Episode 795 Greenland

Notes

Apostolos Tsiouvalas is editor of the newsletter of the Arctic Institute in Tromso, Norway. He updates Barry Stevens and Metta Spencer about the geopolitical drama in Greenland.

Guests

  • Apostolos Tsiouvalas
  • Barry Stevens

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

Arctic, ice, Greenland, indigenous, climate, Denmark, change, sovereignty, island, states, Russian, Canada, agreement, Danish, presence, Russia, navigation, nuclear, Ocean, technologies

SPEAKERS

Apostolos Tsiouvalas, Barry Stevens, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Metta Spencer hosted a conversation with Apostolos Tsiouvalas, a senior fellow at the Arctic Institute in Tromsø, and filmmaker Barry Stevens, about Greenland's vote on a new defense agreement with the United States and about wider Arctic issues. Apostolos expected the Greenlandic parliament to approve the deal, which expands the American presence at the Thule base and creates two new bases while affirming Danish sovereignty and Greenlandic self-determination. Barry asked whether the deal could have been reached without annexation threats, and Apostolos said it could likely have happened anyway, calling claims of Russian and Chinese military presence on the island vague and far from reality.

Read more…

Barry raised a nuclear weapons accident near Thule, with a weapon still lying at the bottom of the sea. Apostolos said Arctic Council research around 2012 found accumulated nuclear material in Inuit breast milk, passed to babies, and that the accident had been hidden during the Cold War. Metta compared this to the American baby-tooth campaign, and Barry linked that campaign to the partial test ban treaty. Apostolos said the bomb's location is uncertain, probably off Cape York. He then explained that Greenland is part of the Kingdom of Denmark, has a referendum path to independence, but depends economically on Danish subsidies, so independence is not feasible now. Annexation ideas, he noted, date back to 1916.

Turning to climate, Apostolos described sea ice as legally ambiguous, neither land nor water, and said ice-breaking technology treats it as an obstruction while Inuit depend on it. He reported hunters unable to use dog sleds or kayaks on unstable ice, and said Sámi reindeer legs fall through the ice, pushing herders toward indoor feeding. Metta said some people enthusiastically welcome Arctic shipping routes, and asked whether indigenous people share that enthusiasm. Apostolos said they generally do not, that trans-polar routes are not commercially viable, and that Canada's North Shipping Corridor Initiative incorporates indigenous knowledge. He added that Canada and Russia claim Arctic passages as internal waters, which the United States challenges by sending vessels.

Apostolos said the Arctic Council excludes security matters and that Russia's participation has been limited since the invasion of Ukraine, though scientific groups are trying to resume collaboration. Metta recalled Gorbachev's 1989 Murmansk speech and raised Russian nuclear sites such as Novaya Zemlya. On geoengineering, Apostolos described Sámi opposition to a Cambridge solar radiation study in Kiruna, a company's glass bead experiment in Alaska conducted without consent, and ice refreezing projects that some indigenous communities welcome. He worried these technologies distract from cutting fossil fuel emissions. Metta favored small-scale experiments, and the conversation ended with thanks after Barry left for an appointment.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:00

Hi, I'm Metta Spencer, and today we're going to go to, I think, Norway, and talk to a Greek, and his name is Apostolos Tsiouvalas, and he is a senior fellow at the Arctic Institute in Tromsø, Norway, and he's editor-in-chief of their, I guess, newsletter called The Arctic This Week, and he works in the Norwegian Center for Law of the Sea. On such topics as polar law and indigenous rights. But our interest today is to talk about Greenland in particular, because as I understand it, today is the day when the Greenlanders are voting to decide whether or not to accept the New Deal with the U.S. And so we'll ask Apostolos about that in a minute.

But let me also introduce my friend Barry Stevens, who is a filmmaker. He makes a lot of marvelous documentary films. And he's going to spend a little while with us, although he has to leave in a bit to go see a doctor. So hi, Apostolos. How are you?

Speaker 2 1:20

I'm great. Great joining your show. Thanks for having me.

Speaker 1 1:24

Well, I'm doing fine. And hi, Barry, how are you?

Speaker 3 1:29

I'm okay, thanks.

Speaker 1 1:30

Okay, let's go. Barry, why don't you take charge since you need all the time you can get with this man?

Speaker 3 1:38

Well, yes, since we're talking about Greenland, and if the day is indeed the vote, which way do you think it's going to go?

Speaker 2 1:48

I'm quite confident that the Greenlandic Parliament is going to pass the vote because there's a long procedure behind that. And often when a state ratifies an international agreement, then this agreement needs to be ratified after signature by the local parliament and then endorsed domestically and enacted in domestic law. So I think that the government of Greenland as well as the government of Denmark and the US, they were all quite keen on having this deal accepted. So I believe that it will be a positive result from the internal parliamentary process in passing the new agreement. What changes? What changes? I mean, the historical relation of U.S.

