Episode 783 Axworthy’s World

Notes

In this episode, Lloyd Axworthy joins Doug Saunders and Barry Stevens to discuss his views on global issues.

Guests

  • Lloyd Axworthy
  • Doug Saunders
  • Barry Stevens

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

nuclear, countries, international, court, weapons, Canada, state, States, United, treaty, justice, Lloyd, came, government, guy, ICC, president, stuff, system, American

SPEAKERS

Lloyd Axworthy, Doug Saunders, Barry Stevens, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Barry Stevens hosted this episode of Project Save the World, titled "Axworthy's World," with guests Doug Saunders and Lloyd Axworthy. The conversation covered nuclear arms control, the International Criminal Court, and the prospects for international cooperation. Stevens opened by citing the expired US-Russia arms control treaty, nuclear threats, a US civil nuclear deal with Saudi Arabia, and the role of artificial intelligence in launch decisions. Axworthy argued that the guardrails built over 40 or 50 years have been eliminated, and he recalled Canada's postwar choice not to become a nuclear state. He said Global Affairs Canada's nuclear diplomacy capacity has been shut down and that Canada is not engaged in current efforts.

Read more…

Saunders argued that recent wars showed nuclear deterrence to be useless against neighbouring states, so the lesson should be that such arsenals are not worth their cost, yet the institutions that could make this point have weakened. Axworthy said other countries were beginning to test the limits as American credibility declined, and that setting norms still matters, citing the Ottawa landmine treaty. Stevens noted that many publics, including in South Korea and France, now favour nuclear options. Saunders replied that European nuclear talk rests on a misunderstanding of NATO as collective defence rather than a US umbrella.

Stevens then turned to the International Criminal Court, citing Marco Rubio's plan to dismantle it and sanctions on a Canadian judge, and asked how dangerous this was. Axworthy argued the effort aims to make the world safe for war criminals, and said Canada has been silent and has not defended its own judges. Saunders said the court has long faced tension between justice and peace, which now appears to have become neither. Stevens argued the sovereign state system creates that conflict, and Axworthy pointed to universal jurisdiction and hybrid courts as useful tools.

Axworthy then described his current work on a Manitoba rail bypass and expressed hope for new forms of collective governance, arguing that Europe's older models should be re-examined. Stevens asked whether such dreams were realistic. Saunders suggested Canada's current stance might reflect a national emergency rather than a lasting drift from its traditions. Axworthy replied that liberal voices have been isolated and that he sees himself keeping ideas alive. Stevens and Saunders then thanked Axworthy.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:00

I'm Larry Stevens. I'm a documentary writer and filmmaker. Joining me is Doug Saunders, a longtime award-winning journalist, beats in numerous countries, perhaps, for my money, the most interesting columnist in the Globe and Mail, Canada's leading No question about that. And he's written very originally about 21st century cities and migration, many things. And we're here to talk with Lloyd Axworthy, whose career spans nearly half a century in public life. As Canada Minister of Foreign Affairs, he led the 1997 Ottawa Treaty banning anti-personnel landmines, presided over the UN Security Council a couple of times, and championed the idea of human security, which is significant for us today, I think, and played a major role in the creation of the International Criminal Court.

And he's been, since then, a university president, chaired the World Refugee and Migration Council, Recently published a memoir and, super interesting to me, served as international co-president of the World Federalist Movement. Fair to say he's been the most significant A very significant critic of Canada's foreign policy and the state of international institutions. So today, we're going to talk about, I hope, nukes and the ICC a little bit, if we can, if we have time. Just to set up the nuclear thing, the last nuclear arms control treaty between Russia and the USA expired earlier this year.

USA is spending a lot of money modernizing its nuclear weapons, and Russia is building Novel weapons to evade the so-called Golden Dome that President Trump thinks will protect the United States, which no doubt Canada will be involved in. Nuclear threats have been made by President Putin and the U.S. President over Iran. And most recently, as you were writing about, Lloyd, Washington has struck a civil nuclear deal with Saudi Arabia, which I think includes enrichment rights. While using military force against Iran's nuclear program. So nuclear age has always been dangerous, but Lloyd, are we in a particularly dangerous time right now?

Speaker 2 2:28

I think it was dangerous because— The efforts of 40, 50 years of building some guardrails, some constraints, some standards, some protective devices, like red phones, have all been eliminated. I think Canada, as I've said before, Has what I always thought was a particular legacy. Going back to 45, 46, where Canada made the decision, which nobody pays much attention to, but we had every single necessary element to become a nuclear weapon state, and we decided not to. The Saint Laurent government, and I've Gone back to Czech Hansard and, you know, there was some preliminary debate, but it was unanimous in the House. I mean, they kind of decided to become a non-nuclear state.

And to me, that set up a legacy, which has been followed ever since, up until now. I think we've, for reasons that we don't, the depth of it, The commitment, and even the machinery, Global Affairs Canada no longer has what for a time was one of the best nuclear development diplomatic centers in GAC. That's all kind of been shut down. No discussions. They don't go to the meetings. We bypassed the whole discussion on the treaty against banning nuclear weapons. We're not engaged in the efforts, as I wrote about, in terms of the proliferation of sharing our issues.

And in fact, I still have a really kind of a serious itch that in the arrangements or agreements we're making with Saudi Arabia, we might just be including uranium and know-how into that package. We never know because the Kearney government isn't very forthcoming in what its deals are. But I think we're now at a stage where you're basically seeing not just a proliferation of potential sites, but as you've described, brand new delivery systems and bombs that can be And increasingly, if you look at the language of the United States and Russia and China, it's a language of saying, well, we're kind of reaching a stage where nuclear weapons are no longer the kind of sober mushroom hanging over the world.

We can do things in a much more targeted, calculated way, which just isn't true. There's just no point to it. So it's one of those pillars of international conflict management that has fallen by the wayside.

Speaker 3 5:52

It's a strange historical moment for this to be occurring, for the institutional infrastructure of non-proliferation to be fading. Because on one hand, we have the language of nuclear deterrence entering the vocabularies of a number of countries again. On the other hand, The last couple of years have really shown the world and countries that might be seeking them how ineffective and pointless the concept of deterrence is, at least against neighboring countries.

Because in the last couple of years, we've seen Ukraine, a non-nuclear state, occupy a province of Russia, an oblast of Russia, a Famously nuclear state for more than a year with knowing full well that Russia would not and could not retaliate because using nuclear weapons against a geographically adjoining country would be effectively be attacking your own population. And we've also seen India and Pakistan go to war against each other and India destroy a significant amount of Pakistan's Air Force and so on in a conventional war, again knowing full well that nuclear deterrent is useless against the geographically adjoining state. You can argue about whether it has any use anywhere else.

So the lesson coming out of this period should be that there's not a lot of value in the considerable expense and risk of developing a nuclear arsenal, yet There's nobody saying that now because, as you say, the institutions that should be doing that have been neutered.

Speaker 2 7:43

Right. Totally. I mean, it's become a kind of commedia dell'arte. You just go through the routines, use the language, you hold meetings, nothing happens. And in fact, in the meantime, you've got North Korea and Egypt and Saudi Arabia and… I mean, they're all beginning to nibble at the corners of this, because I guess in terms of the great power language, the fact that Trump has blown the American mystique of being the all-powerful arbiter, People are kind of losing trust in anything they can do. So they're saying we have to do it ourselves. So, I mean, Europe is a good example where you've now got serious discussions in European countries about would they have to have their own nuclear weapons?

And I go back to one old sort of, I had an international law professor way back in graduate school named Richard Falk. And he said, you know, the basic axiom is if you're Keep producing weapons. One of these days, you're going to use them.

Speaker 1 8:59

Yeah. And in fact, of course, despite deterrence, as you say, not being very effective, or even people can even fight wars while they have nuclear weapons without using them. Nevertheless, they are on a hair trigger. In the sense that the United States has a vast arsenal of land-based missiles, which will be targeted. And therefore, if there's information coming in that they appear to be targeted, the president, of course, has a few five or ten minutes. This president has five or ten minutes to decide whether to use them properly. Or lose them. And then we're adding also artificial intelligence into this mix, which…

Speaker 2 9:39

Into the mix. That's the big… I mean, Barry, just to make that comment, I mean, we're seeing daily, if not twice daily, you know, the President of the United States is basically off his rocker in so many ways. And at what point does his frustration, his anger, his inability to… Win primary nominations in Colorado, force him to say, I'm going to do something dramatic to show exactly. I mean, you just don't know how thin an edge it is between the control system there, because right now there isn't any rule that he doesn't think he can break.

Speaker 1 10:23

Yeah, there was a guy I spoke to who was a former State Department fellow called Tom Countryman, who talked about the ecology, not just the treaties, but the ecology, meaning the network of people who know each other, who know communication. And that does appear to have withered too. Would you say, like, in your time, you would Perhaps have more collegial or conversant relationships with Soviets than exist now.

Speaker 2 10:55

In fact, just a small history tidbit, but the Russian foreign minister at the time, he and I were probably the two strongest sort of anti-nuclears at the time. And we really bonded in a sense because he was pretty quickly dismissed when Putin came in. But there's a lot of—Russians remember that. I mean, I'm just writing a piece that I'm sure nobody will read, but I'm probably the last of a generation of Canadians that actually grew up during World War II and can remember what it was all about. And we're forgetting all that, and with it, the whole nuclear threat, because people were scared silly—Hiroshima, It'll just change the mindset of two or three generations, but it has no impact anymore.

Speaker 1 11:54

Yeah, I've actually often thought that the leaders right up to George H.W. Bush in the United States were in the war. Even Putin now, of course, lost his brother, and so he still perhaps recalls it, although not much. But no other leader really has that actual physical… But, you know, there was the, we talk about it all collapsing, but there is this treaty for the prohibition of nuclear weapons. And I think, I just looked it up, I think 100 countries, that's more than half the countries in the world have signed it. Canada has remained not enthusiastic. And is there any role for those countries? Middle powers who might have some influence, and should they? Is this a good thing?

Speaker 2 12:46

I always go that anything you can build that has the motive or the objective of putting some constraint, some rail guard on the use of weapons and war needs to be encouraged. The treaty itself, I mean, you know, as you said earlier, we did a landmine treaty without great powers of being involved. I'm sorry, the exception, France and Great Britain joined in. But the Americans were disdainful, the Russians, Norway, China, a very small group. They were along with Cuba and sort of Nicaragua and a few others. But the reality is, I think…

Here's a lesson that I think I learned from my time, is that setting norms, I know that sounds like a very kind of United Church kind of expression, but setting norms has an important influence on determining the use of power in the world. And the more you can put some norms out there and extol them and add to them and use them, getting the information out, It's all part of building a sort of bulwark against the ambitions of the military brass who think it's all okay, and politicians who no longer have restraints, and particularly those crazies in Silicon Valley who think that maybe it's a good thing the world destroy itself.

Speaker 3 14:31

That may be the best hope, right? That non-proliferation can become a politically valuable thing to be promoting because the wrong sort of people are, I think there needs to be, like you say, a making of this back into a norm, that people would want to vote for somebody who's talking about non-proliferation. I think there are a few too many countries where Proliferation has become a marketable political idea for some parties. And I think that's just because nobody's saying it clearly enough.

Speaker 2 15:15

Doug, I'd be interested, because you cover it pretty broadly on the international front. Is this a product of just the shift in increasingly more right-wing governments Whose basic ambition is to, as they like to stay, destroy the liberal international democratic systems, or is there something more to it than that right now?

Speaker 3 15:43

Well, the underlying question there is the big question of the day, which is, is this wave of illiberal democrat authoritarians, as they like to say, is it a product of Masses of people having lost their minds, or is it a matter of strongman leaders and extremist parties having manipulated party systems, the electoral systems, and so on to gain control against the will of majorities? And the one source of optimism is that almost nowhere do the people who have these ideas, including the ideas of nuclear proliferation, Have majority support. And the few places where they have, such as Hungary for 15 years and Brazil for a number of years, people have managed to overcome them democratically. Trump has never had a majority.

And if you look at who the actual strong believers in his ideology are, That's an even smaller group. And I think it's when they step over the line into ideas such as arming ourselves up with a nuclear arsenal and therefore becoming a target for reprisals from nuclear arsenal, that's when publics start to switch. So that's why I think what you're saying is important, is because Recognizing that it's a moral wrong and it's a line that we don't want to cross is something that can distinguish principled governments and leaders from the other kind.

Speaker 1 17:33

But isn't it true that a lot of countries, nuclear weapons are almost apolitical in the sense that, for instance, the labor governments of Britain back In the 40s, very much wanted a nuclear weapon. Right now, France is negotiating to extend its nuclear umbrella across Europe, which they seem quite enthusiastic about. South Korea, I think two-thirds of South Koreans or more actually want their government to have a nuclear weapon. And the reason is obvious, because they fear that the United States won't protect them anymore. The idea that nuclear weapons will is probably not true, but nevertheless, that's what's happening.

Speaker 2 18:24

Put your finger on that very important point is that the people, we've increasingly lost fear of nuclear weapons or the sense Awesome destruction that can result. And increasingly, the language is that these are strategic weapons that can be carefully targeted. I mean, we have a generation of people. I deal here on the shores of Lake Winnipeg, where I've got three or four, I have three brothers and a bunch of friends. We've had lots of talks about how today's generation doesn't read, doesn't watch major media, TikTok, Instagram. And the nuclear issue is not part of their lexicon. It's just not there. I have a son who teaches civics, you know, at the junior high, high school level.

And he said, you know, when he raises about Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and people say, what are you talking about? I mean, is it some kind of new kind of confection from Japan? So we really are, there is a real information Distillation going on, I think, on the issue. And when you get countries like Canada that no longer talk about or are interested in it, you weaken it even more. Governments used to provide a fairly strong kind of messaging about it, and they don't anymore.

Speaker 3 20:06

You know, Barry, I think in that messaging that you mentioned in Europe, and I think this is true in some circles in Canada as well, you sort of have a meshing of two misunderstandings or things that we've forgotten, as Lloyd said, one of which, of course, is the moral pointlessness and danger of nuclear weapons. But also as a complete misunderstanding of NATO. And the belief that more European countries would need a nuclear arsenal is based on a complete misunderstanding and thinking of NATO as having been a U.S. umbrella protecting countries. When, of course, the history of NATO shows that Its main function for countries other than the United States was to be a collective defense alliance.

And as a collective, it meant that not every member has to have all the things that all the members do. It was a cost reduction method. We can each have our strengths. So even if you do think that some form of symbolic nuclear deterrence is necessary, For your country, the fact that two European countries already have that should surely be enough. And I think any talk in Germany and so on about developing their own nuclear arsenal is, which, by the way, I don't think is going to go anywhere in that country for a number of reasons. It should be also obvious. But I think it's a misunderstanding of the concept of collective defense that's so important to us right now.

Speaker 1 21:51

It's ironic, just to comment, is that the Manhattan Project was started, a large number of Jewish scientists involved in order to encase the Germans with the Philippines. So it's kind of ironic that they should be interested in it now. But perhaps, because I know you have limited time, Lloyd, is that we could talk about another area of international relations. That's about the ICC, and you've written about it too recently. Marco Rubio, the U.S. Secretary of State, announced last month, July 2026, that the U.S. plans to disable and dismantle brick by brick The ICC, he threatened countries that won't cooperate with it, and he sanctioned a Canadian judge, but 11 offices of the court is what I just read recently.

I think it was last week, the ICC president. These are financials. Yeah, and very financial sanctions. They can't use their banks or credit cards. And this is actually not the first time. Back in the early 2000s, George W. Bush's administration attacked Pass the Hague Invasion Act, punish season that refused to promise to hand over U.S. citizens should be the charge. Anyway, one thing that's striking to me is that how the court's really not very powerful. It doesn't have a police force. It can't arrest Benjamin Netanyahu, Vladimir Putin. They seem to want to attack it. So I guess the question is, is this attack really dangerous? And why are they so concerned about it?

Speaker 2 23:47

Let me just say, I think the Rubio slash Trump effort to dismantle the court is to make the world safe for war criminals. I mean, I think that comes down because they think that they might, in fact, be singled out. But the whole notion that you can use an international judgment against the American exceptionalism is frightening. And Rubio, who's turning into a very nasty piece of goods, he almost makes J.D. Vance look sort of evangelical. This is mission. This is part of the dominance thing.

Because I think that the Americans, let me trace back when we were working on the court, we got involved particularly because Bill Pace, who was the Head of the World Federalists, and they were the major civil society group working on supporting the court at the UN. Bill Pace, you probably remember him. Bill Pace was a terrific guy. And he came up to meet with me about maybe just about seven or eight weeks after we did the landmine treaty. And we had employed, as you might recall, What I call the Amway form of diplomacy. We just knocked on everybody's door until they got tired of us. And Bill came up and said, look, can the Canadian government do the same thing on the UN?

Because we're flagging support out there. We've got all this stuff at New York and Geneva. So we did. And I was in very close touch with Madeleine Albright about it. Who personally thought the court was the right idea. And she claimed that even Clinton did. But they had Jesse Helms and all that crowd in the Senate who were going to sort of cut their budgets if they did it. And the Pentagon has a huge voice in all these decisions. But nevertheless, I remember the night of the vote. We were in Rome. And, you know, Philip Kirsch was the chair of the committee. I mean, Canada really had a lot of fingerprints on the court. And I got a call from Madeleine.

She said, I just want to call and commiserate. I said, about what? She said, well, I've just heard from our delegation that, you know, the whole thing's going down the tube. And I said, Madeleine, I have one asset that State Department officials don't have. I've been in seven elections, and I know how to count. And I said, we're going to win this thing, overwhelmingly. And she said, no, well. And I said, well, man. I said, we'll see what happens six hours from now. And she did call me up to say, you were right. To me, it's one of those examples that we have to keep coming back to. I know Mark Carney doesn't like to do nostalgia things.

But we've had some successes in making things work and making things happen. And I think the ICC, I mean, I go back to, you know, the great debate between Ladropak and sort of the other guy from Ukraine who really did develop from the grassroots basis a genocide convention And that the International Criminal Court, which has been talked about since the 1920s, we finally got to do. Why is this American thing? Because I really think that there is a basic fundamental is that they do not want to have any restraint on their power to do things, whether it's good or bad. But they've now turned it into a kind of sort of malevolent thing.

And using lying, I mean, Ruby gets up and said, oh my God, we're not going to have some U.S. private in Sudan sort of, well, there's nothing in the court that says that. So I feel that in some ways, this is a really nefarious issue. I also have to say this, that Canada has been absolutely missing in action. In coming to grips with it. We don't condemn it. We don't talk about it. We don't even support our own justices. And I think, you know, we owe that to some of the, there was a guy in Global Affairs, Doug, you probably remember, Kessel, who was anti-court and all that kind of stuff.

I mean, it was not a universally-like project when we did it in Foreign Affairs. But I think we're at that stage where Canada is just keeping quiet because it doesn't want to upset the idiot box. And as a result, I think we're losing a lot of recognition and respect for ducking behind the corridor panels and not being able to. I don't mean to say we have to be on the barricade. But surely to God, when a Canadian judge of the International Court is being sanctioned, having her credit cards taken away, can't stay in hotels, that American underground financial system that they manage, and they're using it, basically, I said, to make the war safe for workers.

Speaker 1 29:44

Yeah. And it's part of a general retreat from following rules or following norms. You wrote, I just wrote it down, if the world's most powerful democracy can cripple a tribunal that never joined by threatening everyone who cooperates with it, Then the rules become an a la carte menu, binding when convenient, discarded when not. That was with you and Alan Rock wrote that. So that seems to be a widespread phenomenon. And how do we counter that? And in a sense, I suppose, how do ordinary people watching this video and being frustrated counter it? Hmm.

Speaker 3 30:32

There's always been a tension, even among the more ardent supporting countries of the court of the ICC. Between branches of foreign ministries that are trying to resolve conflicts diplomatically or through other forceful means and those that are pursuing international justice. Now, this tension doesn't really apply in the case of the United States because they don't want any of it.

I would say some of the tensions around the ICC have, I mean, I've certainly heard cases 20, 25, 30 years ago where you would hear people in one branch of Foreign Affairs say, oh, upon learning that there was an ICC prosecution against some African autocrat would say, oh, hell, now that we're prosecuting him, he's going to stay in office forever rather than step down and stop what he's doing. There was always sort of an incomplete project in international justice in reconciling it against other forms of conflict. Do you want justice or do you want peace was always the question that had to be asked about any initiative to prosecute.

However, I think you're right in saying that at this point, what's coming from the United States and other powers is the answer is neither. Thank you very much.

Speaker 1 32:06

Just to comment on that, Doug, the only time there's a conflict between justice and peace is when you don't have a police force. If you have a police force and you're in a city and the criminal is holding a bunch of hostages, there's no conflict.

Speaker 3 32:22

Yeah, but assassination doesn't tend to work so well as an alternative to justice, you know, when it comes to heads of state.

Speaker 1 32:31

No, I just mean that the sovereign state system prevents that, you know, it creates this conflict between peace and justice.

Speaker 2 32:43

Barry, not exactly, because… You know, the corollary to the court is the whole concept of the universal jurisdiction, which was used in the Pinochet case, where Spain said that they brought, once he showed up in London, a case against him for the support he was giving in the killing of Spanish people in Chile at the time. And so we've never, Canada's never really used universal jurisdiction, but there is that under, that's a much longer existing kind of legal standard and norm. But where the court added is that it put a little bit of an infrastructure on top of it, but it also set some very important rules. And recently, I mean, The court is a victim of its own sort of mistakes.

I mean, this whole business around calling the prosecutor should have been dealt with years ago. I mean, and so there's no question it's an unwieldy organization right now. But what's not happening is something that some of us were really pushed for very hard. And we only got one result of it, and that is that the court could be kind of a mother ship and use that to help sort of do kind of hybrid courts between local justice systems and the international justice system. Sierra Leone was one places where there was that hybrid court.

Speaker 3 34:30

Yes, and that worked well, yes.

Speaker 2 34:31

And it worked well, that's right. So it itself has not shown a lot of imagination, but it is investigating. They brought the guy, the Sudanese guy, to court, and he's been judged, I mean, step by step. But like everything else internationally, you have to have champions to keep it going. And the problem is the champions like Canada Again, sitting on the curb. We're not in the game anymore. It really makes me distraught to think that for reasons that really don't hold true, even if you're a real politician, one thing we learned is that if you can assemble, as we did with the landmine, we brought You know, 150 countries to Ottawa for three weeks, and we got to know a lot of people.

We established all kinds of trade, economic, cultural connections that we dined off of for a decade or so, because we were able to initiate an international agreement on something. We're not doing that any now. I mean, we're simply… Everything is seen through the proxy of a willy loom.

Speaker 3 35:58

Are there significant counterparty countries, Lloyd, European countries, other G7 countries, that would want us to step back into these roles, that are looking for partners and coalitions to further international justice, nonproliferation, things like this?

Speaker 2 36:20

Yeah, I think there's governments, there's also civil society groups, there's also law schools, places like that. We used to be sort of the standard in many cases. By the way, our law school system at one time was a huge sort of incubator For good international ideas, laws of the sea, the ozone zone. I mean, Brian Maloney's stuff on APARTA, we've created international law. We don't do it anymore. And partly because the government doesn't support it anymore. But to go back to your question, for example, there is a very strong inkling in certain some of the Nordic states.

I share this with you, but last year, In the Norwegian Parliament, the Storting, the government tabled a 30-page report on Norway's role for peacemaking in a troubled world. And I've talked to people like Kurt and Baller, others who I know there, and they said, they're waiting for Canada to step up because they're very concerned about the Arctic and the fact that it's going to become an American strategic military zone. And as a result, all that work that's gone into keeping it fairly peaceful is going to disappear. Yeah, but one thing that we did, because we were a G7 country, we had a lot of smart people in our foreign affairs departments, and we had political support, which is absolutely essential.

Canadians liked the idea that we would do good things internationally. They liked peacekeeping. They liked the international treaty on the landmines. They liked the protection of women. And the fact that we basically disbanded all that means there isn't much—we're now providing our identity about how we don't drink American wine. Well, there was a time we also said we don't buy into an American sort of imperialism, to use that word first.

Speaker 3 38:40

Right. And when people decided not to lay landmines, it was the Ottawa Treaty.

Speaker 2 38:45

The Ottawa Treaty, that's what it's

Speaker 3 38:46

called.

Speaker 1 38:46

Yeah, you're right. And the norms for that have extended beyond that. To the United States has accepted that norm to it. Even though they're not signatory. That's right. To a certain extent, yeah. And we could talk also about peacekeeping, which of course, as you mentioned just now, Canada has just, I think, last month withdrawn its final peacekeeping. Yes, it did.

Speaker 2 39:12

Another occasion in 10 minutes, and I need to prepare for you a little bit. It's another railway discussion I have to get into.

Speaker 1 39:20

Oh, yeah. The Hudson…

Speaker 2 39:23

No, I've been chairing a rail study for the Premier of Manitoba on rail relocation. And we just came out two weeks ago with a major proposal for doing a rail bypass around Winnipeg using a hydro corridor. We eliminated all the hoops and jumps of having to expropriate. 95% of the land is now publicly owned to do a bypass.

Speaker 3 39:48

Can we bring Wob out to Ontario to… Yeah.

Speaker 2 39:52

Offer some advice. Hey, you watch this guy. He is a superb politician with a very… I think the fact he has a grounding in indigenous cultures makes him a very different kind of guy to deal with. I just want to…

Speaker 1 40:12

If I can just finish up with a very broad question, just to get your comment on it, because you mentioned Louis Saint Laurent back in the day, not signing on to being a nuclear weapons state, but he also believed in the international control. I've just made a couple of very short films about this weird period in 1945 when the atomic scientists led by people like Oppenheim and Einstein actually had this idea that the United States would give up the most powerful weapon in history to an international body. And out of that period also came this, well, the world Federalists and this idea that you could have some kind of actual government for the planet.

Those ideas seem about as far away as the land of Oz right now. But is there any, since you were actually involved in that movement to some extent, is there any possibility of dreaming about, in any realistic way, of any kind of… When we get beyond this stage, assuming we do, this difficult period of conceiving of other forms of governance or larger forms of governance and cooperation for this planet.

Speaker 2 41:32

Yes. Will it happen? I hate to sound sort of, you know, kind of too much of an ingenue or something, but I'm hoping there's a lot of young men and women out there who are looking for something different, and we're not being given it very much. There's not a lot of respect for the political system anymore. We don't have really good political leaders. By that, I don't mean visionaries on the barricades, but I mean Jean Chrétien, who was able to kind of stitch together In the Liberal Party, a liberal progressive wing, a centrist wing, a business wing, we all knew that we could win some, we could lose some, but it wasn't win or take all.

And since the neoliberal stuff came in, increasingly it's polarized, and now we have a Liberal Party, which is no way Jose if you're a progressive, you're just not involved. And so I think there's going to have to be some shifting politically, and I think it's going to happen, because I'm not sure of the present system. I mean, you can't have a country governed by a right of center government and a far right opposition and the other parties. So weak that they can't really provide any leverage. And I don't know how that can happen. But I think there is some serious thinking going on. I mean, the whole issue of governance around the climate issue.

I mean, they're And the fact that Europe was burning up this year and will burn up even more in next year, that we've got forest fires, other control every single year, that eventually people are going to say, we've got to provide some really good. And in a strange way, Trump's done us a favor on the Iran homeless thing because it's making it They care that the fossil fuel system is expensive, it's faulty, and it's vulnerable. Now, how are you going to govern that? Barry, I think, Let's get some Canadians and get some Europeans and let's get some people from Brazil and the Americas and some Americans themselves to talk about how would you do that in a way that isn't sort of top-heavy institutional.

I mean, I think that's the one thing that we end up with the UN that is top-heavy. As opposed to having more flexibility and stuff. And, you know, we use the word confederations and stuff like that. I think we have nearly explored the capacity for various forms of sort of cooperative, collective governance internationally. We've been stuck by kind of a European model that came out of the 20s and 30s and so on. And I think there is a lot of, Space that we now have to look at. And the world federalist should be one of the people who are leading that intellectual exploration.

Speaker 1 44:53

A coalition of willing people and willing places to solve

Speaker 2 44:59

global problems.

Speaker 1 45:01

Listen, thank you very much. Doug, any final comments?

Speaker 3 45:07

No, I'll leave it at those inspiring words or at least not as depressing as they could be under the circumstances. Maybe that's the title. Lloyd, I hope that some of your Dismay at the current state of Canadian politics is an observation of its state during a national emergency and that your party is doing things out of contingency in a national emergency setting rather than has drifted out of its old traditions in a more fundamental way.

Speaker 2 45:51

You know, the thing is that there has been a isolation. I mean, if you look at what's happened since Carney came in, the liberal wing of the party has been, it's not just that it's been isolated, I mean, Friedland's out there doing something, sort of, you've got sort of, Kareem Goulds, who's sort of, they're all, I mean, all of us are out on the outskirts. But I think that they're, But Carnia hasn't quite hit the cement blocks yet, which is going to do if you keep trying to push the pipelines and stuff through indigenous lands and all this stuff. There's going to be a slow re-emerging. You give it to, I mean, but I think, you know, I have the, maybe the sort of…

The sense that it's up to sort of old fogey liberals like me to try to keep the ideas alive while we're going through this period of, as you say, of national emergency.

Speaker 3 46:55

Lloyd, I think you do have to do, you need to get the train back on its track.

Speaker 1 46:59

Thank you, Lloyd, and thank you, Doug.

Speaker 3 47:01

Thank you very much.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments