Episode 789 World Federalist Movement

Notes

In this episode, Eston McKeague passionately advocates for a democratic world federation, discussing how sovereign nation states divide humanity and hinder accountability for global crises.

Guests

  • Eston McKeague
  • Barry Stevens

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

United, states, power, global, state, war, nation, international, system, basically, federation, level, law, Nations, government, believe, court, federalists, humanity, planet

SPEAKERS

Eston McKeague, Barry Stevens, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Eston McKeague, president and executive director of Young World Federalists, joined a host on Episode 789 of Project Save the World, the World Federalist Movement, to discuss the case for a democratic world federation. The host opened by citing recent attacks on the idea of world governance, including remarks at the United Nations, opposition to international control of artificial intelligence, and a promise to dismantle the International Criminal Court. McKeague said this hostility is long-standing and argued that the nation-state system keeps humanity divided and concentrates wealth and power among a few who evade taxes and regulation.

Read more…

McKeague described himself as a proud utopian and said the movement stays neutral on what a world federation should look like, with many members holding their own visions. He proposed a constitutional convention for the earth with elected representatives from around the world. On the United Nations, he argued that General Assembly delegates represent governments rather than peoples, and he favored a UN Parliamentary Assembly elected by citizens, similar to the European Parliament. The host then described federalism as deciding matters at the lowest appropriate level, using a pothole and national threats as examples. McKeague agreed.

McKeague named nuclear weapons, wars of aggression, and artificial intelligence as global issues, and said corporate consolidation of power, including that of tech billionaires, undermines accountability. The host noted that wealthy firms can move capital and shift profits, forcing nation states to compete for investment. McKeague linked this race to the bottom to climate financing and suggested that a globally enforced carbon tax could fund the energy transition. The host recalled Einstein's view that the United Nations was only a stepping stone to a real world government.

McKeague described the International Criminal Court as continuing the justice of Nuremberg, and said Germany feels a historical responsibility toward it. The host noted that Marco Rubio had attacked the court and that the United States never joined the Rome Statute, though it once supported parts of the effort. McKeague called the attacks a mask-off moment, saying criminals dislike courts. For enforcement, he said a world police would be among the last steps, after a world parliament and stronger international law, and must be democratically legitimate. The host said peacekeeping had reduced violence despite its flaws, and noted Canada's withdrawal from it. The conversation closed with McKeague hoping for a united future while fearing destruction may come first.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Speaker 1 0:04

Esther McKegg is president and executive director of Young World Federalists, an organization of young people that advocate for a sustainable, just, and peaceful world through a democratic world federation, a world run by humanity, for humanity, And we're going to talk today a little bit about the complete lack of that, I would say, in the chaos here on planet Earth, how that chaos might be addressed, especially in the light of attacks on the very idea of there being one world to govern. So welcome, Esten.

Speaker 2 0:41

Thank you. Happy to be here.

Speaker 1 0:42

Yeah, it's good to have you. Now, at the United Nations last week, which is in September 2026, Donald Trump said accurately, there is no global government, and while he'd be president, there There'd be no global taxes. He said in the past, we reject the whole ideology of globalism and world governance. This hostility goes way back. One example of the evangelist, I think the 60s, evangelist Pat Robertson said world government would be the work of the devil. But it's ramped up lately. The President of the United States said climate change is a con job and just yesterday rejected any attempt to construct international attempts to control artificial intelligence, what he calls super intelligence.

And most dramatically, Secretary of State of the United States, Marco Rubio, promised to dismantle the International Criminal Court. So, Esten, you are pretty much on the other side of this attack. How does that feel?

Speaker 2 2:10

Well, as you said, it's been going on for a long time. I think the people carrying this narrative today are, you know, just probably the third or fourth generation to do so. So unfortunately, it's nothing really new. So as a worldview, We're very much aware of this, these counter narratives, and where they come from. For me personally, I think that the, you know, the international system of nation states is basically bent on keeping humanity divided. And that controls or that puts a lot of wealth and power in the hands of the few.

And that's sort of what you see is these sort of wealthy and powerful individuals and groups that, you know, manage to evade taxes and regulation with loopholes in the nation state system, obviously speaking out against it. So they have a material interest in speaking against any sort of accountability on their actions.

Speaker 1 3:11

So you root this in the system of nation states, sovereign states, what's sometimes called the Westphalian system. Can you talk a bit about that, why that's an issue?

Speaker 2 3:24

Yeah, well, as I said, I believe that humanity has a sort of inalienable right to be united, and therefore the system of nation states is a sort of aberration against that right, or it goes against it, so to speak. So… I root a lot of issues in the nation-state system. I believe that at the time that ethno-linguistic nation-states were founded in the revolutions of the mid-1800s, I think it made a lot of sense and it gave a lot of minorities sovereignty that were part of larger empires and that at the time was seen as a good thing. And I think protecting minority rights in small languages and cultures is essential in any political system.

But In the current day, when we see so many global challenges go unaddressed, and at the same time this increasing concentration of wealth and power And that and those powerful people, unwilling and unable, but mostly unwilling to even address global challenges, I see that as an issue. And I think that the system of global governance that we have today, which relies so much on national sovereignty, and on the benevolence of key Countries and people basically falls apart when they stop being benevolent. And one could argue was never really a good way to rule the world to begin with.

Speaker 1 4:56

Right. So what would be the solution in an ideal world before we come back to Earth and look at the reality? What would be the ideal?

Speaker 2 5:06

Or is it meaningful to talk

Speaker 1 5:08

about an ideal?

Speaker 2 5:12

Yeah, I'm a proud Utopian. I believe that Utopia starts with you. I think that we are a lot lacking that sort of visionary imagination today. There's a lot of Doomerism and Doomscrolling. And I think we need narratives of hope and of Utopia in order to sort of drag us out morally. From the slump that we're in, but also politically and materially. Yeah, so I definitely believe in ideals and in utopia. And for me, at least for the Young World Federalists, we're very neutral on what that utopia should look like or what that World Federation should look like. We also don't claim that any World Federation is going to create utopia, of course, that will always have issues.

Any political system has issues and problems and challenges, of course. We believe that we should have space to discuss this. So sort of a constitutional convention for the earth where we bring in elected representatives from all corners of the globe to design a political system and to refine it. The United States Constitution is around 250 years old. The UN Charter is over 80 years old. As we can see, just these two documents are not necessarily aging well.

Speaker 1 6:32

We already have some kind of transnational organization in the United Nations, which you mentioned. Don't we already have it?

Speaker 2 6:42

Yeah. Well, yeah, so yeah, just starting there. So the UN General Assembly is, you know, represented, it's made up of delegates. So these people work for their national governments, and they don't necessarily represent their country as a whole, they represent their government. So there's a layer of undemocratic Sort of representation at the General Assembly itself. And sort of, by and large, we believe in a World Federalist as a whole, we believe in a Democratic World Federation where the people making decisions So supranational policy or regulations are elected by the people in a way very similar to the European Parliament.

So we always look to Europe for a pretty good example of this, which started out as very much a confederal or even just an intergovernmental institution and has slowly grown into a relatively strong foundation. Somewhat federated system where the European Parliament is elected by the citizens of Europe. And so that's sort of the model we would love to see what we call a UN Parliamentary Assembly get created by the General Assembly. And it would work very similar for the, for an American audience, it's very similar to like a lower house and an upper house, where the lower house of parliamentary assembly is elected, and it's representing the people as a whole, and then the upper house, the general assembly.

Rep is representing the each country equally. Everybody has one seat in the General Assembly. So sort of a bicameral system is often thought of. But again, we are as there's many different, you know, ideas about what exactly a World Federation should look like. Almost every single person in the movement has their own utopia, which I love. And it's not necessarily our job. And nor do we have the juice as for no more.

Speaker 1 8:43

Let's go with mommy. Oh, my God. Well, I mean, there's a little bit of that that's, you know, not to be sentimental about it, but that's the future, your kid. Yeah. And that's to solve the things we're facing is not just an academic question. It's his survival. Just to say that a federation is based on the idea of making, as I understand it, making decisions at the lowest level possible. If I got a pothole on my street, that's a municipal problem. If I've got in Canada, there's a problem with our socialized health care system, that's a provincial problem. If there's a problem with the United States threatening to invade my country, that's a national problem.

But if there's a World Federation, that would mean that there's a level of government which stands above the sovereign state. Which stands to deal with problems that are in fact affecting everybody on the planet. That would be a fair description of federalism, that it's not designed to sort of interfere with my pothole. It's designed to deal with matters at an appropriate level.

Speaker 2 10:10

Yeah, for sure. Yeah, so that's the subsidiarity principle. And it's like, it's almost the definition of federalism. And I personally think that there's a lot of sort of unitary principles. Countries today that could do with a little bit more of subsidiarity and devolved governance. So just, you know, I live in Germany, so just like next door to me is France, and France is very centralized in Paris. It's almost, you know, an extreme example is basically that the potholes in a small town in southern France are actually dealt with. In Paris, often. And that it's that level of centralization, which is efficient, sometimes, and that's, you know, what they what they like about it.

But right next door, Germany, where, where I live, where it's a federal republic, and there's states and the states. So as a world Federalist, I obviously have an appreciation for Federalism as a whole. And I believe that there could be many different layers in addition to the global layer of education. I think what you'll see in addition to that, I think what you notice is that a lot of local issues, or maybe municipal issues, so to speak, are Also have shared global challenges. I think a really big one that you see cities talking about right now is climate resilience. And connected to that is, of course, like urban planning and mobility, which are things that are solved at the local level.

But there's obviously best practices that can be shared, at least within regions of the world where the cities are in a similar climate and dealing with similar things. And of course, climate change itself is a global problem. And so I think… Finding these interconnections between local issues and global issues is really important. And a central layer or a middle layer like the nation state would be a good sort of intermediary between that and that sort of sharing of sovereignty between a global level and a more local level. So basically, You know, taking some of the sovereignty from the nation state and then sharing it with both the global and local as sort of, at least for me, sort of my personal utopia.

I believe that the nation state has just in a lot of cases is just too much, too much power in one sort of authority. And that leads to basically not the right, not the right solutions. The potholes aren't getting filled and the climate is not getting climate change is not getting dealt with.

Speaker 1 12:51

That's interesting, because one thinks of world federalists or world government people as being, well, we want a world president who will solve all our problems. So it's interesting to hear you talk about possibly there's too much power concentrated in Paris and not enough in the regions. I didn't expect that. And we talked about climate change. That, I think, is the The most obvious, anyway, planetary problem that we're facing, it's not the only one, which would require coordinated action, don't seem to be getting it much. And that is the sort of thing that you would imagine the planetary level of a federal system working. And what were the other problems that you think could be addressed or should be addressed?

Speaker 2 13:48

Yeah, well, the one that really got the whole movement started, you know, with Albert Einstein and the other nuclear scientists in the 40s and 50s was, of course, the advent of nuclear weapons. And so Albert Einstein famously was a big proponent and gave speeches. To the early members of the movement, basically stating that nuclear weapons are too powerful for any one country to hold and all nuclear weapons should be put under the control of a world body. So that remains one of the biggest issues that we sort of campaign against, nuclear proliferation. So in addition to nuclear weapons, you can see that a lot of countries are able to wage sort of wars of aggression or commit grave crimes without any accountability.

Without any consequences for their actions, I view basically all war as a global issue. Any war anywhere is a global issue. Injustices carried out. So war and peace in general, I believe, is a global issue in addition to nuclear weapons. And then, of course, I think the biggest one that a lot of people are talking about right now is artificial intelligence. I'm personally a big user of AI, and I'm still trying to make up my own personal mind about all this talk that AI is some sort of existential risk. There's a lot of opinions on both sides. For me, it's sort of is a symptom of the broader issue of corporate consolidation of power.

That there's a few people in San Francisco that have a lot of power in the world, and one, aren't really paying their fair share of taxes. You mentioned the tech billionaires who have so much power.

Speaker 1 16:28

It reminds me of them going and making places in New Zealand or building bunkers. And also, they have the power to exit the nation state. They have power beyond the sovereign state. And of course, that's true of the whole corporate world and has been for some time. That it's possible for Apple to surface its profits in Ireland and evade taxes there. So they have so much power, especially they can move capital at the speed of light and move around the world quite rapidly. So for them, there is a kind of a world governance already. There is a kind of an ability to simply go anywhere and do anything.

Of course, they have restrictions and the nation state has some power, but they have a great deal of power to cross over it. And therefore, nation states are, their power is limited by even the fact that they have to compete with other nation states to get corporate, to attract that money or the bond market.

Speaker 2 17:32

Sort of the race to the bottom that countries are forced to compete in in order to attract these corporations to set up headquarters or whatever within their borders is a major issue. And so a lot of world federalists are really interested in the sort of financial and economic systems that govern the world. When you talk about how do we solve climate change, a lot of it comes down to financing. And then you say, okay, well, how do we finance mitigation and the energy transition? And then you start to think, well, there's billions of dollars getting lost in sort of corporate tax evasion every year. So if we did pass a global carbon tax that was enforced equally across the globe, that would…

That would provide enough money, theoretically, to help ease the transition towards renewable energies and mitigate the damage that we've already done. So it's easier said than done, obviously. And again, I'm a big proponent of me not solving these issues. I really believe that it's up for the people of the world to come together and debate and solve these issues.

Speaker 1 18:44

Just to go back to what you were saying about war, I remember I actually did a couple of videos on that little period in 1945-46, Einstein being completely dissatisfied with the United Nations, saying, well, okay, but it's just a stepping stone. I think that was his phrase, a stepping stone to a proper world government, you know, that had real teeth or power. Mm-hmm. Oppenheimer, who of course led the invention of the atomic bomb, was very keen on something more limited, but giving the atomic weapon to an international agency, taking it away from the United States, the most powerful weapon that had ever been built. And of course he failed, and they both failed, and there was a concerted counter-attack on it.

Let us just go back to this idea of federation. You cited Europe as an example, although these days from this point of view and this side of the Atlantic, it is looking a little shaky. But nevertheless, that European idea began actually really about war. I mean, of course, the coal and steel union back in the late 40s, early 50s. It was economic. It was efficiency. But underneath that, the dream was that France and Germany wouldn't go to war again, because the first half of the 20th century was absolutely horrific. And the Europe we have now is better. You can drive from Warsaw to Paris without a tank. And that's a big advance. But once it arrives, people sort of forget that history and that purpose.

Do you see that kind of federation as applying to other parts of the world or indeed the whole world?

Speaker 2 20:55

Yeah, I mean, well, federalism as an ideology is very diverse and there's a lot of different parts to it and everybody sort of has their favorite parts. But, you know, increasing regional integration or regionalization of the planet is definitely one pathway towards World Federation. I know the European Federalists are very keen on that. They view the European model as sort of a model that other regions of the world can follow. I personally am never a huge proponent of saying everybody needs to follow what Europe's doing for historical reasons. I think it's just not the right narrative. But nonetheless, I think that there are things to learn.

But I'm more keen to see the different regions of the world maybe come up with their own systems, maybe looking to Europe for inspiration. But I wouldn't necessarily say that the… The pathway that Europe took is the right pathway for West Africa, or the Caribbean, or whatever. And the end result could be different as well. But nonetheless, I do believe that regions, as I've said, you know, I'm a really big I'm a big fan of sort of decentralizing power away from the nation state.

So if we think about, you know, the global level, and then the subnational level, which we were talking about earlier, there is potentially also another level between the nation state and the globe with the regions, basically what So we could imagine a world in which the nation state is joined by stronger subnational units, regional units above the nation state, and then a global level above that. And the global level could even be The region's cooperating and not even the nation states. And so it gets, it gets pretty fun. And to think about these, these crazy utopias and discuss them.

We're very neutral on what it should look like and exactly what path We basically aim to build support for all these different pathways and all these ideas because we know that it needs to be better than it is now. My personal favorite is something much It's much more grassroots and technology driven, as I'm really into civic technology and electronic democracy. It's a growing and very diverse marketplace. That's my personal favorite of, you know, sort of. Global governance is much more individual and technology driven or grassroots global democracy is another way of phrasing it. But then there's, of course, others that say, you know, we should start with stronger integration with with the West.

The so-called Western States or the Global North that should all integrate and have sort of an expanded European Union or a Democratic NATO. And that's the first step to a World Federation. And then there's others that are really into the United Nations and look at the United States. United Nations Charter and go article by article and try and find how can we use the United Nations and how can we make reforms to it, incremental reforms to the United Nations. And maybe that's the way to the World Federation. And so I'm obviously in favor of whatever we can get in order to help us solve these existential crises and democratize the planet. Yeah.

Speaker 1 24:46

So you're talking about different people within the movement. Let's talk about your organization a bit. How big is it? How old is it? Where does it span? Does it span the whole globe? How many members?

Speaker 2 25:00

Yeah, it's a good question. I would say that I'm… I'm now wearing a few different hats, so I'll keep with the Young World Federalist hat on, but I am now the Vice Chair of the World Federalist Movement, which is the umbrella organization that was founded in 1947. And I am the Outreaching Communications Officer for Citizens for Global Solutions, which is also founded in 1947 or 48. And that's the sort of US branch of the whole movement. I'm very integrated with all these different organizations, but the Young World Federalist was founded in around 2020, 2021 by a young 17-year-old from Florida and an Australian from Yeah, from Melbourne.

And they met each other on Reddit and then they tried to get integrated with or try to join basically the World's Federalist Movement. But at that time, for various reasons, they basically didn't get any response when they knocked at the door. And they thought, well, that doesn't work. We need to have a presence. We need to accept people. We need to have a place for people to talk and to join. And so they created a subreddit called Global Tribe, so Reddit community, and then a Discord server. And in the pandemic, it really attracted a lot of people who were stuck at home and we had very, a lot of activity.

And yeah, and so then that was probably the early phase, a lot of online discussions and things like that as everybody was in lockdown. And then as the pandemic sort of weaned away, we started to have more in-person activities and develop a chapter structure.

Speaker 1 26:35

Well, I think what we'll do is we'll take a break now and continue, but with a second part. And I want to ask about some of the fears about any kind of world federalism, such as tyranny, whether or not we need a world police force, and so forth. Some of those fears that I run into anyway. I want to start out with a quote from Einstein. He said, like, rhetorically, he wrote somewhere, Do I fear the tyranny of a world government? Of course I do. But I fear still more the coming of another war. So that's the criticism I hear when I've talked about World Federation is, well, it would just be a tyranny.

You know, you get President Xi or somebody in charge and we'd all be living in a nightmare. What's your response to that kind of fear?

Speaker 2 27:43

I think that we have a lot of tyranny today. That has is not accountable, certainly to humanity as a whole, but often to the people that are a part of those countries. And where the current system of nation states is unable to prevent the concentration of power or more tyrannical actions. So, people are not held accountable, and there's nothing preventing this from getting worse. So, to me, that means that the system needs to be reformed. Now, to your point, to your question about, like, how do we basically decentralize power in a world federal system? In the first part, I was talking a lot about how power in a world federalist sense is very decentralized between the subnational, the regional, and the global level.

And so it's not necessarily about taking all of the power from the nation states and giving it to just another level of government. That's obviously not what we want. That's why we call ourselves world federalists. We use this term. If we wanted that, we call ourselves world royalists or something. We want a world king. We're very, that's why we use this term, basically, this Federalist term, because as you mentioned in the first part, subsidiarity and the devolution and the decentralization of power is key to our ideology. It's the founding principle.

And so I think, at first, if you have a very cursory understanding of world government or world federalism, you think, okay, yeah, you want to basically have a king that is able to exert their will, you know, across the planet, which is obviously not what we want. That sounds terrible. We want to give more power to the people and take power away from the very few individuals that have it today and share it with more people. That's the whole idea. And so I think we already talked quite a bit about that in the first part. Yeah.

Speaker 1 29:59

Yeah, so it would be, in a sense, the rule of law would be the principle rather than the rule of power. Is that a fair thing to say?

Speaker 2 30:10

Yeah, I mean, you can get into, yeah, of course, the rule of law and democratic legitimacy and, yeah, Erechstadt in German. It's all key. A pluralistic democracy, a multi-party democracy. I mean, there's a lot of really… Good ideas that exist in a lot of cool democracies today, federal democracies today, that we can sort of pull from, I would say, in the first part, we also talked about, or you mentioned the The European project and sort of where it was started and the history of that. And now as a German citizen myself, the history of that is very interesting to me. And I have had the chance to go to Nuremberg and go to the site of the Nuremberg trials.

And it's a very interesting museum where they talk all about this, how it was this monumental moment in human history when the victors of the Second World War chose not to You know, basically settle the Second World War by executing a lot of people in a firing squad, but to actually hold them into a court first and have this sort of rule of law and hold people… You know, to bring justice in a legal setting after the Second World War and how that had really never happened before and how it was a monumental thing. And I and then at the end of that exhibition, they talk about the International Criminal Court as the continuation of that.

And I've also been outside the ICC in The Hague and it's a really sort of beautiful narrative and it's one reason why Germany itself is very aligned with the ICC. They feel a historical responsibility to the ICC. They view the ICC as something that essentially is created through the justice that occurred at the end of the Second World War. The caretakers of this history are very much aligned with the need of international law and for holding criminals at the national level accountable. Justice is key to holding government actors and leaders accountable for their crimes against their own people and people in other countries.

And that is part and parcel with a legislative body that is able to pass laws that, of course, the judiciary would be able to enforce. And as you already mentioned, yeah.

Speaker 1 32:54

No, that's really interesting. Yeah, the line from Nuremberg to the ICC, the International Criminal Court, which, of course, a permanent International Criminal Court was long a dream of people who thought about these things in terms of governance for the whole world. You obviously need a court, and also because it prosecutes individuals rather than Visiting collective punishment upon a people, which is the whole cycle of revenge and war, you know, Azerbaijanian, Armenians, back and forth, or whoever. And instead, you say, well, these people did these terrible things. They will be held responsible.

But we're living in a time, a remarkable time, when As I said in the earlier piece that we did, Marco Rubio, the United States Secretary of State, has promised to dismantle the International Criminal Court. It's a very serious attack. And he used the phrase brick by brick, and he used the phrase so-called international law, just contempt for the very idea that you're talking about. And it's a serious attack in that the sanctions upon people who support the court Quite serious. Anyone who deals with the court can be sanctioned. They've already sanctioned judges. Frighteningly, to me, you mentioned Germany as a big supporter. Well, the other, of course, at that time in 1945, the other great criminal tribunal was in Tokyo.

And just last week, the Prime Minister of Japan said she supports Germany. The attack on the criminal court, the international criminal court. So these are tough times. And no, that's just my comment. Do you have any thought about that?

Speaker 2 34:50

It is. It's really difficult when you have the situation that we're in, where the United States, which was never a member of the Rome Statue, never a part of the ICC, because, of course, to be held accountable by the ICC, your national government has to ratify the treaty. And the United States has never even considered that process.

Speaker 1 35:14

But it supported it in some ways, subtly. And there was always people within the United States government who did cooperate, including, I talked to Lloyd Axworthy the other day, who was former foreign minister of Canada, who supported the Landmine Treaty and the ICC. And he said that Madeleine Albright, the then Secretary of State, and Bill Clinton, in fact, were in support of it. And in fact, just a little historical note, it was FDR, President Roosevelt of your country, who really was absolutely key in the creation of the United Nations and key in the decision not to just shoot a bunch of Germans, which Churchill would have been happy to do. And it was he who really was championed that Nuremberg process.

So it's ironic that these attacks are coming from the country that did more to create it than any.

Speaker 2 36:17

Yes. It's devastating. It's more than ironic. It's devastating. This is not the sort of, you know, if you're going to depend on superpowers to sort of lead the way and be benevolent actors, this is obviously not the situation that you want to end up in, where they turn their back. On international law and justice and on human rights and just common human decency and addressing shared challenges across nation states. I think this is a symptom of… The United States realizing that as it's continues to act against sort of international law and justice around the world, the risk of these institutions to its own material interest becomes greater. And so another a shorter way of saying it is that criminals don't like courts.

They don't like them. Why would a criminal like court? And so for them, it's easy. It's easy to say they don't want this. This is bad. They want to be able to go into sovereign nations and abduct the leader and not be afraid that anything is going to happen to the people that did that. Yeah, they want to be able to bomb countries without any repercussions and bomb schools without any repercussions or hospitals or whatever, civilian infrastructure. And they want other countries who are their allies to be able to do the same. And so any system of law and justice that seeks to hold countries accountable for these egregious crimes is a threat to that way of being. So I'm not necessarily surprised.

I think that the doublespeak that we saw in the 20th century, early 2000s with You know, the United States championing the sort of rules-based international order and international law and being a big champion of it at the same time, breaking all the rules and still committing the crimes. You know, that was also embarrassing and very disappointing to see. So part of me is at least happy that the United States has, you know, it's like a mask off moment. You know, they finally are like, you know what, actually, we don't care. We never did. We're full empire all the time. We don't care about this international law stuff. We never did. So I'm kind of like, at least they're honest now.

But at the same time, it's devastating because even the sort of superficial normative platitudes that the United States used to pay and real, as you said, real material support from some high ups in the government. That the United States used to pay towards these international law and just the UN itself has stopped. We're in a new era where it's leading towards more empires and more a feudal-like system, in my opinion.

Speaker 1 39:24

Yeah, we mentioned kings earlier. This is more like a king moment. And making the world safe for war criminals, as somebody has put it. You mentioned that criminals don't like courts. Another thing criminals don't like is police. And Ben Ferencz, who was an old guy who… When I interviewed him, he's now left the planet, but in body at any rate.

Speaker 2 39:50

And he said to me that justice was like a

Speaker 1 39:52

stool with three legs. One was the One was a democratic body to pass laws. Another was a court to try those who've broken that law. But the third leg was the possibility of enforcement. Now, I'd like you to talk about that a little bit, because any imagination of a World Federation, no matter how distributed the power is, still is going to have laws, and there's still going to be conflict. Do we have a police force? Do we have a world police, to quote South Park, that, you know, sorts out conflict and presumably stops it, but maybe also arrests the perpetrators? Is that something, is that part of the world federalist vision?

Speaker 2 41:00

Like I said, we're very neutral on what exactly it's supposed to look like. For many world federalists, that's the most important part of it. And everything else comes secondary. As a proud utopian, I would say that We don't need anything like that. All conflicts should be discussed between people in a peaceful setting, and there should be no need for any sort of violence. And if we're going to build a utopia, we should build a nonviolent utopia. But of course, how realistic is that? So at the end of the day, we're talking about state power and devolving or sharing state power with other levels of government, and the state has a monopoly on violence.

We are de facto talking about at least sharing the monopoly on violence that the current nation state has with with a regional level or potentially a global level on top of that. Because as you say, any law that's passed by elected representatives or any any policy created by the people, you know, needs to be able to be enforced. And that's that's a that's key. And so that's we've talked a lot about the judiciary and the legislative branch. But, yeah, there would need to be sort of an executive branch that then carries out the will of humanity and and protects humanity from from these criminals, which we've talked about now. That's a really.

I think that the world police is probably one of the last things to really come onto the conversation table, unfortunately. I mean, I think it's important, but I think that having a world parliament, And strengthening international law is probably what we want to tackle first, so that there's democratic legitimacy in this executive branch or in this world police, that people don't view it as a, and it's not, but people especially don't see it as a tyranny. It's not a mechanical sort of police force or military force. It needs to be something that people identify with and see it as representing humanity and the interests of humanity as a whole.

And the way to get there is with democracy and participation and inclusivity of all people in the process in designing a world federation or reformed United Nations.

Speaker 1 43:29

Yeah, and there has been sort of a middle ground which we've already done in this world. It's now being weakened like everything else. But peacekeeping, United Nations peacekeeping, for all its many flaws, and people love to attack it. It has objectively, the evidence is that it has reduced violence and has improved stuff. And my own country was a leader, Canada was a leader in this, is now fully withdrawing from it, fully abandoning it. And it has announced that just quite recently. But it has been remarkably effective. With an acknowledgment of the times that it has been disastrously ineffective, but better than nothing.

I just wanted to say about sovereignty and about the power to make war, somebody said to me, was it, I cannot remember the name of the academic, but Alexander Wentz? Anyway, it does not matter. Sovereignty is the right to go outside the sovereign state and kill people. That's what sovereignty is. It's law within that territory. But outside that, you can do whatever the fuck you want. You can kill somebody. And that is what we do with our armies. We send them over to another place and then they have the right to do that. And that is what Hobbes called the state of nature between nations rather than a civil state within a nation.

Which is why, you know, he was advocating in Britain, you know, the idea of a Leviathan who would hold everybody in awe. So the idea of policing and having a world state was very frank in the 40s among world federalists. I mean, I have a little book, which I don't know if you know, by E.B. White. He was the guy who did Charlotte's Web. He used to write for the New Yorker. There's a little book called The Wild Flag. And he's writing in 1945, these columns in the New Yorker saying, yeah, let's do this. Let's have a world state with the World Police Force. I think now what you're saying, I think quite rightly, is that…

The concerns about that and the need to develop a peaceful coordination or a peaceful network globally as a first step. I'm talking a lot, sort of really undercutting the whole idea of an interview, but I just want to say one thing about it, which is that the United States itself is a federation that once was a collection of states. And I heard this from the documentary filmmaker Ken Burns, is that before the United States Civil War, the United States was a plural noun phrase. The United States are. The United States wants. After the Civil War, it was singular. The United States is. The United States wants.

And that change is a psychological, sociological change from a bunch of states to And in a sense, that psychological change is really important for our Earth to get to.

Speaker 2 47:11

Yeah, it's almost the… So that sense of world citizenship is maybe the shortest way of phrasing it, or cosmopolitanism. There's a lot of shared ideas there, and a lot of the people in the movement Especially a lot of the younger ones that are really active on TikTok, view that as the most important first step. Before we even get into international law or world parliament or the United Nations, we need everybody to view themselves as a citizen of the planet and that that has rights and responsibilities and that you love your fellow humans. They even have a hashtag that they like to use called Billions Must Love. So it's really built into this, yeah, what do you, fealty, fidelity, love, this love of humanity.

Which is excellent. And I believe really, really important. And I think that we talked briefly about the World Passport before. I mean, that's a nice sort of artifact that can show this, you know, allegiance or belief in yourself. As something, you know, part of humanity, I think it's really important.

Speaker 1 48:25

Just to clarify, this was started way back in 1945 by a U.S., an American called Gary Davis. And the organization's, I've forgotten the name of it. The World Service Authority. World Service Authority. Thank you. And it issues a world passport, which I have somewhere in my desk here. So the idea of citizenship of the world, that I'm a citizen of the world, it's obviously true. We are both citizens of the world. We live on the same planet. But promoting that idea, you're saying, is important.

Speaker 2 49:12

Yeah, it's key. And I think that art and culture can go a long way. I think we as a movement need to foster artists and creators and cultural people to create art that people can identify with. I think we as World Federalists get very political. We love to talk about How the General Assembly will have a Parliamentary Assembly, and then there'll be a Council of Elders, and then we'll have, you know, a meritocracy over here. And everybody loves to get into this weird, you know, what, what's the perfect World Federation going to look like? And I think that's a fun sort of political exercise.

But at the end of the day, we need sort of attractive iconography and art that's able to bring a lot of people towards these ideas and make a lot of people feel like, ah, yeah, This is something I've always held within me, but I didn't know there was a word for it, and I didn't know that other people thought like that. And so I think that art and culture are key, and it's a key underpinning. I mean, you're not going to get a world parliament, in my humble opinion, you're not really going to get it if 90% of the planet… Identifies as a citizen of their nation first. You need, I think, a key foundational requirement to really anything that we're talking about today.

Speaker 1 50:38

Speaking of arts and culture, science fiction Feels like a very interesting form that relates to what we've been talking about. I've noticed references to sci-fi in some of the communication in young, well, Federalists, particularly perhaps with young people, but also an interest in space. Which seems to be a theme among

Speaker 2 51:08

young Royal Federalists. I mean, the examples are really obvious. I mean, we should not be going, we should not bring these problems that are plaguing the planet into the cosmos. You know, the United States recently announced that they have weapons in space, which is a, that's breaking the outer space treaty to even have that, but they don't care. And there's talks of, you know, bases on the moon. And all these things, which can be cool, but can also be tools to serve nationalism and turn violent and basically bring war to outer space, which, as you said, is a tool of sovereignty. And so it's basically just this… National sovereignty, finding its way to outer space.

And that's obviously, I think, not a good way to do it. And giving all the power to a corporation to do it is also probably not great. That's… You know, basically the Dutch East Indies or the British East Indian Company. You know, we've done this before and it didn't it wasn't good. And so we as World Federalists think that we need to learn from history and not embark on new frontiers as mercantilist companies or as sovereign competitive countries at war with each other, but embark on new frontiers united.

Speaker 1 52:27

Yeah. The. Absolutely. That's a good analogy, the Dutch East India Company and so forth. There is, of course, in the Outer Space Treaty and generally in the United Nations, the sense that, or the explicit requirement that Outside this planet belongs to all mankind or all humankind, we'd say now, or doesn't belong to anybody, in fact. And it's a space without sovereignty, without ownership. And that, of course, is being challenged right now, as you say, with weapons in space and colonization of the moon.

And it seems overall, to bring it back to where We began this conversation an hour ago, these attacks on the idea of there being a globe, the idea of there being any kind of world federation or world cooperation by the current United States government, reveals that there is in a sense sort of two ideas which are antithetical. One of them is The U.S. idea, permanent dominance, that they would dominate the world forever. I don't know how else to put it. And of course, that is challenged by other powers because they're not the only power. So that becomes a classic state power competition, which usually results in war. And we know where that ends now in the age of nuclear weapons.

If you imagine a future for the planet, given climate change, given AI, given pandemics, given war, say 200 years from now, if we imagine us surviving and thriving, it is very hard to imagine it as permanent dominance by the United States or Permanent dominance by China or any of that, the only way one can really imagine us surviving and thriving, to me, is through some kind of cooperative planetary organization, however that's conceived. It's either that or dominance and war, it seems to me.

Speaker 2 54:59

Yeah. I think that that's often a common belief for people outside the movement as well or outside the ideology who believe that say, oh yeah, I mean, probably that will happen eventually. I mean, the world will eventually unite sometime, maybe it's 200 or maybe it's 2000 years in the future. Because it's so prevalent in sci-fi, I just assume, yeah, at some point, you know, it'll be different and maybe it's united. And I think that that's cool. It's very much a resigned position. I think that we face a lot of challenges that require us to act now.

Speaker 1 55:39

Right now.

Speaker 2 55:40

Yeah, we need something new now. We need it like yesterday. So I am not one to say, you know, in 200 years, this will probably be happening. I'm more like, no, we need this, like, we need to make plans to get humanity on a better path now. But, and unfortunately, it's either that or what you, the sort of dichotomy that you posed between a sort of united, more cooperative future and this war, warring and destructive future. And So I am a utopian at my heart, but I also fear that one might need to happen before the other, and we may need to Go through a period of destruction in order for humanity to finally build systems that prevent that sort of thing from happening again.

The only example we have really is the First and the Second World War, which has created the League of Nations and then the United Nations.

Speaker 1 56:37

And so one could argue that that's a necessary requirement. I hope and

Speaker 2 56:51

I wake up every day and work all day trying to argue against that, but I'm not blind to that idea.

Speaker 1 57:02

Wow. From your lips to whatever spirit is out there's ears. Yeah, so hope. We have hope, but not foolish enough to be certain of it. Listen, that's a good way, a good place to end, I think. Thank you, Eston McKeague of Young World Federalists for doing this. It's great, learned a lot, and it's been a great conversation for me. Appreciate it very much. Maybe you could just send me some links, which I'll put, as they say, below. And thank everybody for watching this. And please don't forget, as everyone says, to like and subscribe. We'll see you next time.

Speaker 2 57:49

Thank you very much.

Speaker 1 57:51

Thank you.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments