccines, basically, big, effect, goal, guess
SPEAKERS
David Lee, Metta Spencer.
SUMMARY
David Lee and Metta Spencer took part in this episode of Project Save the World, titled Talk About Health. Metta noted that David is a professor at the New York City College of Technology and that he once worked at the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta. David said Metta's book Two Aspirins and a Comedy influenced him, since it describes how media can bring pleasure, belonging, and even health. Metta explained the title: identifying with a comedic character reproduces that character's emotions in the body, so a doctor might prescribe a comedy. David then turned to the negative effects of media, particularly misinformation.
Read more…
David recalled coding calls to the CDC hotline during the 2009 H1N1 swine flu outbreak, when public information needs were high. He argued that official reassurance, such as a 2020 CDC statement downplaying COVID-19 risk, proved falsely comforting, and that risk communicators should amplify risk rather than downplay it. Metta countered that people often deny frightening information, citing residents who returned to their homes after a Mississauga gas leak despite warnings. David replied, drawing on Kim Witt's research, that fear appeals backfire unless people are given something to do, which gives them a sense of self-efficacy.
On vaccines, David said appeals can present protection as benefiting family and community through herd immunity, and that people resist messages that feel paternalistic, a response he called psychological reactance. Metta described a friend's relative who was gravely ill after a COVID vaccine and who saw refusal as a matter of freedom. David discussed Andrew Wakefield's 1998 autism study, which was debunked and retracted, and said controversy drives clicks on social media. Metta raised AI-generated videos of Bill Gates promoting a product, and David agreed such fakes should be illegal and that platforms faced pressure to add community notes.
The conversation then moved to placebo and nocebo effects, which David described as communicative phenomena, and to speech act theory, which Metta linked to an Oxford philosopher. David said his forthcoming textbook examines patient-provider communication from a patient's perspective. He questioned whether communication is automatically therapeutic and preferred cultural humility to cultural competence. Metta said therapy's benefit cannot be taken for granted and that Rogerian listening is extremely simple, and she proposed a later talk about emotions, which David accepted.
Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.
Speaker 1 0:03
I met a Spencer. Well, you know, I don't think there's another person so far that I've interviewed in this series of shows to whom I can say, I attended your second birthday party. But I attended David Lee's second birthday party. It was in his grandmother's backyard. And we all had a good time. And I don't remember the cake, but I bet there was a cake too. So hi, David. How are you?
Speaker 2 0:31
Fine. How are you, Metta? Great to see you.
Speaker 1 0:34
Good. And we haven't been in touch all that time in between your second birthday party and just now when you introduced me to your wife. But now you are a professor at the City University of New York in what I don't recognize. It's a special university dedicated to technology. Is that right?
Speaker 2 1:01
It's the New York City College of Technology. It's one of the CUNY colleges. And my field is communication. And we have started a program in health communication.
Speaker 1 1:18
That's where you come in. I knew through your mother that you had been working several years at the, is it the Center for Disease Control in Atlanta?
Speaker 2 1:29
I did spend one year there. It was a big influence on me. Yeah.
Speaker 1 1:35
So that tilted you toward research in communication about health, right? Yeah, indeed. Well, we had a brief encounter on your mother's phone a while back, and I decided, boy, I want to know more about that work. So tell me what you're up to.
Speaker 2 1:55
Great. Well, thanks for that intro. And indeed, I have known Mehta since before I can remember. And one of the books that you wrote, Mehta, that had an influence on me was called Two Aspirins in a Comedy. And that book is about how we derive pleasure from the media. And not just pleasure, but… A sense of belonging or a sense of satisfaction. And we were talking earlier about how the media can be a source of health, too, because it could be comforting to meet up with your favorite characters and identify with them.
Speaker 1 2:47
David, I'm not going to probe you. I don't want to talk about my book. I want to talk about yours. Sure, sure. Or you've got two in the works. But what I do want to maybe explain worthwhile is how the title to Aspirin of the Comedy, what that means. Because one of the things that I was exploring in that book is the fact that when we identify by empathizing with a character, Then we actually replicate in our own bodies the emotions that the characters have. And the emotions involve hormones and all kinds of chemical things and matters that actually have an impact. So I can imagine a time when I might go to the doctor and say, I have, you know, I'm not feeling well.
And he or she checks me out and says, well, You know how we have the thing about go home and take two aspirins and call me in the morning? Well, I could imagine a doctor saying, go home, take two aspirins, and watch a comedy, and then call me in the morning. And so that's why I named the book Two Aspirins and a Comedy, because I think that we can actually get health benefits or detrimental effects, because I know that if I watch a horror show, Boy, it does horrible things to my body. But other people I know just love horror shows, and I don't know why. Anyway, I want to say, let's not talk about my book, but let's talk about yours.
Speaker 2 4:24
Okay, because I'm about to segue. So my segue is that communication is about emotion, and it's about… Affirmation of previously held beliefs. And it's not necessarily so true that it has to be true or false. And so while you're looking at the positive effects of media, I'm looking at some of the negative effects. And particularly, I'm interested in the issue of misinformation. So around vaccines is a great example. While I was at the CDC, I coded calls to 1-800-CDC. And we wanted to know, what is the public asking about H1N1? That was when H1N1 made its big debut on the world stage. And this is 2009, 2010. So a long time ago, but I've been dining out on this experience ever since.
Speaker 1 5:31
Now, hold on. That seems awfully early to me.
Speaker 2 5:37
Yeah, so we're not talking about COVID, we're talking about the last big one, which was swine flu, H1N1.
Speaker 1 5:43
Swine flu, okay.
Speaker 2 5:45
And one of the things that's interesting is that people wanted to… They had very high information needs, and that's typical of any pandemic or crisis, is that people's need for factual information is higher than normal because they need to know things like, is there a vaccine? Where can I get the vaccine? Should my children stay home from school? Can I avoid pork? To avoid getting swine flu, you know, can I still eat bacon? People had all kinds of questions like this. And what it made me realize was that we put our faith in public health officials and, but we don't always have the right technical language to talk about it.
And so It seems to me that in the case of COVID-19, we had kind of a backlash. We had anti-vaxxers. Anti-vaxxers are of course among us and have been long before COVID-19, but now they really had an impact during our previous pandemic. And it didn't help that official sources were Questioning the efficacy of vaccines. And there's a quote from the head of the CDC at the time who said, I think in late February 2020, that at this time we don't see a significant risk to the public. Six months later, There were half a million dead from COVID-19. So it's an example of risk attenuation, of playing down the risks.
And of course, the president at that time, I know that you're in Canada, but I live in the US talking about that. The president of the US said, don't worry, all this will go away in a couple of weeks. And so it turned out to be falsely reassuring. And one of the cardinal rules in risk communication is that you don't want to overly downplay the risk. If anything, you want to heighten the risk. So they talk about risk amplification. It's better to err on the side of being Extra cautious and people not getting sick than it is to be under cautious. And then people can come back later and say, you didn't warn us about this. You're the public official that we're trusting.
And we weren't properly warned.
Speaker 1 8:55
Well, but on the other hand, I've never taught or read much about In the area of disaster research in sociology. So I don't really know what I'm talking about. But my strong impression about what those people have hammered at us about is that there is a definite tendency for people to deny scary information. That if you can go up and down the street with a bullhorn on your car, The police saying, run for your lives. There's a dam about to break and we're going to all be swept away. And people will shrug and ignore it. And I think, you know, at one time there were, I was on sabbatical at the time, but away.
But there was some sort of big gas leak from a train wreck in Mississauga in Toronto. And They did exactly that. They tried to evacuate everybody in the, I guess, in Mississauga. And people sneaked back in to get back into their houses and stay there, despite being warned how dangerous it was. Now, that to me is crazy. I mean, but isn't it the normal thing that people do?
Speaker 2 10:23
Yeah, it's interesting. I've looked into that a little bit, too. And, you know, there's something called fear appeals, where you appeal to people's sense of fear, and you warn them about the dangers of being exposed. So it depends on if you say that there's a risk that exposure to this chemical will cause long term health problems, or how in detail you want to go. And those types of fear-mongering tactics don't tend to work. So people have what's called a counter-persuasive reaction, where they sort of deny what's happening. So the people's capacity for denial is quite amazing.
Speaker 1 11:13
But how could you warn them, you'd better damn well take this vaccine if you know what's good for you, without… Implying that if you don't, there's a lot to be afraid of.
Speaker 2 11:26
And that's what I was just getting to is that there's a professor named Kim Witt, W-I-T-T-E, and her research into fear appeals found that people will have a counter-persuasive reaction to fear appeals unless you give them something to do. So people want to have something to do in response to a threat. And so if you make it clear that you can help your community by making sure that people without cars evacuate with you. So if you sell it to people as this is going to be beneficial for the community, And you give them a sense of feeling useful, whether they really are or not, that has a positive effect.
And so if you take a fear appeal and you couple it with something they can do, that gives people what they call self-efficacy, which is the sense that, you know, I have some agency in this situation and I'm not just a hapless victim.
Speaker 1 12:46
It's brilliant. How can you do that with vaccines? I mean, you can't, I can't help my neighbor. Oh, you might say, well, why don't you check and see if you can help your neighbor get to the hospital and take a vaccine or something? Is that what you want? Or is it sufficient to simply say, there's something you can do for yourself. You can get vaccinated. Is that enough action?
Speaker 2 13:16
And it's not just for yourself, right, but it's for the herd immunity. So there's people within the community that are immune compromised for some reason, and they might have respiratory problems and they can't actually, some people are allergic to vaccines. So if other people around them are vaccinated, that provides some measure of protection for them as well. The thing about vaccine appeals is that you can sell it in that way. If not for yourself, then for the people in your family. If not for yourself, then the community around you. And people are more inclined to see it as this isn't selfishly self-protective, but it's altruistic in some way. And I'm actually Helping the public health response.
But when it comes to the anti-vaxxers, that's another story. They really have their own pitch and their own appeals. It's become highly politicized.
Speaker 1 14:33
Well, I don't spend enough time understanding people who are outside my bubble. But I do have a dear friend who has a relative who actually did get sick. From the COVID vaccine, very ill, very close to death. And she, to my great surprise, does not see vaccination the way I do, as I think of it as a duty, you know, exactly because it does protect other people. Right. But she sees it as a matter of freedom. If you believe in democracy and freedom and everybody has the right to decide for themselves, et cetera, and you think that you might have inherited a gene that makes you susceptible to some risk from this vaccine, then it's your obvious right to decline it.
And I think it's not, or if you do want to decline it, you've got some… As long
Speaker 2 15:52
as people in your circle or in the community have been vaccinated, one person might be able to sneak through because they're protected by the other people, ironically. So it's an exceptionalism that, yes, it's fine for them, but not for me.
Speaker 1 16:14
Well, but is that part of the discourse? I don't talk to anti-vaxxers, not as a matter of intentional avoidance, but I just don't know any except this lady. And I don't know how they think. How do they get around the reality that you have to have a certain percentage of your friend's Vaccinated in order to be safe, this herd effect.
Speaker 2 16:48
Yeah, the herd immunity. And sometimes it's called community immunity because people don't like the zoological connotations of the herd, you know, that sounds. But people that are, the fact is, is that it is a probabilistic thing that whether or not you're going to catch a disease Or whether or not you're going to have a side effect. And it's not unheard of, you know, like in one book chapter that I wrote about vaccines, you do see serious allergic reactions. Sometimes, you know, one in 100,000 or, you know, eight in a million, that type of thing. So it's extremely rare, but it does happen. And remember, we're talking about inoculations going on in the tens and hundreds of millions and billions of people.
So imagine the billions of people that had to get vaccinated for COVID for, you know, for that level of immunity to be reached. And I think, to your question, like, how do you get them To understand that, the science is a little bit complex and you need to be able to think in terms of probability. And the other thing is that that sort of libertarian attitude of it's my body and I'll do what I want, you know, I'm an
Speaker 1 18:23
American, damn it.
Speaker 2 18:26
That goes a long way and it could even be pushed to extremes where Just the very fact that somebody wants me to wear a mask is a great affront to my sense of liberty. And in the literature, it's called psychological reactance. When you tell people what to do in a very paternalistic way, I'm wagging my finger here, then they react negatively. And they say, hey, don't tell me what to do. I'm my own person. So the task for the communicator is to say, to encourage people to do something in a way that doesn't impinge on their sense of autonomy.
So sometimes you could, instead of telling them you need to get vaccinated, you can say it indirectly, like those who are vaccinated are better protected against COVID, against COVID. Not COVID, because you can still get COVID after you've been vaccinated, but the hope is that it will result in a less serious outcome when you get infected, that it won't be as bad.
Speaker 1 19:50
Okay, I can see that. So what is the… The usual pitch of the anti-vax people, how did they try to, they succeed, so it must matter, they succeed in convincing a lot of other people that they should not vaccinate their children. And that is, you know, they're doing it not just with COVID, but all kinds of vaccines that refer to COVID. The possibility that kids get autism from, et cetera. Is there any kind of evidence? And is there any basis for that argument?
Speaker 2 20:38
Yeah, great question. Well, I'm not an epidemiologist, but I have looked into it. And there was one paper that came out, I believe, in 1998 by this guy, Andrew Wakefield. That found a link between vaccination and autism and it was the sort of the linchpin in this whole anti-vaxxer movement and then it turned out that it wasn't a very good study and the sample size was really small and there were controls that it was kind of a naturalistic setting so there were no controls for Other confounding factors. You gotta figure with something like autism, the hypothesis of unicausality is gonna be tricky because kids are exposed not just to vaccines, but all kinds of other things, just air pollution and different ingredients
Speaker 1 21:40
and foods.
Speaker 2 21:43
And so the difficulty in determining that causality Is that it's probably multifactorial. But anyways, this guy Wakefield was pretty soundly debunked by the scientific community. And in fact, the journal that it came out in, which I think was BMJ, had to retract the publication. And yet the anti-vaccine movement was thriving. And there are a lot of products that are sold. For anti-vaxxers, things like chelation therapy or colloidal silver. These are kind of folk cures that allegedly prevent diseases. So there is some momentum behind it that way. And there are also people that get views because It figures that controversy sells. And I think a lot of people on social media understand that.
That just by saying something controversial, like Bill Gates is trying to microchip you when he puts that, when you get a vaccine. That's something that's, wow, so outlandish that you click just to find out what they're saying.
Speaker 1 23:12
Is Bill Gates really doing that or is that just a lie?
Speaker 2 23:15
That's just one of those outlandish.
Speaker 1 23:19
You know, that's one of the things that I've seen lately that really freaked me out. It was a video of somebody trying to promote some kind of cognitive, you know, keeping Alzheimer's away kind of treatment. And they had a long video. It was like half an hour long or more. With Bill Gates pitching for this product. And it's, boy, it looked and sounded real. And it, because they had, you know, they can do it. They can take an image of a person and wiggle it around and make their mouth synchronize with their voice and take their voice and make Same real voice sound. It really, really was convincing.
So I went on to AI to find out and found out that it was a fraud, but it's quite hard. Now, I think that kind of thing should be absolutely illegal.
Speaker 2 24:26
Yeah, I do too. And there's no shortage of that type of thing where you can see someone, a public figure that you recognize endorsing some product or Stating, making claims that they don't otherwise make. And you can do it very realistically through AI.
Speaker 1 24:45
Well, now you are, as an expert on communication about health, you in a position, if you could get together with some other people doing some kind of research, to really, with your credentials, with your authority, make a campaign to… Make such lies and misinformation illegal and make them at least label it, this is faked. If they want to look at it, I mean, go ahead and look, but they should know that what they're seeing is not true. And I don't know whether anybody is actually working on making that kind of legal change take place.
Speaker 2 25:38
Yeah, and there are people that are out there doing it. They're putting pressure on tech companies to have more safeguards in place to avoid this kind of thing from spreading around. But the problem is there's a perverse incentive for the social media companies because anything that's getting clicks, anything that's gaining traction, is something that they're making money off of because they're getting it. Advertisements in front of more eyes. They're kind of tempted to look the other way when this kind of stuff is going around. However, people did pressure them into putting what are called community notes on social media posts.
And so if you object to something, you can tag it as clarification and you can put your own two cents in about why this is false or why this is…
Speaker 1 26:43
I haven't ever seen one. Yeah. I mean, and I watch a lot of YouTube videos. Yeah. But I have not seen anything, even questioning the validity of some of these stories. And of course, it's not just ones that do these fake images and fake voices, but they make up stories that are absurd. Yeah. Yeah, I just yesterday had to apologize to a friend because I'd sent her something, a video that I had caught watching on YouTube of a place in Canada that allegedly was produced, you know, 15,000 years ago. And they found this ruins of a temple or something. And to me, it looked just like Angkor Wat and wherever that is. It was clearly an Asian temple. And I thought they were claiming it.
But no, they didn't actually claim that this was in Canada. It's just one of the images that they put in among all the others that, you know, some of which were real. And they were talking about how 19 or 20,000 years ago, there were people living in Canada. And I believe that. But give me some better evidence than things that were made in Angkor Wat.
Speaker 2 28:07
Yeah. And sometimes the excuse is, well, we wanted something illustrative of what it might have looked like. So we went into AI and we gave it a prompt of like, please create a picture of some ancient civilization, you know, and then they use that. And yeah, I mean, photo, photo realism used to Be this kind of indubitable evidence that we had, like, look, it's on camera, it's on video, but that's gone. There's nothing like that anymore. So any photographic evidence in the form of still pictures or motion pictures just can be dismissed right away as, well, that's just AI.
Speaker 1 28:53
They just
Speaker 2 28:54
managed to make it up.
Speaker 1 28:56
Yeah, but it's serious because, I mean, this could kill people. If you get misinformed about, for example, how to avoid Alzheimer's, I mean, you know, whatever.
Speaker 2 29:09
And it preys upon vulnerable people, too, because people that are, you know, on YouTube and you see an ad for a certain kind of cancer cure, and you're kind of motivated because, let's say, the person has cancer. And so you're motivated to buy into this. Well, it's only $20. I can at least buy it. So I think there's a big risk from pharmaceutical drugs who market their products very aggressively. But I almost think that there's a lot of so-called folk cures or new age cures that might be dubious as well.
Speaker 1 29:56
Yeah, I'm one of the big consumers. I'm really open to all kinds of possibilities. Yeah, me too. Do you? You actually go and buy that stuff. I have shelves full of pills that I once bought. Now I've forgotten what it was for because I don't stay with it. I guess that's saving grace. I've probably saved my life by it. Forgetting to take pills.
Speaker 2 30:23
There used to be if you had a sign of a cold, you would take these little sugar pills. It was called Ocilococcium or something. I used to get that and I swore by it. Because supposedly you take these, you put it under your tongue and it could avert a serious cold or respiratory infection. But I have no idea if that was just the placebo effect. And speaking of the force of communication, the placebo effect is probably one of the most amazing examples.
Speaker 1 31:01
Right. OK. You know, I've never had a conversation about that. I have no idea how it works or why it works, but I know that it does work. That's what I've read. So explain that to me. And how do you understand that? What's the mechanism?
Speaker 2 31:22
Well, I have a hypothesis about it. And it's speculative. But to me, it's the fact that people give this to you and it's someone you trust. And they say, here, take this. It's good for what ails you. And to the extent that you want it to work, it does work in some way. And so we're talking about the power of some authoritative source giving it to you and saying, you know, this is going to make you better. And it's almost like you want to believe it. And so my view on it is that When it comes to the placebo effect, and then there's the nocebo effect, which is kind of the opposite of that. That it's basically a communicative phenomenon.
Speaker 1 32:27
I'm sorry, nocebo is, this is going to make you feel worse?
Speaker 2 32:32
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1 32:34
Why would anybody tell everybody that?
Speaker 2 32:36
Right, right. Well, let's say a competitor has a drug. That you don't want people to take. So you go on a message board and you say, this made me feel terrible. And just the power of suggestion. People could read that and say, well, I don't know if it's true or false or if it's common, but just now that I've been exposed to that idea, I can't stop thinking about it. So it suggests that people are…
Speaker 1 33:06
But I think it might have something to do with That sometimes, if you're looking for subtle changes in how you feel, it's kind of hard to tell. You know, I was in the hospital for a month, and it just got out a month ago. And people are always asking me, well, do you feel better now than before you went into the hospital? I stopped and I think, and I don't know. I might feel better now, I might feel worse. I'm not feeling that different. So I kind of equivocate, you know. But that's not, if somebody had said, you see how much better you feel now than before you went in? Aren't you feeling energetic? I can see you.
You're hopping around and you're looking much livelier. I'd say, oh yeah, I might very well say, yeah, yeah. I guess I am better.
Speaker 2 34:08
Because sometimes we don't even know ourselves because we can't see ourselves. We can't see our own ears. So we definitely take cues from how we're regarded by others. If someone says something like that, that's a form of evidence that would suggest, yeah, maybe I am really doing better. And I think communication is a very social thing that we We build our sense of reality from what other people say and the things that we read and the things that we hear, et cetera. And in that sense, we're very dependent on communication. So sometimes we talk about events in the world as if we had some unmediated access to it.
But in fact, we're getting the news story from the nightly news or Or from CNN or whatever, or MSNBC or whatever our source is.
Speaker 1 35:15
I just yesterday watched something where a guy was talking about how he had miscreated reality. That when he was a child, there was a bomb that landed in their backyard or something. And he describes it because he was in London during the Blitz. And he describes what it looked like and all the reactions people had and on and on and on. And then he talked to his brother and his brother said, you weren't even there. You were away at boarding school. And he had made this whole thing up because he heard about it. And we can fill in things and as if we had really… He says, I think I… It was as clear to me as other memories that I had. Fascinating. Yeah.
Speaker 2 36:14
That it took on the status of a memory. It was that real and that rehearsed in his own mind. It turned out he wasn't there.
Speaker 1 36:23
Communication is a force.
Speaker 2 36:26
Yeah.
Speaker 1 36:26
And it really affects our lives in ways that, I mean, you went back to logical positivism as a contrast. I think other people would like to hear you Is that part of your book, your forthcoming book?
Speaker 2 36:39
Yeah, it is. And thanks for asking about it. And it's a little esoteric, I suppose, but the idea with logical positivism and the Vienna Circle philosophers was that we want language to be exact and we want to look to the sciences as a form of exact communication. And so you can make true or false statements, and really that's what communication should be, is true or false statements about the world. But there's other forms of statements which are value judgments, and technically that's not something verifiable, and so we should just ignore that type of thing.
And so obviously I'm oversimplifying, but There's a famous line in a book by Wittgenstein, it's the last line of Tractatus, and he says, about that of which we cannot speak we should remain silent. So basically that philosophy doesn't have any opinion whatever on moral issues. And I think that that was found to be pretty impossible. I mean where do you go from there? So there's been a lot of criticism since then. Incidentally, like I was just finding out about how there's philosophers like Elizabeth Anscombe and Philippa Foote who were at Cambridge or maybe Cambridge or Oxford. Yeah, they were at Oxford. And that they kind of brought moral philosophy back in and say, look, you can't think that. Those types of statements are meaningless.
It just doesn't make sense. And so the reason I talk about it is because there was like the ordinary language philosophy which came out of that says, well, that's not all we do with communication. It's not just about depicting things or representing things, but we also do it to express our emotions or we communicate to tell someone what to do. We give orders, we give commands, and we do things like make promises. And you look at those type of statements, like a promise, like, I promise to visit you next weekend. Like, is that a true or false statement? Well, by itself, it can't really be evaluated by that criteria.
And then supposing you didn't show up the following week, And you could say, well, that turned out to be a lie. You promised that you would come, and you didn't. But still, the promise, just by committing, just by saying those words, you're actually making that promise.
Speaker 1 39:45
Actually, I think it was John Cyril who refers to that as speech acts.
Speaker 2 39:51
Yeah.
Speaker 1 39:51
He was an Oxford philosopher, and I took a course with him.
Speaker 2 39:54
Oh, yeah?
Speaker 1 39:55
Yeah. And I remember, you know, he would… He had a whole category of speech acts. I mean, for example, to say I do in a wedding ceremony, you better mean it.
Speaker 2 40:10
Right.
Speaker 1 40:10
Because there are consequences of saying that, you know. Yeah. You can't take it back. If you want to try to take it back, it's going to be a challenge a whole different way.
Speaker 2 40:22
So whether you do or don't, it has consequences because basically you've committed yourself to this. To this marriage, this relationship.
Speaker 1 40:32
Yeah. Yeah. Anyway. So you were talking about logical positivism. And is it, you say, Philippa Foot and Anscombe. Anscombe, yeah. The ones who brought moral philosophy back into play. Is that right?
Speaker 2 40:52
Yeah. And, I mean, it's always interested me. And the field, the Parallel field in linguistics is called pragmatics. And they basically talk about how people use communication to arrange to make social arrangements and things
Speaker 1 41:13
like that.
Speaker 2 41:14
And it's not always stating what's true or false. But if you're the president and you say something's true, that has a big difference from just somebody Who doesn't have that kind of institutional authority to say something is true or false. Oh, well, what do they know?
Speaker 1 41:35
Are you as an accredited scientist?
Speaker 2 41:39
Right.
Speaker 1 41:40
Should you got more authority than the next door neighbor maybe?
Speaker 2 41:45
I used to think that was a good criteria that someone can speak with greater authority if they've If they're a scientist and they've studied this issue. But with this sort of, there's kind of a backlash against intellectualism, which has been written about ever since the presidential candidate. They asked him, well, are you the thinking man's president? And he said, no. Well, I want to win a majority here in this country. Adelaide Stevenson, I think.
Speaker 1 42:28
Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2 42:29
Yeah. And so, but basically, I have a phrase in my book, I talk about the layosphere, and it's sort of a neologism that where lay people are on equal footing with specialists, And this is a very democratic concept, you know, that my opinion is just as good as yours. And so you don't want to be elitist about it. But at the same time, people that talk about vaccines being harmful, you know, I'm more inclined to believe an epidemiologist who studied this topic. And Ultimately, I don't think all opinions are equally good.
Speaker 1 43:25
No, but you know, there's a whole movement, I don't know whether to go into this, because I don't know whether I can get out of it alive, this kind of proposal to talk about the way I think biology is actually moving in the direction that we would, you and I probably would both prefer, that is recognizing That this non-physical moral dimension is serious and real and should be paid attention to. Because there is research now showing that different cells, for example, have goals. But there's a guy named Michael Levin who works at Tuff University and has a whole research outfit in which he says, you know, we're surrounded by minds and millions of minds that, you know, way more minds than we recognize.
We only recognize minds that are sort of like us, but you need to be thinking about the minds of animals and And, you know, cells and components of your body because they have goals. And if you get in their notion, his notion is that intelligence, which is the basis of minds, intelligence is the way William James defined it. It has to do with if a person or even a cell has a mind, that a goal that it's Programmed to do or ready to do or it's really its goal and you get in the way and block it, it's going to think of alternative ways around it to try to get to the goal that it takes seriously.
Speaker 2 45:25
Wow.
Speaker 1 45:27
And they can show, he does show, cells experimentally in the physical lab doing that kind of work. If you cut off one limb, it will try to grow it back, but it may try to make it look like the previous one, and it may or may not succeed.
Speaker 2 45:54
It probably won't succeed completely,
Speaker 1 45:56
but you can see how it's actually recalculating what to do. Anyway, there's a long thing I recommend that everybody… Because he says, you know, that you need to, that without teleology, without the notion that people and beings and minds have goals, you can't make sense of even basic biology.
Speaker 2 46:30
Yeah, wow.
Speaker 1 46:31
Yeah, wow. So anyway, this goal orientation is in a way the basis of morality, right? You have a sense of what you should be doing. I think I know what I'm supposed to be doing most of the time.
Speaker 2 46:48
Yeah.
Speaker 1 46:49
It's a terrible thing when once in a while and I really am in a dilemma not knowing what I should do. But I think most people have a sense of what they're, What ideally they should be doing with their lives. And it comes up all the time. You have to change. Well, I have to change my goal a little bit. And people do. So that is moral reasoning. And yet it's fundamental to even animals or plants.
Speaker 2 47:22
Fascinating. Yeah. I want to look into that. I mean, I'm sure I've come across… Michael Levin, but the idea of teleology is really fascinating to me, because for a long time, it's been kind of a dirty word, like teleological explanations for things are like, well, it seems like it's almost a cop-out in some way. And yet, like you said, it's kind of hard to get around it, especially when you're talking about… These incredibly complex sequences that proteins have to do to reproduce and the RNA locks in with the other. I mean, that's not my field at all, but it's fascinating and it's so orderly and purposeful. And so I guess… I'm thinking about communication, even lying or misinformation, as something that's purposeful.
And it has a goal, an end goal, which is to deceive, but also to advance one's own agenda. When you talk about speech act theory, that's the idea that communication is purposeful and that There's this kind of elocutionary subtext.
Speaker 1 49:00
The notion that you should only talk about facts, demonstrable material facts that you can measure. You take your tape razor and that's how you know what's real. But mathematicians have a whole realm, Plato, Platonic realm, where Such truths exist as, say, the Pythagorean Theorem, or Planck's Constant, or some, how fast the, you know, there are things, there are truths, factual truths, that are influential over people making political or action decisions. I mean, if you're designing a new rocket or something, you're going to be able to use the truths that exist in this non-material realm. And those constrain the decisions that you can make about engineering, for example.
Speaker 2 50:19
And you can't necessarily point… To it in the world and say, well, here, this is a demonstration right here, but the truth is on paper, on the computer screen.
Speaker 1 50:31
Now, where are you going with your next work? You're writing two books, I understand. Yeah. Give me a preview.
Speaker 2 50:40
Well, one of them is a textbook about communicating in healthcare settings between healthcare providers and patients. And of course, I don't have any clinical experience whatsoever. However, I'm taking the position that I'm a patient, and I have been a patient practically my whole life. And so I do have an insider's perspective as a patient. So I'm trying to create a patient-centered viewpoint of the communication process. And also trying to be… You know, compassionate or empathetic towards healthcare providers who have a purpose and they have a lot of things that they need to accomplish in a short amount of time. And I would really love to stay in chat for longer, but they have pretty regimented number of things and usually they're overworked and underpaid.
So nurses are, you know, looking after 17 beds or something like that. So that book, one of the things that I'm kind of questioning in that book is the idea of therapeutic communication. The idea that that communication is sort of de facto therapeutic. And hey, I agree, like we were talking about a TV show that can really give you sustenance. Or let's take an example of talk therapy where a therapist really helps you uncover truths about yourself. And then the example from the recovery community is people going to meetings and talking in a group of people that also have this problem.
And they're able to say, talk about the things in their lives that make them Liable to relapse into alcoholism or drugs or what have you. And so I'm the first one to say, yes, communication is therapeutic. However, the fact of whether it is therapeutic should be an outcome, not something that you can automatically do going in. So if you say, I'm about to have a therapeutic conversation with you, then it's like, well, how do you know we haven't? The conversation hasn't commenced yet.
Speaker 1 53:22
Well, I've had some very untherapeutic, anti-therapeutic communications in therapy.
Speaker 2 53:29
Yeah, and in healthcare, maybe? Yeah.
Speaker 1 53:33
Sure.
Speaker 2 53:34
Yeah. And so whether or not it is therapeutic is kind of suspended until the end of the interaction. And so I don't use that term, which a lot of the Textbooks have, which is like what we're doing is therapeutic communication.
Speaker 1 53:55
Well, I guess really the question to me is how can you improve the likelihood that it's going to be therapeutic?
Speaker 2 54:03
Yeah, you're right.
Speaker 1 54:04
Because I do not take for granted that therapy is likely to be helpful. I've seen some very bad things come from it. And it may be that just mainly, usually getting people to talk. And Rogerian, to do Rogerian therapy is extremely simple. Any fool could just say, yeah, yeah, I guess what you mean is this, isn't that what you just said? And you don't get very creative there and you don't use much intuition. But it maybe is good. I have a friend. He's part of our little Project Save the World. He usually chimes in once a month when we have a global town hall. And he lives in Croatia, in Avukovar, where the people are still, there are social effects of the war.
Not just the war that broke up Yugoslavia, but World War II. You know, the effects of You know, groups that sided with the Nazis and so on. But he trains, he's a psychiatrist, and he will train people on Zoom to be therapists, and he calls them barefoot therapists, because he teaches them to basically go and help people who have been through a war and are still suffering the effects of it, either as a victim of violence or The perpetrator of violence, because that's equally painful or can be, and teaches them how to be therapeutic in their communication. Well, how good is he at that? How would I know?
Speaker 2 56:01
Well, that's a great question, and I don't want to discount the possibility that something could be therapeutic a priori. Like that just the very fact of communication is what makes it therapeutic. And I do think that social contact is just a very enriching experience. But there's another term which I have issue with that they talk about in the textbooks, and that's cultural competence. And cultural competence is like, well, I'm trained, I'm a culturally competent communicator. Therefore, regardless of what culture you're from, I can communicate with you successfully. And I do think that people need to be very sensitive to culture and tuned into differences in the way that People communicate and linguistic differences.
However, I'm just not sure that it's something you can have a priori going into a conversation. And really, your cultural competence is not a given, depending on how the interaction goes. So I prefer a term called cultural humility, which is… Kind of more like, yeah, well, like, let's say the patient that I'm dealing with is Chinese, but that doesn't mean that I speak to them in Chinese, or that they're Chinese in the same way that someone in Shanghai is Chinese, because this person grew up in Queens, and English was their first language, and so In other words, not jumping to conclusions about, oh, you're Chinese? I've got this. I've got this covered.
And so avoiding any ethnic stereotypes in the process of saying, oh, well, if you're African-American, you do this, this, this, and this. And if you're Indian, you do this, this. So that's another kind of polemic of the book that
Speaker 1 58:28
Well, that's fine, actually. I don't think you want to go there, but probably. And that is the whole woke issue. Because it's relevant, you know. When people say, well, only people of my ethnicity can write about the experience of being Italian or Italian in America. And you are really from… So you have no right to write about us and we have the right to, we should be organizing. I never was much of a, I was never much into that stream of thought, even when it was popular, but thank goodness it's, that's one place where I'm
Speaker 2 59:18
afraid I sort of agree with Trump.
Speaker 1 59:22
That was a bad, bad thing. Kind of an ideology.
Speaker 2 59:27
Yeah, I mean, that people on the right try to say that this idea of woke is typical of people on the left. And I think that's probably false, that people I know that identify as left wing are equally unimpressed by, you know, woke. And there's been a long time critique on the left of identity politics. And I do think that I want to be sensitive to people's, to that. And I wouldn't dare to speak on behalf of someone or someone's group because it's just so presumptuous. But the idea of woke, I mean, what's the alternative? Being asleep, you know? That seems to be the alternative that people want. But I think the term woke has a lot of connotations.
And as far as it being like, you can't speak on my behalf, that seems fair enough to me.
Speaker 1 1:00:43
Okay, that's fair enough, too. I'm just trying to imagine whether that had any impact in the area of health communication.
Speaker 2 1:00:52
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, good question. It does. And so, for example, there might be a critique that because the medical establishment and pharmaceutical establishment are mostly white men, that their reasoning is suspect and it's white supremacist. And I wouldn't say that is necessarily true. It's true that white men are overrepresented in science and in education.
Speaker 1 1:01:32
As much now, I tell you, when I was in hospital, I think the majority of the doctors were female. And most of them would look like 16-year-old beauty queens.
Speaker 2 1:01:44
It's funny because my mom was in the hospital too recently, and I noticed that too. So is that even true anymore that it's mainly white men? But certainly when you see the CEO is often a man, but not always. And I guess what I'm saying is that because I'm a white man, anything I say is basically categorically suspect because of my You know, my identity or my subject position. And I kind of have come to accept that fact that, you know, take everything that this guy says with a grain of salt because he's white and he's male. And if that's…
Speaker 1 1:02:36
I'll straighten you out. Just come on. Come over for dinner someday. Okay. I'll work on your head. I'm a culturally competent person, so you can trust me. I'll do a good job with you.
Speaker 2 1:02:52
Well, this has been a therapeutic conversation.
Speaker 1 1:02:57
I don't think so, but I think it's been a fun one. I've enjoyed it very much. Anyway, time's up. Let's do it again. And this time, let's talk about drama and empathy and things like that. What that does, you know, talking, communicating about emotions and how you share them by just expressing it, you know. So I'll set up a deal. You willing?
Speaker 2 1:03:27
Sure, sure.
Speaker 1 1:03:29
Terrific. Okay, take care. Okay, thanks, Meta.
Speaker 2 1:03:32
Okay, bye.
Speaker 1 1:03:33
Thank you.
