Episode 779 The Albedo Imperative

Notes

Robbie Tulip and Gene Fry discuss how declining planetary albedo, primarily due to cloud loss, accelerates climate warming, necessitating urgent albedo restoration alongside carbon removal efforts.

https://projectsavetheworld.substack.com/p/episode-779-the-albedo-imperative

Guests

  • Robbie Tulip
  • Gene Fry

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

climate, carbon, albedo, air, temperature, degrees, earth, emissions, warming, ice, cloud, clouds, feedbacks, ago, Gene, cooling, effect, ocean, thinking, change

SPEAKERS

Robbie Tulip, Gene Fry, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Robbie Tulip and Gene Fry discuss albedo, the reflectivity of the Earth's surface, and its role in climate change in this episode of Project Save the World, titled The Albedo Imperative. Tulip introduces Fry, a retired resource economist who has studied climate change for decades, and explains the difference between forcings and feedbacks. He argues that the darkening of the planet, especially the dissolving of ocean cloud banks, is a major self-reinforcing feedback that carbon cuts struggle to counter. Fry agrees the process matters but doubts it is the only cause of falling cloud cover. He points to reduced plankton emissions, lower human sulfur emissions, and possibly other factors.

Read more…

Tulip cites a James Hansen slide that attributes most of the reduced albedo to clouds, and he calls cloud attribution understudied. Fry questions Hansen's figure, arguing that satellite-observed albedo decline implies about 2.19 watts per square metre rather than 1.5, and suspects clouds are underestimated. Fry describes his ice core analysis, which found temperature and CO2 following a similar relationship over 25 million years. He argues that the standard three-degree climate sensitivity leaves out slow feedbacks such as ice sheets and vegetation colour, so the true figure may be far higher. Tulip replies that slow feedbacks could prove faster than assumed.

Tulip describes committed warming and argues that models assuming temperatures fall after emissions stop are too optimistic. Fry agrees that temperatures will rise much further, citing permafrost thaw, forest losses from declining soil moisture, and microbial activity in warmer soils. Tulip argues that the Paris net zero target is only a waystation toward large net negative emissions, which he says are not being achieved, so sunlight reflection is needed to stabilise the climate first. Fry agrees that carbon removal takes time and warns of tipping cascades. Tulip raises the risk of Atlantic circulation collapse and uses a fever analogy to argue for precaution and urgent cooling.

Fry proposes marine cloud brightening and stratospheric aerosol injection, which he sees as the most effective option, and suggests that combined with carbon removal it could hold peak warming near two and a half degrees. Tulip argues for a fundamental review of climate policy and an albedo accord modelled on the Montreal Protocol. Fry cites a study by David Keith estimating about fourteen times more deaths without the injection. Tulip doubts that wind and solar remain cheap once system costs are included, while Fry says fossil fuel use is plateauing. The pair discuss risk framing and industry involvement. Fry concludes that restoring albedo should come first while carbon is removed, and Tulip thanks him.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:00

I'm Robbie Tulip and here with Project Save the World to talk with my friend and colleague, Gene Fry. Jean and I have worked together in the Healthy Planet Foundation. Action Coalition and with a particular focus on the on the topic of albedo and Gene can give you a bit of his background, PhD with Cornell I believe and Quite an interesting scholarly career, but taking a really interesting scholarly approach on the problems of climate change and the role of, for example, clouds and The darkening of the earth as a primary driver of climate change. And so we'll just be able in this call to delve into some of Gene's work on climate change.

Albedo, the reflectivity of sunlight and how climate change has been changing that and how that has been a major feedback reinforcing climate change. So, Gene, could you say a few words to introduce yourself, please?

Speaker 2 1:22

Yes, I grew up in Fayetteville, Arkansas, a valedictorian at the University Town City High School. Went to Cornell University for undergrad, went away for 11 years, came back for a master's and PhD. Being resource economics, money meets the environment. Worked on economics and nuclear power plants for my dissertation, solar energy before that. And most of my paid career was focused on evaluating savings and enabling those from electric energy efficiency programs, mostly in Massachusetts, some in Connecticut, partly for state government, partly for private enterprise. And I retired when I turned 63, 14 years ago, I guess. And I'd been studying climate change in one sense or another since 36 years ago, shortly after I got my PhD. I went to college.

A lecture by David Rind, whose boss was Jim Hansen, and he presented a paper they had in process looking at doubled CO2, four and a half degrees Celsius warming, 30 to 50 percent reduction in food, and a whole lot of other things that went along with that. And that has held my total attention for 36 years, mostly on the sidelines until I retired.

Speaker 1 2:57

So you gave a talk to the Healthy Planet Action Coalition in February with the title of Albedo Feedbacks, Dominate Current and Future Warming to Five Degrees Celsius or More. And that's a really surprising title because the usual assumption is, of the climate action community is that it's new emissions that are dominating warming and yet so there's this distinction in climate Climate science between forcings and feedbacks. And that is when we take an action to add carbon dioxide or methane to the atmosphere that forces the temperature to rise through the greenhouse effect. But the greenhouse effect then has these feedback processes. And the main feedback process is that the planet is getting darker. That is…

That when, for example, 90% of the heat from global warming is physically going into the ocean and then the ocean is heating up as a result and it heats up. There are big cloud banks over the ocean and it makes those cloud banks start to dissolve. You've done some really interesting research on that gene. The dissolving of the cloud bank, that then is what's called a climate feedback because As the cloud dissolves, more sunlight gets through to the ocean. That heats up the ocean even more, which then dissolves the clouds even more. So it's an accelerating, self-reinforcing process. And it's really hard for any action on carbon to have any effect on that feedback process.

So it's got really interesting questions for climate stability and climate policy.

Speaker 2 5:07

Well, I've been learning a lot as I go. I've not had climatology training, but I've certainly noticed that based on work by George Saliutis operating out of NASA, I think that's published in late 2024 and sort of an update in early 2025, was showing that the Cloud cover over the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans had been decreasing over almost all this time period from 1984 to 2019. After the first two years, it was decreasing almost uniformly, if not, there were some ups and downs, but basically down. And I thought that the process that you had described three minutes ago Was a good candidate to be the main driver of that.

I did, however, a multiple regression analysis, basically a trend line, and found that the Cloud cover, the decrease in cloud cover correlated better with time than it did with sea surface temperature. And that was puzzled, and I brought that up in another group not very long ago, NOAC, which you're probably also acquainted with. He said, I wonder if something else is going on. That was just a few weeks ago. And a fellow named Brian von Hertzen, who you know, said, well, the plankton, which produce cloud-condensate nuclei out of the oceans, has been declining, and there have been less dimethyl sulfides Mercaptan and a third substance that I don't remember the name of, and that could explain some of it.

And I was thinking today about what else is going on during that time. And another thing that was going on is that, in general, a lot more sattus. Humans have been reducing our own sulfur emissions, which is another important source of cloud condensation nuclei. And it's often somewhat hard to separate that from… Cloud Trends. And I suspect that the process that you outlined is an important one, but at this point I'm skeptical that it's the only one involved. And it's not that I feel confident in saying X is due to this process you described and Y is due to our declining sulfur emissions, Z is due to declining emissions from plankton.

There may be other factors involved, and my research has not progressed far enough to A partition among what are suspected reasons for that going on. But what is really key is this is very real. And what happens, it's easier to understand the feedback loops if you look at a different albedo source, which is snow and ice. As most people know, those are white, at least when fresh. And they melt when things get warmer, and when they melt, the sunlight, instead of bouncing off, mostly bouncing off the white surface, is hitting a much darker surface. In the case of sea ice, that's water underneath, which absorbs most of the incipient sunlight, and that speeds up the heating.

Especially under where the sea ice was, which leads to more melting sea ice. And on land, it's a similar thing with the snow. And those are better known examples where the temperature feedback is very well established. And I think there's a temperature feedback basically when the world was getting hotter, clouds were getting fewer. And that was terribly widespread. And it was strongest in the tropical areas, especially where the sun was most directly overhead, and therefore clouds have the greatest cooling effect by not letting the sunlight hit the surface of the earth.

Speaker 1 10:14

James Hansen made this slide, inferred contributions to reduced earth albedo from his 2025 article, Global Warming Has Accelerated the United Notions and the Public Well-Informed. I've added the percentages just to help understand the numbers, but what he started with was saying that the The Snow and Ice Measurement and the Ship Measurement, that is that the International Maritime Organization decreed in 2020 to remove sulfur. From shipping fuels, that those factors are quite well known. And it leaves the remainder, this 62%, as clouds. That is so that the darkening of the earth from 100 watts Reflectivity per square metre at the turn of the century to now below 98 watts, so like a 2% darkening by that measure, is mainly from this cloud dissolving problem.

And as you're explaining, Gene, the attribution of the causes of cloud design is still quite understudied and not well understood. Measured and scientifically understood, like James Hansen commented that there had been proposals to improve the scientific study of ocean clouds, but they'd not been funded with satellites and so on. And so the data quantity is not really what it should be, but it's… I view it as a security issue, I suppose. You know, I'm thinking about this in terms of human impacts and climate policy. When we've got this really big feedback that's accelerating the warming of the planet, like you're seeing it at the moment. I'm here in Australia in winter.

Europe and North America are having such a hot summer and the trouble is that that heat is just steadily growing and so we can only expect it to get hotter unless we do something about

Speaker 2 12:40

it. I looked at another graph in that same paper which you are very familiar with and that shows the Earth's albedo over the period 2000 to late 2000, early 2025, and that shows the albedo decreasing by 0.64% of 100%, or somewhat over 2% of its value at the initial start of the period. And what comes out of that when you multiply by the Basically the solar insulation divided by the area the earth is you get 2.19 watts per square meter. That graph from Hansen has I believe 1.5 watts per square meter and I'm very curious about what I see as the Missing 0.7 watts per square meter, which seems to have been observed by the satellites, and what Hansen came up with there.

My gut feeling is he has underestimated the cloud effect. There may have been some vegetation changes in the color of vegetation, but I think those are pretty minor and they happen only on land. Although I suppose there might be changes in the color of the ocean. And I think the cloud effect may be larger. Where I started out, if I can go back a little bit, 11 years ago, I looked at the graph that Al Gore made famous looking across the last few ice ages with ice core data. And I graphed basically, instead of against time, I graphed Temperature against CO2 and applied a reasonable polar to global temperature conversion. And I came out with what fell out of that.

That trend line based on the ice core data was that at that time we had less CO2 in the air and the long run equilibrium temperature for the then current CO2, which was right around 400 parts per million, maybe slightly less, was 4.9 degrees Celsius. And we were then about 1.0, maybe a little less. I said, wow, there's something big going on here. And What can change? And it's the albedo, as you said. And as you saw in my presentation in February, I've extended that to 25 million years, and not just the cold times, but also the hot times. For most of the last 25 million years, except for the last 3 million years, Earth has been hotter than now.

And the equation, the trend line over those Hotter times is virtually identical to that during the colder times, which surprised me very much. But I think that that leaves me the gut feeling that there's even more happening with clouds than Jim Hansen's 0.9 watts per square meter says. And I'm trying to reconcile with that. With some equations I've come up with recently about how to calculate what's called Earth climate sensitivity, what most people have in the, you know, 1979 was estimated by Charny and some other people to be around three degrees Celsius warming for doubled CO2.

And then I'm looking at the record of the past, and that's telling me it's actually about nine degrees So the Earth climate sensitivity does not include all the feedbacks. It only includes fairly short-run feedbacks. And it doesn't include changes in ice sheets. It doesn't include changes in the color of vegetation as you move from dark green conifers to not as dark green. Deciduous trees to grasses which are still even less dark and then you move to dirt and sand.

Speaker 1 17:27

But with the scale of emissions, the problem is that some of those slow feedbacks might prove to be faster than has been assumed.

Speaker 2 17:41

Yes, although I think the more interesting alternative, which I was getting to, is that the fast feedbacks are much larger than was assumed there. When you take clouds into account, and there may not be very much difference between Between the long-run climate sensitivity and the short-run Earth climate sensitivity, ECS, which has been pegged for many years at three degrees. And what happens is the main differences I see is ice sheets melt, but the area of ice sheets is less than the area of sea ice, and it's not really… This may be 0.4 watts per square meter, but it's not really a lot in the larger scheme of things.

And the changes in vegetation are actually going to make a lighter colored planet as you lose more of your darkness. And that goes in the opposite direction. Well, what's left, uh, changes in, uh, long-term changes in carbon cycle and ocean carbonate chemistry. And I'm not, I don't really know very much about that. But my sense of things is clouds are the really, really big deal. And the other things that have used to be the gap between three degrees shortland climate sensitivity and nine, uh, Long run after tens of thousands of years, hundreds of thousands of years, is not that great.

Some of the recent Earth climate system models or climate models have been estimating the short run, the ECS, which has been taken to be three, they're estimated almost six. Hanson estimated 4.5 or 4.8 recently. And I think it may well be very much higher than that, due primarily Or maybe even almost entirely to clouds. So I said, it appears to me that Anson left out what was the difference between the 1.5 he got from the ships, the clouds, and the ice snow, and the 2.19, which is a change in the albedo over that, what I thought was the same time period.

Speaker 1 20:06

I haven't done any

Speaker 2 20:07

calculations by that, but

Speaker 1 20:11

Look, this is just so interesting and important, Jane, for climate policy and climate science, because what we've got is this problem of Earth energy equilibrium and climate sensitivity, which The official policies, that is the consensus scientific agreement through the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, seem to be quite But complacent against what the science is saying now. And I'm really interested in the problem of committed warming. That is the idea that if we… If we look at what the temperature was in the past when the Earth had the current level of greenhouse gases and compare that today, then there's an underlying pressure for the temperature to rise to that equilibrium.

And so that means that the warming that we've had so far From the current level of greenhouse gases is not all of the warming that that level is going to cause. Very much so, just very, very much so. And so that raises a real problem with the scientific discussion around what's called the zero emission commitment. So there's been this modelling method within the IPCC and the scientific community to just do an imaginary thought exercise. If we suddenly stopped emitting CO2, what would happen to the temperature? And there's this supposed consensus view that the temperature would go down. But my hunch is that the temperature would actually keep going up for quite a while. And then you have to factor in the…

Speaker 2 22:33

I think that the historical record is… There's no way it's going down. It's going up. It's going way up. The climate record is clear, and they've got a bunch of wishful thinking if they think they stop putting carbon in the air either by 2050 or even immediately. The temperature now is more than two-thirds driven by the albedo feedbacks. When we stop putting climate in the air, it will be all driven by the albedo feedbacks. The albedo feedbacks are quite large. And certainly they've had this idea in the past that stop putting carbon in the air, things will be fine. Well, they won't be fine. They're going to eventually get up to what happened the last time we had this much CO2 in the air.

It's basically nine degrees. We're at about 1.4 now. And that's when I say level. Yeah, the sea level will rise more slowly, I think, than the temperature does, because there's a lot of thickness of ice. But we're in for serious temperature rise. I mean, the modeling I did in the wake of the studies I did 11 years ago with the Vostok Ice Course was I was showing, we're looking at five degree, well four to five degrees by 2100, five degrees a little bit more by a century from now. Those are really tough.

The second problem I saw sort of back in that analysis, but I fleshed it out a little more for the presentation five months ago to HPAC, is that With that much warming, you're not only having more albedo feedbacks by melting more ice and the cloud effects, which are more complex than that, but are also a snowballing effect or an amplifying feedback loop. You're also unleashing the major carbon sinks and turning into carbon sources. I knew a guy who was working on his PhD at MIT maybe 15 years ago, and his group was looking, when are the oceans going to turn into carbon sources instead of carbon sinks? You've got the permafrost. We know that has become a carbon source.

It's not becoming as fast as our worst nightmares, but it's becoming one. I mean, 10 years ago, it was about as much warming from that as from the U.S. automobile fleet. And I don't know how that's changed. It's probably increased a little bit.

Speaker 1 25:51

So with the cross-melting, there's the release of both methane and CO2? Yep, got a double whammy there.

Speaker 2 25:59

And we're going to lose our forests. Forests require enough soil moisture to function, most of all. And soil moisture has been generally declining, and especially it declines more as temperatures heat up. You can have more rainfall, but More of the rain runs off and less seeps down into the soil. And that has a huge effect, making it much more difficult to sustain the forest we already have. So you may lose quite a bit of carbon stored in forests. And the problem in soils is it warms up. Microorganisms rev up their activity as it gets warmer. And I don't know quantities there, but it's going to be a problem.

Speaker 1 26:47

We've got this situation with climate policy that the governments of the world endorsed the Paris Agreement to seek net zero emissions by 2050. As the key policy, and then that was reinforced in this decade by the UN calling for a halving of world CO2 emissions by 2030. And instead of a decline of emissions, of course, we've seen a steady escalation and an acceleration of emissions as like data centers and just energy hunger in Europe. Across the world has increased. And so the whole framework of the Paris Accord, firstly, there's this problem that the net zero emissions target, it's only actually a way station on the journey towards massive net negative emissions.

And part of my concern is that decarbonizing the economy Doesn't actually offer a path towards that net negative emissions that's required. It's only effectively, you know, mining carbon dioxide from the air and the sea, mining methane. That's at a really vast scale, it's multi-gigathon scale, that's going to make much of a difference. That is exactly what we need to do.

Speaker 2 28:23

Net zero is a way station to taking… Yeah. Yeah, we've got to get that carbon out of the air, but that takes a lot of time. And in that time, we're going to be heating up. Right now, we're heating up, I think, 0.36 degrees Celsius per decade. That may increase, although I'm not. Also, there's tipping elements. Yeah, we've got the tipping cascades for all kinds of things. Yeah.

Speaker 1 29:13

And so what it all gets down to, Gene, is that we need sunlight reflection technologies to cool the earth and stabilize the climate. And there's a lot of political opposition to climate change. To that, people say that it's more important to cut emissions, whereas I would say it's much more important as the immediate climate policy objective to stabilise the climate. It's like in medicine, you stabilise the patient and then you can start to think about the longer term agenda.

Speaker 2 29:51

Yeah, I did some modeling, very crude modeling, a little bit better than back of the envelope, but not a lot. And suppose we did as well as I think we can do with taking carbon out of the air. And it's growing maybe 10, 20% a year now, but it really… You're not going to get gigatons before 2040 per year, and it may be after 2040 before we get to the gigaton level. And we need to be to the 2030, 40 gigaton year of CO2 removal, and that's probably not going to be happening until 2060, 2070.

And by then, with the albedo feedbacks, we're going to be Well, we won't get to 4.5 at the end of the century with that, but we'll peak probably over 3 degrees Celsius, maybe sometime around 2050 to 2070. And a lot of bad things can happen. You're going to unleash your tipping points. There are going to be a cascade. The thing about tipping points is there… Very fast in geological time, but they take a number of years, sometimes decades in human times. I think you see some of that with the ocean current that spans the Atlantic Ocean from north to south, and we're worried about that collapsing.

And it's been slowing down, and the signal-to-noise ratio is not as high as you might like to say it's definitely collapsing, but it probably is. And the question is, how long did that take? I mean, you've got these huge forest fires right now burning.

Speaker 1 31:38

If I could just pick you up on the AMOC collapse, so the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation. What I worry about Gene, is taking a precautionary approach to these vast natural systems. And we just don't know what the impact of the sudden massive carbon pulse that we've introduced into the system will be. Like it could be that the impact Anthropogenic warming on the natural systems is bigger than we have modeled, that the system could be more fragile and sensitive than we assume. And so the precautionary You know, like when you're next to a cliff, you step back from the cliff or you make sure that there's a fence. But it's like we're sort of teetering on the edge of the cliff without any guardrail.

And the precautionary approach should be to do what we can to slow down the warming as much as possible in the cheapest, most efficient ways that we can, because we just don't know what all of the, like things we mentioned, the permafrost before, you know, it could be that all of that extra methane and CO2 that's melting out of the permafrost could just completely swamp All of the climate benefit of our emission reductions.

Speaker 2 33:15

That's very true. And I certainly worry about the oceans becoming a carbon source as they warm up. Gases are less soluble in water as it warms up. And that's where most of the carbon is. It's not tied up in rocks. But I think the main thing, the main driver here is changes in the albedo. And those will continue to be multiples of the effect from the greenhouse gases themselves. And you're going to, as I think we both know, basically hell breaks loose on the route to past three and up to four and even five degrees.

Speaker 1 33:56

And, you know, Just on that, Gene, I think it's important to draw an analogy between a person and the planet to say that when you've got a fever of one degrees Celsius, you can still function. But when you're running a temperature like three degrees, you're in bed and you need to rest. Otherwise, you could get worse. Five degrees, you die. Is that about right? Lovely. Yeah, and so, like, if we're just, you know, complacent, you know, running a marathon despite having a one and a half degree fever, it's a very high risk, and we ought to be a lot more precautionary about temperature.

Speaker 2 34:49

Yeah, while we need to take all that carbon out of the air, And we need to stop emissions, which is our legacy emissions are so large that that's priority number three. Second priority is to take all the carbon out of the air, but that By the time that's well enough underway to be consistent with something like we grew up with, climate, you'll have too much coming up from the carbon sinks, terminated carbon sources, beginning with the ocean and going through permafrost. So, yeah, it's just terribly important to… Reverse the albedo loss. And when I describe this to various people I meet, I often describe it as rebuilding clouds.

Except the most important of those, you can do marine clouds, which are closely akin to the ship contrails we lost with the International Maritime Organization regulations. But you have ships dedicated to do marine cloud brightening. You can use airplanes or rockets of some sort to put cloud condensation nuclei in the upper troposphere. And get your molecules of water vapor, which is an important greenhouse gas, and get those glommed onto ice crystals so you don't have very many water vapor molecules in the upper troposphere, and you can allow more radiation to escape. But I think the most important is to put clouds in what might be called clouds in the stratosphere, where the Fallout ratio is on the order of a year instead of a week.

And I think maybe you mentioned stratospheric aerosol injection earlier. That seems to have the biggest bang for the buck, and that combined with the other methods, which can do their own smaller pieces, has the potential to hold the peak Temperature to not very much more than two and a half degrees Celsius.

And that's considerably hotter than now, but when you combine that with taking the carbon out of the air we've put in there over the last century and a half, but especially in the last 20, 30 years, You can bring that temperature curve down to something that's sustainable and probably by the end of the century bring it down to what it is now and it will continue on that downward trajectory as we keep the cooling on and a larger and larger portion of the CO2 we put in the air we've taken out as years go by. It's a very big chore and If all we do is cool Earth off and we don't take carbon out of the air, we fail. Kapoof.

Speaker 1 38:05

Yes, that's exactly right, Gene. And yet I think that there needs to be… A fundamental review of climate policies because I completely agree with you that stratospheric aerosol injection has to be the primary cooling technology because it's the only one that's quite simple in In technology, in effect, there are questions around side effects but the situation is that the disease is so much worse Side effects that, you know, not to do stratospheric aerosol injection is the equivalent of refusing modern treatments for cancer. And so it's incredibly dangerous. You know, the patient can die when they just rely on treatments that don't work.

And unfortunately, that's what the climate crisis The policy community has determined that the consensus view is that it's more important to subsidize energy reform than to stabilize the climate. The effect of the moral hazard logic that says we must prevent any physical action to restore planetary albedo because it will undermine the subsidies that are going to wind So there needs to be a big shift in the paradigm of climate policy.

So we need the Global thinking that's required to deploy stratospheric aerosol injection and to test up the range of other possible cooling technologies that can complement that, like if we see SAI as the main cooling Then we need to work out how to mine all of that excess carbon out of out of the air and sea which we're just at a very preliminary state you know we just and we need to integrate this into our security thinking because you know when you look at the at the impacts of global warming On human systems, on the economy and society, let alone the biosphere and biodiversity. It's just a really dangerous future that we're facing that we need to take.

Like cooling the planet has a big peace, security, prosperity dividend, I suppose. So there's a couple of reflections.

Speaker 2 41:21

Yeah, one thing I like to bring up is analysis done by a fellow who has feet in both worlds, CO2 removal and cooling Earth off. His name is David Keith. And he and a couple of colleagues did a study a bit more than a year ago where they looked, what's the effect on people dying, large scale? Of doing a stratospheric aerosol injection and not doing it. And basically you've got 14 times as many people dying if you don't than if you do. There would be modest problems. It's possible that some of the side benefits in terms of precipitation, in terms of ocean currents behaving much better for us, would be some side benefits besides just the mortality.

And it's likely to have beneficial effects in some geographies and modest pretty one and modest disbenefits in other geographical areas. But I think on the overall, it's just so hugely, hugely better. And of course, it buys us time to take all that CO2 out of the air that we put in it. I can't overstate the importance of that enough. And the idea that we need to concentrate all our resources on not putting carbon in the air, we already have huge amounts. And that's driving, I mean, the equilibrium temperature for what's already in the air. Is close to nine degrees Celsius. And probably the majority of that heating, probably a good half of it, is going to be over the next century. And that's committed warming.

Yes. And there's committed warming beyond that. But it's, you know, we get enough a century from now. Things fall apart. You lose most of the world's food supply. You lose most of the world's fresh water. You lose most of the forest. You lose most of the species. And you lose most of the people. And that's a very, very high cost to focus just on food. The easy stuff, not putting carbon in the air. It's cheaper not to put carbon in the air than it is to put carbon in the air. That's, I mean, solar, wind are cheap, electric vehicles, heat pumps, whole nine yards.

Speaker 1 44:13

I even find that quite a difficult proposition, Gene, because I know wind and solar are cheaper at the point of production. But when you integrate all of the system costs and backup and storage and transmission and various other costs that are involved, my feeling is that The economic benefits of wind and solar have been somewhat exaggerated. And it's like we're in a situation where there's an expectation that the current level of fossil fuel use will continue at current or higher levels for decades to come.

Speaker 2 45:05

I think that's really incorrect. Fossil fuel use is peaking now. It is on a plateau, and it's barely different from what it was three years ago. Almost all the investment going forward, nobody's investing in new fossil fuel power plants. Not nobody, but most of them are not. And China… The production from coal-fired power plants is headed down. It varies depending on the climate and how But they're being used as peaker plants and intermediate plants. And China is focusing, of course, on building a lot of transmission to the solar and wind they built because a lot of that is getting curtailed because it's too far from the load centers. And that's the emphasis of their upcoming five-year plan.

Speaker 1 46:14

And there's also been the impact of the war in Iran. Some analysis suggests that that has led to a return to coal in China. I think what it illustrates is that You know, cutting emissions is actually really difficult. And so, you know, we had the Paris Accord say, let's cut emissions in half by 2030. And it's gone the other way. Well, sorry, the Paris Accord didn't actually say that. It was more the UN at the… Sixth assessment report that was in order to stay below 1.5, that's what was needed. But there's been like that idea of really big economic transformation is essentially not accepted by the capitalist system. It's marginal to their thinking.

And so I'm interested in how The thinking around restoring albedo can be something that's much more possible than cutting emissions in the short term. And so thinking about getting industries on board with the idea of supporting the governance that's needed to advocate for cooling the earth.

Speaker 2 47:51

I think that's a great idea. We have a couple of semi-industrial outfits, much smaller, that are dedicated to albedo restoration, and they're planning on making some money from that. I think one has said they're using calcium carbonate core with the silica gel, and they're doing it micro to nano sizes, so it'll stay up there. I think another thing to talk about is risk. We've taken some risky course. We've been geoengineering Earth's atmosphere for many centuries, but especially in the last century or two. And people are scared of geoengineering. I think we should stop that geoengineering of putting all the carbon in the air. But I think we need to talk about risk. And I'm not really very much of an authority on that.

We have some other people in our orbits who talk the language of risk better.

Speaker 1 48:56

Sandy Trust is with the Institute of Accuaries in the UK. And actuaries have a very strong focus on risk. And so they are receptive to the argument that the risk analysis is not between intervention and intervention. A previous stable climate. It's between intervention and what would be the outcome without the intervention. So what's known as a risk-risk framework of analysis.

Speaker 2 49:35

That's what I was talking about with David Geith's analysis.

Speaker 1 49:39

Yeah, in terms of… Yeah, so the risk of not proceeding with cooling vastly exceeds the risk of proceeding.

Speaker 2 49:50

Yes, and I think there's a bias toward thinking you look only at the risk of an intervention while ignoring the risks of what you're already doing. And I think that's underlaying so much of the thinking that gets related to politicians. If you want to do something else, you ignore the cost of what you're currently doing. And the cost of inaction is huge. Said to be zero, assumed to be zero. And that's a big error in people's thinking, especially when you have the feedbacks we've unleashed and the albedo feedbacks are really very large. And they proceed for the most part without further injection of greenhouse gases.

You inject more greenhouse gases and get a little bit worse a little bit sooner, but we're going to get there unless we cool Earth off. Help.

Speaker 1 51:03

Yeah so there's this issue around the tipping elements that if we don't proceed with cooling the earth then like we're already at a situation where coral reefs are facing severe peril from bleaching and the general estimate is that global warming of 1.5 degrees is enough to Massively degrade, if not completely destroy the world's coral reefs. And so we're already at that threshold. And then the tipping point community has estimated a range of other Earth system destabilization impacts at 1.5 to 2.5 degrees. And so the further risk is that, as you were saying before, that those tipping elements can cascade, that they can interact in ways that we don't understand and haven't predicted.

Speaker 2 52:19

Yep, there are unknowns out there. Some things that are known but not as well known fail to show up on global climate models, but I think those by and large are getting better than they used to be.

Speaker 1 52:38

And so the most important precaution is to slow the increase of heat because the heat is the essential driver of the feedbacks and the system disruptions.

Speaker 2 52:55

And I think it's important to realize where we are. Jim Hansen said not many months ago, there's talk about keep 1.5 alive, and he says 1.5 is dead. And we probably cannot avoid hitting two degrees. And it's partly a question of how fast… And how strongly we can ramp up direct cooling interventions. I think especially the one that ramps up fastest and its biggest is stratospheric aerosol injection. It might take 20 years, but maybe we can do it within 10. Maybe even sooner. That's my wishful thinking. It'd save a lot of people a lot of pain if we could do that.

Speaker 1 53:43

Yeah, like a moonshot approach when you consider what the United States was able to achieve from President Kennedy's call to send a man to the moon and bring him safely back within the decade of the 1960s. That was an extraordinary achievement with a whole lot of spin-off benefits for the society. If we had visionary leadership today that said we aim to stop temperature rising within a decade, and then bring temperature back down towards the stable level. Long-term temperature of the Holocene in which our economy and society evolved. To me, that's a moonshot vision that ought to be able to inspire broader political understanding and interest so that we can reform our climate policies to a strategy that actually makes a bit more sense.

Speaker 2 55:02

Well, I think I've put the right incentives in. You've got Stardust and Making Sunsets, the two corporations I alluded to earlier, working on stratospheric aerosol injection. And there's a lot to be done. And I think with the right incentives and that would mean money and perhaps some other things. One thing I've been pushing for a dozen years is to set a rising price on carbon and have that prevail worldwide. And that's happening in Europe. It's happening in China. There are little pieces of the U.S. in the electricity center that have that in the Northeast and also in California and Washington.

Um, and we need to have that apply not only to carbon, we need something similar for, um, and we also have that for CO2 removal here in the United States, called Section 45Q Tax Credit. And we need something similar for the most important tool in our toolbox during the next 20 years, and that is, of course, re-brightening the earth. Um, Rebuilding clouds, as I call it.

Speaker 1 56:20

Yeah, and I think of it, as I've said before, that an albedo accord modelled on the Montreal Protocol for ozone depleting substances can provide the governance and Advocacy and cooperation that's needed to advocate and test and deploy sunlight reflection technologies because the problem is that the Disinformation campaigns that have sowed fear and hostility towards sunlight reflection methods need to be overcome through a public It was a public information effort in order to build the constituencies of support and the public understanding of climate policy. Is something that can bring together business with science and government to engage, especially, I think, with the countries who see the greatest peril from global warming for them, and then build that into a…

Globally accepted approach that can deploy stratospheric aerosol injection and other cooling technology. Okay, so Gene, we're ready to wind up. Would you like to provide us with a concluding statement that reviews some of our conversation and summarizes some of the implications?

Speaker 2 58:15

We need to put… Rebuilding Earth's albedo, re-brightening Earth at the top of our agenda. We can do it fast and save a lot of suffering and prevent or delay many of carbon sinks turning to carbon sources. We can use capitalism. We can be guided by an albedo accord. We need, of course, to remove basically all the carbon we put in the air over the centuries, especially in the last 50 years. And so the albedo enhancement cannot stand on its own, but it's the time-wise, it's the primary thing to do now. And we need to keep doing it until we've taken all the carbon out of the air we put in, including any future emissions.

Speaker 1 59:18

Thank you very much, Gene. And I really appreciated the conversation. I really welcome your very considered and learned understanding of the science that surrounds all of And I think it's a really vital contribution to the broader policy understanding. So I really hope that people are able to watch this talk. It'll be up on the internet. Project Save the World website. We really thank Masa and her team at Project Save the World for the opportunity to share this information. So thanks again, Gene, for joining us, and we'll conclude at that point.

Speaker 2 1:00:08

Okay. Well, thank you, Robert.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments