Notes
Tariq Rauf warns that weapons have reached outer space, Muhammad Mominulhwag reports from the Rohingya camps, and Tom Hedberg, Sam Hall and Alan Haber discuss misinformation and citizens' assemblies.
Guests
- Tariq Rauf
- Tom Hedberg
- Bill Leikam
- Marilyn Krieger
Video
Podcast
SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
government, space, Burma, Rohingya, Canada, Canadian, home, nuclear, States, United, weapons, Chinese, global, Greenland, international, North, Bangladesh, defense, citizen, anyway
SPEAKERS
Metta Spencer, Marilyn Krieger, Alan Haber, Tom Hedberg, Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance, Shane Steinman, Bill Leikam, Tariq Rauf, participants.
SUMMARY
Metta Spencer hosted the October 2026 Global Town Hall of Project Save the World, with Alan Haber, Tom Hedberg, Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance, Shane Steinman, Bill Leikam, Marilyn Krieger, Tariq Rauf, and newcomer Sam Hall taking part. Alan Haber described his summer in France and argued that peace could become the central demand of coming years, contrasting full-spectrum domination with cooperation. Tom Hedberg described his work against misinformation and argued that the public must know the facts. Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance described visiting Rohingya refugee camps in Bangladesh and asked for pressure on Myanmar to honor repatriation agreements.
Read more…
Shane Steinman said he spent about sixteen years on the Peace of Jerusalem initiative, is stepping back from it, and has a paper on the physics of consciousness under review at CERN. Bill Leikam said that reading Michael Levin's book and studying altered states led him to conclude that consciousness is a whole greater than the sum of its parts, which he illustrated with a flower dissected by students. Metta Spencer summarized Levin's view that a whole imposes a pattern on its cells. Sam Hall described Forgefield and an ideation assembly drawing on sortition, which Metta Spencer endorsed. Bill Leikam then described efforts to remove concrete from Matadero Creek to restore wildlife passage.
Tariq Rauf argued that the United States had placed non-nuclear weapons in space, weakening the 1967 Outer Space Treaty, and mentioned a Chinese presentation of a lunar rock about 4 billion years old. He said the Golden Dome missile defense project would need Canadian radars and that Canada faced pressure to join. Western states wanted to keep room for non-nuclear space weapons, while China and Russia wanted a broader ban. Shane Steinman asked whether Canada still mattered given Greenland and Alaska, and Tariq Rauf answered that Canada held the bulk of the Arctic frontage. Tariq Rauf also described the Greenland base history and the Chinese interest in its minerals.
Metta Spencer returned to Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance, who called for a timeline for Rohingya return, recognition of their citizenship, and emergency sanctions. Metta Spencer argued that resolutions were inadequate and that penalties on the Myanmar government were needed. Alan Haber compared the Rohingya situation to the Palestinian right of return. Metta Spencer said enforcing international law was essential. Marilyn Krieger then described a local study of mountain lion crossings, using culverts and cameras, and concerns about agencies clearing forests under fire-prevention permits. Metta Spencer asked for objective criteria, and Marilyn Krieger said responsible Indigenous fire methods existed. Metta Spencer then ended the call.
Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. A speaker the team did not list is shown as “Participant”.
Metta Spencer
Hi, I'm Metta Spencer, and today is Sunday, October the 25th, 2026, and that means this is the last Sunday in the month, which is when we hold our monthly Global Town Hall. And I've already opened the door, because my friend Peter Wadhams has been… was sitting here quite a while before. He came early, and I didn't let him in, because I was putting on my lipstick and combing my hair, and I don't like to have anybody watch me comb my hair.
Participant
Certainly, because I'm guessing calc… doing the calculations for the time, so… answers wrongly.
Metta Spencer
Anyway, there's two other people in the waiting room, and I'd better let them in, because we're going to talk about good news… good heavens knows what. No, I'll check first to see who they are. One is Alan Haber, oh, and the other one is… is not really a person, it's a… It's a machine that, records what we're saying. So that one of my other friends, Ryan von Herzen, can, can parti… participate in Australia without, actually being present. And so he gets to sleep in, because it's the middle of the night there. But he'll join us later, I think. He's a really good guy. And there's Alan haber. Well, hello, Alan! See if I can move it… I'll be able to take out.
Marilyn Krieger
Looks like shade left.
Metta Spencer
Okay. Well, we have to, Okay, Alan, let's go back to France. When you wrote me last, you were in France for the summer. I think. Now… What was that all about? I think you go because your wife is from France, right?
Alan Haber
Yeah, Odile, my wife. And partner… is French, grew up in France, and Morocco, and North Africa, and… Came to America, and we met in Berkeley. And her family has a house in a little village in Burgundy. summer, you know, we go there and connect with the French family of brother and sisters, and… Odile is now the senior of the family. And that is a respite in some way from the activities of Ann Arbor. And an opportunity to think some different things through, and it's a beautiful old house. 1666 is carved in the roof beam. In a village of 500 people. And except for Odile, you know, I'm the only one there who speaks English.
So it's an interesting experience, and it's a, L… And then I'm back to America, and reflecting on how, from a distance, things look close up. In America… and a very indeterminate, progressive movement, still with a centrist in control of the Democratic Party. And I perceive a, prospective opening. In the next several years, with the next, government, however this midterm turns out. Where peace could actually be the central question of discussion. Do we put peace as our demand? Which affects all the different movements we've been struggling for? Or just, somehow that, A basic question of whether a system is full-spectrum domination, like the war system all over the world, and in our schools and everywhere.
Or is it a PE system of full-spectrum cooperation, and actually use a space of great indeterminacy, should we lose so long? to, actually introduce system change as the basic human need. Which affects all our subsystems and pieces, the basic question. Did we, live so long? Anyhow, that's what's on my mind, and I hope we could have some discussion in this, town hall. On how to put…
Metta Spencer
Listen, I want… I want that very conversation, but before we do, we have to… I should tell people who you are, because you've been… you haven't attended recently, and probably most people don't know. the name Alan haber, because back in the 60s, you know, during the, the great… last great leftist kind of reformist movement in the U.S, you were one of the great leaders of… was it Students for Democratic Society?
Alan Haber
Yes, SDS, and we, of course, are now, we've continued. There are 40-some student SDS groups, but there's also Seniors for Democratic Society, and
Metta Spencer
for a democratic society.
Alan Haber
and Semites for democratic society is a very important group right now, given the state of the world, so…
Metta Spencer
So much.
Alan Haber
And it's really the call that all of us are involved in this world situation, and we have a solidarity for democratic society that we have to activate. That's what we're all somehow about, and how to find one another, and a useful, progressive Change the world's way.
Metta Spencer
Well, you and I are pretty much the same generation, much older than most of the other people who are also seniors who attend this meeting, but they're… we've got several years on them. And I was never a member of SDS, but I certainly knew about it because I lived in Berkeley. During the, free speech movement. The whole works. So, I was very familiar with SDS, and many of my friends were engaged. And you were one of the great leaders. So, we can get back to talking about that, and seeing how to… move it forward now, but I have another couple of, people who just joined us, I should greet them. One is Dr. Hedberg. And, Dr.
Hedberg is a scientist, and And his own kind of firebrand. He's very keen on… Doing work against, the, misinformation and disinformation that has become so prevalent today. But his face is not showing. I've got 3 people here who just think they can get away with just putting their names up, and… and I will let that stand. No siree. I expect everybody to show their faces, so… Dr. Hedberg, according to your…
Participant
off.
Tom Hedberg
Let me… let me explain. Because it's Sunday, I'm doing this from home, it's a rare chance to be at home, and alas, my home machine does not have a camera. Now, I will take a… if we get a break, I have an extra one upstairs, I'm gonna see if I can hook it up, but my apologies, I do not have a camera built in at the moment.
Metta Spencer
Okay, well…
Tom Hedberg
what I look like anyway.
Metta Spencer
I know, but no, no, actually, I don't know much about what you look like, or… I know a lot about how you talk. You have a big mouth.
Tom Hedberg
I will, I will try and find a camera, I promise.
Metta Spencer
Okay, fine, that's good. And, Muhammad, your name was here a moment ago, but it went… went off. Now all… now all I see is Muhammad. And there are plenty of other Muhammads in this world, so, sir, you have to introduce yourself and tell us who you are.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Oh, hi, this is, Muhammad Mominulhwag. I am actually, Live and work in Toronto, Canada. I am the Director for Peace and Justice Alliance, and I work for Democracy and Human Rights for last 15 years, now I am visiting Bangladesh. And I, had the opportunity to attend, your program several times, and I raised the issue about the ousted, dictator and fascist kleptocracy, Sheikhasina regime, who now escaped to India. I raised the issue. Now, I'm visiting Bangladesh, post-dictitorial, situation, what's going on in Bangladesh. Recently, I had the opportunity to visit, world's largest, refuzi camp, Rohingya, refuzi camp. I went there, you know, over 1.2 million Rohingya refugees now, in Bangladesh, Rohingya.
They are struggling with their shelter, food, and they want global, solidarity and advocacy to go back their home, because they are now living in inhumanitarian situation. And Bangladesh, as a host country, they could not, help them, because they are also a poor nation. I went there, and if you give me permission after this meeting, or during the meeting, I can show, some picture of them, and actually, they are living, in humanitarian condition. Tiny houses, made by… Bembo and Polythene. Global donor agencies and the government, they used to pay Monthly, about $12 to $16. Now, for the global crisis and global economic, situation, they… reduce the ration. Now they are paying monthly a person $6 to $7. It is very hard for them to survive.
And during the… yeah, so they… we call to the global, community to increase their… Donor financial assistance, also, they need to work, because, you know, 1978 and 1992, Rohin… Burma and Bangladesh government had agreement, repatriation. Indeed, in that time. Burma, now in Myanmar, they said that Rohingya, they are national, they are… they are citizens, but they are not giving their citizenship right, they are… freedom. Now, Rohingya people want the implementation of that. Agreement. 1978 and 1992 agreement. So that is that they are called, Rohingya people call, and you know, how long they will stay here without their But Rohingya people say that we want to go back our home. dignified way as a citizen of, Burma.
Now… I am actually went there, and I… I could not help them lot, but I was trying to… listen, and I want to bring to your audience and this program, Global Town Hall Meeting, is there any way we can raise this issue in the globalist stage that Rohingya people, should get their rights, and they need to go back their home, because they are not citizens of Bangladesh, they are the citizen of the
Metta Spencer
glad that you're here, because I want you to tell us more about this. And the last I heard, the Rohingya people were living on some kind of island that they were given. But it looked like it wasn't really a sustainable place to live, that there would be floods and that sort of thing. Is that still the case?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Yeah, the… actually, the previous government, they sent, about 100,000 Rohingya forcefully to the different place, it's called Bashant Chor, it's another island, isolated island.
Metta Spencer
Okay. I think we all agree with you, and we want to come back in a bit and talk about maybe ways we might be able to think of a way of hoping. But I have three newcomers here, Shane Stein Steinman, Bill Leikam, who's a real regular. And Sam Hall, who's a newbie.
Shane Steinman
I'm on.
Metta Spencer
Yeah, good. Okay, tell us what you've been doing in, I think maybe the last 15 years. I think that's maybe the last time I talked to you.
Shane Steinman
Well, I think… I think I was on about 5 or 6 years ago. Yeah, it's been a little while. For about 16 years, sort of ending this year, I was working on the PEACE of Jerusalem project, initiative, I guess it's officially. And, that has been, like, a, something that's close to my heart, for a long time, and I'm just stepping back from that now, sort of letting the ideas that were created during that… that process, because it's really a document creation process. Letting those ideas sort of simmer, and see if people pick them up and use them for something good.
Anyway, for the last 5 years, I've also been… as I've been stepping back from that role, I've been involving myself more with something that's further afield in physics, the physics of consciousness, and I've recently submitted a paper, which is still under review at CERN, and so I'm just waiting to hear back on that.
Metta Spencer
Oh, wow, now there, my ears are flapping already.
Shane Steinman
I know.
Metta Spencer
Oh, I am okay. I want to hear more about that, because about 3 nights a week, I spend an hour or so watching a video of Michael Levin. And the physics of consciousness is a… is a term that is suddenly becoming very, very, Oh, okay. Now you've got a whole bunch of people waiting to hear. Well, let's come back to it in a little bit, because I will… I am personally very interested in that, although I don't know how many of us here are. We are mostly on a different wavelength. Oh, Bill, Leikam! All right, I was about to fall on you anyway. Sure,
Bill Leikam
I just… I… just about a month, two months ago, finished Michael's book. on the nature of consciousness. Back in the 1970s, I was going to work on a PhD at the University of California at Santa Cruz, because they had a program up there on the nature of consciousness. That kicked me into… I didn't… I never did, make it up there to, Santa Cruz, but… That led me into a series of studies on the nature of altered states of consciousness, and using altered states to as a foil to, ordinary consciousness, I have come to the conclusion overall, at my age of 86 years old. That consciousness is the whole that is more than the sum of its parts.
Metta Spencer
Okay. That's really, provocative. provocative statement, because, of course, one has to say, what do you mean by that? So, in the next couple of minutes, tell us what you mean by that, and then we'll go on, because I want to greet Sam Hall in a moment, but you… I'm so keen to hear this, so please proceed. Yeah, yeah.
Bill Leikam
Well… I've always held that that scientific adage that the whole is more than some of its parts is not as well known as it should be, because when I was teaching, school. I, got into this with my students. And one day, I brought with me a flower. And I put that on the table. And I said, what do I have here? And they said, well, a flower, right? Yeah. So I started picking the flower apart. Putting the pedals here and there. And by the time we got done with it, I said, is this the same? That's what we started with. And they said, well, no, of course not. So, that's a… that's a model, or an example.
Metta Spencer
Okay.
Bill Leikam
out of the hole, is more than the parts.
Metta Spencer
Hmm? All right, well now, I don't know whether I want to go… No, I'll save it for later. The thing that Michael Levin adds to this is the concern, the interest in how… A whole, the whole, brings coherence to the part. In other words, he's interested in the way entities organize themselves. You know, we start off as one cell, and look at us now. And somehow, all of these… these little parts, kept splitting and dividing and doing things and interacting and cooperating and… and whatnot, until… look at how, you know, what… what we've turned into.
The question is, how… The whole organism has a pattern, a design, that it That it then imposes on the individual cells to make them into a coherent, interacting, interdependent, set of organisms… organ… organs that make, a real Fully grown human. or plant. organism. And that interest in how the parts manage to organize themselves and make something larger than the sum of the parts is, of course, the big mystery. How do we do it? And I think that is the… one of the biggest mysteries of all.
What Michael Levin says is that there is, There is an invisible pattern that gets invoked and applied when moving all these pieces together and informing the individual parts what their role is, and what their duty is, and what they're supposed to be doing. And each little part only knows only knows what it's supposed to be doing. It's a very limited notion of what its goal is, but they do He maintains that all of the parts actually are conscious, but in a very reduced way.
They certainly have they can't talk politics, they don't know that they're even part of a bigger organism, probably, but they all know pretty much what they're supposed to be doing, and they will do their very best to keep doing it, and do… so if you move them around. They will… and if you get in their way, and you obstruct what their goal is, keep them from fulfilling their goal. they will try to… to, overcome the obstacles and… and do the best to do what they're… they're programmed to do. But that programming is not something built in physically. It's… it's a… it's a pattern, and… and it's not visible.
But it's more or less what Plato had in mind when he talked about I didn't turn it off, I want to see where it is. Okay, anything… you… here's your moment. Make your pitch for whatever, cause you want to convince us of today.
Tom Hedberg
Well, you know, first of all, I think it's very interesting what you're just talking about, about pieces being part of a whole and organized consciousness and whatnot. I did kind of a elongated poem on this called Metamorphosis, and it takes the thesis that insects which, as you know, are a very, very, highly defined clade of organisms on this planet, are part of a larger whole, which was called the Caneuwa. And, it's kind of a neat home. Anyway, I don't want to get into that, but… Metamorphosis.
Metta Spencer
Oh, okay.
Tom Hedberg
I'll bring it this way, but as long as you can… if I do this, you should be able to hear me pretty well. It's called… it's called metamorphosis, and it has to do with this kind of funky idea that insects are part of a larger organism that has been developing and evolving since the Paleozoic. So, it's kind of a neat… it's part of a collection of 21 stories in my book called Continental Drift. And, anyway, I don't want to get into that, but, kind of, kind of a fun thing to write. But now, to get…
Metta Spencer
I want to get into it, but maybe not this moment, but… Okay, authentic to you, maybe.
Tom Hedberg
Metta, I'll send it to you, no problem, you'll enjoy reading it. Okay, so… but basically, what Metta was saying before about misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda, I think, very clearly it is one of the biggest problems We're dealing with nowadays, globally, because scientific reality, and in fact, reality itself, is under attack. By, extremely well-funded political and corporate interests. And if the public believes a lot of, excuse me, bullshit, which is being disseminated like mad globally by very, again, well-funded, well-connected political and corporate interests. We're not going to accomplish anything unless we have the public on our side, and the only way the public is going to be on our side, so to speak, is if they know what the facts are.
And the problem is the facts are actively under attack. Now, the reason I can speak to this is I'm head of International Medical Crisis Response Alliance, which is a branch of the United Nations, ECASOC. We work But, we have found that a lot of the videos and, Educational modules that we have developed have come under attack by people who are believing misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda, and accusing us of liberal, you know, this, that, and the other thing. Nonstop. So, anyway, that's what our program is. We have a, A specific approach, which is called DTTC, or Disseminating Truth in Telecommunications. which I'd be happy to talk to anyone about at greater length, but basically what it does is addresses the problems at the root.
Or, you know, in medical terms, you talk about the etiology of the disease itself. Because we have a global problem with belief. In misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda, and the support of leaders and politicians and corporate figures who general… who continually pump this stuff out. In order to solve the problem, you don't deal with the end result, which is the leaders and the politicians who are dealing with it. You deal with the people who are electing them to begin with, and who are supporting them, and who are not revolting against what they're doing. So, we're addressing the problem of misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda via the DTTC program, which basically, in a nutshell, and I'll wrap up right after this.
Metta Spencer
Rona, what is DTTC?
Tom Hedberg
Exseminating truth in telecommunications.
Metta Spencer
And this is an existing movement of some kind?
Tom Hedberg
It is, yes. It's a very well-defined program, that IMCRA has been pursuing for about 3 years now. And just to give you a better idea… How do you mean?
Metta Spencer
This is a movement that you have created.
Tom Hedberg
Correct, myself and colleagues.
Metta Spencer
Okay.
Tom Hedberg
And basically, just to put it in a nutshell, what DTTC does is it looks at why MDP, or misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda. is so attractive and so seductive to millions upon millions of people. Why do they believe this bullshit? Why do they elect the people who pump this crap out? why does… why do people like Kennedy get into the position where a guy who is a vaccine denier and a vaccine talker actually gets to be, you know. this high in the government. I mean, why do we have the leaders' leaders in the United States that we have right now? We have that garbage because people believe The propaganda that's been pumped out for now…
Bill Leikam
30 years.
Tom Hedberg
Since… since shortly after Reagan. And the trick is that if you want to convince people. Of what you're trying to sell. you use a very, very carefully, psychologically, main… how shall I put this best? A psychologically adapted approach to make what you're selling seductive. It's advertising. You use, in the case of Americans, you use soldiers, you use flapping flags, you use weeping eagles, you use yellow ribbons, you use a vernacular and a terminology that sort of resonates with the good old boys, with, you know. we're Americans, you know, we stand up for America, sort of, quasi-pseudo-patriotic kind of crap, and people love it.
They just eat it up, which is why they keep electing and supporting The people who are responsible for generating the problems we're dealing with, not to… find a point on. So what DTTC does. Is it pumps out, via social media, the same… And using the same psychological techniques that MDP does. the truth, basically. Exposing the lies for what they are, telling the truth about medical and scientific reality, and doing it in such a way that it is attractive and psychologically seductive to the same people who otherwise believe the MDC. And…
Metta Spencer
Okay.
Tom Hedberg
That's it in a nutshell. I, you know, I can define it better, but it's essentially addressing the problem at the root. Why do people believe this garbage? Why do they elect the people who dish this stuff out? It's because the propaganda is so sophisticated. And what we're trying to do is counter that propaganda by
Metta Spencer
Okay, all right. I've heard it before, but, you've got it in a nutshell now, so thank you.
Tom Hedberg
Hopefully, sure.
Metta Spencer
All right, I want to go on and talk to Sam Hall, because I, Oops.
Participant
Anyway, but… To build, kind of, on the ideas of… the… whole being greater than the sum of its parts, and how that sort of ties into our work. So my wife, Zara, and I, we run Forgefield, which you might think of as an organization that It's kind of doing… for… human social coordination, like, similar function of how open source software works, of, like, basically that we want to develop new models for bringing together people with different skills to take on big picture challenges. One of those models that might be particularly relevant here is this framework of an ideation assembly, which is basically pulling together, like, concepts from existing citizens' assembly methodologies, such as sortition. And bringing in the real-life stakeholders.
Metta Spencer
Now, if you use those words around me, I just go into ecstasy, because I believe in sortition and citizens' assemblies as one of the main things that we should draw on for saving the world. I think that is the way we're going to get there. If we're going to get there at all, we have to get people together and have them deliberate together. Not just exchange slogans, but actually do serious thinking, and… and refer to evidence, and… and so on. So… I want you to… I actually… what I think I want to do is invite you, Shane, to give me a phone call, or we can do it by Zoom, which is even better.
Have a personal conversation about how, You and I are going to have to have this part of the conversation, Off… not here.
Participant
And, so… That's something that's… Unmute.
Metta Spencer
How about you? What are you up to? You'll like them.
Bill Leikam
Oh, oh, oh, oh, I didn't… because I talked so much, I mean, I'm talking more. What am I up to? I'm up to, Influencing the, California Department of Fish and Game Commission. So that, they will, begin to, develop policy for the, California Department of Fish and Wildlife. What our objective is, is to, get… a system in place in California here. ecosystem imbalance. And we here in California don't know anything about the population. And we don't know where the population is in decline, we don't know where it's stable, nor where it's growing. And we need to know that in order for us to be able to make a clear assessment Of, the health of, wildlife systems that are pretty much throughout California.
And, so that's the most active right now. In regard to part of that. We're also, into a monstrous project, which may be taking traction. At this point, and that is that, in the late 80s and early 90s. Here in Silicon Valley. Valley Water… laid concrete in all of the creeks that are flowing from the Santa Cruz Mountains except one. And, what it did was it cut off the, passageway corridors, between the San Francisco Baylands and the, Santa Cruz Mountains, It cut… it cut that in half. It… out cut… the wildlife won't go up those streams, because there's no shelter for them. And so, we are working to get, one creek, Matadoro Creek, where I have all my trail cameras. Get the concrete out of there.
and open up a passageway for the wildlife to get to the Santa Cruz Mountains, because in the San Francisco Baylands. It's, I'm gonna use a big word. It's sick. There are a lot of, diseases, etc, canine distemper being the most prevalent. That is killing, our, Some of… some of the wildlife, gray foxes, like the one behind me. And, raccoons, and so forth. Goes on and on and on. We're working to increase the health of the San Francisco Bay Baylands.
Metta Spencer
Thank you. Well, good for you. I'm sure we're all enthusiastic supporters, even if we don't live in California or know the Minister of Fish and Wildlife. So, let me go back to Paul Warebos, who now is going to be visible. Hi, Paul, how are you?
Tariq Rauf
travel.
Metta Spencer
So I'm… Let's find out what you've been doing. I should tell people who you are a little bit. Tariq is somebody I can always count on when I want somebody to talk about, nuclear issues or, weapons, war and peace issues, global governments, governance issues. He is a specialist on Nuclear Matters, because he worked for a long time for the IAEA, if I hope I'm getting this correct. TARIQ, which is based in Vienna, and I guess he still lives in Vienna. Maybe you got attached to the place and didn't want to leave, I don't know.
But at any rate, he also, goes to UN events, but he definitely prefers not to go to New York, so… If a meeting is held in New York, he may re-enter now. So… Tell me, TARIQ, what issues are… Particularly, important to you right now?
Tariq Rauf
Yes, so here in Vienna, we not only have the International Atomic Energy Agency and the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization, but we also have the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. So, a few weeks ago, the United States announced that it had put weapons in space. So these are not nuclear weapons, but non-nuclear weapons. So we have a global treaty from 1967, called the Outer Space Treaty, which prohibits putting nuclear weapons in space. So, space was the last, frontier or environment. That humankind had not placed weapons in. And now, space is also weaponized. And it's only a matter of time before we will see, I think, nuclear weapons deployed in space as well.
But in contrast, A few days ago, the Chinese presented two. the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. A spec of a lunar sample. that was collected by a Chinese lunar mission from the backside of the moon. And so this, piece of rock, lunar rock. is characterized to be more than 4 million years old, which is considered to be older than 99% of the rocks on Earth. And here is… well, it's not showing. displayed at the Vienna International Center, where the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Aerospace is based.
Metta Spencer
So…
Tariq Rauf
We have…
Metta Spencer
Try again. I didn't… I mean, your hand sort of fluttered past, but you need to hold it still in front of your camera. I want to see that rock.
Tariq Rauf
I will send you the picture separately, if it's not picking up for some reason. But I'll send you a couple of pictures. There's also a lunar rock that was presented by the United States several decades ago. So I will send that to you by email. So now this is… this is one of the current discussions here. That we want to keep space peaceful, not weaponized, because, you know, if there is disruption in space, all of the satellites will go down. So we would not be able to have this conversation that we are having on Zoom. If you went to Loblaws, you wouldn't be able to buy anything because the cash registers would not be working. If you went to the ATM to get some money.
You wouldn't be able to draw money out, because all of these connections go by a space-based link, in addition to undersea cables. So, this is a new… domain of warfare and military competition that unfortunately has been opened up, and it affects Canada because of the so-called Golden Dome. Which is a pet project of President Trump. And as you know, there is a lot of pressure on Canada. to join the Golden Dome, project. And thus far, Canada has sort of shied away from it. And this, in a sense, is going back to an earlier concept under the Reagan administration in the 1980s called the Strategic Defense Initiative. So, you know, we are part of the North American Aerospace Defense arrangement with the United States.
for the aerospace defense of North America, that's Canada and the United States. So, if the Golden Dome is to be deployed, the U.S. will need Canadian radars, the North Warning System, based in the high north of Canada. Plus other military assets, and a lot of military spending. And unfortunately, the Canadian Parliament has not discussed this issue sufficiently, nor did the… the previous government, nor the current government under Prime Minister Kearney. To some extent, you know, they are preoccupied with the tariffs and the trade war. that has been unleashed on Canada by the U.S, so there is very little bandwidth left in foreign affairs and in the Government of Canada to also pick up another front of confrontation, with the United States.
Metta Spencer
But…
Tariq Rauf
many in the Canadian defense industry seem to be supportive of the Golden Dome project and putting more money into this venture. In addition to the increased defense spending that the current government has, authorized. Here in Western Europe, there is a huge scare that the Russians are coming, and people are being asked to lay down a supply for two weeks of food and water. And this is unnecessary scaremongering. And the people who are laughing their way to the bank. Are the defense contractors, because now everyone wants long-term defense contracts. for long-term supply of new weapons and bombs. And you see the riots in Paris, in Italy, even in Vienna.
Where people are now coming out in the streets, protesting against rising prices, particularly of fuel, oil and gas, petrol and diesel, to fuel one's car industry. And when the price of diesel goes up, everything goes up, because all the vegetables in the And Loblaws are delivered by trucks using diesel, and same thing here in Vienna. So we now have at least, you know, not only is there a Sybil Spice, but also the right-wing parties are also gaining, and it's likely that in the French presidential election, six months from now, the ultra-right-wing party led by Marie Le Pen likely will win. In the United Kingdom, if there were to be an election, again, the right-wing party would win there again.
We have right-wing governments in Norway, in Sweden, in Italy, and so on, in Hungary. So, we have this negative wave coming, where more and more we might see more civil strife.
Metta Spencer
Hmm. Okay. Well, it sounds to me like we need an article in Peace Magazine about this… the Chinese initiative, and how it connects with public opinion, in… in Europe. Is that a reasonable thing to hope for? Or is that the way you would formulate the challenge? Hello!
Tariq Rauf
I'll ask my Chinese friends, they probably have something written up on the… On the piece of rock that they donated, which is more in a broader context of space, rather than bringing in the civil strife and so on, because it's a little bit…
Metta Spencer
Right.
Tariq Rauf
Disconnected from the space issue, let's.
Metta Spencer
I would agree. But what I'm interested in is, even when I was reading in the paper about the Chinese initiative, which I didn't read much about, but I just simply wondered whether What they are proposing is really, What we would hope for. Or are they doing some self-serving, declaration.
Tariq Rauf
Well, so, as I mentioned, we have this 1967 treaty on outer space, which prohibits putting nuclear weapons in space, or testing nuclear weapons in space. So the Americans, supported by the Canadians and the Europeans, want a reaffirmation that there will be no nuclear weapons put in place. But China, Russia, and many countries of the Global South Want a broader commitment of no weapons in space. Neither nuclear nor non-nuclear. So, the Western countries are leaving open the space for putting non-nuclear weapons in space, because they have the technology advantage, because of artificial intelligence, more satellites in space, more accuracy for the time being, and since the Russians and the Chinese are behind in this technology. They would prefer a global ban on Any weapons in space.
So, that is the current divide, in Geneva. It is in Geneva that we have, the discussions on prevention of an arms race in outer space. So, Geneva is prevention of an arms race in outer space, and a UN framework, and in Vienna is the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. In Vienna, it's decided the orbits for satellites, for example, like the Starlink satellites of Musk. So countries have to register their satellites, and they are assigned an orbit, so that the satellites don't collide with each other, and so on. So that's exclusively peaceful. And when it comes to the military aspects of outer space, then we do this in Geneva.
And there, the discussions have been deadlocked for decades, and I already explained to you what the division of position is on weapons in space.
Metta Spencer
How do the European states see, the Golden Dome project?
Tariq Rauf
It depends whether it's more of a right-wing government or a left-wing government, but the Golden Dome is not to protect the Europeans, it's to protect Homeland America. America first. And in order to protect the United States, by default, they also have to include Canada. Because all the Russian missiles, for the most part, or bombers, would come over the North Pole. and overfly Canadian territory. They're not going to come over the South Pole, or fly over Europe, like planes do, to come across. So…
Metta Spencer
Do you think that the Canadian, Government will go along with with Trump. I mean, it sounded like it when Carney, right off the bat, sounded like he was ready to play ball. Izzy, or is that just a… move to placate Trump and buy time to be able to create his own distance from the U.S.
Tariq Rauf
Well, traditionally, the Canadian Department of National Defense is generally supportive of any U.S. military a project that involves Canada. Their fear is that if they don't have a finger in the pie, the US will leave them behind, and then they will not be playing in the same sandbox. As Americans. This is the whole discussion for getting this F-35. fighter planes, so that the Canadians can play in the same sandbox as their bigger friends south of the border. I mean, the Canadians, if they buy the F-35s, are only going to buy a few. The Americans are going to buy hundreds. So, in the Golden Dome, it's the same, and then the Canadian industry thinks that they may get contracts to build components of the Golden Dome.
But historically, in Canadian-American defense contracts. The spin-offs that are promised for Canadian industry. Never really materialized, so… not more than 10%. of the offsets promised to Canadian defense industry in a Canadian-US defense contract come to Canada, although promises are for 80%, 90%, 70%, and so on. So if the Europeans are interested, they may wish… they might want to bite… take a bite out of the contracts. But the Golden Dome is not for their defense, it's for the defense of North America.
Tom Hedberg
Metta?
Metta Spencer
Yeah, okay, yes, Tom, I think.
Tom Hedberg
I got a couple of questions for TARIQ, if I may.
Metta Spencer
Yeah, well, yeah, that's what I hope, is other people will ask questions. Yeah, go.
Tom Hedberg
Yeah, Terry, we're both part of… clearly, we're both part of the UN, my organization, and yours. I've got a question. What is the best way to get in touch with you? Is there a specific email, or do you prefer SMS or phone calls? What's best? All right, will do. The second thing is regarding the whole Chinese business, I didn't know that much about it, but, you had said that they picked up some material from the far side of the moon? You said it was 4 million years old. I mean, you mean 4 billion, correct? If it's older than Earth.
Tariq Rauf
I was just looking at something, I need to double-check whether it was 4 million. Yeah, you're right, it's 4 billion.
Tom Hedberg
Yes, perfectly.
Tariq Rauf
3,900 million.
Tom Hedberg
Amazing, yeah, really neat stuff. Thank you so much.
Tariq Rauf
For picking that up.
Metta Spencer
Okay, terrific. Okay.
Shane Steinman
Metta, I have a question for TARIQ.
Metta Spencer
Cheers!
Shane Steinman
TARIQ, regarding the Golden Dome, is Canada really as much of a factor as it once was, given the new arrangements that the U.S. has with Greenland, and also their position in Alaska?
Tariq Rauf
Yeah, but you're right. But, you know, Greenland is further out into the Atlantic and the East, and then Alaska has very small frontage to the Arctic Ocean. The bulk of the frontage in our hemisphere in the Arctic Ocean is us, Canada. So, the radars in Fairbanks and so on, they could pick up planes flying out of Vladivostok and flying over the North Pacific not going over the… the… the North Pole, so to speak. But the ballistic missiles will come on a trajectory, for the most part, over the North Pole. And, there's also, you know, they may also want to send their strategic bombers over the North Pole, because it's the shortest distance, depending on where the strategic bombers are launched from, from Russian bases.
So, the North Warning System, or Canadian radars, will be an integral part of the Golden Dome. It will not necessarily be the most important part, in one sense. But without the Canadian component, there will be a big hole. And also, we talk about low flyers. So the low flyers are cruise missiles. So the ballistic missiles will come through space. But the cruise missiles will come through the atmosphere, and they can also be what's called terrain-hugging, flying very low. over the surface of the Earth. And the Russians already announced a few years ago the Burveznik, which is claimed to be a nuclear-powered cruise missile. Which means that it would be traveling extremely fast compared to existing cruise missiles, which use jet engines, like on planes.
Hold on.
Metta Spencer
How in the world can you use a nuclear thing as a propellant?
Tariq Rauf
Well, both the Americans and the Soviets researched this during the Cold War. To put a small nuclear reactor on the thing? And so, it is producing a lot of energy, which is running the jet motor, the ramjet. So that can fly at several times the speed of sound. In theory, So, even the Russians have not deployed this Burbestnik, because The tests have not been successful, so many of these things look good on a computer screen. in, designing, and then a CAD system that actually Building it, and testing it, and then building it in numbers. Given the cost, The technology, and so on.
Metta Spencer
Alright, I interrupted you. continue, whatever I busted into.
Tariq Rauf
For now, if you were speaking to me.
Shane Steinman
Tariq, okay, I, I, I take, I take that point. Sorry, you know what? I don't want, I don't wanna, I don't want to take away from what you were saying, so I'm just gonna sit back for a second. Pardon me.
Tariq Rauf
Yeah, coming to Greenland, Greenland is basically a territory grabbed by Trump, because, you know, he wants to go back to the Yalta system of spheres of influence. So now that we have this projected meeting coming up in Beijing in ETEC, the Asia-Pacific Economic I forget what the C stands for, where people are talking about, Presidents Xi, Putin, and Trump meeting together to divide up the world in spheres of influence. like what was done at Georgia between Churchill, Roosevelt, and Stalin. So already, Trump has declared the Dunro Doctrine. from the Monroe Doctrine, where the American president said all of North and South America is the American backyard, and no Europeans or others should come in there, and that is why the U.S.
very nearly brought us to a nuclear war when the Soviets deployed nuclear missiles in Cuba in 1962. So, Trump has already said that if you look at the globe, Greenland belongs in the North American Hemisphere, it doesn't belong in the European Hemisphere, and therefore, he wants control over it. And basically, he wants to go down in history as somebody who enlarged the United States, and that's why he has these crazy dreams of, you know, the 51st state being us, Canada, and so on. And so, traditionally, during the Cold War, there were two big bases in Greenland, with big radars, and this was also a refueling base. for American strategic bombers. So during the Cold War, there was an operation called Operation Chromedome.
Where the strategic bombers, fully loaded with nuclear weapons, were up in the air 24 hours. on the rationale that the Russians or Soviets could have a surprise attack. Destroy all the missiles and the airfields, and then these bombers would not be able to take off. So these planes would be on long-range missions, and they would be refueled in the air, and then some of these were based in Greenland. And then one of these bombers crashed, and the nuclear bombs fell out, and not all of the bombs were recovered according to historical records. So there might be one or two deep down in the ice that were never really recovered.
And there was also a cleanup operation because of one of… one of the bombs split open. They didn't explode because of the safety devices, but some of the radioactive contents spilled out, and so they had to be scraped up, and… rendered safe. So that's… that's the reason why the U.S. has always had a footprint in Greenland, and President Trump, being a greedy guy, wants to take it over and plant the flag on it, and fortunately, the Danes and the Greenlanders have Resisted, but they still capitulated. by signing this 99-year-long free T, or whatever, extending the U.S.'s sovereignty over the airbase. That's…
Metta Spencer
already have… The, you know, the question is, how much was that a capitulation? And how much of that was Trump, backing down?
Tariq Rauf
Well, we really don't know, but according to… so he backed down from taking it over. But the Greenlanders and the Danes agreed to the United States expanding its footprint.
Metta Spencer
Hmm.
Tariq Rauf
on the base.
Metta Spencer
Hmm.
Tariq Rauf
Now, several years ago, the Chinese discovered That, one of the byproducts of mining, potash or something is uranium, and there are also rare earths in Greenland. So the Chinese went in there and made a lot of investments in Greenland. And the Greenlanders, being Indigenous peoples, like the Canadian Indigenous peoples compared to, you know, Canadians in the South and Danes in Denmark, their economic situation was not at the same level. So when the Chinese came in promising investment and jobs and leading to an improvement in the standard of living, the Greenlanders were agreeable to making agreements with the Chinese. So, this got the hackles of the United States and the Europeans that the Chinese are coming, the Chinese are coming.
And then the Chinese declared themselves to be a near-Arctic country. So, you know, we have 8 countries that are members of the Arctic Council. The two countries that have the largest real estate in the Arctic are Russia, followed by Canada, and then you have the Scandinavians and the Americans in Alaska. So, one part of the Trump policy towards Greenland also was driven by driving the Chinese out of Greenland, so that they don't have access to the rare earths. That apparently are… Can be mined in Greenland.
Shane Steinman
There's no doubt that Trump introduces a lot of noise into the general scenario, in order to give himself the best position for negotiations. And he's done this with Canada, he's done this with Greenland, saying that Canada's gonna be the 51st state, Greenland's gonna be part of the United States as well.
Tariq Rauf
Well, you know, the Carnegie government already, I think, started from the Trudeau government, they already conceded a little bit on American exports of agricultural products into Canada. And I remember a long time back, I was reading somewhere, you know, you have these factory farms in the United States, which produce chickens and beef and eggs, and some of these factory farms are so big that they produce enough eggs in one day, then all of the province of Ontario or Quebec And these are all, you know, chickens that never see the light of day.
They… they hatch, and they die, and the coops… You know, chicken meat… this is a lot of pressure here in Europe, because on Austria, there are very strict food standards, and the Americans have been pushing for exports of chicken meat, and the Europeans say, well, you wash your chicken meat in chlorine. before you put it on the shelves, because of the unhygienic conditions in the chicken coops. And we do not want this. And the Americans say, well, the buyer in Loblaws doesn't need to know where the chicken came from. All the buyer needs to know that it's chicken. And so that's the pressure that they want to put on Canada and others, so drive the small farmers out of business.
And these huge factory farms are owned by corporations. These are no longer family, family farms. This is… these are all run on business models, they're all run on genetically modified seeds, genetically modified animals. These animals are… and agriculture is pumped full of chemicals, and we don't need to know any of that. All we need to see is the green lettuce in the store and go buy it.
Metta Spencer
Well, okay, I think we've covered the water for… Not enough here. Thank you so much, TARIQ. You're really a font of wisdom. I need to call on some folks who I really promised an opportunity to elaborate their thoughts. That would be, Alan Haber and, Muhammad. Oh, yeah. So these are not Rohingya themselves. Okay. And why do they have to take stops? What are these stops? And what are we seeing here? That's what I want to know.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
So, these are the, Rohingya refugees. stand there, and they, because I speak in front of them that why global leaders and international community need to pressure Parma government, Myanmar government, to implement the 1978 and 1992 Parma and Bangladesh Agreement. that, Barma agreed that Rohingya, the citizen of that country. And we call to increase the funding. Now, the funding is very small, very low. They should get higher funding.
Metta Spencer
Okay, so there was an agreement between Burma and Bangladesh.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
taking time to bring these Rohingya refugees to back their home. Now the… I can show you some other picture that they want to go back their home, and they say, we don't want to stay as a refugee in Bangladesh. We want to go back our home. According to the 2019-1978 and 1992 agreement, because Burma agreed they are the citizen of the Burma. Rohingya is the citizen of Burma.
Metta Spencer
Now, hold on, let me make sure I understand. Burma agreed again and again, and still agrees, that these people are Burma citizens, right?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Right. But they are not agreeing now, there's us ignoring, denying.
Metta Spencer
Oh, they are now denying that they are citizens of Burma.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Yeah, and that's why they forcefully displaced these people, on 2017.
Metta Spencer
Okay, is there any procedure in which international law can be established? That it's… is there any way of saying for sure what legally, according to the World Court or whatever, these people are Burma citizens of Burma. Or… Is the challenge now to enforce the law, the international law, or is the challenge to really even establish what the international law says?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
International community need to pressure, because it is a geopolitics in Parma, India, China, USA, and Japan.
Metta Spencer
Well, now, all of those countries agree that these people are citizens of Burma. It's just a question of getting them to… put their, you know, energy where their mouth is, is that right? To enforce the law, or to do what they can to make the law apply.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Rise of the Rohingya, right? I'm a Canadian, Canadian government should provide me all the support as I am a citizen, right? Same thing, Burma, citizen now living in human condition. Now, international community need to bring highest level pressure, extraordinary measures against Burma government that they should Agree that, okay, they are our citizens, we will bring them to their homeland.
Metta Spencer
Hmm?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
And also, need to increase the… Financial assistance during the transition period, right?
Metta Spencer
Okay, what proposals are being floated for how to apply pressure? If you want the Canadian government to do something, sounds like a good idea, what do you want them to do? What could Canada or any other country do that might actually put enough pressure to have an influence on the current government of Burma.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
So, Canadian government, United States of America, European Union, and all other international community global governance. need to take one resolution, that Burma agreed, the Rohingya are their citizen. So, there should be a timeline that they will bring their citizen back to their homeland. And also, they have to create an atmosphere that Burma people will live, dignifiedly, with… peacefully, with respectfully, as a citizen of Burma. And also, they should create houses, because Burma, Junta, and Rakhain Army, they burn all the houses. There is no house, no infrastructure to live, so there should be infrastructure.
there should be, job opportunity, you need to create job and other infrastructure, so everybody should come blindly, because there should be example for the global community, like Rohingya, so then other countries will not forcefully displace ethnic people from their home, right? There is a lot of ethnic people who migrated from one country to another country during the, like, British government, when they ruled the subcontinent, Bangladesh, India.
Metta Spencer
Let's not go into ancient history. Let's talk right now about what should be done. And it sounds like you're recommending a lot of goodwill, saying everybody should play nicely now, as if, you know, all you have to do is say it. I'm thinking that if you really want to have an impact, these countries, Europe and Canada and so on, should, have a plan for penalties for Burma if they don't comply. That there needs to be real international law, and it should be enforced.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Yes.
Metta Spencer
What measures are you talking about that would actually hurt Burma if they don't comply?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
So there should be a, like, a comprehensive sanction against Burma and other countries who have investment in the Rakhine state, because we had the USA, Japan, India, mainly India, they invested a lot of money in the Rakhine, state. So those countries invested in the place where the Rohingya people were lived, there should be a punishment. And then they will bring the Rohingya to their home back, right? They want to go back. They say, we are not machine, we are human. I want to show you picture.
Metta Spencer
No, no. Let's leave off the photos right now. I want to get… because we don't have all that much time, I want to get down to looking at the actual proposal, because I think I haven't heard you say what actually… well, for example, I said somebody should be punished. Now, I think you made it… left it sounding like those countries or these people who invested in Raken State should be punished, those companies or whoever. Well, those are the people that need to be punished. It needs to be the Burma government, isn't it? And how are you going to get that part?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
party, both parties.
Metta Spencer
Well… Why… why is that going to help? If you punish the investors for investing in Rakhine State, well, that's… I would think that'd have very little influence. If you don't… the main thing is you've got to publish the government of Burma, which I believe nowadays, includes, The lady herself, you know. Is that true?
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Aung San Suki, during her regime, they killed Rohingya, you know, in her tenure, in her time. She got the Nobel Peace Prize, but during her tenure, millions… of Rohingya forcefully displaced from their home.
Metta Spencer
Yeah, well, she made very, very democratic noises, but it… what…
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
now the Burma government say there is a civil war between the pro-democracy activists and the military junta, but how long Bangladesh could keep these Rohingya refugees in this country? Because when Bangladesh is struggling to survive with their own people, they don't have enough pond to, like, give… provide a baset, or provide shelter for their own people, and now the local Bangladeshi community want International community need to bring a resolution, special measures. to bring these Rohingya refugees dignified peacefully to their home.
Metta Spencer
Frankly, I don't… Muhammad, I don't think bringing a resolution is worth anything. Sometimes you gotta do something stronger. You gotta do something like, say. all of the government officials can't visit our country. We won't give you a visa to come into any Western country unless you… change your behavior, shape up, or you can't be accepted as a citizen, a decent citizen of the world, etc. Do something like that, or do something that really hurts them. And, and.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Yeah, we want an emergency sanction.
Metta Spencer
I don't think any resolution is adequate. Okay, I want to leave room for somebody else to speak to this question, as I'm not here just for myself. You speak, but we only have a few minutes left, and My friend, Alexey Prokhorenko in Warsaw has just joined us. I always like to say hi to Alexey, so we've got to wind up this conversation in, let's say, another 5 minutes. But one of you other folks here, on this this meeting, I want you to… Enter your own thoughts about this situation. In,
Alan Haber
It seems very much to me A lied with the situation of displaced Palestinians needing also to go home. The right of return is not simply here. I'm so appreciative to Mohammed for telling this story, because I knew basically nothing. But it is a more common situation, and I would hope this struggle for return and a society being prepared to accept return could also be seen in more universal terms if this is something the Palestinians and the Israelis should learn from also. There are millions of people needing to be welcomed back home and reintegrated into a country that thought they were gone forever.
Metta Spencer
Thank you.
Mohammed Peace And Justice Alliance
Yeah, thank you.
Metta Spencer
Yeah, good idea. Anybody else? there must be people who have a good idea of what we can do to really… I think that if we want peace, one of the most important places to begin working for it is to make sure that we have ways of enforcing international law, and we don't right now. We just… the International Court will give a verdict, and it might have been out blowing in the wind. There's just nothing… has no… no influence, has no impact on what actually happens, and… Has to. We gotta shape up. All right, anybody else on this question? Because otherwise, I'm gonna go on. Alright, I think let's go on now, and
Marilyn Krieger
Hi, just a second here.
Metta Spencer
Okay.
Marilyn Krieger
We're… we're all shaking, but it has to do… we're starting a study, locally, because there's this, freeway. It has to do with putting culverts and overpasses over freeways. So, near where my house is. There's a stretch of highway where there have been quite a few mountain lion strikes lately, as well as.
Metta Spencer
Sorry, what… what strikes? Mountain.
Marilyn Krieger
well, all animals, also deer, all sorts of animals, but, the organization I'm working on, we focus on, On lions, on mountain lions, and bobcats. But we focus on the whole picture. So we're gonna be starting a study Which I'm gonna be, a part of. We're putting 48 new cameras out. What we're trying to figure out, there's a lot of politics involved, but we… we want to put culverts in. We think they're more effective than the overpasses. We're having, funding issues with the local agencies, so before that happens, before they put those culverts in, we think there should be fences. So anyway, that's kind of what I've been working on. That's one of the projects I'm working on.
I'm still working on the deforestation project as well. Which we talked about, I've talked about. Oh, the, project member I told you… I think I showed, I showed you some pictures where they're, what's happening because of, the fires. Well, there's overreaction, and they're… There are some agencies that are essentially going in and, burning down forests. I mean, I'm not… just not burning down… cutting… they're cutting the forests, and it's affecting climate. I mean, we're talking acres and acres and miles and miles of areas, and so there's a… and I'm working I'm… finding other organizations that are also involved. So anyway, that's kind of an.
Metta Spencer
Now, hold on. Now, this… I remember what you're talking about now, but I'm not completely clear. Their only reason for cutting these trees is not to get the wood for the lumber industry. It's to clear away things that might be flammable and cause a fire.
Marilyn Krieger
Well, they have very good reason for doing it, though they're overdoing it. We have fire issues, terrible. you know, and the forests are burning, and it's just… it's… and then, homes are burnt. I mean, you've been seeing it on the news, I'm sure. So, what's happening is that, They're doing fire suppression, and the way they are doing fire suppression, in some cases, not all, they are overdoing it in that there are a lot of, Indigenous trees that are being… that are protected, that are being, destroyed. And there's… because there are exemptions being issued, there is no overseeing, or very little over… environmental overseeing. So, it's, it's… yes, something has to be done, absolutely, but not to that extent.
One property, there are hundreds, hundreds of acres. And it's… it's affecting the climate as well. It's… it's not… it's not a good thing. So, anyway, so that's something I'm, I've been working on, and contacting… getting in touch with other organizations that are concerned about it. Yes, we don't want fires, you know, that, tree removal, complete tree removal and destruction of those forests is not the answer either.
Metta Spencer
Okay, now it sounds like what you need is some sort of objective, measure of where you can… you should cut Underbrush, or trees, or whatever, to reduce the flammability of the region. And where you shouldn't. And if it's just a subjective guess that people who think one way are in power, and they get their way, and the other side just has to… Forget it and accept it.
Marilyn Krieger
Well, they… they already… they have… that is in place. Definitely that is in place. It's just that, It's… some areas have gotten, should we say, a bit out of control, but I am going to say the Indigenous populations, and a lot of… a lot of it's being done very responsibly, don't get me wrong, and What… okay, one area where I am right now, there's this area called Big Basin, and in 2020, we had terrible fires that you've probably heard about. I… I was evacuated twice over it. big base had completely burned, and that's very close to where I live up here.
And what they found is the areas that… where they used the Indigenous methods, and they were maintaining through the years, although they burned, they… wasn't such a complete, terrible burn as the other areas. So, they are using some of these methods, and there are other ways that they can do it. They can do it responsibly. But what's happening is some of the government organizations, the county organizations, because they're issuing… they're issuing these permits, are doing it in a way that is not responsible. And that's… Really, and the other project I'm working on is related to that, because what's happened is that the animals that live And this is what I'm seeing.
Of course, correlation is not causation, as we know, and so there are other factors involved, but there does seem to be more deer, more, more other animals wandering down into the suburbs. Because their natural habitats are being destroyed. Also, more seem to be, but I'm not saying there are other factors involved, more, strikes, more, more deaths on the freeways that are adjacent to these areas. So, it all, all…
Metta Spencer
Ellen, I hate to do this, but I'm gonna have to cut this off quick, because there's somebody Okay, bye, friends. Take care. Bye.
