Episode 790 Antisemitism

Notes

In this episode, Michele Landsberg, and Seth Klein discuss the resurgence of anti-Semitism, analyzing its deep connections to systemic capitalism, historical trauma, and political propaganda.

Guests

  • Michele Landsberg
  • Seth Klein
  • Metta Spencer

Video

Podcast

🎧 Listen on Substack

SUMMARY and TRANSCRIPT

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

Jewish, anti-semitism, Jews, never, school, book, Israel, kids, community, Seth, agree, Gaza, Michelle, mainstream, status, genocide, students, system, true, anti-semitic

SPEAKERS

Michele Landsberg, Seth Klein, Metta Spencer.

SUMMARY

Metta Spencer hosted this episode of Project Save the World on antisemitism, with guests Michele Landsberg and Seth Klein. Seth first described the sold-out Vancouver event for Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor's new book. Michele then recalled growing up in Toronto during the war, facing open hatred of Jews, including demands about her religion at school and a graduate school recommendation refused by an antisemitic dean. She argued that today's concern mixes real hatred with anti-Zionism, which she said government policy wrongly treats as antisemitism.

Read more…

Seth described his own childhood in Montreal's Jewish community, where he met little antisemitism until a year in England. He said antisemitism is rising in several countries and is connected to the war in Gaza, though the reaction to Gaza has given cover to genuine antisemites. Metta argued that harassment of Jewish people is antisemitism itself, motivated by Gaza. Michele said protests against the genocide are not antisemitism, and she raised Islamophobia as an overlooked problem. Metta then described a 1960s survey of American high school students, in which she found that envy of successful Jewish students was the main source of tension.

Michele described becoming a Zionist as a teenager, then gradually losing that loyalty as she learned about Israel's occupation and the lies she had been taught. Seth said Jewish children are often taught a victim identity, and he described learning as a child to donate to the Jewish National Fund. Michele also described a Jewish committee's dispute with a mainstream Jewish organization over aid to Roma refugees. Metta said that the current antisemitism is about Israel rather than envy, and she worried that framing it around Jewish attitudes could blame the victim. Michele added that ignorance and family stories also sustain antisemitism.

Seth proposed organizing as the answer, citing Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor's account of Zohran Mamdani's New York campaign. Michele agreed that non-Jews should speak up against antisemitism, as men do against misogyny. Michele then blamed capitalism for the anger that fuels fascism, while Metta, drawing on Weber, argued that status and dignity matter as much as money. Michele rejected envy as the cause and stressed closed opportunities. Seth then left the call, and Metta and Michele ended by saying they had not settled how to overcome the resentment.

Transcript made by speech recognition from the episode as published; names and unusual words may be wrong. The speakers are told apart by number, not by name.

Metta Spencer 0:00

Hi, I'm Metta Spencer. Today we're going to tackle a very sensitive and difficult and painful subject, but it's one that's very much in the news today. I'm happy to say that I can welcome some people who I've known them separately for many, many years. Michele Landsberg, everybody will recognize, at least Canadians will recognize as a Long-term, very eminent journalist. And in her extended, there's a man named Seth Klein, whom I have known since he was a teenager, when he traveled across Canada, giving talks to other high school students about nuclear weapons and trying to promote nuclear disarmament.

But they're all part of the same family, a family, a very distinguished family, Related to the New Democratic Party and to a very successful current journalist writer, Naomi Klein. So Seth is Naomi's brother and Michelle is her mother-in-law. And as I understand it, she just had a big book launch or something in Vancouver last night. And we can certainly want to start off by asking how that went. So hello, Michelle, and hello, Seth.

Speaker 2 1:40

Hi, Mehta.

Speaker 3 1:41

Hi, Mehta.

Metta Spencer 1:43

Great to have you here.

Speaker 3 1:44

I like that. That's a good description.

Metta Spencer 1:50

Okay, so let's, I'm going to ask Seth first, tell me a little bit about last night's Wingding event. Something went on in Vancouver that filled the house.

Speaker 3 2:05

Oh, well, and in Toronto a few days ago, Naomi has a new book out co-authored with Astra Taylor called End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World. So they've been on a big book tour all over the world. And the last night of the book tour was last night in Vancouver. So there were about 1,500 people. And the book is doing extremely well. I've read the book. It's an extraordinary book.

Metta Spencer 2:39

Great. All right. Well, I haven't got to it yet, but I will. But we're going to be talking primarily about anti-Semitism today because, you know, I didn't think it would ever get to this stage again. I really am shocked. It certainly is. It's, again, part of our everyday life that we read something about somebody getting badly traded. And the real question is, what's this all about? Very mysterious. So, Michelle, why don't you, I know that we have lived through very different periods of time. I'm older than you are, I think. I'm 95, and I've forgotten what.

But last time we had a conversation, you shared a lot about what your experience with Indo-Semitism had been mostly in your youth and even professionally when you were a very famous journalist here in Toronto. And you can recap a little of that if you will for us. And I think that Seth being much younger than either of us We'll have experienced something quite different.

Speaker 2 4:02

Yes. Well, I was born in Toronto in 1939. That's a very significant date. And from my earliest years, I experienced very direct and open hatred of Jews. It was a predominant sentiment in the city. It wasn't a minority view. It was mirrored in the newspapers every day. Jews were portrayed as something sinister and foreign and possibly evil. And at school, even registering for kindergarten, public school, they demanded to know my religion, and my mother was Palpably frightened at that question. The war was still on and we felt very isolated and endangered. And that continued throughout my schooling of being threatened with the scrap for not praying to Jesus and so on. It was just a constant that we learned to live with.

I think today, and you know, you're right, I did experience it professionally. I wanted to go to graduate school. My very anti-Semitic dean refused to give me the recommendation, so I became a journalist instead. I'm glad I did. But I think that it's a very different picture today, that Nazi kind of hatred of Jews It's quite different from what people are now defining as anti-Semitism. And it's being confused constantly with anti-Zionist positions. I experienced that quite directly. People call me for my anti-genocide position. They call me a self-hating Jew or a Jewish anti-Semite, which is ridiculous in my view. But mixing up anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism is part of the, I think, deeply felt analysis of mainstream Jews.

And in part, it's also a weapon against any criticism of Israel to deliberately conflate it, conflate anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. And even officially, our government has done that through the public safety. Whatever it's called, what's it called, the Public Safety Council? I forget, but just very recently, a month or so ago, they defined criticism of Zionism as anti-Semitic, and that's public policy, which means when I'm out there on the street every other week leading the women in black vigil against the genocide, I could be arrested for… Standing for anti-Zionist views. I mean, it's preposterous to define

Speaker 3 7:04

anti-Zionist views. Effectively, the lobby group that supplanted the Canadian Jewish Congress, which used to be a very broad tent organization, lots of organizational members, and now we have this single group. It's an Israel lobby group that has replaced it and has very actively been getting governments at every level, federal, provincial, municipal, to pass these motions on. With a very particular definition of anti-Semitism that does equate anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. But to come back to your starting question, Mehta, obviously my childhood experience was very different from Michelle's. I'm 30 years younger. I was born in Montreal. Montreal has… Had and has a large Jewish community.

And I was, you know, in it because I went to a Jewish elementary school, so I didn't experience anti-Semitism much at all. Everyone was Jewish. And in fact, really, my first main exposure to it was when I was in grade seven, we lived in England for one year. And there, it was a bit shocking to suddenly experience, you know, just these, just these, You know, people just using these derogatory comments without even thinking about it.

Speaker 2 8:30

Conventionally, just like Toronto.

Speaker 3 8:32

Don't you me or stuff like this without even knowing what it means. But, you know, I do think anti-Semitism… Zionism has evolved just as Zionism has evolved. These things are always manifesting in different ways. They mean different things over time. But certainly… It is an issue once again. I mean, when I was a kid, when we learned about World War II and the Nazis, the fight against fascism was an historic story. It was a rearview mirror story. We defeated it. We created these post-war institutions and conventions that would prevent it from ever happening again.

And that proves not to be true, that it is on the rise and on the march again, and manifests in different ways, which is in part what Naomi and Astra's book is about, is this end times fascism. It's back, but history doesn't repeat it. It rhymes, and it manifests in a different way.

Speaker 2 9:46

Well put. Well put, Seth. And I think, to my mind, having watched the evolution of these social attitudes and political attitudes The current spike in anti-Semitism, and it does exist, though I think it's very overdrawn and over interpreted. I don't think it's nearly as bad as so many say it is, but there's certainly been a spike and I think that's almost entirely due To Israel's brutal genocide against the Palestinians. I think people have reacted against it, protested it, expressed their alarm and disgust at the slaughter of children. And Jewish communities say that's anti-Semitism, which, of course, it isn't in the least.

Speaker 3 10:37

I mean, I might phrase that slightly differently. I do think the rise in anti-Semitism that we've seen is very much connected to the genocide in Gaza. But I think it has… It's that the reaction to it has… Provided cover for some genuine anti-Semites. Yes, I agree. What they've held in the darker parts of their hearts. There is no doubt that anti-Semitism here and in the UK and the US, Australia, it's on the rise. And we've seen an increase in some horrendous, in the case of Australia, deadly attacks. Some of which are related to what's happened in Gaza. I mean, look, we just recently had this event in Belleville, on the other hand, which had nothing to do with that.

You know, this guy somehow equated some Jewish conspiracy to COVID or something like that. He was just a deranged neo-Nazi. So… I think when you get the mainstream Jewish organizations like B'nai B'rith who are tracking an increase in anti-Semitism, some of that increase is real and some of it is garbage. In fact, what they're tracking is anti-Zionism that they are incorrectly equating with anti-Semitism.

Metta Spencer 12:10

I think when you have people harassing people, You have to have police sometimes protecting schools now because there's a real threat to people, to children. Now, that has to be called anti-Semitism. Whatever it is, it's not good. And it's against Jews. But do you want to call it anti-Zionism? I think it is anti-Semitism itself. Instigated by and motivated by and all focusing on and whipped up by reaction against what has happened in Gaza in the last few years.

Speaker 2 12:58

Now, while your wording is a bit ambiguous there, Mette, the mainstream Jewish community like to say, it's you left-wingers who are protesting the genocide, who are causing all this anti-Semitism. On the contrary, I think that the large majority of Canadians would agree with us in criticism of the genocide. And it's the genocide itself that is spiking the antisemitism, not our protest against it. And yes, I agree, it's hideous that they have to have police guards at schools and synagogues. And I'm not sure how real the threat always is. So Belville was a horrible example, not so much of antisemitism, but there was Philadelphia. Don't forget the mass shooting in the mosque in Montreal.

I mean, I think the Muslims suffer from this as much as we Jews do. So why all the public focus on antisemitism rather than Islamophobia? They're both scourges in a democracy. And one seems hardly ever mentioned.

Metta Spencer 14:15

I wrote a book once about anti-Semitism. I spent two years studying 8th, 10th, and 12th grade students in the U.S. with survey analysis, 5,000 kids almost. And I did the analysis of it and I wrote the book. I found… Very simply, to put it very simply, what those kids were upset about when they, what was breaking up the friendships and the good relations between the high school students was envy. The white and non-Jewish kids envied the successful Jewish kids. And where they were numerous, they had more Breaking relationships, and the relationships were being broken at the behest of the parents of the Jewish kids, not the Christian or non-Jewish kids, white, local. We separated the black kids separately.

Speaker 2 15:22

That might have been specific to Berkeley, California, because…

Metta Spencer 15:25

Nope. It was three cities in the East Coast. Oh, East Coast. This was about 1962 when we did the survey.

Speaker 3 15:40

I mean, that's pretty old. I wasn't even alive yet. That's right.

Metta Spencer 15:45

That's my point. That what has happened in the meantime, later on, I taught at universities for 40 years. And I never, ever, sorry, but Michelle, your experience was so different. I never encountered one anti-Semitic word or deed. And I'm from high school kids in Asbury Park, I'll tell you.

Speaker 2 16:12

I have to ask you directly. Are you Jewish? No, I'm not. And that's why you never saw one word of anti-Semitism. I can assure you that Gentile friends of mine say, oh, no, that didn't exist. No, we never heard a word of it.

Metta Spencer 16:29

Yes, that I sure as hell ran in and knew and was very familiar with anti-Semitism among the high school students. There was several years earlier. Yeah. What had happened in the meantime? There was apparently a significant change in the attitudes of Jewish parents who were, I think, stopped as much pressure as they were putting on their high school kids.

Speaker 3 17:00

Julie Medda, I have to say, I think what you're describing is sort of a classic immigrant evolutionary story. I do, too. What you're describing is the Jewish kids experiencing in the early 60s might well be what Asian kids experienced. I was going to say that. But I think it speaks to a broader point, which is, you know, it's interesting you use the word envy. This is the thing about fascism and racism. Is that it takes economic crisis and it asks people to punch down. That is its modus operandi. It's part of why Marx called anti-Semitism the socialism of fools.

Because instead of giving people a worldview and a framework to make sense of these economic crises in a coherent way, it says it's that guy over there. And sometimes Jews have been the recipient of that and victimized by that, and sometimes it's somebody else. But I do think, to Michelle's earlier point, and this is what I was trying to write about in the piece that I think led to you wanting to talk to me, Mehta, something's out of whack. I would say in our Jewish community. There is a rise in anti-Semitism. The incidences that you are describing are of course anti-Semitic. And all violence is unacceptable like that. But as Michelle said, mercifully nobody in Canada has been killed.

The Muslim community cannot say the same. There have been, in history, two incidences that were murders. Horrible, horrible. And there's 74,000 people dead in Gaza. So when in the Jewish community so much of the conversation sort of fixates on both real and imaginary increases in anti-Semitism, Within that larger context, my feeling is something's out of balance, something is out of whack here in terms of where our focus should be.

Speaker 2 19:26

You spoke so well. I said that so well, Seth. That's exactly right.

Metta Spencer 19:32

Okay, I agree, but what is out of whack now? Our job is to figure out what's the source of this upsurge. Well, if I may…

Speaker 2 19:43

I became a Zionist because of the amount of anti-Semitism I experienced as a child. I want to make it clear my family was very uneducated. They were not Zionists. I don't think they'd ever heard the word. But when I was 13, I was introduced to the Zionist youth movement. And having experienced so much direct hatefulness all my young life, I embraced this with fervor and excitement because here I finally was with a group of Jewish kids. I grew up outside the community and these were kids like me. They wanted to argue about ideas. You know, it was a whole world of books and folklore and dancing and aspiration and hopefulness and it was Captivating and seductive. And so I know how Zionism feels.

It was part of me. And I know how painful it is to undo all the propaganda that consciously or unconsciously we were taught. We were taught how the Arabs just left Israel spontaneously in 1948 because the other Arab countries told them, oh, just leave and we'll get you back there in a couple of weeks. What a monstrous lie. I never thought to criticize it when I was a young teenager. Many, many such lies. We just imbibed, open-eyed. I spent a year in Israel when I was 17, 18. I began to have my doubts. And gradually, in the years afterwards, Israel's behavior, the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, I was very opposed to that, as were so many Israelis.

And I began, you know, my loyalty began to be chipped away, but at every step it hurt. Even as far as Sabra and Shatila, if you remember those massacres in the refugee camps in Lebanon, I alone among all my left-wing friends, and I was well on into adulthood, I was still defending Israel. It hurt too much to give up that belief system that I grew up with. It wasn't until I moved to New York for a few wonderful years and I met all sorts of left-wing Jews who felt perfectly free to criticize Israel without feeling that they were being disloyal or cast out or a self-hating Jew. And I realized there were more open-minded cultures that existed for me as a Jew.

That began my process. I had to educate myself. I had to read a lot. I had to undo all the propaganda I had learned. Now, I think what's happening now is there's so many who, like I was, are clinging to that core identity. We're the victims. We're the righteous ones. We're the good ones. We suffered in the Holocaust. We could never inflict any bad thing on others. It's easy to want to believe that and to believe that we're the good ones and that we're always the victims and never the victimizers. And that's what I see among many even younger people in the Jewish community who never really suffered from anti-Semitism and are indignant at having anything negative said about Israel.

And they're not willing, as far as I can see, to look within Or even to look at the agonizing horror in Gaza.

Metta Spencer 23:34

Michelle, if I were doing a study again today, I would not try to interview Jews. I want to interview anti-Semitic people. To find out what they believe, what they think, what their feelings are, what their resentments are, et cetera, just as we did with the high school students. And I can tell you that, as far as I can tell, that's changed a lot. I know that in those days, the main, when I asked kids questions about how their relationships or their feelings about Jews, they were saying things that only indicated that they resented and had And envied them because they were doing well. And they admired them. They enjoyed them. They wished they could be friends with them, but they were being rejected.

And that was true then. It stopped being true because 10 years later when I was teaching and for the next 40 years when I was teaching, I never ran into that at all. I never saw it among the non-Jews.

Speaker 3 24:38

Well, the rejection, by the way, is…

Metta Spencer 24:41

We have anti-Semitism again. And it's not envy. It's not because Jews are successful and they're not. It is not that. It's about, look at Israel. That's the problem. That's what, if you ask them why they're angry, why they dislike Jews, it has nothing to do with how successful they are in school or are they dating, are they willing to date me, et cetera. It is only about What are they doing in Gaza? Yeah. It would be a mix.

Speaker 3 25:17

In fairness, it would be a mix. It would be a mix.

Speaker 2 25:20

A whole variety.

Speaker 3 25:21

It's a variety. The neo-Nazis don't give a damn about Gaza. Right. They're anti-Semitic for their own reasons. I just want to come back to… So, Michelle's description of… What she learned and had to unlearn in her youth, I really can relate to. You know, the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza happened in a war that occurred the year before I was born. And I, and so that's how long the occupation is. 58 years old. And then I went to this Jewish elementary school. We learned Hebrew and Yiddish every day. But as Michelle is describing, a few things stand out to me. One, we were taught that we were victims.

We were imbued with a kind of victim complex, which, by the way, when you describe sort of a feeling of rejection that the Jews… Part of that, I think, is about how a society kind of battens down the hatches and… Self-defensively. In some cases in self-defense, and in some cases it gets self-perpetuated by that, by teaching that victimhood. And so for a lot of Jews, they remain stuck there, right? Their ability to see the truth in the present is clouded. But the other thing I remember from my Jewish elementary school, You know, it's interesting, like Palestinians are often criticized for saying from the river to the sea.

Well, when my Hebrew teacher taught us how to draw a map of Israel on the blackboard, there was no carve out for Gaza. There was no carve out for the West Bank.

Speaker 2 27:21

That's right.

Speaker 3 27:22

It was the river to the sea.

Speaker 2 27:23

Yeah.

Speaker 3 27:26

And the other thing I remember is that every time we spoke English in Hebrew class, we had to put a dime in this little blue box.

Speaker 2 27:34

Yep.

Speaker 3 27:35

That was raising money for the Jewish National Fund.

Speaker 2 27:37

Jewish National Fund.

Speaker 3 27:39

And we were buying trees in Israel. We were making the desert bloom. And nobody told us that that was happening on bulldozed Palestinian communities. Yeah, right. So that's part of… Where a lot of people need to unlearn a lot of stuff. I had to, just as Michelle had to, I had to 30 years later, I had to unlearn a lot of stuff. The one thing I would say, Michelle, is that while it's true that there are young Jews who refuse to look at this stuff, it is equally true that there are a whole lot of young Jews who are horrified, who joined the protest.

And in fact, the last three years have not only made them anti-Zionists, but have actually, in a kind of sad way, Alienated them from their own Jewishness. I totally agree. Because they don't hear leaders from their own Jewish community condemning what is happening. But they do have the clarity to see that while there may have been attractive elements of Zionism and labor Zionism back in the day, that Israel currently has an anti-democratic fascist government.

Speaker 2 28:51

To put up mildly and soak her up. And, you know, the arrogance of the mainstream dominant Jewish community, the Sija people, I just want to give a little example of why they're so outraged that there's criticism arising now from their own youth and from outside. Maybe 10, 15, maybe it was 15 years ago, I was part of a little committee. The Jewish Committee for the Roma. At that time, the Roma were refugees from Czechoslovakia and Hungary were being thrown back into danger by the Canadian government. As Jews, there were some of us, including some very eminent immigration lawyers, who were horrified because we had a connection with the Roma. They were also targeted for extermination. Nobody talks about them.

So I joined that committee with alacrity and after A few months of flambering around, we weren't quite sure how we could change things. We got a letter from Sija on their letterhead saying, you are to seize and desist immediately. What right did they have to tell us because they didn't like somehow that we were calling ourselves a Jewish committee to defend the Roma. How it displeased them, I don't want to think about, but the arrogance and that's how they behaved. In all ways, against any criticism of Israel or of mainstream Jewish opinions. So not surprising there's a rebellion now.

Speaker 3 30:26

You know, your example of that committee, though, for me, what it drives home, you know, what all of us learn is often kind of embedded in us through story. We learn about these past historic events and traumas and so on. But we derive, depending on who's teaching it and how they're teaching it, we derive different lessons. So for many in the mainstream Jewish community, the lessons that they derive, and this was certainly true of what I would say was driven home at my elementary school, is never again to us. Never let this happen again to us.

Speaker 2 31:09

There is also,

Speaker 3 31:11

and always has been, a sizable minority within the Jewish community, and it kind of come from this tradition of tikkun olam, this commandment to rebuild the world, where these same stories are told in a somewhat different way, and where the lesson derived is never again to anyone. Which is why Jews… Are both overrepresented in the mainstream conservative universe and overrepresented in all these left-wing groups and solidarity movements.

Speaker 2 31:48

In the civil rights movement, in anti-apartheid in South Africa. And it was communicated to me, and I want to say how perfectly you put it in the stories. My parents were so apolitical and quite uneducated. All I knew was We always automatically sympathize with the underdog, whoever they were, so that the minute I ran into this hideous history in the United States of anti-black racism, I was horrified and I immediately took the side of Anyone being persecuted because of race. And that ran through my whole youth. That was just, I thought that was Jewish. So I was horrified to learn of other Jews who didn't give a damn about Those causes, I thought that was the way to be Jewish.

And it was transmitted just through my parents, very simple way of saying, oh, isn't that terrible when something bad happened to minorities or underdogs?

Speaker 3 32:52

That ought to do it, because, I mean, here we are talking about

Metta Spencer 33:22

Antisemitism entirely from the standpoint of the Jewish community as somehow the cause of it. You know, Jewish attitudes need to be improved. And if Jews didn't just think this way, feeling like victims and feeling those attitudes, that everything would go away. You know, I think we need to broaden the horizon a little bit because it can't just be that people are reacting against the,

Speaker 2 33:57

oh no, and I have to say it's again what Seth said, the stories. Why, when my own children were little, the age of Seth, exactly, a neighbor, a Gentile neighbor threw mud on my daughter who was six years old and Told her about dirty Jews. And they explained to my son, who was then four, that you could always tell a Jew by their nose. And, you know, ignorance is a large part of anti-Semitism as well. And those are stories passed down in families. So we're not saying that it's all caused by Jewish denial of the genocide, not by a long shot. There are many kinds of anti-Semitism. And ignorance is one of them.

The main causes, just repeating unthinkingly what your grandpa said about the Jews in his small town, you know.

Metta Spencer 34:50

Okay. Let me tell you about one of the other books that was produced within that big project that I was part of at Berkeley. Gertrude Selznick and Steven Steinberg wrote a book about Anti-Semitism as a cultural product. And what they argued, and I think is absolutely true, is that you can't avoid learning and hearing anti-Semitism ideas, just as you can't grow up in, say, the U.S. without knowing Mary Had a Little Lamb or all of these nursery rhymes or all of these other Things that are just part of the cultural environment, when you're growing up, you will hear all of those things. And you can, everybody learns those ideas that Jews have big noses or whatever.

And it's just part of what you grow up with. And we're all anti-Semitic in the sense that we absorb these stereotypes and beliefs and false ideas and as maybe correct ideas too. But you overcome them if you get, you know, if you're lucky. You get exposed to things that enable you to kind of bracket them and say, yeah, I know these stereotypes or these myths about people. But of course, I hope I don't act on the basis of them anymore. I hope I can, you know, Well, it changes over time, as I said. Look,

Speaker 3 37:02

All racism and sexism is a social construct, and the nature of its ferocity or tepidness changes over time and circumstances in place.

Metta Spencer 37:19

Yeah, I think I could have to say, as most people would, to be honest, would say, yeah, I've heard that, and I maybe once believed it, and I maybe once felt it, and I'm not I remember feeling very resentful in one case where I felt I was being excluded. And so maybe, you know, in that situation, you could say I was anti-Semitic. So I think everybody has got some of that and we just learned to kind of manage it, not let it out of the box too much.

Speaker 3 37:55

I mean, for what it's worth, part of the intent for me in writing the piece that led to asking for this interview was to write something as a Jew for other Jews and to say, look, we're all wrestling with a resurgence of anti-Semitism. The question is, what do you do about it? What should we do about it? And my point is that I actually think that the silence of many mainstream Jewish organizations in condemning the genocide and the fact that the Siegel lobby comes down like a ton of bricks any time a politician in Canada deigns to criticize Israel frequently silences so much of that criticism. Has two effects.

A, it increases the sense of impunity of the Israeli government, that they can get away with anything. But also… To the extent that it's silencing in that way, it causes a problem because the anti-Semites out there, and again, they're out there, they are, in a similar way as the mainstream Jewish organizations, they are also equating Judaism and Zionism. And the more we have Jewish people and Jewish leaders… Strongly criticizing and condemning these horrors and these monstrous activities by Israel. I actually think that helps the cause of fighting anti-Semitism. So as the leader of the NDP or Zach Polanski, who's the Jewish leader of the Green Party of the UK, and they are speaking out against the genocide.

I actually think they're doing way more than these mainstream Jewish groups in confronting antisemitism because they're exposing the lie that all Jews feel and think this way. And we need more of that.

Metta Spencer 40:15

I absolutely agree, but you know, here we are, we're having a conversation between two different perspectives. You said, what do we do about it? How can we fix it? What can we do to repair this problem? And I want to say the same thing. And you're saying it's, you know, what you're saying in a way is it would be a lot better if Jews would be more critical of Israel or

Speaker 3 40:42

Among other things. Look, I'm not saying that's the total solution to antisemitism, and it's going to keep evolving. And to the extent that we're also seeing an increase in neo-Nazi white supremacy, they don't care. Like I said, they don't care about what's going on in Gaza. They're antisemitic for their own reasons, and confronting them looks different. Confronting them looks like confronting them out with with countermarches and so on and making you feel like losers. So, you know, it's it's varied and the responses need to be. Different depending on who it is, and they need to be able to embrace solidarity across different communities. It's all a piece of it.

But my point in this article was primarily to say something as a Jew to other Jews.

Metta Spencer 41:35

Okay, got it. And I'm not Jewish. So I want to say something constructive too. Now, there's a little bit of a difference because if I say… Take your argument and make too much of a story of it. I would be saying, well, really, anti-Semitism now is being caused by Jews, because look at how they continue, etc. Your argument makes me say, blame the victim, in a way. Blame people who…

Speaker 3 42:09

Well, then look, you don't have to make that argument. You don't have to make that argument. But I think, you know, Judy Rebick, our friend Judy Rebick, had a piece recently defending Avi, actually, for some horrendous stuff in the National Post. But she made a really interesting point.

Metta Spencer 42:29

We should say who Avi is.

Speaker 3 42:31

Avi Lewis, Michelle's son, who is the leader of the NDP, and who gets embroiled in a lot of these controversies. But Judy's point was, you know, this idea that, you know, Part of this is I had a couple of Jews react to my piece saying, look, I'm Jewish, but I'm not responsible for Israel. I don't support them. Why are you making me responsible? And Judy's point, who's also Jewish, was to say, well, it's sort of reminiscent of the white collar men's movement in opposition to violence against women. Which basically, look, they weren't the ones engaged in violence against women, but they were recognizing that as men, and it being a male problem, they had an onus to speak up. That's right.

Speaker 2 43:25

Agreed. And I don't think that in any way we're saying it's the Jews causing anti-Semitism. We're saying it's the deliberate conflating of anti-Semitism. Zionism with anti-Semitism, promulgated mainly by the Jewish community, but not exclusively, that leads to people confusing the two. And that does, I think, increase the appearance of anti-Semitism. So that's only one part of it, Manda, as we've discussed. Ignorance is a large part of it. Hereditary narratives are another part of it. I think the envy part of it is long gone. At least in North America, Jews are so normalized in their societies that we don't stand out as those little strivers getting all the highest marks in high school, which I agree did happen at one time.

But I think no longer, as Seth said, Asian kids are the ones now who are The striving immigrants scoring spectacularly and doing so well. So it changes with every wave of immigration. And there are many, many causes of anti-Semitism. And I think a big part of it is that loser element of people so oppressed by the capitalist system we're living under, like those proud boys marching and saying, Jews will not replace us. It was so idiotic. They are outcasts from economic prosperity. They're outcasts from hope, optimism for their future. So they turn to whomever they can blame for it and usually not the right target as we have seen. But there's so many causes for it.

Seth pointed out fascism builds on that, on the anger and Fury of the dispossessed.

Speaker 3 45:32

Often legitimate. Often legitimate feelings of abandonment and oppression.

Metta Spencer 45:41

I really believe that. In fact, when I said I never found anti-Semitism when I was teaching 40 years in the university, but I I saw a lot of anti-Chinese. There was a period now when Chinese students were… I remember I was on the governing council and there was a motion to limit the number of Chinese we would let in and so on.

Speaker 2 46:12

There was a scandal at one time when CTV said that all these foreign Chinese students are taking over the medical school at University of Toronto. They were all Canadian of Asian origin, as it turned out, and they were stirring up hatred of foreigners. I mean, it just keeps happening.

Metta Spencer 46:32

Well, but there were allowing a lot of immigrants to come in, and the motion in the governing council would stop taking all of these foreigners. And from Asia, there was also a year when I heard the word Paki. Everywhere I went, all the students were talking, they would write term papers justifying their prejudice against Pakistanis. I don't know even what was going on.

Speaker 3 46:58

All these things come in waves. The victims change over time. It's a through line. The through line remains very similar throughout. And the question

Metta Spencer 47:10

is why? Because I, you know, one thing that sociologists all have to learn is we have to study the debate between Marx and Weber, because the key difference between those two sociologists was that Marx believed that money was the root of all evil, so to speak, that The cleavages and the conflicts in society all had to do with social class and who had the most property. But Weber was saying, yeah, okay, that counts for something and maybe quite a bit. But there's also such things as status. And people who have higher prestige than others, regardless of their income, that matters a lot. Because the people who have low status, especially people who are losing status as a group, Community, losing their position in the society.

They have the resentment. And that, I think, accounts for the anti-elitism of today. You know, the prejudice and anger toward…

Speaker 3 48:16

And a lot of misogyny. But I think this is the through line that I was getting at. Whether it's about economic fissures or status and people who formerly had status feeling like they're losing their status, whether it's men over women or whites over blacks or what have you, the through line of White supremacy and fascism and patriarchy is those in power convincing those aggrieved to say, don't look at us.

Metta Spencer 49:03

But the problem with that is if we're right now, the conversation for a moment looked like we were going to talk about what to do about it, how we can contribute to fixing it. And my problem with that is I don't know how to overcome that sense of resentment on the part of people who are angry because they've lost status or the group is regarded as less prestigious than it should be or that they feel they deserve. I think it's true.

Speaker 3 49:39

Let me come back because I have to leave in a moment at the top of the hour, but maybe you started me off with my sister's book and maybe I'll bring it back. The answer is organizing.

Speaker 2 49:53

The answer is…

Speaker 3 49:57

Naomi and Astra, near the end of their book, spend a bunch of time looking at the Zora Mandami campaign in New York as this case study of A challenge to fascism, to In many ways, he does great education. He's a popular educator historian, but he does it with fun and joy and multiracial celebration. And, you know, he won 50% of the vote and a whole bunch of young men who 12 months after they voted for Donald Trump, who were animated by all the vile hate Turned around 12 months later and voted for this guy.

Speaker 2 50:46

All right. What a wonderful summing up. That's so perfect an example. Couldn't agree more. And I also think that just like men have to step up around misogyny and patriarchy. Been waiting a long time for that to happen. Yeah. I think non-Jews have to step up their game against anti-Semitism and say, whoa, Bak, I just heard you in the cafeteria saying something about Jews and I want to intervene. You know, I've never seen that happen, actually. Maybe it's about time.

Metta Spencer 51:22

Good question. I'm trying to rack my brain for instances of that. But as I say, the survey we did was, you know, a questionnaire. And so I never had any contact with these high school kids. And when I was teaching at university, I never heard it. I did intervene when students wrote. It was quite difficult, you know, when people would write term papers justifying their hatred of Pakistanis, which was only brief, I think.

Speaker 2 51:54

It was brief, but important to reject it and critique it.

Metta Spencer 51:58

Absolutely. And I had one student who was a Pakistani who was driving taxis at night. And I asked him how often he encountered a conflict, you know, a statement or any Pakistani comment. Oh, two or three times a night. I couldn't imagine it. It's true. That's indeed, you do. I think people do step up then. When they hear something like that, they'll probably… Intervene and say, well, come on now. It's such a treat to be with both of you. And I'll let you go, but I want to wind up with Michelle, because I don't know, we've got another five minutes we can use. I don't want to miss one minute with Michelle.

Speaker 3 52:46

All right, I'm going to go.

Speaker 2 52:47

Take

Metta Spencer 52:49

care, Sarah. Have you read Naomi's book yet?

Speaker 2 52:53

I haven't finished it yet, but it's wonderful. It's a terrific, very important book. It debuted at number two on the New York Times bestseller list, so it's really…

Metta Spencer 53:08

What does she say about the source of this end-time fascism?

Speaker 2 53:15

Seth said it. It's the capitalist system that we are all existing in that has enriched Less than 1% to an insane, unimaginable degree that we have trillionaires romping around with chainsaws, attacking the poorest among us. And such a system is bound to create anger, futility, hopelessness, and outrage. In a way that, if you look at our political systems, has very few outlets now that are effective. And so they turn to people beneath them or other outsiders. It's as old as the hills. It's as old as humanity. This is what always happens. And yet people don't see The economic system we're living in because it's invisible as the air we breathe. A fish doesn't think about the water and we don't think about capitalism.

But I believe that's really the source. So many are immiserated and so few are living in unimagined luxury, insane and useless luxury that They're now dispensing with the need for the rest of the Earth. They're daydreaming about living on Mars or in spaceships.

Metta Spencer 54:47

I haven't read Naomi's book, and I'm going to react in terms of what I was saying a little while ago about Weber and Marx. From what I'm hearing you say, it's about money. I think it's about money for sure. When you've got trillionaires on the planet, there shouldn't be any. But at any rate, I think it's also about the sense of dignity and of prestige and of sense of being as important as anybody else in society. So this is about a status as well as a financial well-being. Because there can be a lot of people who are prosperous enough, they're not poor, but they really hate educated professionals, politicians, journalists, professors, AI people, no matter what.

They have every resentment of the elite people in society And feel that we need to take these university people down a peg or two. And these, you know, scientists, they don't believe in science or medicine or vaccinators and all of these people who keep telling them what to do to how to live better. They resent that. And my problem is I don't quite know how to overcome that.

Speaker 2 56:29

I can believe deeply that changing the system so that those very people who resent the scientists Have a chance to get educated, to go to university without incurring crushing debt, to learn some science themselves. It's because that whole world is closed to them, hopelessly closed to them. They will never be one of the elites, and that's because of the system we're living in. It's not just money. It's the whole structure of the capitalist system that keeps them down and And so they're fermenting in these conspiracy theories. I mean, they can achieve status. That's no longer a closed door. They can be influencers on social media and be known by a million times more than any scientist.

The internet has opened up a whole world of celebrity that didn't exist before. It's open to some teenage girl in her bedroom. It's not so much that. They're shutting out from economic prosperity or any hope of that advancement and education and just basic well-being, health care. And I mean, it turns into these simmering resentments that may well be targeted at the elites. I don't question that. I know they are. But I think the source of them is not envy. I think it's because they're being crushed and shut out by the system, not by the elites.

Metta Spencer 58:06

We're getting close to talking about the key core, I think. I think the question is, I'm not sure that we agree or I'm not sure that we even disagree. We have slightly different angles on it, but I think, I think, This is getting closer to really thinking about what's the source of the resentment. And there's some kind of extreme resentment on the part of millions and billions of people in the world now that has to be understood properly and rectified About people of goodwill. And I'm, you know, with the best will in the world, I may be one of those people. I'm one, you're one of the elite.

And if they feel resentful because of the way I'm treating them, I want to know what I'm saying and doing that I could change myself. So I wouldn't be hurting people.

Speaker 2 59:10

Look, you and I are different. I may be one of the elite now, but I sure didn't grow up that way. But I grew up in a time when I could go to university for an amount of money that I could earn in the summer. That's impossible now. The social structures were kind enough and generous enough after World War that people like me, just in that generation, had hope. I think that's completely closed off by the greedy kind of corporate capitalism that we have now. People growing up like me, without educated parents, without any means, with no wealth or status, cannot hope to get… I mean, it's very rare, but my whole generation had that optimism. Not so now.

I think that's what it's all about.

Metta Spencer 1:00:02

We've really come down to talking about what's core or what's key, and we appreciate that very much. Certainly, I agree with you in terms of finances, the idea that there are There's trillionaires in the world. That's ridiculous. And of course, there shouldn't be any billionaires either. There should be something. And in terms of what to do with the money issue, I think we do agree completely. The difference, if we have any, is I think there may be something more in addition to worrying about actual financial matters. I think it's also something extra having to do with dignity or A sense of, you know, equality socially. And I haven't figured out how I'm going to change my lifestyle to meet that challenge.

And I want to think about it some more. But we've come to over our time.

Speaker 2 1:01:04

Thank you so much, Amanda. It's been fun talking with you.

Metta Spencer 1:01:07

A lot of fun. Thank you. And blessings to you and to your family. Okay.

Speaker 2 1:01:11

Thank you.

Metta Spencer 1:01:12

Bye. Bye-bye.


Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments