Notes
A Project Save the World forum with Heather Herrygers and Paul Zeitz
Guests
- Heather Herrygers
- Paul Zeitz
Video
Podcast
SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
independent, political, parties, Heather, party, democracy, citizens, together, American, money, independents, movement, power, Paul, believe, ideological, deliberative, elected, candidates, issues
SPEAKERS
Heather Herrygers, Paul Zeitz, Metta Spencer.
SUMMARY
Metta Spencer hosts this episode of Project Save the World, titled "Renew US Democracy," with guests Heather Herrygers and Paul Zeitz. The conversation covers independent voters, the role of political parties, and efforts to reform American democracy through deliberation. Spencer opens by noting that Zeitz is working to renew American democracy, and that Herrygers has recently joined him in a collaboration with her new organization, Independent Voice.
Read more…
Herrygers explains that Independent Voice launched publicly in January 2026 as a sole proprietor LLC and functions as a networking vehicle for independent-minded voters, leaders, and organizations rather than a new political party. She cites the claim that about 45 percent of the electorate is independent and sets a goal of one-third of Congress being independent by 2026. Spencer raises Elene Landemore's book Politics Without Politicians and asks whether the country could do without political parties. Herrygers says that is a large question, that parties are powerful, and that independent representation matters most. Zeitz agrees parties are strong and not likely to disappear soon, and describes a growing ecosystem of organizations giving independents a voice, including a recent independent convention and viable independent candidates.
Zeitz outlines the layers of his renew democracy strategy, including blocking, bridging, belonging, and renewing efforts, and describes a nationwide deliberation campaign aiming for a national citizens assembly in early 2028. Spencer brings up James Fishkin's proposal for a deliberation day before elections. Zeitz supports deliberative polling and says it could be scaled with online and AI tools. Herrygers adds that independent candidates model deliberative town halls and that representatives should collaborate with constituents.
Spencer raises European extremist parties and asks whether the speakers would share any positions with them. Zeitz rejects the flat political spectrum, stresses cross-ideological dialogue, and describes a Harvard gathering on an Article V convention that discussed balanced budgets and term limits. Herrygers agrees and says voters crave solutions beyond binary thinking. Spencer then turns to money in politics, and the speakers discuss campaign funding, independent senators, and the idea of an independent fulcrum caucus. Spencer also questions how voters can separately support different issues, and a guest proposes citizens assemblies to decide issues independently. Zeitz concludes that the group agrees on transforming the system to include citizen voice, and the episode ends with thanks.
Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong.
Hi, I'm Meta Spencer. Um, today I'm uh going to reconnect with a man who by now is becoming sort of an old friend. That's Paul Guys. He's been on this show at least twice and I hope maybe another three or four times before he accomplishes his main objective in life, which is to renew America's democracy. and he is the co-coordinator of an organization with that close to that title, Renew American Democracy. And that means that he's going to kind of become a founding father. He's going to he and his friends going to bring people together to consider rewriting America's Constitution and basic understandings as I was led to believe. a few months ago.
Goals may have changed somewhat now because he's made a new friendship with a person who's working on slightly different project but they are collaborating now and that is Heather Heriggers. Heather is the I don't know whether you're the chair or what's your role as in this new organization called Independent Voice. Uh, hi Heather. tell me.
Um, I'm going to start right off by saying I know nothing about you except we talked two minutes ago and uh that I know I've I've inferred that you and Paul think you have goals that are in alignment and that uh somehow you can work together and maybe benefit both of your projects by uh collaborating and that since that is a new thing and I see that you've been going out giving speeches together on the same platform and so on that I better um get acquainted with you. So, hello Heather. Hello. How are you Meta? Great. Glad to glad to meet you and I want you to tell me more.
Let's start off with your um your campaign or your project, your movement that you're trying to accomplish something for America's in good elections and and then Paul will explain to me how that connects with uh his renew American democracy. Okay. Fantastic. Who are you? Oh, sure. Thank you for having me. Um my name is Heather Heriggers. As you said, I'm the CEO and founder of Independent Voice. Uh we launched publicly in January of 2026, so not that long ago. I came originally from the democracy reform space. Uh I was very active with the Forward Party and then I worked for No Labels for two and a half years, primarily on presidential ballot access for a 2024 unity ticket. Hold on.
You you worked for the I thought you said labels. What' you say? I worked for No Labels, an organization that got attempted to put a a third option on the ballot for president in 2024. Oh, I don't think I ever knew about that. Oh, sorry. That's okay. Um, but I've been a lifelong independent. I grew up in a nonpartisan house. My mom is a Greek immigrant and my dad served in the military in Vietnam. And we only talked about how we would solve problems. We didn't talk about um whose side was better than the other and every time my dad voted it was for Mickey Mouse and Donald Duck. I had no idea uh what any political affiliation there was.
Um and so after raising kids for 13 years and working in the democracy reform and uh third option space so to speak, I thought that there was something that needed to form to serve independent voters. um we are at 45% of the American electorate is an independent voter and every generation uh younger than me is more independent than the one that came before it. Um so I set out to build a network to shape smarter policy, stronger institutions and a more representative government um by informing, empowering and engaging independent-minded voters, leaders and organizations. So independent voice convenes people all across the country on a monthly basis to what I say crosspollinate um on our efforts.
Maybe it's democracy reform, maybe it's primary um election advocacy or litigation. Uh we have people all across the country talking about what they're doing and learning from each other and empowering each other to continue the work and keep growing and also to share the voices of other independents that may or may not be thought of much by the general media. That's you put a lot into one long sentence. Okay, that's very informative. But it leaves me with the first initial question is is this a new political party? No. Um it's independent voice is actually a sole proprietor LLC and so it's just a networking uh it's a vehicle for networking for people in the movement for independent leadership.
Um, most I would say I don't want to speak for all independents, but primarily a lot of independents believe that when Washington delivered his farewell address and and warned us about the nature of political parties and how they could usurp the power of the people, uh, that he was right. And so, it's not about forming a new party. It's about declaring our independence, asserting that, and and serving each other. Okay. Well, I I'm you've touched already on a question that I really have been worried about. In other words, I don't have a fixed opinion and I'm not sure what I should believe.
And that is for the last uh year on my iPad I've had uh a book by Elen Landore uh about uh called Politics Without Politicians. And uh the book basically she's a person who's very famous for her support of u uh citizens assemblies and um and she had a previous book that was uh leading in that and she does all her work on that. Uh but this book is an argument uh that relates to what you just mentioned.
That is she's arguing that we shouldn't have political parties and that as you some of the founding fathers also believed that it would be dangerous to have that would be one of the big problems with democracy is you might get these groups that um have these factions. And so I I look at this and I read it and I I I must say I've only read 10% of the book over the last year because I don't have enough time. But every time I can pick it up, I I worry about it because I don't know what to believe. Could we do without political parties? And do you believe that we should try to get along without political parties?
That's a huge question and I have not written a book about it myself. Um, and I can understand why it's it's a lot to think about. Um, I I my personal goal is that one-third of Congress will be independent by 206. Um, I think that if we can at least have more voices in our people's house and our representative um, government, we will be better off. Whether or not we evolve into removing political parties entirely, that's really up to the American people and the path we choose to take collectively.
So, I don't think that political parties have become very powerful and um I don't think they're going away anytime soon because of their power and because of all the laws that really do uh prevent competition outside of them. So, would we be better off? Maybe. I that would be a really long thorough discussion and study for me to commit to an answer. Um but do I believe that we'll be better off if if we have independent voices in our Congress? 100%. Yes. Uh all right. So let me ask Paul uh that very question. And I don't know that we've even talked about it uh before, have we? What do you think? Could we could we get along without political parties? Do we need them?
And would would be even be better off without them? Yeah, I think Helen Landom's thesis is really focused on politics without politicians. Um, she's focused on elevating the voice of citizens in decision-m policym through deliberative democracy through citizens assemblies. Um, there are people that talk about getting rid of political parties and some magical reality. I don't, like Heather said, they're very powerful. They're very strong, and I don't see that as immediately happening anytime soon. What I do see happening is the movement that uh Heather and I are both part of. I'm a lifelong registered independent. Heather is organizing independent voices.
There is a whole ecosystem of organizations that are uh strengthening in the United States now to try to better reflect the perspective of people that don't want to be part of the Democratic party or the Republican party. And that Heather cited that I think the latest survey I saw was about 48% of Americans now identify as independent and uh millennial and Gen Z it's even higher up to 57%. So uh both the Democratic and the Republican party are actually minority parties and the majority of Americans don't fit into those boxes. The challenge is is that the political architecture or infrastructure rather is established within the two-party system. the independents are less well organized and less cohesive, if you will, which is kind of good, right?
Uh, you know, Heather taught me to say independence, we we don't fit in no boxes. And, uh, if we're not going to be in a box, then it makes it harder to organize ourselves. That is part of the beauty of it, but it's also part of the challenge. We there is efforts underway like with Heather's group and other uh key organizations out there to try to organize independent voters and so that there can be uh independent candidates for office that can actually win elections. And I'm excited. Heather and I both attended and we spoke together at the independent national convention which was a movement of independent voices. Really it's not a political party.
I didn't hear anyone in that room talk about we're forming a new party. We're actually just trying to elevate independent voices. And now there are candidates for office uh for the US Senate and for the House of Representatives that are viable, strong former veteran, former university presidents, uh people who are established leaders in their communities are now in competitive races for this 2026 midterm election. Okay. And uh did do they or you all uh support particular candidates? Do you have a you say you had a convention? Do do you decide who would be the best of these university professors uh presidents and and veterans? That's an interesting question.
I I think that there's one organization that has decided who they think is the most viable and then there are other organizations that have endorsed candidates. Independent voice as a network does not endorse any individual candidates. We we behave on a choose your own adventure uh type strategy I guess. Um so our network members decide who they want to support, how they want to support them, if they want to give their time or finances to a particular candidate. However, through the United Independence Framework and there's a pack that was presenting a slate at the Independent National Convention, is it called Independence Win? I think the the that that's the pack is called Independence Win.
And they presented a slate of seven candidates that they felt were the most viable and they fundraised around them at that convention. Um, and I think that we'll see more of those kinds of things moving forward, but this is the first time that independents have presented a slate through at least one political organization, not necessarily myself or Paul's, and Paul's not a political organization by any means. I think I I'm beginning to get a sense of what you do, but uh I'm not sure that I have given enough attention to explaining what Paul is up to. before I try to see how you're going to work together.
I uh in previous conversations I I was following you, Paul, and I'm I'm I'd still like to stay up to date with your doings, but tell me your plan. You're going to host Yeah. So, I think uh we've talked about on prior episodes the work that's been underway around uh renewing American democracy. Um it's a a mezzo level strategy that is looking at all the actors that are out there uh working to re uh to protect and renew American democracy. So uh there is a whole maybe 15,000 or more organizations are operating at the local state and federal level in the United States.
There's a lot of them that are doing blocking, meaning upholding current norms, blocking an assault on our democratic norms and our democratic institutions there. You know, all the lawsuits that are being filed against this regime and all the protests and non-ooperation efforts that are uh underway, that's a area that we're aware of and uh tracking. And then there's a lot of other sectors like the bridging movement [clears throat] uh thousands of organizations working to depolarize to create safe spaces for uh people across the ideological spectrum to come together to explore how to solve problems together. The premier group I would say in that space or one of the groups that I would shout out is Braver Angels which is a cross ideological organization.
and they have chapters uh in every state across the country. Um and they bring together blue, red and independence to have a dialogue to figure out how to solve like the immigration crisis or other priorities that emerge. Um then there's the belonging uh part of the movement which is focusing on building uh civic and deliberative infrastructure like creating civic hubs at the local level where people can come together to work together at the local level across ideological uh boundaries and across issue areas. Um and those groups are starting to form around the country now. It's a civic infrastructure that's been very weak in the past, but it's strengthening right now. Then I'm really rooted and centered in the renew uh the renewing our democracy pillar.
And we're really focusing on using deliberative democracy, harnessing the wisdom of the American people to bring forward the ideas about what the people want and how they want their government to be set up and how they want it to run going forward into the future. The the underpinning of all that is what is the power pillar and that's really the work that uh is about building a cross ideological uh mo uh move political movement from the left all the way to the right of people that are committed to democratic uh processes, democratic practice and the rule of law. that it should be applied equally for all people and that all people have a right to human dignity and human rights.
So that's where Heather and I our zones came together because uh we believe that the independent movement and the movement of independent voices we don't believe it we witness it there. These people all agree with the analysis that the system is broken the system is rigged independent voters like myself I live in Maryland. I'm not allowed to vote in open primaries. These are my tax dollars are used to run primary elections. Why aren't you allowed to vote in uh open because I'm only allowed you're in the primary the uh phase of the election cycle uh if you have to be registered as a Democrat and then you're allowed to vote for Democrats if you're registered as a Yes. Everywhere is it? No.
It's about 15 states representing I think 23 million Americans that aren't allowed to vote in primaries due to these rules that have been written by the political parties. Uhhuh. Okay. But now your movement, Renew American democracy, you were mostly when I talked to you some time ago, you were planning to hold a big meeting to talk about uh what needs to be in the US Constitution or if not the Constitution officially at least the consensus about how how the US needs to work at a level where you can actually implement some changes. Um, are is that what you're still doing? Are you planning a a big conference to to redesign the structure of American governance?
Yeah, I I think that the work is evolving and right now we're focusing on what's called the nationwide deliberation campaign, which is a uh a group of organizations coming together to try to catalyze a d a dialogue and deliberation by the American people, including at the grassroots, grassroots dialogues, grassroots consultations, grassroots deliberation, then online deliberation and these uh then deliberative the polling, then citizens assemblies, which are starting to happen in many states now. And then yes, ultimately we're aiming for a uh national citizens assembly uh that would uh review all the ideas coming from all the states from all the local level deliberations and then come up with a prioritized set of uh reforms.
And that can include constitutional amendments or amendment bundles that uh the public would uh the people would like to see happen. Plus, it could include also transformative legislation. Um we're aiming for that to happen in the first quarter of 2028. Um and there is an active dialogue about uh aiming for that and trying to create that. It's not 100% guaranteed yet, I would say, at this point.
Um, but the idea is that we can use all of 2027 for those deliberations, synthesize that, arrange a citizens assembly, and then have a people's proposal that has political legitimacy as we enter into the 2028 election cycle, and then use that to lo advocate and lobby with elected officials and people that are running for office uh, going into the 2028 cycle. Well, it seems to me that some of these earlier steps in you mentioned several phases of this pro project that uh you mentioned uh deliberation and um I I did an interview with um Fishkin in James Fishkin. Yeah. Fishkin.
And one of his big ideas is u to have before every election have a national holiday or something so that everything is push all everyday business gets pushed aside but meetings get held where all citizens get together and discuss the policies that are um to be decided. you know that the issues that that need to be deliberated and that before people vote they should have a good conversation with other other voters and um so he would have I think a special day for everybody to meet in their local I don't know school or someplace and and and deliberate all day about the topics and the issues that are that need to be discussed.
I think that in itself would have a lot of beneficial effects if in fact people would do it. I think most voters are not likely to be I don't think we'd get a majority of voters, but wouldn't that be wonderful right there if we get people to think before voting? Yeah.
Yeah, I mean I'll come in and then let Heather I mean James James Fishkin is a pioneer a leader in the deliberative polling methodology and uh his idea of like taking a pause creating a space for people to actually deliberate is integral to what we're talking about and uh the deliberative polling methodology has been used successfully here in the United States in Pennsylvania and Texas and also globally and now with the advent of uh online platform forms and technology also AI synthesis uh capabilities that now exist these things can be scaled to thousands of people so we're work we're in discussions with them if we could raise the money we could have it happen immediately of statewide deliberative polling and national deliberative polling uh where what you said is actually what we're seeking is to you know take to harness the wisdom of the American people to really listen to each other and to tackle the tough issues that seem intractable, but the actual truth is that most Americans agree about win-win solutions when they're given those options.
when we break out of the manufactured outrage and the extreme uh rhetoric and the attack mode that's underway in in the Twitter sphere and you know in the in the media circus that's going on. Uh most Americans are fed up with it, turning it off and want to see actual win-win solutions be co-created. when we're when we're with each other, we actually respect each other and we want to learn from each other and we want to come up with the best win-win solution. So, yeah, I'm all for what Fishton's calling for. Excellent. Well, Heather, how about you?
uh what your movement of of independence uh are you building into it or maybe by collaborating you will be uh working with Paul in the same direction but uh is is part of your project to uh build in more discussion and deliberation among citizens before they make decisions or um is that really for for for him to do and you to do something different. No, I I think it's it's two-part. It's both. Um some of these independents that are running have modeled that deliberative process. I Mike Dugen, for example, ran briefly for governor as an independent in the state of Michigan and I had the um opportunity to kind of watch him work in an education setting because I serve on my school board.
and he had a town hall and he proposed his ideas to the group and then he said now you tell me what you think you teach me what I don't know you poke holes in my plan you help me make it better and that's where the representative of the people can really serve the people and and utilize the knowledge the collective wisdom to make better decisions and I think that in general that is where America's moving no matter what um because we do have all the tools at our disposal there's no reason for our elected representatives not to listen to us and not to collaborate on decisions. And so I think that's going to be the standardized norm going forward.
I know many um races now where the incumbents aren't holding any town halls and the only one walking around knocking on doors is is the independent. And so if you're not willing to talk with the people you you're you know you're you've been elected to serve, I don't I don't know how you even do your job. And and so I think that standard is coming to to the ballot no matter what either, you know, the movement does or or not. And and I don't think you're going to be elected as easily if you're not willing to work in a deliberative fashion. Um it's just I think it's the way of the future. Well, that's the optimistic view of the future.
Uh but today I was I think it's a New York Times article about uh the politics of Europe. It's not just France that you know the last few days have been having uh riots bad riots apparently but um it's it's a larger trend which is that the centrist parties are now losing support especially among young people uh and very disenchanted young people who are really con not at all committed to democracy anymore. Uh in fact are believing as you and I probably believe that democracy is broken. So their solution instead of uh stepping outside of the part party system and looking at centrist collaborative procedures which I think you are doing um they are voting they're swinging out to the extremes.
So you have, you know, Marine Le Pen will probably win the next election I if if largely because of the riots that these people have been participating in the last few days. Um and the same of course with Germany with the you know that party uh and uh and and uh even Britain you know could be so apparently the pessimistic view of the future that this guy was or person I don't know who it was uh was exposing is that we'll get a fraction will we get a fractionated or a fractioned uh electorate that can't cooperate at all because they don't have any centrist parties in any power. But you'll have fights between the extreme left and the extreme right.
And the extreme right are probably ahead of the extreme left, but both of them uh will dominate. and um and instead of this beautiful picture that you've both been presenting of centrist collaboration, tell me. Yeah. Can I just clarify? I You're using the word centrism in a way that I'm not sure Heather and I are I don't even know what we each think about that, but I just want to clarify that I' I've never used that word. What I've been saying is cross ideological perspectives which you know we want to hear from people across the ideological spectrum. If you're on the far left and the far right the majority of people over 80% are not on the extremes.
They're somewhere in that c you know middle middle zone. Um but the solutions that could come out could fall anywhere on that ideological spectrum in my view. So I just want you know we don't you know centism isn't necessarily always the right answer in terms of like watering everything down. And that's what I think the young people are saying to us. You know my generation uh I'm a I'm a baby boomer. I'm the end of the baby boomers. We we always accepted um lesser of two evils and we said, you know, that's that's what we have to put up with. And I think what they're saying is no, we're not going to put up with that.
We want real solutions to real to the real major crises that we're facing in our climate, in our in in our economy, and in our democracy. And so they're not saying we should have these watered down, middle-of the road solutions that lead to nowhere. um they want real transformation and they want their voices to be heard in the political system in the political process. So that's what we're talking about.
or at least from the renew American democracy perspective, we're talking about creating uh new way a new culture and a new way of involving people in the political system which is through deliberative democracy which is open and welcome to all ideological perspectives and and I think to just piggyback on that a little bit um personally I reject the flatline political spectrum. I think it's obsolete. It needs to be three-dimensional and fluid.
um because we're always coming up with new ideas and and discovering things but also I think it's more of a collective consensus building process so across all ideologies um I don't think I have a fixed ideology per se on on any one subject at any one time always um but bringing all the voices to the table to work together collectively to to build consensus I is really the way we see solutions being I am I I'm I'm not trying to force you to say something you'd want to say, but if if you can you think of any extremist party position, you know, the AFP or D or whatever Germany uh or uh Marine Lean or this Farage guy, uh these these extremist parties, can you think of any argument or any uh position that they are taking that you would include in any of your own um positions.
Um I I just think you know I don't I I think you avoid the extremist terminology the ex term extremism. It would make sense but same time I think you are centrists because I doubt that you would vote for any of those extreme candidates or support the positions that they take. Is that fair enough or am I really Can you show Well, I I can give you a concrete example. I I think we should stay focused on the United States.
I can't really I'm not a comment on the political parties in France and Germany to be able to comment on their positions, but I'll give you a concrete example and I think Heather and I can relate to this, which is that um I I recently attended a conference at Harvard called V the People uh focusing on an article 5 constitutional convention. And this was a cross ideological gathering. I mean it was the far right to the far left and everything in between really look asking the question about can we amend the constitution. So there was uh constitutional amendment topics that were discussed in depth. One was a balanced budget amendment.
You know, as you know, the United States right now has a $14 trillion official debt, but people at this meeting were talking about it being much larger and questioning the economic and financial uh sustainability of our government uh because of the massive debt that is being incurred every day. Um also term limits was another topic. So these are topics that people on the left and the right, you know, think should be explored and should be discussed and maybe we should figure out how to run our country with financial management [clears throat] uh discipline and maybe it's okay to think about uh both members of Congress uh Senate as well as the Supreme Court having term limits.
uh those are reasonable policy reforms that uh I would say people across the ideological spectrum are thinking about right now and what we're trying to do is create spaces where those dialogues and those deliberations can happen and concrete reform proposals that everyone can agree to or a majority of people can agree to can be brought forward to the public. So I think that's what I'm saying is saying that the the political system, this manufactured outrage right now forces the polarization blocks the ability to actually deliberate and come up with win-win solutions. It's designed by them to keep it that way so that they can maintain their political power.
Whereas most of the public where no matter how you identify as left, center, right, we're stuck in this paralysis of we can't solve anything. Yeah. Got it. Okay. He Heather I want Heather to respond to that if you don't mind. Yeah, sure. Sure. I I think Paul Paul and I agree a lot. Um and and you said it really well. So, but I I do think that there's, you know, transparency in general.
I I live in a very conservative area in West Michigan and I spoke up on behalf of the people and I received notification as an elected official that I had more friends than I knew even though our ideologies might be different although I don't know how they know what my ideologies are because I've never publicly explained them. Um, so there is a craving for what is inherently American when it comes to priorities from any extreme um to no extreme at all. And so I just think it's we've been programmed to think in a very binary way and to undo that is a long process.
But I think it's a necessary pro process to even achieve um any progress in our country because like Paul said, we're we're really just frozen here in this back and forth fighting, pointing fingers, not really we're not evolving as a country through our elected officials and it really is a shame and it should be unacceptable to most Americans. Okay. Well, now if you've mentioned some of the policy changes that would make a difference, term limits, for example, it's a great idea, but I would start by all means with attention on how to get money so much out of the picture because the reason political parties uh have all the power, the most important reason is money goes through political parties.
And uh I don't know how you could expect comparable amounts of money to go through independent movements. Um lots of luck, but you're going to have to explain to me how that might work and and also how in in Paul has already given me some stepbystep phases of his plan. What are the steps that you expect to go through in promoting the importance of of uh independent uh voters? And I've asked you too many questions all in one whack. So, pick one and answer that one. Whatever. Okay. Well, starting with money. Um, I don't think money is absolutely everything in politics when you have the people behind you, just like we saw in Wisconsin with Elon Musk, um, and this Supreme Court.
Um, he tried to buy that election and he failed. The people overcame the the pocketbook, so to speak. I think independents are going to be a little more creative. They're going to be a little more in have a little more ingenuity, and they're going to work the ground harder. And so what they lack in money they'll make up for in grit and innovation.
I do think the money will come because I realized in the last three four months um I went to an investors for a better America conference and people who have lifelong investments foundations um lots of generational wealth are truly concerned with the state of our politics today and have come to the decision that maybe one side or the other is not going to save their trust fund. And it's true. So with the rising national debt that won't be addressed by either party in power in the last 26 years, uh we really do have a problem on our hands. And so if you can find representation that's willing to address our problems, I think you have an advantage already.
Um in deeply uncontested races, um you can run an independent. In three states, there's independents running without a Democratic opponent against a Republican because the Democrats are not winning and they've realized that they can't fight what they're up against, um, without the independent movement along their side. So, um, will the money come? I believe so. I believe it's there. We're actually doing some calculations on fundraising for 2027 that are very promising and it's only about, um, a fifth of the the share of the pot, so to speak. And I think if we, you know, for example, TV ads are the worst way to spend political dollars from a costbenefit perspective. And what do traditional parties do? Political ads.
And so if they want to put their money there, then more power to them. But independents are going to use the money in ways that are are more productive outside of the traditional lanes. Can you think of or tell me of a candidate, an independent candidate who actually got elected besides Bernie Sanders? Are you're talking about in the Senate? No, I'm talking about anywhere as governors or as anything. Well, we Well, there are two independent Senate, right? I mean, there's Angus King in Maine and Bernie Sanders that are both independents now. They are caucusing with the Democrats.
So I think um Heather maybe you want to talk about the independent fulcrum caucus concept as well or you know I'd like to put that on the table. Yeah. Yeah. Um well and that's Paul brings up a good point. So even if there are independents right now in Congress, they're not serving the independent voice. They're serving a partisan perspective. Um, and so the independents that are running for Congress in 2026, that are on the ballot in November or now, um, they, a handful of them have promised not to caucus or or build a bridge with they're going to build a bridge with everyone, but they want to be their own independent force.
And so what that does is it creates what you call a fulcrum, which is kind of like a point of balance. So picture a teeter totter and on one side is Republican, on the other side is Democrat. And the the point in the middle that can shift the weight or the power in one direction or the other is the independence. And so if you have a really narrowly divided Senate, for example, and you have a handful of independents there, then neither party has the majority, and I don't even know if they know will know what to do with that.
Um but then you can you can have power to decide who's the speaker of the house if it happens to be in the house of representatives or you can have you know for um appointments by the presidential um branch of government right so there's power there even though you're a minority you become the um you become the power broker really and you're the mediating force for reason and service instead of party power and you can't get primar If you win a general election, you're there's no threat to you. That's what happens to a lot of these um Democrats and Republicans who might be well-intentioned.
Um if they don't tow the party line from, you know, Donald Trump or Joe Biden, if they're not doing what the party wants at the national level, they can't even serve their constituents because they'll just lose their job. And so, they're really in a hard spot themselves as well. And it shouldn't be that they want to protect their their job because it should really be a temporary stay in our government. Um but they they they're not going to move the needle for the people. They're going to move the needle for the party because that's what it's all about to them. Yeah.
But no, the the question I asked was tell me how many independent candidates you can remember that got elected and you didn't come up with much. uh which is a kind of a reminder that it's it's harder to do if you're an independent because you don't have the money behind you. Maybe there are a lot of other reasons. Uh I think probably it's very simple.
People can only think in terms of have voting for two different packages and these packages they don't have any to say about what gets put into the say you have two sacks and you're putting different combinations of of issues in in the in the various sacks was somebody in these parties aggregate issues decide whether uh ar you know gun control belongs in the same sack as whether boys can use girls washrooms or uh whether to fund the WH. Why do those combinations of issues line up the way they do? Somebody makes that happen. And that's what a party is for is so that when you when when they get through, you know this what's the content of the sack that they're committed to.
And I I I would love to say that if I come out with a different combination of of issues, you know, I think, you know, gun control doesn't belong in the same sack as using what, you know, whether boys can transexuals can run in the races or competitions with the other the sex they've joined. That kind of thing. I don't think those are connected. And I have different points of view about these then you know then other people the voters have to decide well you know which is my priority. I I think it gets much harder for the voter.
It's simple if you say here are your choices this package or this package and and yet that is the problem is we don't have any um real control over what gets packaged together. Yeah, I mean you're you're there. I think we're in a different moment in US history where you're describing what I would say is the the past in terms of the entrenched two-party political system. You're right. It is controlled by money and politics. you know, Citizens United and those Supreme Court rulings that allowed unlimited uh corporate and dark money spending uh for elections has distorted and reinforced the power of these two parties. However, the American people are rejecting that and you know, it's a process of that manifesting now.
So I think that there are a lot of efforts underway to uh take down the uh money and politics issue. For example, there's a major uh lawsuit happening in the state of Maine uh to overturn uh the funding of super PACs Hawaii just implemented a reform that candidates there in the next election cannot accept corporate money. Uh there's uh many uh movements. The American Promise uh is uh making significant progress in advancing a constitutional amendment to uh overturn Citizens United. Move to amend. There's another movement doing the same kind of thing. And uh the two parties that have held all that unbridled power are fracturing. The Republican party's fractured from principled Republicans versus the MAGAites.
And then the Democratic parties fractured from corporate Democrats and the DSA, the Democratic Socialists of America. And as I said earlier, the majority of Americans are fed up with both of them and going for the independents. This election is the first time in my lifetime where there's actually a viable slate of independent candidates that are that could uh win elections in the Senate and the House and then form together an independent fulcrum caucus that Heather described to create a mediation uh role to bring together uh sane people who really want to solve problems from both sides of the aisle across ideological solutions. That's what we need.
Um, and so I think I think that it because the crisis is so severe right now, these innovations, these transformations are more and more likely and more and more possible. I don't think people are going to be uh putting up with this entrenched uh manufactured outrage uh on the far left and the far right controlling the system for very much longer because it's painful. People are suffering. people can't pay their bills. The medical debt, the cost of living, the cost of food, the cost of gas and diesel is so high right now and out of whack that the people in the United States are going to be uh demanding uh political reform.
And so the independents that Heather's representing and that I'm connected to are leading this effort for renewing American democracy. Okay. I love that. Um I'm still going to pick at it a little bit because Go for it. Yeah, I'm stuck back here in this thing about how come certain issues get packaged together. What what makes one point of view on a particular issue the the rightwing point of view and uh uh another uh issue uh uh [clears throat] also the right-wing point of view. I don't know. Not always. There's sometimes I find, you know, I I I don't know which camp I should belong in. And but then let's say I just I decide I really want to vote for these separately.
I what I ca what I'm worried about let's say are two main issues. Let's make it up. One would be the World Trade Organiz World Health Organization, WHO. I think we should definitely be funding that and supporting it and so on. And my other issue, let's say, is I I don't want boys using girls washrooms. How can I support those points of view separately without uh taking a position uh you know deciding what which party I want to vote vote for because I I don't see any any way of of uh taking my independent positions and turning them into reality except without sorry I I think without representation, you can't.
And and I met a man from um through the forward party work that is was a Republican and he's he's gay and he's married to a black man and he is a pro he was a pro-life Republican. He was on the floor, not when Nixon was nominated, but at that convention that Nixon was nominated at and he said that people wore pro-life buttons at the Republican National Convention. And I I explain it like this over time. You know, when you go into a major city like Atlanta, there's 10 lanes of traffic and that's what each party typically uh accepted in terms of ideological positions. But now it's like a two track in the woods.
If you don't fall between those two lines, you're outed and and there is no home for you. And that's why Open Primaries has calculated that 10,000 Americans a day are leaving the parties. and you you there's you're canceled, you have no home. If you don't conform, get out. Then where do you go? Where do you build any political will? And so that's where the independent movement is has a broad range of acceptance. And and really, you know, maybe I won't agree with my elected representative on every issue, but I shouldn't have to be a single issue voter just to pick a side and pick a side.
I really should be able to find a good leader that's willing to do hard work and listen and navigate difficult conversations and solutions that can deliver. And we just don't have that. We have a failure of leadership. And so I I guess I still think that you have to do your v way your solution is you've got to do something to make it easier to find candidates who support the same combination of of issues that you believe in. And I don't think I want to do it that way. I think that that can be if you're going to have to have elections, that's the only way to do it.
You got to choose an a a candidate and presumably you do that by looking at what they believe in or what they stand for. But I would rather have separate citizens assemblies so that you you set up a ci citizens assembly to to talk about my my issue, let's say, of the World Health Organization and what to do to support it or not to support it, how to get out. And then you have a different citizens assembly has the task of deciding for the whole electorate as a as a legislative inst institution. Uh whether or not we should let's say u you know boys run in the same transgender people run in the opposite sexes athletic competitions if that's the thing that interests me.
And so these these issues get de decided independently of each other and not by choosing hopefully the kind of candidate that that with the same combination of preferences that I would have. I guess I don't think you're ever going to find somebody you agree with 100% of the time anyway ever. But I do think that citizens assemblies can help guide elected officials in their decision-making process. I don't and and then if you're not following the recommendation of a citizens assembly, I guess you're probably not going to get reelected in my opinion. If we rewrite the rules of our government and we govern by citizens assembly, I guess that's a definitely anything's possible.
Um but when you talk about major transformation and change, it's definitely a slow process. So, um I see where you're going, I think. Um and I I just I I don't I don't know. Paul, do you have some thoughts that you want to share? Yeah, I mean I think I I think we agree that we need to transform the political system to include pathways for the citizens voice to be heard um like through citizens assemblies and that's what we're we're agreeing on that I think with you and um yeah I don't think there's ideological purity with any elected official. So I think the you the way I see it is that we have elected officials.
We want to see more diversity in how they're affiliating themselves rather than just these two options. A third you know independent option and then same time bringing in deliberative democracy to make sure that the citizens voice is empowered to uh influence budget decisions, policym amending the constitution all the elements of of governance. So, um, anyway, thank you so much for this wonderful conversation. It's been really fantastic. I appreciate this opportunity. Every time you come in, Paul, I'm thrilled to hear what you're doing. And now, Heather, you too. It's really good to meet you and good luck. Good luck. And I I can help support it. I'm all for it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Bye. Thanks. Have a good week.