Army and Greenland can be traced nearly 80 years back, right, with the 1951 agreement on the militarization of Pitufik, as it's now called Thule, as most people know it, in the northwest part of Greenland, in Cape York, in Avanershoek. And according to this agreement, there is a permanent U.S. presence in the station of approximately… 200 military people together with 500 more officers. So in total, the base can host maximum 1000 people, but 600-700 people have been always there. And this includes also Canadian individuals, Danish military officers, some security personnel as well as scientific personnel engaged in the base.

But with that agreement, Officially, Greenland and Denmark, they give the green light to the Americans to expand the scope of the base and expand as well the military presence on the island. This entails the creation of two new American bases, one in Narsarsuak and one in Mesterwick. So at the same time, Any military action by non-NATO members is not allowed on the island, which is not really a new thing, but the agreement comes to affirm the close relationship of Denmark and the US when it comes to security and their friendship within the NATO and collaboration within the NATO alliance.

A lot of things might change, but it's mostly an affirmation of a long established relationship that has been happening with respect to the island for a long time. And I would also like to highlight that the agreement came also to acknowledge the self-determination of the Greenlandic people and it does not set into questions Any questions of sovereignty, any issues of sovereignty with respect to the island, because most of the public debate in early 2026 has been about whether Danish sovereignty, the sovereignty of the kingdom over the island, can be challenged actually by the American presence. But eventually with All these efforts, what Trump and the US administration managed to push is a better military agreement on better terms.

Speaker 1 5:23

Wait a minute, let me clarify from my own mind. You're saying that for the last several years, the American presence could have already been challenging Danish sovereignty? I was not aware that there had been any, that the U.S. had anything to say about Danish sovereignty. I knew that the Greenlanders and the Danes had not exactly comparable or identical views. But what does the U.S. have to do with that?

Speaker 2 6:04

I didn't say that the U.S. presence is challenging Danish sovereignty on the island. First of all, to make it clear for the viewers as well, Greenland belongs together with the Faroe Islands to the Kingdom of Denmark. So the sovereign state is the Kingdom of Denmark. And within the NATO alliance, there is a long term established military collaboration between the United States and Denmark. Because for matters of security, it is still Denmark as a sovereign state that is responsible for the defense of the island. So what actually came to challenge us is this narrative, this discourse on public discourse about potential annexation of Greenland to the United States, all those threats by President Trump and so on.

But the actual reality is not that this relationship The American presence of the island has been challenging Danish sovereignty. But with pushing the limits of Denmark, they managed to get a way better military agreement for the protection of the island.

Speaker 3 7:13

Couldn't they have had that without all these threats of annexation? I mean, wasn't that deal basically something they could have had anyway?

Speaker 2 7:22

Absolutely. I mean, people are arguing that the Arctic today is experiencing a new Cold War period, right? The diplomacy is giving space to more raw power dynamics. And we can see that this specific administration of the United States at the moment is very keen on those rather extremist narratives in order to succeed a certain diplomatic gain. The entire picture just backed an agreement that could perhaps unavoidable happen anyway. And I find all those statements about Russian and Chinese presence in Greenland quite vague and far from reality because there has not been a military presence by Russian or Chinese on Greenland land that could be threatened to American Security or to NATO security per se.

In fact, Green Lanterns themselves have been kicking out both China and Russia from many investment projects on the island because there has been quite a few stories in the past where Chinese and Russian investors were trying to get some sort of influence Through creation of infrastructure on the island, expansion of airports and so on. But in reality, this has not really been enabled, neither by Denmark or by Grenaders themselves. Instead, Greenland has been always closed to the United States and in the Americas have been those expanding existing infrastructure with creation of airports and roads already since Truman's administration in the 50s. So there is a long And

Speaker 3 9:13

with nuclear weapons, too. I mean, they used to have B-52s carrying nuclear weapons at what I've always called Thule at that base. In fact, there's a very famous nuclear weapons accident, a nuclear weapon that still lies at the bottom of the sea out there. Sorry, go ahead.

Speaker 2 9:34

I just wanted to add, I lived quite some time in Kanak, in Avan Airstrack, which is just 150 km north of the Thule base. And people were saying that still in different examinations, they can find nuclear material accumulated in their own bodies and even on breastfeeding milk. And there was a research by the Arctic Council exactly on the topic that found accumulated nuclear material on breastfeeders in 2012, if I record correctly. So it is still there and has a long lasting impact for the environment. Because those communities are predominantly fed on marine mammals and those live quite long and they are top predators on the chain. So accumulation moves from plankton to big mammals.

Speaker 1 10:40

Did you say breastfeeders?

Speaker 2 10:42

Yes.

Speaker 1 10:43

Babies.

Speaker 2 10:45

Inuit women breastfeeding, exactly. So this was going directly to the babies through Bailey.

Speaker 1 10:51

Oh, my God. Well, here, this is something we would want to publicize because I had never heard that and I'm astounded. Has this been well publicized? Because, you know, back in the early days of the Cold War, a lot of women in North America collected baby teeth And sent them in to be analyzed. And that really made a difference. Because when they showed that babies, baby teeth, had radioactive contamination, it made a big impact on public opinion.

Speaker 3 11:31

And the partial test ban treaty came out of that to a large degree.

Speaker 1 11:36

Yeah. And I haven't heard that, that anybody's been doing anything equivalent to that. When did this happen, this study of baby teeth? Breast milk, for that matter, I guess you could even…

Speaker 2 11:52

I think that was approximately 15 years ago. And within the Arctic, it gained quite good publicity. And I'm not sure about potential process to compensate and so on. But during the Cold War period, the whole accident was hidden for quite some time until it eventually came up.

Speaker 1 12:14

Do they know more or less where the bomb fell and where they should go looking for it? Or is it just too big an area to try to do a search?

Speaker 2 12:26

I mean, the area is vast and it's covered by sea ice for most of the year, but it is supposed to be somewhere off the coast of Cape York. And I'm pretty sure that the impact have also reached the Ellesmere Island on the Canadian side of the pool in surrounding the area. That's really interesting.

Speaker 1 12:50

Eric, don't make a documentary. We need to have this shown.

Speaker 3 12:56

What's this?

Speaker 1 12:57

Sorry? I want you to go make a documentary movie about this.

Speaker 3 13:02

Oh, I see. Yeah. Well, I am working, of course, on that documentary about nuclear weapons, and nuclear accidents are a big part of that. And that's a very famous one, the one in Northern Greenland. There are implications on sovereignty, and you just said that the vote that's happening today affirms Greenlandic sovereignty, presumably with the borders and national defense still resting with Copenhagen. But is this affirmation of Greenlandic sovereignty in the agreement something new or more advanced? Or is it just a reaffirmation of what was before?

Speaker 2 13:52

Right. So it's an affirmation of Greenlandic self-determination, which already acknowledged in the 2009 Self-Government Act by the Danish Parliament. So to make the things clear, sovereignty on the island lies with the Kingdom of Denmark. Greenland, however, is a country within Denmark and the Greenlandic people are a people with a right to self-determination like all peoples in the world. However, at the moment, Greenland is a part of the Kingdom, but it does not have sovereignty per se, in the sense that as a sovereign state. Of course, there is a big discourse and momentum on sovereignty by those advocating for Greenland independence, but the question of independence is At the moment, perhaps a bit silenced because of all this geopolitical turbulence in response to the U .S.

interest on the island and the Greenland government has been quite clear that For us, if we have to remain with someone at this point, is Denmark. So we're talking about Danish sovereignty. So the defense agreement came to acknowledge this long-lasting collaboration of friendship and alliance between Denmark, Greenland and the US, acknowledge the Danish sovereignty on the island and the Greenland people's self-determination. As the foremost principle. Under Danish law, under the Self-Government Act for Greenland of 2009, the Self-Styre-Aklav, as it's called in Danish, there is a process for Greenland to, anytime they want to, through referendum to achieve independence, which will entail that then they become a sovereign state.

However, this is not happening at this point because it is not physical at this point of time because Greenland is economically also linked to Denmark. I think they receive approximately $730 million It's approximately 6 billion Danish kroner per year as a subsidized by the Kingdom. So much of their annual budget depends on this support they receive from the Danish government. So while the possibility of independence is still there, it can't It is not feasible at this point that Greenlanders would decide to do so. But if they decide to do so, they have all the legal means to do that.

Speaker 1 16:58

Do you think their attitude, the Greenlanders' attitude toward Denmark has become more cordial as a result of this threat to their own self-determination from the US? And had it ever happened before, Had any other president or other influential person in the US ever previously proposed taking over Greenland?

Speaker 2 17:26

I mean, the annexation of Greenland has been a question always, right? It was first addressed in 1916, when the US bought Virgin Islands, the West Indies from Denmark, and the question of Greenland was also set there. At this point, Greenland was still a colony. And under the League of Nations mandate, so it was not part constitutionally recognized to the Kingdom of Denmark. This happened only in 1951 or 1953, if I recall correctly, when Greenland became an indispensable part of the Kingdom. So in 1916, it was the first interest.

And then under Truman's administration in the 50s, the question of purchasing Greenland came But even in the late 19th century, certain American politicians, when, for example, the purchase of Alaska took place, the question of Greenland was also discussed there. But formal proposal happened only in the 50s under Truman's administration. And then it got reiterated again later with Trump administration. But the US has been always interested in the island. My taking is that the entire geopolitical situation with respect to the island brought Greenland closer to Denmark because they have been working on a protracted decolonization process over the last few decades. There is trust between the two authorities.

Of course, the impacts of colonization are still there, but Greenland, in one way or the other, They are collaborating with Denmark in that regard. Denmark ensures the protection of the island through the exercise of sovereignty, decides on issues on defense and security, and then these questions of resource management, for example, or local offers are arrested with the Greenland government per se.

So this whole situation brought Greenland Closer to Denmark and this is also affirmed by the Greenland government saying that if we had to choose between the US and Denmark, the question is, it's not even a matter of question, we want to remain with Denmark and approximately 90% of Greenlanders view themselves as part of them, as remaining part of them compared to becoming a part of the United States because they are still part of a social welfare state. I'm pretty sure they will not be willing to become the new American US state. However, there is a very small minority of Greenlanders that they also feel that the u.s.

could be the trajectory for them to decouple further from the kingdom and from the colonial rule that they have for uh over uh three centuries now two centuries

Speaker 3 20:40

that that that would be a I think something of a of A strategic mistake on their part. I don't think that their prospects would be much greater. Earlier this year, I was in Mexico, and in Oaxaca, Mexico, and there was a shop that was selling T-shirts with a Greenland flag on them. And Greenland's flag is, of course, one of the coolest flags in the world. One of the most beautiful flags in the world.

Speaker 1 21:12

I have to take a picture of it.

Speaker 3 21:13

Oh, it's great. It's a very cool flag. But it was very clear at that point earlier this year when the president was making noises about annexing Canada, dominating everything, and basically owning the Americas. And that was, but that moment seems to have passed. I wonder if, Mere, you may wish to continue on this issue of independence for Greenland, but I was wondering about the effects of climate change. And also, Apostolos, you've talked, or you've written, A lot about the law of sea and ice, which really interests me. It's something I've never even thought of before. I guess the question is, how is climate change and the reduction of sea ice an important thing to talk about, and how is it affecting all these matters?

Speaker 2 22:12

Perhaps a conclusion to the previous discussion on Greenland and sovereignty. Something that I forgot to mention is that the Greenlanders themselves, and then I'm moving it twice, the Greenlanders themselves make it quite clear through the Inuit circumstances They made clear that for us, and in Greenland I want to mention 89% of the entire population is Inuit, they made clear that for the Inuit there is no such thing, such a better colonizer, whether we talk about Americans, whether we talk about About Denmark, the Green Ladder should be thought as a people with their own right to self-determination. But out of pragmatic necessity, the situation now is moving elsewhere. So to move into the ice, ice is a really fascinating topic.

And I wrote my PhD dissertation actually on that. And my first monograph on the issue is coming this February with Rutledge. So I encourage you to look further. Congratulations. I'm discussing the question of ice, also because of climate change, but because ice is not land, ice is not water, it can be used as both, it can be used as none, it's something that creates confusion to legal imagination, right? In law, we like to think of definitions, typologies, boundaries. Ice is just a material substance that blurs the limits between all of those. We have law of the sea, we have law of the land, we never had laws about the ice. Indigenous peoples did, but Arctic states never did so.

The question of whether under ice there is land, there is water, there is resources, has been always driving legal imagination and has led different Arctic states regulating ice-covered areas differently. In light of climate change, this confusion is perhaps retreating a bit because we have more and less and less ice covered, so more and more accessible areas of the Arctic Ocean, which mean excellent conditions for increasing circumpolar navigation. We have the development of ice breaking, increasingly employed ice breaking technologies in the Arctic, which Directly break the material condition of the ice. They see ice as an obstruction, as something to be circumnavigated.

And at the same time, we have Arctic indigenous people, such as the Inuit, to refer again, who are people of the cryosphere, as they call it themselves. They live, walk, hunt on ice. So ice is fundamental to their very being in the Arctic. And then the whole idea of climate change is Together with the advancement of ice breaking technologies is creating fundamental challenges to their very existence in the Arctic or has led many of those to adapt to a completely new reality.

For example, when I was Living in Northwest Greenland, hunters were telling me that because of this unclear condition of the ice, the ice is not solid enough to dog sled on it and go out for hunting, and it's not liquid enough to allow us to go out with a boat for kayaking and hunting or fishing. So it's this liminal condition that is creating fundamental challenges.

Speaker 1 26:00

I also had a conversation with somebody about, I think it was actually Norway. It could have been any other Scandinavian country, but I think the Sami people and some others were finding that they can't do reindeer herding anymore because the animal's legs fall through the ice and cut their legs. Is that a widespread problem? But if so, you can see that, well, that would be the end of I mean, that would really jeopardize the livelihood of a lot of indigenous people.

Speaker 2 26:39

You're absolutely right. So this is a widespread problem. I would say everywhere in the Arctic, but perhaps predominantly here because of Gulf Stream. The temperatures are quite mild, so it's easier with climate change for the ice materiality and condition to be exposed compared to polar areas in Russia, where the temperatures are by definition way colder, although of course they are also suffering With similar problems, reindeer heading, nomads especially there. The thing with the reindeers of the Sami in Scandinavia is that because of this unstable condition of the accumulated snow and ice, their legs are falling apart. So it's very difficult for them to walk. They often fall on lakes or get trapped or they can basically not reach food because of this condition.

There is a tendency for many of those to be increasingly domesticated in several SIDAs. SIDA is the localized geographical unit of administration of reindeer herding. And in several of those in Norway, the reindeers are kept for a part of the year indoors, or at least in circumvented. Ascribed areas where they can better control their feeding processes. But of course, this leads them to natural adaptation to the animal, to a new condition, right? Because it stops being a forager, a being that is out grazing in the wild, and then it's expecting food to be provided to it.

Speaker 1 28:29

Now, some people, even peace activists who normally have political concerns, Opinion that is contrary to U.S. and the people who want to ignore climate change. Even some of my friends talk only with enthusiasm about the opening of the Arctic passageways so that commercial shipping can go through. And they seem to treat it only as a, A wonderful advancement to have ships that can certainly go quicker through the Arctic than they would otherwise. But I wonder if any of the native people, the indigenous populations who live in that area also are happy about this development, or I would imagine most of them would much prefer to see things restored to The kind of environment that they were used to in their youth. Is that the case?

Speaker 2 29:37

So this is absolutely the case. I mean, in fact, There is a story that says that with the development of circumpolar navigation, we are talking about Northwest Passage, Northeast Passage, and the transpolar route, other core straits for international navigation will start losing prominence because the Arctic will provide 50% of the actual geographical distance to be done. But at the moment, and in the decades to come, because of the actual condition of the Arctic Ocean, plus the presence of ice, but also the hydrological conditions, we are talking about relatively shallow waters With way more severe weather conditions, including also storms, winds, compared to other passages on the planet.

So even if the ice was retreating for good, I don't believe that those alternative shipping roads could indeed replace the global trade or become the prominent. Like if you look right now at the global chart that depicts navigation at the global level, you can see that Circumpolar navigation is the least developed in the entire planet, even if it's in the heart of the news of everyday geopolitical debate and everybody wants a piece of navigating the Arctic. For Arctic indigenous peoples, these questions are of course relevant because they are dependent on many of those ice-covered areas.

I mean, you live in Canada, and I would think that perhaps Canada is one of the most innovative states when it comes to the incorporation of indigenous interests and knowledge in those polar shipping planning. And a few years behind, the government launched this North Shipping Corridor Initiative, which is basically an A dynamic atlas of determining shipping routes in the Northwest Passage that takes into consideration knowledge of indigenous peoples as well as traditional mobility patterns of local hunters, which means that They try to dynamically, adaptively, readjust seasonally shipping activities within the Northwest Passage by taking into consideration the interests of indigenous peoples.

This is quite a new initiative, so I don't really know how it will function in practice, but compared to other Arctic jurisdictions, they have similar issues. It seems quite innovative. For example, in the Russian Arctic, The question of indigenous peoples and their traditional fishing activities or other ice-dependent activities are not really considered.

Speaker 3 32:40

Oh, really? Really. And I would think that in the Canadian context, that's more important, just because the geography of the Arctic archipelago in Canada is much tighter. Those passages are tiny compared to the open water above Siberia and around Scandinavia.

Speaker 2 33:03

Yes. And I mean… The thing is, Canada has also been using the argument of the indigenous presence on its Arctic archipelago as a means to maintain sovereignty. They want to have the Northwest Passage as internal waters because of the historical presence. Doctrine of historic rights has been used elsewhere by states and international law to claim sovereignty in areas that there is basically very limited presence by state vessels or military or so on. So Canada sees the Inuit presence of its Arctic archipelago as a tool, if one can call it, to maintain its own Arctic interests.

Speaker 3 33:49

I've read that Canada and Russia actually are allies in the sense of having a similar argument about their territorial waters and the United States being on the opposite side of that argument. I don't know if that's true, but it seems… Oh, this is true.

Speaker 2 34:09

It's both the EU, but it's also the United States, but also other states and the European Union that they have been constantly provoking those passages indeed as passages, because Canada and Russia do not see the Northwest Passages. They see it as part of their own internal waters, where they have drawn straight baselines, what we call in the Law of the Sea, wherein innocent passage by other vessels should not That should not be allowed unless it's actually permitted and given access by those coastal states, while the others claim that those passages should be seen as passages of international navigation.

And that's why the Americans were sending vessels both in the Northwest Passage and in the Northeast Passage, just to challenge Canadian and Russian sovereignty over those waters. So these are still contested areas. But again, geopolitically, compared to other places in the world, the level of confrontation is minimal. But the Arctic, because of its distance from the rest, it's often depicted as this forefront of confrontation.

And even if we're undergoing now with the Russian invasion of of Ukraine, the pose of the Arctic Council, the main collaboration forum in the Arctic region and the US ambitions about Greenland and all this overall turbulence of the peaceful relationships of what we call the Arctic exceptionalism in the arena, there is still no Not a situation of confrontation in place. There is still collaboration occurring out of pragmatic necessity in several levels.

Speaker 3 36:10

And yet the Arctic Council no longer includes Russia, unless I'm mistaken.

Speaker 2 36:15

There has now been an effort to start to partially reproduce them, at least when it comes to the working groups of the Arctic Council, that they deal with scientific research. And I do believe and I want to hope that when the situation in Ukraine settle, that they can all sit together. We cannot talk about the Arctic without Russia. If you look at the circumpolar map, half of the Arctic region is Russia, right? And now we are doing Arctic policy with the Arctic Seven, which is the four Arctic littoral states, US, Canada, Norway, and the Kingdom of Denmark, together with Iceland, Finland, and Sweden, and keeping The second or probably the biggest in large geographically area of the Arctic out.

So you can't have scientific research without all players in. But I know that although a scientific boycott has also been endorsed since the full scale invasion, there has been some efforts to restart collaboration. And for example, by the end of the Norwegian termmanship of the Arctic Council, All Arctic Indigenous permanent participants resumed together for the first time, showing that the permanent participants are the organizations of the different Arctic Indigenous peoples, including RIPON, the Russian Association on Indigenous Peoples, so that they are having this permanent status within the Arctic Council. They resumed the activity, trying to show to the states that we should still try to work together.

But this is not happening at the high level at the moment because the Arctic Council includes, in addition to the scientific groups and projects to be done, high level political fora where foreign ministers are sitting together and they are concluding with a presidential declaration and so on. So some of these processes are not fully operating or are operating without Russia in In the game.

Speaker 3 38:19

I'm terribly sorry. I'm going to be late anyway, but I do have to make this appointment. And you can cut this out, Meta. I'm really sorry to leave because it's a fascinating discussion. I mean, really fascinating. And there's a dozen more things I wanted to ask.

Speaker 1 38:35

Yeah, I appreciate your being here.

Speaker 3 38:38

And thanks for everything.

Speaker 1 38:39

So I do not have a clear sense of How strongly various countries are taking positions. I mean, this thing about the simple question of do you favor or oppose the opening of the Arctic passageways for commercial shipping. And I don't realize whether, I'm not clear how much different countries are taking strong positions. And how much are they just trying to get the best outcome they can for their own advantages? Tell me, officially, even let's say the Arctic Council, is it clear, explicit that it does or does not favor such developments?

Speaker 2 39:38

Yes, so first of all, questions of sovereignty, security, and those issues are beyond the umbrella of interest of the Arctic Council and they are not addressed there. Circumpolar navigation at the moment is not prohibited. It's not that it's closed to anyone. There's different opinions by different states, but both Canada and Russia enable vessels to pass as long as they comply with the internal rules. The thing is that, for example, they require In the Northeast Passage, for example, and shipping is a bit beyond my expertise, but I have an overall knowledge. They require escorting, for example, by Russian ice breaking, Russian pilots, certain taxation schemes. So certain processes, they are very costful for the others to operate, but they are not closed.

And the trans-polar shipping route that implies navigation through the North Pole is not yet feasible because of climate change.

Speaker 1 40:39

Even if you had the optimum number of icebreakers and stuff, you can't actually make it safe and easy to move through the Arctic with ships.

Speaker 2 40:52

It's not commercially viable.

Speaker 1 40:55

I see.

Speaker 2 40:55

Scientific vessels have come through. While testing, they have reached the 90 degree north, but it is not economically viable for vessels to pursue activities. So we are doing, it's quite speculative, the entire discussion about trans-polar navigation. But the Arctic states do not specifically oppose or approve that because it's not feasible at the moment. But they try to be precocious and proactive on what can happen. And for example, we have the Central Arctic Ocean Fisheries Agreement that bans any… Illegal, unreported or unregulated fishing activities and has established a moratorium for the protection of fisheries in the Central Arctic Ocean.

And again, fisheries in the Central Arctic Ocean are not feasible at the moment because of the ice and they are not economically viable because most species are not that north. They do like cold waters and with climate change they migrate north, but they are not at this point commercially viable stocks in the Central Arctic Ocean. Arctic Ocean, but they want to be proactive because they know that with climate change there is less ice in the central Arctic Ocean, more navigation, More space is moving northwards, and we don't know where this whole story is going.

And this, of course, triggering also geopolitical questions, like the American interest in Greenland, to go back to that, was initially framed as a response also to the increase of navigation around Greenland by Russian and Chinese vessels in pursuit of their own geopolitical interest in the Arctic.

Speaker 1 42:42

Well, clearly Russia has plenty of interests in the Arctic. Their population in the Arctic is far greater than the number of cities. They have big cities in the Arctic and no other country. Well, I guess Toronto is all right.

Speaker 2 43:03

Trump is quite big, but there are settlements like Arkhangelsk and Murmansk in Russia, both in the Kola Peninsula, but also in the Russian Siberia. They have been highly populated already since Stalin's era and all the way to the collapse of the Soviet Union. Because there was a lot of industrial activity in the Russian Arctic. And there is militarization, zones and bases all over to the Russian Arctic Islands. So Russia has always been very interested in the Arctic. But also Russia has been historically the one interested in starting Russian collaboration in the Arctic and dialogue. And I know Meta, you've done quite some work with post-Soviet Union politics and the work of Gorbachev as well.

And I want to mention that President Gorbachev was the one that envied He envisioned a connected Arctic in 1989 in the famous Murmansk speech where he said that the Arctic needs to be developed as a non-military area of collaboration and keep all these discussions about nuclear weapons outside the Arctic context. And this is where the very idea about the Arctic Environmental Protection Plan established in Finland in 1991 It got planted and that set the seeds for the development of the Arctic Council a couple of years later, which consolidated this circumpolar collaboration.

Speaker 1 44:46

Yeah, he was enthusiastic about a nuclear weapon-free zone in the Arctic. But on the contrary, I think there were plenty of nuclear weapons in the Arctic. And if only, you know, if you think of Novaya Zemla.

Speaker 2 45:05

Yes, Novaya Zemla has a big base at the moment for .

Speaker 1 45:10

Yeah. Well, and I believe that there are real, you talked about radiation hazards for babies, you know, but the area with the old ships around Murmansk, I believe, they're, Problems about contamination and radiation risks there. At least there were. Maybe they've cleaned it all up by now. I don't know. Can people go in there? Can you visit if you wanted to go look around?

Speaker 2 45:45

You mean in Greenland where the accident happened? No.

Speaker 1 45:49

I mean in Murmansk and the area of that peninsula and so on where there's so many

Speaker 2 46:00

I don't know if there's tourism operating, but you can visit those areas. I hold a Greek passport and for me it's quite easy to get tourist access to the Russian Federation. Yeah, and there used to be quite a few Russian operators running tourism in its northernmost regions.

Speaker 1 46:29

How about the attitude of the Greenlanders? How much anxiety is there and how much effort is there to promote stronger measures regarding climate change? I talked to an indigenous leader in Canada who often has traveled in the indigenous communities of Northern Canada and who says that he finds that the elders are the ones who are somehow reluctant to take strong actions, that they are… They tend to say, well, this is just part of nature and we just have to accept it and find ways of surviving and making our livelihood in an environment where the ice is all melting. And he can't get them to agitate for Canada to take stronger measures.

I don't know how widespread that is, but my impression is that the Sámi people in In Scandinavia are more political and politically active on the topic. Tell me, what are the public opinion, how are the winds blowing among the indigenous people about life change?

Speaker 2 48:00

So you're very right with what you have just asserted. To start with, I'm not an indigenous, right? And I'm not either a Sami or a Greenlandic to represent their own view on climate change and ours were their relational way of being with the Arctic nature. But from my experience in Greenland, people are, of course, reacting to the very phenomenon of climate change because they see Huge problems with the ice, we talked about the material condition of the ice, challenges with coastal erosion, challenges with melting permafrost and problems with infrastructure, whether it is roads in their settlements or even their actual houses getting cracked or falling apart.

So these are images we have seen and we have been talking about the first climate refuges in the Arctic and those unfortunately are indigenous peoples, the least responsible for those phenomena and this predominantly happening in the west coast of Alaska that is most exposed to extreme weather phenomena as well. Of course, in Scandinavia, the summits are, as you said, they're very political and they are very vocal against climate change. So climate activism here is a big thing. I didn't encounter that so much when I was living in Greenland, yet I can see that people are indeed reacting because they see their world changing vastly.

But what I want to highlight, something I gained in my experience in the field, is I was talking about all these strange conditions of that climate has been brought to people who have been doing these activities from time immemorial. And a hunter told me that today what in the Arctic indigenous peoples are very adaptive. They have adapted, they have survived colonization, they have survived genocide, they have survived relocation, they have survived a lot of things. So today, they are also highly adaptive to climate change. And they told me, we don't plan activities as before.

We open the door, we read the weather, we read the clouds, we use the knowledge of the elders to read the environment, and then we decide, today I'm going hunting, today I'm going fishing. The problem is that with climate change, this readability of the natural world It becomes increasingly hard to pursue, especially for the younger ones. They have not that long experience in being in the field. Knowledge of the elders is what still keeps Arctic cultures alive. There is a tendency towards strong intergenerational knowledge transfer, also backed by activism. Indigenous activism, climate activism, and so on.

But there is also a tendency for the young generations to also disconnect from their ancestral roots and lose this knowledge in light of westernization, modernization, technological advancements, and so on.

Speaker 1 51:21

A few years ago, I think it was David Keith at Harvard at that time who was trying to do an experiment in the Arctic with, I think it was some sort of weather balloon or something, a preliminary, very apparently quite a harmless experiment where he would release Something that would reflect light, I believe. It was in preparation for developing solar radiation reflection and so on. And I believe it was the Sami people who stopped it and wouldn't allow it to proceed. Is that the case? But I also interviewed a few young people who were… Very much in favor of doing geoengineering. And so I presume that they were acting in opposition to the elders and the people who had enough power to prevent this.

Do you know the story?

Speaker 2 52:29

Yes, in fact, my postdoctoral position here is linked to a project of studying the legal implication of cryospheric engineering, sea ice geoengineering in particular. And we have, I mean, the case in the Arctic started with this Cambridge study on solar radiation management in Kiruna, in Sapmi, in the Swedish side. That was not welcomed at all by indigenous peoples, because exactly we don't know those impacts of technological interventions in the environment. However, in the last few years, there is a tendency by both Americans, but also British and Dutch companies Private companies to start to slowly engage with experimental ice engineering.

And I don't know if you have heard about that, but there's a company called Real Ice right now in Cambridge Bay in Canada trying to re-freeze coastal waters with the goal to expand those technologies and re-freeze a large part of the Arctic Ocean. So I know that Because of the potential of those technologies to refreeze ice and maintain the material condition of the Arctic ecosystem and the Arctic cryosphere, they are often very much welcomed by Arctic indigenous peoples who may see their traditional ice trails being refrozen Being open again for hunting and traditional activities. At the same time, however, some communities have been strongly opposing those endeavors.

And I want to refer to another experiment about spreading silica beads on ice, like glass beads, quartz, to increase its albido and send more light back to the atmosphere. So there was a company that conducted that in, I think their name was Arctic Ice, I think, in Alaska, and they didn't consult or ask for the free prior and informed consent of the indigenous communities living there, and they just went there and they spread those glass beads, but they were eventually Proved to be harmful for animals that digested them after they did some ecotoxicological exams when it comes to the traffic chain. So that was the case that those technologies were not really welcomed.

And I'm pretty sure indigenous communities from location to location are also very much polarized as to whether they should be pro- Or against ice geoengineering. Because we have this dual dynamic, right? At one place, a new technology coming to intervene in their lives and give some benefits. At the same time, is this another colonial tool? Is this another way of extraction, of capitalism expansion in traditional territories? And an excuse for engineering the planet while continuing doing business as usual, doing industrial business and not cutting fossil fuel emissions. For example, aquaculture, which is a huge thing in Norway, has been perceived in a similar vein.

It came to indigenous communities, it came to local Sámi communities and gave a lot of job opportunities, so some people have Embraced it. At the same time, it created a lot of environmental challenges. It pushed wild caught population outside the fjords and it fundamentally and drastically changed several ecosystems and small scale activities and indigenous activities dependent on fishing by the coast were the most impacted by those those chains. So I see with Geoengineering, similar way of tensions, like with all new technologies. Some people, including indigenous peoples, are pro, some against. My biggest personal problem with climate interventions is that they are not Helping with stopping fossil fuel production.

Business continues as usual and it will continue because of those technologies until they are entrenched and we know the results may take decades plus they may bring irreversible challenges. Some scholars, for example, worry that if we freeze the Arctic ice here in a certain period and then Those technologies are removed after they completed their goal, then the planet's natural mechanism may react so abruptly that the acceleration of change will be way, way worse. So we don't know how that, we don't know also the impact transboundary beyond the Arctic of those climate interventions, but ice freezing because exactly of its local experimental use now, It doesn't seem so harmful at the macro level, but we don't know.

And if it's employed indeed to keep freezing the Central Arctic Ocean, then that may have other impacts within the Arctic and beyond. But with that, only time will know.

Speaker 1 58:32

But time won't show unless people actually do the experimentation. I mean, I agree there may be serious problems, but I'm in favor of starting the research And the experimentation on a small scale. And then, you know, I always if I'm going to jump in a pond, I want to stick my toe in first to see what I'm going to encounter. So, you know, do it on a small scale to begin with. And therefore, I think that what is what needed. I think I wanted to do an interview with some of those people in Cambridge Bay, but I never I haven't yet managed to get an interview with them. I think Hugh Hunt at Cambridge is connected with that.

And it seems to be very similar to what is already done in Canada by making ice roads in the winter. The only way people can travel is by freezing the ice and then they can move along those roads. But this, I gather, is Is freezing a small bay to see how, if you put, if you spray ice, it's what they do with ice rinks. That's how they keep them in good shape. They go around with a sprayer, spray some water on top of the ice, which of course freezes. And it's, you know, that's how they keep thickening the ice throughout the winter. And they do that on top of the ocean now.

But, I think there are questions about how extensive that can be, because it takes a certain amount of energy, and you can't spray the whole Arctic, you know.

Speaker 2 1:00:22

I mean, do you ultimately want to move that into green energy, like fully autonomous green energy generated vehicles? And I think there is another company now called Ice Reflection that is doing experimental, again, these were Dutch operators first testing in Svalbard in the And now they moved on Ellsmer Island as well, I think, on the West Coast across Greenland. And they are trying with experiments there and they are running it full with fully green energy resources, if I recall correctly. But of course, these are extremely, extremely costful and the visibility is not yet… Yeah, I'm certain, but technology develops fast. There is millions spent on new technologies and that we live in a planet that new technologies are driving politics.

And then you see that the government of the US right now, it's exactly selling this narrative. We are like a tech oriented world. So maybe in the future, tremendous amounts will be spent to those new technologies. And I hope it's for good. But I want to recall in 2009, when they first started talking about climate interventions in the Arctic in particular, all indigenous peoples beyond the Arctic sat together in Ankara, in Alaska, and signed a declaration. Where they clearly framed climate interventions as false solution to climate change. And they said that if there is knowledge to be considered with dealing with climate change, this should be our knowledge, the traditional knowledge, because this has lasted change forever.

Speaker 1 1:02:16

Well, you can promote them. I believe in letting all kinds of new ideas come. Flourish, or be at least attempted, because I think we need all the help we can get.

Speaker 3 1:02:29

I'm quite worried about the prospect.

Speaker 1 1:02:34

Anyway, this has been absolutely fascinating. I'm so glad we finally found a way to have our conversation after technological glitches. So I'll be back in touch with you. Thank you so much.

Speaker 2 1:02:47

Thank you so much, Thelma. That was lovely. Great meeting you and keep up the great. So have a good day.

Speaker 1 1:02:53

You too. Bye.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments