Episode 787 Old Sociologists

Notes

This episode features Louis Kriesberg and Metta Spencer discussing their studies on war, conflict, and preventing violent disasters.

Guests

  • Louis Kriesberg
  • Metta Spencer

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

sociology, peace, old, studies, Chicago, conflict, University, war, research, wanted, books, social, Parsons, program, students, book, Columbia, department, independent, Syracuse

SPEAKERS

Louis Kriesberg, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Episode 787 of Project Save the World, titled "Old Sociologists," features host Metta Spencer, who is 95, and guest Louis Kriesberg, who is 100, in a conversation about sociology, war, and peace. Spencer opened by recalling their long acquaintance and her own doubts about where sociology has gone. Kriesberg described growing up in Chicago after his parents fled Tsarist Russia, becoming fascinated by the violence of the 1930s, and falling in love with sociology at the University of Chicago while looking for ways to stop war. He recounted an instructorship at Columbia, a Fulbright study of the European coal and steel industry as a route to reconciliation between Germany and France, and later work at Syracuse on civil rights, feminism, and social conflict, which led to his 1986 book Constructive Conflicts.

Read more…

The two compared the theoretical traditions of Chicago and Columbia. Kriesberg said Chicago emphasized fieldwork and understanding people's perspectives, while Columbia followed a Harvard-style approach of making categories, which he found ridiculous. Spencer added that Chicago was a breeding ground for American sociology, that Herbert Blumer carried George Herbert Mead's legacy at Berkeley, and that Merton was a good theorist while Parsons loved inventing categories. Kriesberg said graduate students secretly read Parsons but thought him silly. They then turned to sociology's declining status. Spencer said sociologists no longer appear on panels, that she could no longer find books she wanted at convention exhibits, and that communication and cultural studies have absorbed material that once belonged to sociology.

Kriesberg described how conflict research met resistance, beginning with Vietnam War protests and a committee in the American Sociological Association that eventually became a group. He said the field of conflict resolution partly arose because some researchers avoided the word peace, which communists had used. Spencer said she created a Peace and Conflict Studies program at the University of Toronto, which she ran for thirteen years, and that political scientists resisted it. Kriesberg described Hewlett Foundation funding for conflict resolution centers and a nonviolence program at Syracuse. Both lamented the state of the U.S. Institute of Peace under the Trump administration, and Spencer asked whether it had reopened.

Spencer said peace studies graduates rarely became activists and that young people do not want to join organizations run by older people, so she had come to believe recruitment should wait until they are about 65. Kriesberg argued that nonviolent resistance to the MAGA movement is growing in the United States, with trained local groups able to mobilize large demonstrations. Spencer asked whether sociology could become more actionable, and Kriesberg said he was a little optimistic. Spencer said she hoped sociology would change course, and the two ended by joking about their friendship, her naming him her successor on an old book series, and the pleasures of being 100.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:00

Hi, I'm Metta Spencer. And boy, am I going to do something different than you're expecting because I've never done this before. I was sitting here kind of feeling sorry for myself a while ago because I tried so hard to get somebody to be on my show this week. And I used to be able to do five shows a week and I can't even do one sometimes. And this is one of those weeks. So here I was. Kind of thinking, you know, okay, I'm really over the hill. I can't do it anymore.

When the phone rings, and here is another old person, and he has more reason to think he's over the hill than I do, because I am now 95 years old, and he is 100 years old. And how many old people do you know have made it to 100? And… What are they like? Well, now, if you have, this is a show for people who are experimental and willing to watch something that I have no idea what's going to come out of this conversation. But if you are willing to consider thinking about what it's going to be like to be 95 or 100 years old, you've come to the right place because we're going to tell you.

And we're actually going to reveal it Because if I had to explain what it's like, I wouldn't get it right for even myself probably because some days I'm very different from others. And I sure wouldn't get it right for all of my viewers because some people think I'm one way and some people think I'm very different. But I think that Louis Kriesberg is the same way all the time. I mean, he looks like and acts like the guy I knew. Oh, what was it? When did we meet? 40 years ago, Lou? At least. At least. Well, maybe more. Could be more. Anyway, he is a sociologist, and I used to be. I don't know whether I want to claim to be anymore for various reasons.

I don't think like a sociologist, maybe, and I don't like the way sociology has turned. I think it's kind of going to the dogs, and that's what you expect old people to say, that they're The world is going to the dogs, and it was much better when we were young. But this time, I think everybody would agree with us. Things were better 50, 60 years ago in so many ways than today. And we're all worried about and trying to figure out why we have these right-wing movements around the world and why we can't even stop climate change when we know Various things that would work to stop it, but we can't make it happen.

And why AI is already trying to, what's it trying to do, kill us all? I don't know. But it's going to do it if we don't watch out. So everybody agrees that we're really in trouble now. And only Lou and I can tell you what's gone wrong, because we know, right? Right. So what do you think's gone wrong, Lou? Tell me a little bit about your own history. See, the thing is, I met Lou, I don't know whether this was right after we met or what, but we were both sociologists and we were both interested in the sociology of conflict and war and peace and that kind of thing.

I was really into the disarmament movement of the 80s and doing a lot of work on that. And I started a program in Peace and Conflict Studies at my campus for the University of Toronto. And I wrote a textbook in which I think I was probably a leader in doing this because I'm not sure other people have done it since, but I created a chapter on war, war and peace. And I think for an introductory sociology textbook, that was probably an early An early invention, wasn't it, Lou? Wasn't I kind of a leader? Yeah, I think so. Yeah. Okay, so Lou was already the editor of a series of books, compilations of articles that one was on Russia and Eastern Europe. And…

So he wanted a vacation or something, and he said, would you like to do the editing of this series? And I thought, I don't know anything about it. Sure, okay. And then I became the editor of the series and had a good time doing it until one of the editors, one of the people who wanted to be part of the team of editing a certain issue was, Stole all the manuscripts from me. Can you believe it? A sociology professor stole the manuscripts from me and published them in her own name. And I wrote to the company and they didn't do anything about it. I was too busy to do it, but I did stop the editing. I didn't do it after that.

So that was the first crooked sociologist I ever met. Luke, start off and tell me a little about your history. I don't know what you were like when you were young. I think you were already white-haired when I met you.

Speaker 2 6:22

Well, it's a simple story for me at the beginning. My parents fled Tsarist, Russia, and I grew up in Chicago, obsessed by the terrible violence that I saw everywhere, in Spain, in China, with the Japanese and Asian. I listened to Hitler on the radio. I was fascinated and made collections of scrapbooks of the horrors of war. There was a chewing gum card collection that you could make on the horrors of war. Really? And this was something that I just was obsessed with. And I, for some unknown reason, I felt that I had to do something about this. It was an obligation.

Speaker 1 7:53

And at the same time… Now, what years are we talking about? This was when you were a child or in high school? I was a child.

Speaker 2 8:05

I was still… Early years of high school, that at the same time, I was considered to be a very good artist. And I thought I was an artist. And I practiced that. But at the same time, I started to go to college at the University of Chicago. I was going not for art, because that I had done in Mexico already, but because I wanted to know how I could stop the madness. I thought, I'll learn. And while I was in college, which was very fasted in Chicago, I fell in love with sociology.

Speaker 1 9:19

Well, now that is the place to have been, because probably, and I don't know what years you're talking about, but the University of Chicago was mecca for sociology. And it was really the breeding ground for sociology. Most of American original changes and developments. And I think sociology largely did develop in the U.S. So it was the U of Chicago that really started a lot.

Speaker 2 9:53

Yes. Well, the interesting thing also, we were sure that our sociology was sociology. And… I tried even in the master's thesis or writing a dissertation to make some adoption that was relevant to the problem of war. And I graduated, and I moved to, my first job was at the Columbia University, which was the other great university of sociology. But they had very different theories, which we at Chicago thought were nonsense. But I was an instructor now at Columbia.

Speaker 1 11:05

Hold on, because you said something that made me start trying to recall. I'm trying to think of how Columbia differed in theory, in their theoretical approach, from Chicago. Chicago was a place for George Herbert Mead and people who wanted to do Participant observation, that kind of in-person, trying to understand through empathy and so on, role-taking, as we called it. And I think of Chicago as a place where really survey research developed. I don't know. I'm trying to recall where you would have identified somebody there who had a different theoretical approach. How would you say Chicago differed theoretically?

Speaker 2 12:00

Well, there was demography was strong, but also what you were describing. Fieldwork, observation, get a feeling for the perspective of the people you're studying. And we regarded what was going on at Columbia was an offspring from Harvard And the idea was to make categories and names of different things. And we thought that was so ridiculous.

Speaker 1 12:50

Well, you know, that would have been certainly Pitterim, I think. And then, of course, Parsons, the Parsonian approach. Yes. Yeah, and I remember being obliged to read The Structure of Social Action, which was quite an embracing ordeal. But there were people in Berkeley. I was a student in Berkeley. And we had sort of that kind of cleavage within the sociology faculty as well, because Herbert Bloomer, of course, was the great acolyte of George Herbert Mead. And definitely was persuading us that we had to take the role of the other and we had to interact with ourselves and so on.

But they didn't have much use for Parsons until, of course, Neil Swelzer came along and he had been a student of Parsons and I think even had written some things with Parsons as a very young man. So, yeah, there were certainly differences of opinion among the sociology faculty, and it might have sort of reflected this difference between Columbia and the University of Chicago. But by the time I got there, Berkeley was the mecca, you know, like George Herbert Mead had his day and had passed on, but Herbert Bloomer had He obviously was wearing the mantle of George Herbert Mead or trying to. And really, he built the sociology department in Berkeley in the first decade or so.

When he came, he made it into quite a stunning center for sociology.

Speaker 2 14:45

Well, you know, her room was at Chicago before he went to Berkeley. And I remember very clearly the classes of Bloomer holding up a chair with one hand. He was a football player also. Showing that, is this a chair? If you're not sitting on it, nobody's sitting on it. Anyway, it was… These were little clubs of fighters. We, as the graduate students, wouldn't read Parsons, but as graduate students, some of us would read it under the table, but we thought it was silly. At Columbia, that was esteemed, and Merton and Lazarus Feld were the voices. Merton was extremely clever in his speech. He worked very diligently. Anyway, Well,

Speaker 1 16:09

actually, that's interesting that you mentioned Merton because I was asking, now, who would have been a theorist at Columbia? Of course, it would have been Merton. Merton was the – and I think he was a good theorist, really. I thought he – I wouldn't put him in the same category as Parsons, who loved to invent categories and things. You're right. Although even Parsons sometimes produced something – Worth reading.

I once, you know, I edited a textbook by taking all the books in the series that Prentice Hall had published, little black thin books on different topics, like about 15 different books on, you know, one would be on, you know, deviance and one on, well, one of them was on something like the sociology of law or something like that. It wasn't quite the title, but that was, Had been written by Parsons. It was quite a readable book, quite an interesting book. So I think Parsons could have been forgiven for a lot of his weaknesses.

Speaker 2 17:21

For me, this was all not the point. I wanted to know how to stop goddamn wars. And… As an instructor, I tried to find some research working on that was relevant to that. My boss wasn't interested in this sort of thing. I was a lousy teacher because I never had any experience teaching, but I also was I had an interest that was not jibing with them, and my three-year contract was not renewed. I fortunately got a Fulbright to do research and I chose, what gave me that was a study of the coal and steel industry in Europe and wanted to see whether that organization It meant contribute to reconciliation between Germany and France.

So I had a year in Cologne interviewing People in the coal and steel industry. And indeed, there were features of that structure which were conducive to shared interests and reconciliation.

Speaker 1 19:25

Well, hell, it became the basis of the EU in a way. I mean, am I exaggerating? That organization?

Speaker 2 19:39

I was delighted. I drove all over Europe. I did the research that I thought was relevant. I had a postdoc back at Chicago. I wrote my Three articles. I wanted to write a book, but I realized somebody else had already written that book. What? What do you mean? On the coal and steel community. But I was sort of stuck and I ended up taking a job at Chicago at National Opinion Research Center. I think that would give me some compensation for while I learned more that would be useful. And after four years there, I had a family and two sons, babies. And I was told by the rough director, you have no future here.

Speaker 1 21:13

Well, look, I mean, if you were trained as a, You know, symbolic interactionist. And then you tried to switch to survey research. There's a gap there. And I can understand why he might have some doubt about whether anybody could leap from one to the other.

Speaker 2 21:34

Yeah, but it was something I didn't want to spend my, you know, studies on medical conditions and dentistry. I was happy to leave. My wife was not wanting to leave Chicago, but… We left, and I came to Syracuse. And at Syracuse, there was great activism. The civil rights struggle was underway. There was housing issues. I and other faculty members participated. We did civil rights demonstrations. The women's movement sprang up and we had, my wife convinced me to be a feminist, which I became, and the leader A former national leader of now was a local leader in Syracuse and a good friend.

And I would go to the now meetings and there was all the struggles that I might want to address were And it didn't directly deal with war, but I had begun to shift as my way of making sociology relevant for war Social conflict is an important field of activity. And so I began writing about social conflict as a way of sneaking in for me The way of fighting for peace that sociology was neglecting. And soon I recognized that there were other people. There were peace studies. There were other people who shared this interest. And thereon, I always was doing the research relating to social conflict and how violence could be reduced. And I wrote books step by step. And you edited a lot of books.

Actually, once I had the number of journal articles and books, I felt pretty confident that I was onto something. I published, it came out in 1986, a book called Constructive Conflicts. And this was my way of slipping in how sociology was relevant for all kinds of conflicts, including wars and violence. And the books flowed thereafter.

Speaker 1 26:18

I'm trying to visualize our timetables. You know, when were you at what stage of development? I know that we began meeting in sociology meetings, sometimes at the ASA, American Sociological Association meetings, which had a section on War or Conflict, I don't remember what it was titled. It was a very good section, and some of the papers there were terrific. I don't know how well they're functioning now. I haven't been to a sociology convention in 20 years, I don't know, a long time. And so I don't know what they're going through. But I do know that there's certainly… I think has been a loss of status for sociology in a number of ways.

I remember, you know, one of my first jobs was working for Seymour Martin Lipset right after he wrote Political Man. I think he was writing another one on The First New Nation or something like that. And I worked for him that summer. And at that time, you know, it was… If you had a TV show or broadcast or radio or a panel discussion, a lot of times we did actual physical meetings. People actually went to an auditorium and sat in a chair to listen to people. And if there was a panel discussion, for sure, you'd have at least one sociologist on it. Well, that's not true anymore.

And I'm not quite sure how it has happened, but I think sociology is not as interesting and is not regarded as important as it used to be. And I think it may be partly because, well, for one thing, they do so much quantification and everything gets to be mathematical. And, you know, that sort of thing, which, you know, I don't know, that's all right, but that's not what I wanted to do. But mostly, there are other fields that have come up, you know, communication studies, or cultural studies, things like that. I don't know why they needed a separate department, but they do. They are now, I would say, communication studies in a university is probably… Bigger on the average now than a sociology department.

Would you guess at that? I don't know. I'm making this up. It's probably not true. But am I onto something? Or do you see another reason for this strange decline? I mean, when I stopped going to conventions, it was because there's nothing I wanted to hear. And I would go to the book exhibits where you could buy or order books. And I used to go home with a whole suitcase full of books from a convention. But toward the end, I got so I could walk through the whole book exhibit and not see anything I wanted to take home. So, you know, that's not a good sign. What do you think's happened to sociology? Totally.

Speaker 2 29:50

I would step a little bit earlier in the history. Incidentally, I was a good friend of Marty Lipset and a colleague of his and a wonderful guy, brilliant. I love to tell stories about him, but the- Who was your friend who knew him? Who was your friend? But I think it's interesting that the move to do conflict sort of work was resisted. The beginning was the demonstrations against the war in Vietnam and the Some of the members of the association said, we have to make a resolution about that. And the authorities said, no, no, that's not for us. And they compromised by setting up a committee, of which I was a member of. And there were, Elise was a leader of it.

And after three years, they said, you have to be a group or nothing. And so we chose to become a group. But that was by a small segment then of the association that began to deal more directly with social issues and contentions. So it wasn't at the birth of sociology, administrators and leaders. It was a faction of that group and gradually, you know, other things came up. We had a study, a new society for the study of social problems. Maybe because that we would honestly deal with problems. I was president of it for one year and it was the attitudes were quite different and it remains smaller. Interesting. So the slippage Was from positions which never were very radical in thought.

Speaker 1 33:05

Okay, that's fair enough. And in fact, I think I'm realizing now that you occupied a much more strategic position in those days than I did. I don't think I was ever on the board or an officer or decision maker in any of these positions. Steps along the slippage route. Because if you had to build this new organization, I wasn't in on that. I would come and give papers maybe, but I don't think I was ever one of the decision makers as you were. So would you now… Give a critique of what went wrong, if you even think that it went wrong.

I mean, I guess we both say that sociology would be a more interesting field now if we did focus more on problem solving, you know, trying to find solutions to social problems. And that's exactly what I do with my own, you know, little outfit here, this problem. Project Save the World is just focused on disasters that might come and wipe out a billion people or so and what we can do that might help prevent it. And you show up every so often for one of our global town halls and help straighten us out.

Speaker 2 34:38

Well, what also happened was the creation of a new project Social research field, what was casually called a conflict resolution because the people in Michigan who were looking for a name were afraid to use the word peace. Seriously. Oh, sure. Peace was being used by the communists. And to avoid being thought that they were commies, they would have not used the word peace.

Speaker 1 35:24

It didn't happen just in sociology. That was also, I still get it. I still get friends who like what we're doing in terms of actual empirical argumentation and research, but who say, well, just not use that word peace. And, you know, and they're good people, and they're not sociologists. They're, you know, journalists or whatever, and they don't like that word. I understand that.

Speaker 2 35:55

Well, that, I think, did melt away. So some of the journals began using the word peace and people did. I think in Europe, it was the same thing. In France, they didn't want to use the word war or peace because that was communists also. But in the States, I think that became mute. But by then, there were peace research associations. People were getting to offer degrees in what was called conflict resolution for a while. And so sociology was robbed in a way of some of that kind of work because it was being taken over by this new field.

Speaker 1 37:08

Well, I mean, that's what I was complaining about when I said that communication studies and cultural studies and things like that have kind of swallowed up all of the Material that would, you know, would have been sociology earlier. And you're right, peace studies did become more or less an independent discipline. And I kind of think… I mean, all of this, it isn't just fake that we had to worry about the communists using this word because they did. All of the communists in North America and I guess around the world had these peace councils and they would claim that they were the peace people and we were not.

And so that did carry some impact on And then I started, I formed a Peace and Conflict Studies program at the campus of the University of Toronto. And I ran it for 13 years until I retired. And then I kept on teaching some of the courses that I had created. One was on nonviolence and negotiation, you know, a fourth year course and so on, seminars. So I kept on doing that, but it was an independent interdisciplinary program. So I'd get people from the philosophy department and the history department and whatever. The only people who didn't want to have anything to do with it were political scientists.

They felt we, you know, I was encroaching on their territory because what the hell does this woman know about politics, right? We're the political scientists.

Speaker 2 38:54

Okay. And then came the Hewlett Foundation. The Hewlett Foundation put up money establish Conflict Resolution Centers to Build Theory. And they gave the first one to Harvard because as one of the guys who was our mentor in the relations with the Hewlett, something will come out of it if it goes to Harvard. But Harvard's interest in it was taken over by somebody in the law school who would make it a study of negotiation. But in other places, like Syracuse, we… Did it on conflict resolution with the idea that it would cover international conflicts as well as domestic conflicts. We got, in 1986, we got a grant. There already were five or six centers, and we were supposed to do whatever we wanted to do.

What did you wind up doing? Well, what we ended up doing was studying nonviolent ways in which conflict could be conducted effectively and with some benefits. And it became very easy… Uniquely, I think, in Syracuse, when the students took over the campuses, again, because of the Kent State grotesque of students, the students in Syracuse said, teach us nonviolence. And two years later, And they hired somebody who set up a program on nonviolence, which then gave a part of the width that got us a contract, a grant from the Hewlett Foundation. And so I think we were doing what I liked and what I thought Needed to be done. I was in heaven.

Speaker 1 42:14

Yeah, yeah. Well, what's happening there now? I mean, have you seen, you know, when I retired, they closed the program that I had created at my campus, University of Toronto. And I didn't mind because I knew that if, If they tried to keep it going and replaced me, they would have just hired somebody who didn't necessarily know anything about peace studies. And I'd rather have it not exist than not be a good program. So I was, you know, content to have it closed. There are still programs going in around here. One, the main campus of University of Toronto, which I never had any contact with. Somehow we were very separate projects.

And then there's another one big at Conrad Grebel College at the University of Waterloo.

Speaker 2 43:15

They give degrees in- In Manitoba?

Speaker 1 43:20

No, here in Waterloo, Ontario. It's an hour's drive from here.

Speaker 2 43:27

University of Manitoba?

Speaker 1 43:32

No, there is one in Manitoba, yeah. Yes, there is. It's happening. But in general, I think the peace studies movement, you know, trying to expand and develop it into a real profession or an academic field, I think that has not stopped, but I don't think it's booming anymore, right?

Speaker 2 44:00

Well, I don't… I think… It's expanded so that it exists, but not maybe as boldly or as centrally. At the great beginning, like the two Programs in Manitoba where the staff by people graduated from Syracuse. And there were centers built in many other places. They had an attraction to students from other countries. There are also non-academic centers. Search for Common Grounds is a big industry of conflict resolution work. Yes. And it's totally independent.

Speaker 1 45:13

And Peter Ackerman had a wonderful program going, right? A few blocks from the White House on top of one of those highfalutin towers. But if he's passed on, and I don't know how much it's doing these days, I think they have moved. They moved someplace over close to the Institute for Peace, which, by the way, the fact that Trump is in power and has been able to really almost, I guess, really shut down the U.S. Institute of Peace… I took a course there once just to look the place over. I thought it was doing good stuff. Not everything, maybe, but I enjoyed being there, and I thought it was a real contribution.

But they say now, or at least last I heard, there are rats running around the place because it was shut down. I mean, Trump managed to cut it down. I don't know. Has it been reopened, and do you know whether it's functioning?

Speaker 2 46:20

I don't think it was reopened. It was a very important center for many years, really linking together the academic with the State Department stuff. It always was somewhat State Department-y, but it did do training and research for more nonviolent processes in major international conflicts. Some people were critical, saying, well, it was too much State Department. But it was a good bridge. And it is outrageous, well, among all the other outrageous things that Trump has done.

Speaker 1 47:27

By the way, when I said that, I thought that the… Peace education, independent movement within academia is slipping. I didn't mean specifically Manitoba. I really don't know that much about the Manitoba program, but I think overall it's not booming the way it was in, let's say, the 80s. That worldwide, there were many, many people wanting to get degrees, even PhDs in peace. And I thought that was terrific while it lasted. But, you know, Johann Galton always wanted to have that be independent of academia somehow. That peace studies should… They have its own program separate from universities. And they started, he and this other fellow, wonderful guy, I can't remember his name, started Peace University independently. But, you know, now he's passed on.

Introduce me to Paula. Yeah, Paula. Hello, Paula.

Metta Spencer 48:51

Hi.

Speaker 1 48:52

Hi. I don't know much about you. Tell me about yourself. You're an academic, too, aren't you?

Speaker 4 48:59

I'll just hang back from grocery shopping. I can't do it right now.

Speaker 1 49:02

Aren't you an academic?

Speaker 2 49:06

No, she's not. But her husband had been the chair of anthropology, so she knows that world very well. I see.

Speaker 1 49:22

Blue. This has been a really fun thing to do. Do you have any further advice about it? You know, by the way, when it comes to Peace Studies students, I have to say don't think that it's turning them into activists. And I do see that there's, you know, I think the gap between advocacy and promotion of a particular value like peace is a perfectly legitimate part of academic work. But my feeling is that the What I did, teaching peace studies, did not do much for promoting peace. And that is, I probably taught several thousand students. And I don't think more than two or three of them ever became peace activists or engaged in any major…

Campaign for any kind of social reform or development or advocacy. And I could easily blame myself because I didn't try to make them into flaming radical activists, but I did think that they would be interested in organizations that were NGOs that were working on those issues, and they never were. But now I've come to see it probably isn't something that we should have expected or I should have expected, because these were young people. Young people are at a stage in their lives when they want to be independent, and they should be. They're becoming independent, and they are to some extent. But they do not want to join NGOs run by old people. And old people keep trying to get them.

All the organizations that I know of, the old people keep saying, we've got to recruit some young members. Well, why? Leave them alone. They want to do it on their own. And when there's an issue that does capture their attention and their concern, they will do it on their own. For example, I remember back in the time when the first Gulf War took place, you know, the Iraq War and all the bombing and stuff. And I had this Peace Studies Resource Center and hardly anybody had been coming in there. But they then made that resource center into the place where they would hold their meetings to set up. You know, rallies.

And they would independently set up student rallies in the main halls of the college, or meaning open places where they could have a thousand people. So I think the thing is, that's, you know, when they're 20 years old or so, is the wrong time to try to get them into Peace organizations that are already existing and run by old people, they want to do it on their own and they should if they're going to do it at all. And mostly they don't do it very long because they're trying to get on the ladder and then they're about to get married and then they're going to have a family and then they're going to have mortgages to pay off and all of that stuff.

So they're not going to be ready. So what you need to do is just wait because they get old, as we can attest. They will get old and when they get to be 65, that's when you want to go and recruit them because old people already still know a few things and can do useful things. And then they're really ready because they're retiring and they want something to to fill their time and an NGO is just the right thing. So most NGOs that I know of are run by old people and consist of old people. And I would not recommend even trying very hard to recruit young people into our organizations.

I think they will do it themselves when they have the right time of life with the right opportunities and the right concerns. So they'll do it for themselves. So that is kind of the piece I've made with myself, kind of forgiving myself for not having really created a whole new generation of red-hot anti-war campaigners and so on. What do you think?

Speaker 2 54:43

Well, I think in the United States, there is a Particular circumstance such that the ideas of nonviolence and resistance and social change is growing as a form of resistance to the MAGA movement There are trainings, demonstrations, There are small groups, local groups, that are organized to resist what Trump is trying to do for his own glory and wealth. And some of that is… Nationally coordinated as well. But they could have millions demonstrating without a broken window. They've been trained in disciplines how to do mass demonstrations. They know how to mobilize the neighborhood. All this concern about, oh, Some of the Republicans are getting worried about the re-election. Well, they have good reason.

But that is partly using the skills and the techniques and the idea of collective action, cooperation, resisting no less.

Speaker 1 56:49

Anyway, we've covered the waterfront here, and I think there may be people who will give sociology another look, that maybe there's still time to make sociology more into a kind of actionable project that I think some of the early American sociologists would have approved. You think?

Speaker 2 57:22

I think I have a little optimistic.

Speaker 1 57:29

Well, I'm optimistic that these things do change course. And I hope that sociology does, because there's certainly need for the kind of research that sociologists do. Should be able to contribute. And I think everybody's in this world to contribute something. So it's been fun, my dear friend. And I thank you for having appointed me your successor in running a series of editing a series of books. What was that 50 years ago? It's been fun. And it's also great to see you again. You're looking great. And It just shows how wonderful it is to be 100 years old. Can't beat that.

Speaker 2 58:18

I recommend it.

Speaker 1 58:20

Thank you, dear. See you. Take care. Bye.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments