Episode 797 Nonviolent Defence of Canada?

Notes

Invasion may be easy; occupation is hell. Richard Sandbrook makes the case for a civilian defense of Canada, and fellow members press him on whether it would work in practice.

Guests

  • Arnd Jurgensen
  • Rose Dyson
  • Barry Stevens
  • Nicholas Wedgwood

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

defense, nonviolent, government, Canada, forces, support, armed, effective, force, international, civil, nonviolence, United, aggression, Canadian, military, resistance, wanted, communications, invasion

SPEAKERS

Richard Sandbrook, Arnd Jurgensen, Metta Spencer, Barry Stevens, Rose Dyson, participants.

SUMMARY

This episode of Project Save the World, hosted by Metta Spencer, discussed nonviolent defence of Canada with Richard Sandbrook, Arnd Jurgensen, Rose Dyson, Barry Stevens, Metta Spencer and several other participants. Richard Sandbrook opened by defining nonviolent defence as unarmed civilians using nonviolent methods to deter and defeat aggression. He described it as decentralized, cited the Minneapolis mobilization against Operation Urban Surge as an example, and distinguished two scenarios: an invasion on the Ukraine model and a Venezuelan-style takeover producing a vassal state. He argued nonviolent defence could work against both, and proposed joint deployment in which armed forces would operate mainly in the sparsely populated North.

Read more…

Arnd Jurgensen asked how much government buy-in would be needed for training, noting that tools used against an illegitimate takeover could also be turned against existing governments. Sandbrook replied that government support alone would not suffice, that a bottom-up approach like Germany's was needed, and that building social movements in cities could take decades. A participant raised communications. Rose Dyson asked whether Carney's announced sovereign information backbone was key to defence, and another participant replied that infrastructure vulnerabilities and long satellite timelines made this difficult. Robin asked about effectiveness, and Barry Stevens asked whether armed forces and nonviolent activists had ever coordinated. A skeptic said nonviolent defence had never worked in their experience.

Metta Spencer argued that misinformation and propaganda let elites shape public opinion, and that UN peacekeepers had lost the ability to use deadly force. Barry Stevens cited a Princeton scholar's data set of 115 ceasefires and civil wars, saying 80 per cent succeeded in preventing renewed fighting, and urged looking at the actual record. A participant pointed to Ukraine's civilian resistance as evidence of an existing capacity. Sandbrook said nonviolent defence required trust and cooperation at the local level. Another participant argued that investing in community resilience was affordable given Canada's size, and that civil society should lay the groundwork. Robin asked about deterrence, and Sandbrook answered that it comes from a united population and alliances.

Barry Stevens argued that Canada faces pressure from U.S. hemispheric ambitions, citing the Golden Dome, boundary disputes and Arctic waters, and stressed international law. A participant raised Hans Island and economic strength. Another asked why international law bodies were not resolving disputes, and Arnd Jurgensen pointed to double standards over Iran and Ukraine. Metta Spencer then proposed a motion. Sandbrook suggested calling on government to consider nonviolent defence as a strategic option. Participants proposed combining government study with civil society action. The group voted by reaction buttons on a formulation that nonviolent defence is worth exploring by the peace community and should be considered by government. Metta Spencer noted next week's session would address Common Security.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. A speaker the team did not list is shown as “Participant”.

Richard Sandbrook

involving unarmed civilian force and the Canadian Armed Forces. So I want to begin with the issue of what is nonviolent defense. Well, basically, it's the same thing as what the Europeans call social defense. what World Without War calls unarmed civilian defense. And what Gene Sharp referred to as civilian-based defense. His close cousin is obviously nonviolent or civil resistance. For a general definition, I provide the following. Nonviolent defense Involves unarmed civilians who employ a variety of nonviolent methods to deter and defeat aggression of various sorts. So let me now be more specific. First of all, nonviolent defense is necessarily decentralized. There's no central body that exercises control over the decentralized local chapters.

In each of the localities, a committee emerges, composed of major organizations, and perhaps a local chapter. Preparation is obviously very important. So what organizations are involved? Well, I think the… the Minneapolis mobilization. between December 2025 and February 2026 against Operation Urban Surge provides a very Good example of the kind of organizations that would be involved at the, at the decentralized local level. Because I think Minneapolis is really the paradigmatic case in North America for nonviolent defense. And of course, you'll immediately say, well, this wasn't a case of nonviolent defense, it was more in the form of civil resistance. In fact, the two are very closely linked. the people of Minneapolis, They… Believe they were being invaded by, by federal forces.

In fact, the Attorney General of Minnesota condemned the invasion of Minnesota by federal forces. So there are around 4,000 Armed and masked. Friends, that sort of thing. So, fifthly, how does joint deployment work effectively? Now, the two forms of defense clearly follow clashing logics of effectiveness. Obviously, the military Succeeds by reaching maximum Damage upon the enemy's troops' supply lines or infrastructure. On the other hand, and in contrast, nonviolent defenders are effective. by… not… Threatening any bodily harm to the invading forces. I think one can refer in ideal, typical types to two ideal, typical types of aggression, two scenarios of aggression. The first, scenario is a familiar one of invasion and occupation. We can call this the Ukraine model of aggression.

So here, a great power attacks a neighbor, usually after first trying to destabilize it through hybrid warfare. Invasion is what nonviolent defense was initially designed to deter and defeat. The essential principle of nonviolent defense is that stronger powers can invade and occupy a country, but they cannot conquer it as long as citizens continue to resist nonviolently. Non-cooperation and protests signal mass refusal to assent to foreign rule. The second scenario of aggression His reduction of Canada to a vassal state. Let's call this… for the sake of argument, the Venezuelan model of aggression, which is also the model that the U.S. is hoping to apply to Cuba. In this scenario, The great power employs hybrid attacks. To weaken and intimidate a neighbor.

Then seeks to decapitate or replace the government with a far-right, quizzling regime, and if successful. The result is a neocolony, or a vassal state, as in Venezuela, or as in Belarus, in relation to Russia. And, if this strategy The strategy is of higher probability than invasion, because less is at stake for the aggressor. And yet, if effective, it still gains the aggressor access to Canada's water, natural resources, and favourable trade arrangements. The question is, can nonviolent defense be effective against both forms of aggression? I think so. Of course, effectiveness. Yes, Arnd.

Arnd Jurgensen

Thank you for, for a very good, and, and very concise, explanation of, of, nonviolent resistance. The one question that occurred to me in this context is how much buy-in would have… would there have to be from, in this case, the Canadian government, to… promote especially the training for this kind of, kind of nonviolent resistance to a possible takeover of the government.

And it occurs to me in that context that A lot of the tools that would be involved in terms of opposing an illegitimate takeover of our government, either by direct force or through some kind of a hybrid takeover, the Venezuelan model or something along those lines, are also tools that can be used against Existing governments, and consequently, that governments might be rather reluctant to provide their citizens with the kinds of training that might make them able to resist their own government's policy initiatives.

Richard Sandbrook

And it's unlikely ever to be effective on its own. You can't expect government or the armed forces to feel sympathetic towards a nonviolent defense. I mean, we just have to rethink of the government to begin with. there's going to be a great reluctance on the part of government to actually adopt this nonviolent defense, because, among other things, it creates enormous uncertainty for them. I mean, what they're doing is in facilitating decentralized, nonviolent defense is, is, And, have… hundreds of of, people who… act as their advocates and intellectual think tanks to promote their viewpoints. So, it's a difficult political conundrum. So, top-down approaches through government by themselves will not work. The other approach is a bottom-up approach.

Which is followed by some, European… in time now, like in Germany, for example. I may say that the Canadian Coalition for Nonviolent Defense is part of an international network on social defense, which includes a lot of Europeans. interacting, sharing knowledge, so that the Germans have a view of a top-down approach, a bottom-up approach to implementation, which is to work within communities, within certain cities, to make a social movement For social defense, and eventually, over years, to win enough popular support to make a city sort of, basing itself on declaring itself to be a non-military zone, that's the idea. But of course, it takes decades for that to work, if it ever does.

Metta Spencer

I'll be richer.

Participant

Hi, I'm interested mostly in something that hasn't been mentioned so far, which is the aspect of communications, and how communications can be maintained between different acting parties and larger organizational structures. In light of the likelihood, indeed high probability, that elites and systems of communications will be captured likely first. Cheers.

Richard Sandbrook

Robin.

Participant

Hi, I wanted to go into the whole question of effectiveness of, nonviolent defense. And, I mean… I mean, there's the domestic side, and then there's the invasion from broad side of it, and being Remembrance Day, I think. In the minds of many people, Nonviolent defense would not have been successful. at least… I mean, it might have minimized certain responses by, let's say, the Nazi invasion, even Europe.

it might have reduced some violent activity by the Nazis, but I think most people would think it wouldn't have been sufficient to prevent the Holocaust, for instance, so… so I wanted to ask, what you think… I mean, I'm gonna put this into the context of, you know, everybody knows about Erica Chenoweth's work on the effectiveness, you know, that nonviolent defense, or nonviolence has been twice as effective as violence historically, although that has weakened, I think, recently, but, Nonetheless. when you say it's twice as effective, that does imply that there's a minority in the numbers where it's not effective. And I actually don't remember what she said, what the characteristics were of the non-effective.

events, but, what do you say about that, you know, in terms of, you know, I think a lot of people would say, you know, I support a non-offensive… not offensive… I would support nonviolent resistance. Where it is possible, but it's not possible always. So, what should we think about that?

Richard Sandbrook

The thing about nonviolent defense is silver bullet for success in all conflicts. So it would be incorrect for anyone to suggest that this is the way to go that will always be effective, which is why I… I am pressing the idea of a joint deployment Because I don't think that in Canada we'd ever see a situation in which nonviolent defense would be the, would be everything. In other words, all we can hope for is partial demilitarization, not total demilitarization, but that itself is well worth working on. Now, in terms of the…

Participant

Just before, just before… I wanted… I wanted to ask you about that joint, relationship, because I think it would ring true to many people, but the assumption would be… that there would be non-violent and violent responses when you say a joint measure, or are you saying that the need for the violent by the armed forces would be reduced If not eliminated by, the nonviolent element.

Richard Sandbrook

I'm saying in the southern towns and cities, that the only presence of the, of the Canadian Armed Forces would be… and to counter drone attacks, if there were any. Cyber attacks, and provided intelligence, services like that. But then outside of this band, in their own territory, the North, for example, they would be able to use violence, because there are no civilians, or very few civilians, throughout the northern part of Canada. And there only are the three oceans as well, so this is where the armed forces would operate. It seems that that's the kind of pattern we have in mind. Yeah, Barry.

Barry Stevens

Thank you, for the presentation. It's really interesting stuff, and I guess it follows on from what Robin was saying. The image of the Canadian forces, and the very unlikely, extremely unlikely event at this point. of the United States, invading Canada, although I think it's wrong to say that it, you know, it's never… it's never… it's never happened. They have invaded us several times. But, it's not impossible in the next few decades, they might again. But, the prospect of the… I'm sorry? Oh, four times, yes. Four times, yes. And the prospect of the Canadian Armed Forces coordinating with a nonviolent defense is, it's hard to imagine the command structure of the forces doing that.

In a sense, they be kind of like… deploying a division of nonviolence that they're hiding behind, which they would then… which… sort of as human shields, in a sense. That's how it would be conceived of or seen. I understand it's regional and you're proposing that they would defend the north or remote areas. But, so I guess I would wonder, has there ever been A historical example of a coordination Of nonviolent action in an organized way. Between armed forces and, nonviolent activists. Does anyone know about that?

Richard Sandbrook

Not to my knowledge.

Participant

How about in peacekeeping? I've never experienced where that's happened, I don't know.

Participant

I, I have very little hope for nonviolent defense. Simply because human nature Although it has changed with all the… Contextual modernizations we face. Nonviolent defense. In my view, it has never worked in my experience. NATO. ASEAN, UN… civilian UN member businessman in East Timor, Yeah, I'm sorry, I'm just… Unable to support it.

Rose Dyson

Okay, I'd like to come back to the issue of communications and how that might be handled. It seems to me, in terms of aggression or a takeover in some way by the Americans, it's probably likely to include our nationwide internet network, and Carney announced last Tuesday, I think, that the federal government will be financing a sovereign, approach to this information backbone that, that, better links us to Europe and Asia and so on, and so that all our communications, including our banking and financial transactions don't have to go through an American system of some way. Isn't that kind of key to defense against the Americans? An American invasion.

Participant

I think, if you look at it from the technical perspective, Rose, this sort of thing could be… could be done through the .ca space, because that is a sovereign, space to Canada, and you couldn't rely, really, on the… like, most people don't want to punch in IP addresses to get somewhere, they want to go to, like, a known… You know, English or French, domain, to, to coordinate. I don't think it's something that can be easily done, because we're talking about 15 to 20 years to get any sort of competitive, you know, Starlink type of system up there.

And you're also talking at least another 5 to 10 years from now to get a really good, secure Canadian system that uses the existing trunk lines and other communication. systems. By shutting down 15 to… somewhere between 15 and 40 key sites, you can basically shut off the communications in Canada. Because everything, you know, the 70% of traffic runs through Toronto, and it's, like, 151 Front Street, I believe, where the main trunk comes in here.

And then there's the lines that run out, that go undersea, across, across the Atlantic, those can be disrupted easily, as we saw in the In Europe, with the undersea cables being disrupted, and no one's quite sure who did it, but there's a lot of, there's a lot of sensitivity that our systems have that make them quite vulnerable, to disruption.

Rose Dyson

Well, do you think that Carney's plan is really going to take 15 to 20 years to bring about? I mean, what do you make of his announcement, and… attempt to do something to cure our…

Participant

I don't know if you've seen our spaceport, but it's basically… our spaceport is a, is a concrete pad that's, like, 25 by 35 feet. And so, I think if we're going to be launching our own satellites up there, it's going to be quite a while until we, you know, not only get the funding in place to do it, but to roll it out, to test everything, to build those satellites.

The launch vehicles themselves are, you know, Maybe we just… we just buy the, the launch vehicles that Tesla… that, sorry, SpaceX is retiring, now that they're getting Starship online, and, we go with their, with their pre-existing rockets that we're… they're now phasing out, because they, they're, you know, much less efficient, pound for pound, when you're talking about lifting stuff into the heavens.

Rose Dyson

Sounds very complicated.

Metta Spencer

Yeah.

Participant

Much more important than, talking about systems of communications is the communications themselves. And that is because right now we're living in an age when misinformation, disinformation, and propaganda are dominating information systems being disseminated worldwide. If you want to talk about nonviolence, or you want to talk about what's going to be driving aggression, you have to have a population behind it, and a population involved in it. And right now, we are facing an incredible amount of danger because the elites that we're being referred to are the ones who are controlling the sources of and the content of information That gets out to the public.

And basically, they can, because the public is extremely susceptible to propaganda, these elites can control what people think, what they do, and what they want to do, and what they will support by their government. And that relates to the U.S. invading Canada, Canada invading the U.S. you know, Venezuela invading… Guatemala, whatever, it's the same thing. That's one point. Another point, that was brought up, and I think Richard said before the issue came up about nonviolence in cooperation with the military. We work with the UN, so I've had some pretty good insights into how the UN peacekeeping forces work, and they don't work terribly well.

They're sent in there to give the impression of, of an armed force protecting the local population, but as De Cuellar has said recently, their teeth have pretty much been pulled in terms of being able to use deadly force to… support nonviolence. They can't do anything. So they are there as, a military force, or a quasi-military force, supporting nonviolence, but basically, they're sitting ducks. The soldiers, they take pot shots at the UN soldiers, and right now they've pulled back forces in a lot of places, so that aspect of it doesn't work terribly well. That's it, thank you.

Barry Stevens

Yeah, I think I was first, Nicholas. Yeah, no problem. I just wanted to cite, because of all this talk about peacekeeping being so hopeless, or nonviolence being hopeless. that, and I just looked this up. There's a scholar called Virginia Page Fortner, I put her link in the chat, from Princeton. did, a data set of 115 ceasefires and civil wars from 1944 to 1997. And, 80% of them succeeded in preventing the reignition of the war or the conflict involved. Now, we remember, of course. Rwanda, and many others. And the problems that, was just being, outlined regarding the, passivity or the difficulties of armed forces personnel not being able to have the rules of engagement sufficient enough to… or robust enough to counter an attack.

Well, that is an operational problem, for sure, but the data suggests that peacekeeping has been effective. And I think that's an important thing to look at the actual, the actual record, and not just our… Our… are tragic anecdotes. Not that they're… not that they're invalid, because, you know, the failures have been really, really salient and awful, but it's not just the failures.

Metta Spencer

Thanks, Mary. And, I think, I don't know, Mr. OPS, he called you Nicholas, so let's say Nicholas, if that's who you are, and then Jill.

Participant

Yeah, thank you. I… so… America really degrades in a terrible, terrible way, but it could happen still. I mean, we had two Trumps, we could have a third, whoever it is. But, projecting over to Ukraine, People think that they weren't per… sufficiently prepared. There is talk that they didn't have a really strong military, and this miracle that happened in which they held back Russia, followed two color revolutions, two of them, so… You know, everything that we've been discussing now, is kind of proven there, that, you know, the civilian, capability had already been developed, you know, that muscle was very, very strong. And, in the Canadian context. How, how could we possibly strengthen that muscle of, of, of, of peaceful… activism.

And I think, you know, I mean, sort of here we have in Toronto Dougies taking away our bike lanes, and, you know, if we were in Amsterdam or, Copenhagen. people would take it lying down. They'd be lying down on the streets, interrupting traffic, all sorts of things. I just… I just wanted, you know, is there any capability for Canadians to to kind of rally around anything to, to actually prepare, just, just, I guess what Kearney calls the tail possibility of, of, of something terrible happening. But, just… How do we, as civilians, prepare for this remote possibility that we have to prepare for? Because it's happened 4 times!

Richard Sandbrook

To influence political figures. And hope that over time, you pick up momentum at the local level. But there's no doubt that you cannot have… you cannot have nonviolent defense without having a great deal of sense of trust and cooperation at the local level, since no one's going to stand up there on the line You know, they don't trust their fellows to really have their backs. That's the simple fact of the matter.

Metta Spencer

Jill.

Participant

Yeah, thank you very much for all of your comments. I really believe that nonviolence action, nonviolent movements, nonviolent resistance, comes when it is required. And I have seen that in my own experience. As you know, I have… a lengthy Indian experience, but I also agree with Nicholas, the colored revolutions were another example. And so… Canada did not face, until recently, a real sense of its existential problems, you know? It became clear that hybrid warfare was becoming more and more, evident. And so I think nonviolent, this CCND that, Richard was talking about, is a natural emergence of that.

But I'd like to raise an additional point that I think The need to… Canada is a very large country, and even if we were to spend 10% of our GDP on defense, I'm not sure that we can defend it against all of the future threats that not only could be the United States, but later could be China, or Russia in the Arctic, or even greater threats like the climate crisis. So, what I think is that it is a really good investment. To invest in communities to become resilient against these threats, so we don't need to put all of our social programs at risk to have 5% go into the military. And we, see this as our responsibility. In future.

Now, it sounds very idealistic, but I think it will… Slowly become clear to people that the threats have to be dealt with in a way that is affordable as well. And just finally to say, I don't think, Richard, we have to worry about the association with the Ministry of Defense. Ministry of Defense will be there anyway. It's rather that we have to, as civil society, lay the grounds for a nonviolent defense. That's… The only way that any kind of, coordination can take place, but also accountability can take place. There you go.

Metta Spencer

Robin?

Participant

I wonder, if, the whole topic of deterrence can be looked at, because, I mean, most people think that police forces are required in a… even in a democracy, because there will be villains and so on. But deterrence is in part A threat to use violence, and not necessarily the deployment of it, where the violence is deterred. So I'm wondering, Richard and others, if you could… if you could say something about that sort of gray zone. You're armed, but you don't use arms. And this comes up in UN peacekeeping, too, which is limited use of force, or or likelihood of non-use of force, except when attacked by others in self-defense. But they're still, they're still, they're armed.

Therefore, there's a threat of use of force, but the force may not happen because there's that threat. I wonder if you could… We could talk a little bit about that deterrence element.

Richard Sandbrook

Well, let me just say very briefly that the best nonviolent defense is obviously one that's never used. So I think that, the idea… I mean, where deterrence comes from is a view that the population of a certain country is united. Is, is, trained, is determined to maintain its sovereignty, has built up alliances. with other countries, other groups in other countries, but also other governments. They may not be alliances that lead to physical intervention, but at least support verbally, condemnation of a rogue state, if that one should invade, and also alliances within within the United States to the many non-blind groups that have organized… that have been organized for many years, but now are much larger in their presence.

So I think if you develop a situation like that, then you have a very strong deterrent effect.

Barry Stevens

Yeah, I just wanted to go back to the situation of Canada, while it relates to what you were just saying. I don't think it's likely that some directions of the United States have… will change, and one of those is a kind of, hemispheric domination, which has been advanced by the Trump administration, and so we are going to be in conflict. Very unlikely we'll be invaded. But in lots of ways, and already are compromised or have to keep in mind what the U.S. wants. I mean, for instance, the Golden Dome. you know, we're going to spend about 30 or 40 billion dollars on North Warning Defense, which could be part of missile defense, which could be part of a nuclear war.

And a nuclear war, of course, is fought over Canada. But just more specifically, we have a couple of disputes with the United States, one about the boundary line that extends north from Yukon and Alaska. They have a different view of where it is. And, and then also the amount of territorial waters in which On that issue, we are allied with Russia. Russia and us agree that our territorial waters extend further than the United States thinks, and that's actually quite significant for the Northwest Passage. But all of that… but the main point I want to make, which actually comes out of that, Richard, is that having alliances and resilience on the community level, all that's important.

But… International law is something that Canada should be pursuing and engaging with and supporting with all our voices and our diplomatic strength. The International Court of Justice can resolve these kind of issues, and we should be more vigorously supporting the International Criminal Court, but… and the United Nations, none of which appeared in the recent, Canadian, the Prime Minister's statement about Canada's security. None of those phrases existed. And, And I thought it was deplorable that they didn't, but I think that's what we should be remembering, that as a middle power, and as moral beings, international law is extremely significant. Thanks.

Metta Spencer

Thank you. Ms. Shane.

Participant

Hi, just to, add to, Barry's point about, sovereignty and, waters, we used to share a, border with, with Denmark. In, in the north, between Ellesmere Island and Greenland. And the… the solution to that dispute which was, for many years, represented by a swapping of liquors that each team would leave there when they left, Hands Island. It was decided a couple years ago to split Hands Island. And now that the U.S. has, has, sovereignty for defense in Greenland, it makes us, actual partners with, the U.S. regarding the, the Nair Strait and the passages on either side of Hands Island.

in both cases, Hands Island being situated roughly in the middle of the Narrow Strait, the, the sovereign waters are, less… or greater than the distance from… from one shore to the island on both sides. So anyway, just to add that, people keep it in the hopper and think about things like that. Another thing I wanted to bring up was economy, as was mentioned by Jill. And, rather than strictly investing in the economy and the government investing in the economy, which it does… Not so great a job, maybe a 40% effective rate. per dollar invested. The natural strength of the economy is extremely important to developing robust defense and maintaining networks and other things that we need, and the military as well, and an efficient military.

I absolutely believe in an efficient military, but I don't think it's a replacement for the military. So naturally strong economy is extremely important, especially given the size of our country and, and the, you know, the challenges that we have in defending such a large property, and, which we do, aerospace-wise with the United States through NORAD. But, there's, you know, the, the seed dimension of it as well is very important as the north opens up. And the last thing I wanted to mention, was… What if the… what if the, the threat is, from enemies within? how do we react to that?

Police forces can do a certain amount, but if the, if the, the, the trust and the, and then the firmness of the government isn't also behind those. civilian forces, and things are allowed to percolate out of control, that could be a problem that we would be dealing with on the streets. Thank you.

Participant

Yes, thank you very much, and greetings to everyone. from U.S. and Canada. I want to ask, where are the international law bodies that handle A settlement of disputes and the courts. Why should we be hearing of this in the 20th century? It's not the best.

Metta Spencer

You want an answer? But explain your question a little bit, please.

Arnd Jurgensen

I think the point is absolutely right. I think that the international institutions for settling these kinds of disputes have been largely ignored, and international law has been largely ignored. And I think that the current example of the conflict in Iran is a very good example of how in the discussions in the Security Council, immediately after the invasion. took place, as most of you are probably well aware, there were lots of denunciations of Iran for attacking its neighbors in an unprovoked manner, but none of the European or North American countries stood up and denounced the illegal attack against Iran by Israel and the United States. In that sense, there's a huge double standard in the international system.

Where the West generally has little or no problem denouncing Russia's actions against Ukraine, but applies a very different standard to itself. And the same thing goes with large parts of the Global South, where international law and international organizations just don't seem to play the role that they are intended to play elsewhere in the world. So, thank you for that point. I think I totally agree. Lizzy…

Metta Spencer

That's fine. Now, we have come, theoretically, to the end of our list of people with their hands out, but, we usually, in these meetings. Reach a decision about some recommendation that we could share, that we tend to all agree to. And I guess the question today would be, do we encourage and urge the Government of Canada to begin preparatory work, or the government… the people of Canada, to do the job of preparing a system of nonviolent defense? And and we haven't made that clear what we think it would be exactly, but I think that much we may or may not be able to vote for, decide whether we think that's a reasonable thing to do.

In addition, we may say that in order to make it work, we have to do something else. And I think maybe Arnd and Lizzy are pointing to, what I would consider a major sort of prerequisite for the success of nonviolent resistance in Canada, and that would be that we be in full Throated support of international law, every chance we get. So, if somebody wants to, move, introduce a motion that we, vote in favor of a particular type of, planning, I think we should take the moment to do that, and then we'll have to say goodbye. Anybody would want to, extemporaneously invent a motion to see how much support there is for nonviolence as a means of defending Canada. Yeah, okay, alright.

Arnd Jurgensen

Can we perhaps phrase that not in terms of should the Government of Canada pursue a program of training for nonviolence defense? I think that's rather unlikely in the current circumstances, but rather to say, is it something that the peace community in general should be pursuing and.

Participant

Express.

Arnd Jurgensen

to a greater extent. And I think on that, we would probably find a much more wide agreement.

Barry Stevens

I agree.

Participant

I think the phrasing is okay, I think. It doesn't presuppose that it will be always effective, so… and so I'm looking at the exceptions more than… Where it might be effective. And so, you know, those who wish to support these measures and training, I'm sure are already on it. Whether they'll get a good reception or not, I don't know. I certainly would support The effort.

Metta Spencer

You know, I think Jill mentioned not only having the government prepare for nonviolent resistance and defense, but also civil society. In other words, we should get on with it. Is that what you meant to say, Jill?

Participant

Absolutely. That, because the country is so big, because we have some semblance of community opinion for defending our sovereignty at this particular time, it seems quite ripe. For peace groups to engage in this with civil society.

Metta Spencer

Okay, anybody, any, other quibbles, or, amendments, or that sort of thing? Or shall we, proceed and see how many of us, would agree with the motion, I guess it is, that aren't, Deliberated.

Participant

I'm gonna, I'm gonna reserve my, my vote, because I think it's, it's too complex a topic with so many different dimensions to it that, it would be hard for me to agree to one particular thing at this, at this time.

Metta Spencer

Okay. Sorry, I don't…

Participant

I don't… I mean, on that point, I mean, if this was to exclude other measures, including police and use of armed force in certain circumstances, then I would oppose it, but I would support it if it's to support an option that would be useful, and hopefully would spread and become more popular and more useful down the road. I would support it on that basis. I wouldn't have supported if it excluded other Including armed force measures.

Metta Spencer

Now, okay, thank you, now I'm… Sorry?

Richard Sandbrook

And I say that… that I think the… Probably the best motion, from my point of view, is that we, Call upon the government to give serious consideration to the strategic concept of nonviolent defense. putting it that way does not suggest that it's the be-all and end-all, but just making the point, which I think is highly valid, that it is a kind of strategic option that needs to be investigated further and experimented in.

Metta Spencer

Okay, thank you. Would that… would that, be compatible with Jill's suggestion that civil society get on with it, whether or not the government does? Is that compatible, Jill, to your mind?

Participant

I mean, I, I don't think we need to exclude, you know, getting the government aware of nonviolent defense, but I think the action will come from civil society. If it doesn't, we can't expect the government to To… just by sanctioning it, that they're going to do much about it. Because it's a local… it's something that has to happen locally, in community, building up the resilience of communities.

Metta Spencer

Okay. How about you?

Participant

How about combine the two? Combine the two. The government be asked to investigate, as Richard had said, and civil society similarly, engage and develop measures, that kind of thing. I mean, I think Jill is absolutely right, that if the government were to pursue it and look at it, the government would then be handing it… the government would then be handing it.

Participant

Yeah, yeah, Newton. Good.

Participant

government. The government would then be handing it over to civil society to deploy it, because it's not going to be the armed forces. If it's non-violent resistance.

Metta Spencer

Yeah, all right. Good, I think we are at the point we can vote for this, and realizing, of course, that nothing Enormous is going to happen as a result of our vote, but we can… test the waters, was that right? Okay with everybody? Okay, I don't even know how to do it technologically here, because there are a bunch of people who are here, but not visible. They've turned off their microphones and their… and their cameras, at least, most…

Arnd Jurgensen

Everyone can use the react button to put their thumbs up to vote for it, or down to vote against.

Metta Spencer

Okay, do you all know how to do that? I wouldn't know how to do it. How do you do it?

Arnd Jurgensen

At the bottom of your screen, there's a react… there's a react… it's a little heart, and you push on that, and it gives you various, various possibilities for reacting, including a heart shape for if you love it, if you… thumbs up if you support it, thumbs down if you don't.

Metta Spencer

Okay, guys, let's see, let me click here, but raise your hand. Okay, you see the thing about the bottom? React. So let's all raise our hand. And, and leave them up long enough. For me to count this at the, At the end, a thumbs up is just as good, I gather. Not everybody's doing this, though. What if you don't do it? Does that mean.

Richard Sandbrook

I'm not sure what the motion is precisely, I'm sorry I've lost track of what it is now.

Arnd Jurgensen

I think the way we phrased it at the end is that nonviolent defense is worth exploring by the peace community and should be taken into consideration by the government for support.

Metta Spencer

Is everybody happy with that formulation? Okay, we've got some thumbs up. We have a few missing, but I'll tell you, if you can't figure out how to put your hand or your thumb up, you can go into the chat and type your name in and say yes. And I will… I will count it at the end, alright? Okay, some of you don't have… and if you don't, that means you're not voting for it, but you're not necessarily voting against it either. Alright, is that okay?

Participant

Well, you could ask… you could ask for opposition.

Metta Spencer

Yeah, right now, who thinks it's a stupid idea? Anybody want to speak against it? Okay, well, I don't hear anybody. Okay, well, we're over time, but we will have to trim anyway, so thank you all, and come back next week. Please try to sign in with the registration. You can go to our website, tosavetheworld.ca. And, and, there's a registration. form there, or you can access us that way. And I believe the next one is on Common Security, is it not?

Arnd Jurgensen

That's correct.

Metta Spencer

Next week, very good. Which we were going to do before, but we… we just deferred it till everybody's here. All right, friends, thank you very much.

Barry Stevens

That's up.

Arnd Jurgensen

It's a great time, and I hope to see you.

Richard Sandbrook

You're like.

Participant

Yeah, see you next week.

Metta Spencer

Beautiful.

Participant

Thank you, everybody.

Participant

Cheers, everyone.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments